The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's your idea, Sol88, so it's up to you to present a scientific case.

Why not start with something easy? For example, show - in a scientific manner - that the observational data on comets is consistent with them being ROCK.

To be clear, not a quote from someone, nor some handwaving, but something along the lines of:

- ROCK has a bulk density of X.
- This observational data on Comet Y is consistent with it having a bulk density of between 0.8X and 1.2X.

Well, apparently ROCK can have a bulk density of ~.4g/cm3!

Fancy that. :thumbsup:
 
A "don't accept the assumption" lie emphasizes URL="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12507311#post12507311"]his electric comet insanity[/URL].

The assumption in the example I mentioned is that the deluded Thunderbolts cult and its followers such as Sol88 may have a point. Rosetta might have a charge. 67P might have a charge. Those charges will cause a force (like charges repel, unlike charges attract :p). So do some easy math using standard physics to see what those charges might be. Find out that 67P gets a charge so enormous that it is totally obvious and will be detected.

Yes in simpleton electrostatics you'd be correct but the actual situation is far more complex!

Plasma is dynamic and the currents operate in a circuit!

This has only recently been "discovered" by the mainstream.

I'd suspect the charge that Rosetta "sees" in not from the nucleus but the double layer that the mainstream call the diamagnetic cavity!

Rosetta flew in and out of this "layer" so in the equation F = Ke * q1 * q2 / r2

So we only deduce the charge on Rosetta q1 and r2 is very small if we keep skimming this layer.

The q2 charge does not electrostaticly discharge the nucleus to 0v.

As shown in the recent papers!

So it still a very viable option as the same effect as been noticed at Oumuamua
5. We know it got a little speed boost.

A rapid response observing campaign allowed us to watch as ‘Oumuamua got an unexpected boost in speed. The acceleration slightly changed its course from earlier predictions. Davide Farnocchia, of the Center for Near Earth Object Studies (CNEOS) at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, said:

If not from "outgassing" because it's not a comet then it must be an alien space craft!!

Hilarious!

Make the mainstream seem like cranks!
 
An insane "recently discovered" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity

Plasma is dynamic and the currents operate in a circuit!

This has only recently been "discovered" by the mainstream.
An insane "recently discovered" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity.

Plasma being dynamic has been known for a century. Current do not "operate in a circuit". Describing some plasmas using circuit theory has been in use for decades, e.g. by the mainstream plasma physicist Hannes Alfven :jaw-dropp!
 
Diamagnetic cavity = double layer delusion as part of his electric comet insanity

I'd suspect the charge that Rosetta "sees" in not from the nucleus but the double layer that the mainstream call the diamagnetic cavity!
Diamagnetic cavity = double layer delusion as part of his electric comet insanity.
A diamagnetic cavity is the absence of a magnetic field.
A double layer is two layers of moving charges which generates magnetic fields between them and have never been seen at a comet.
 
Lies and "As shown in the recent papers" debunking his electric comet insanity

So we only deduce ...As shown in the recent papers!
Lies and "As shown in the recent papers" debunking his electric comet insanity.

Delusions are not deductions.

Electric Comets III: Mass vs. Charge
Harvey's updated computation.
For his deluded cult to discard the measurement of 67P's mass, they need 67P to be charged to ~35 Gigavolts :jaw-dropp. The lack of evidence for the effects of this enormous collated in all comet papers is what debunks his electric comet insanity.
 
An 'Oumuamua delusion to derail from his electric comet insanity

So it still a very viable option as the same effect as been noticed at Oumuamua
An 'Oumuamua delusion to derail from his electric comet insanity.

A delusion has no effect.

There is no evidence that 'Oumuamua is a comet. No coma seen. No tail seen. There is unexplained acceleration. An explanation is outgassing from ices but no coma or tails. Another is radiation pressure but that needs a vey odd shape of the asteroid (odd enough that there is speculation about being a solar sail).
 
Last edited:
ignorant gibberish to derail from his electric comet insanity

Rosetta flew in and out of this "layer" so in the equation F = Ke * q1 * q2 / r2
ignorant gibberish to derail from his electric comet insanity

Plasma is not a single charge and so the charges (plural!) in a comet coma cannot be q1 or q2. A double layer (which has never been seen around a comet and cannot form around a comet) is obviously 2 layers of many charges. Coulomb's law applies to 2 point charges.
 
Another spate of ~436 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 28 November 2018
Another spate of ~459 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 29 November 2018
 
"Wet Asteroids" insanity to derail from his electric comet insanity.

A "Wet Asteroids" video from the ignorant, deluded and lying Thunderbolts cult :jaw-dropp!
No point in watching even more delusions and lies from the Thunderbolts cult but even the title is a lie that the gullible Sol88 falls for hook, line and sinker as he has for all of their lies.

The description has the cult inanity of scientist "astonishment" probably from press releases since they are ignorant about the existence of scientific literature :p! Add a probable lie by omission in the description and maybe video because the explanations for the discovery will be in the press releases and news articles.

This is a single, massive asteroid 16 Psyche
Psyche (/ˈsaɪkiː/ SY-kee; minor planet designation: 16 Psyche) is one of the ten most massive asteroids in the asteroid belt. It is over 200 km (120 mi) in diameter and contains a little less than 1% of the mass of the entire asteroid belt. It is thought to be the exposed iron core of a protoplanet.[4] It is the most massive metallic M-type asteroid.
...
The NASA Infrared Telescope Facility at the Mauna Kea Observatories released evidence (~3 μm absorption feature) of the presence of water or hydroxyl ions on the asteroid in October 2016. The water is believed to have reached Psyche via past impacts from smaller asteroids containing volatile substances such as carbon, hydrogen and water.[19][20][21][22]
 
Last edited:
Oi rc!


NEW PAPER, NEW DISCUSSION

Models of Rosetta/OSIRIS 67P dust coma phase function

ABSTRACT
The phase function of the dust coma of comet 67P has been determined from Rosetta/OSIRIS images (Bertini et al. 2017). This function show a deep minimum at phase angles near 100., and a strong backscattering enhancement. These two properties cannot be reproduced by regular models of cometary dust, most of them based on wavelength-sized and randomly-oriented aggregate particles. We show, however, that an ensamble of oriented elongated particles of a wide variety of aspect ratios, with radii r &10 .m, and whose long axes are perpendicular to the direction of the solar radiation, are capable of reproducing the observed phase function. These particles must be absorbing, with an imaginary part of the refractive index of about 0.1 to match the expected geometric albedo, and with porosity in the 60-70% range.

and there is a force aligning them! While the paper states 3.2. Models assuming size distributions of particles aligned to the solar radiation direction

I'd postulate the Electric filed centered on the nucleus would do the job!

Very interesting, especially in conjunction with

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a
plasma environment
doi:10.1002/2013GL058268

We found that under certain conditions the spontaneously
generated water ice grains are not spherical but instead
are highly elongated, i.e., are ellipsoidal.


Believe tusenfem commented on this awhile back.


Another FAIL for the dirtysnowball model!
 
I like that but why do asteroids have more water than comets?

Wet Asteriods

When mainstream get that little problem sorted perhaps we can discuss that comets are rocky bodies.

Nope. You said there would be no ice on or in comets. You were wrong. You lost. And still cannot explain why asteroids on elliptical orbits don't outgas, as promised by the idiot Thornhill. You are batting zero after more than a decade of commenting on this crap.
 
X-wind, Grand tack, Nice

Handbrake turns indeed.

How did the refractory minerals end up in the very icy comet Wild2?

Ha ha joker!

Try reading some science, you clown. All you have is an evidence-free, failed model.
 
Comets and Asteroids are a continuum!


Not distinct objects. Unlike the old idea that comets were mostly ice and asteroids are mostly rock.

Not that much of a continuum. Comets always outgas. The vast majority of asteroids, even on eccentric orbits, do not. Explain why. For the squillionth time. This is a fundamental claim of the electric comet woo. It fails. Badly. Why do you refuse to address these failures of your idiotic, evidence-free woo?
 
No you need more than one model to test and compare.

Gravity only has been shown to be inadequate.

Gravity has been shown inadequate for what? You are lying, again. As usual. It is all you have left, isn't it?
 
Can’t do it.


Common sense and life experience counts as well.

Pure theoretical physics is nothing more than farietales and fiction.

But I digress.

Nope, you are lying. Nobody with any common sense believes comets were blasted off of planets by electrical woo. Only an idiot would believe such nonsense. As you have proven.
 
SAFIRE have already had a win and my money’s on them PROVING with peer review papers and the data returned from Parker solar probe.

So unfortunately for me SAFIRE will prove the Sun has a radial electric field not the other way round
.

SAFIRE is a heap of crap, and has accomplished nothing. Nor will it. And any radial electric field would be measured. It isn't. Fail.
 
So more than happy to bide my time (‘cos I’m just a interested lay person with no maths skills at all) and watch while the mainstream have no choice but to come up with a new model to be able to reconcile the data from Rosetta.

Nope, not only do you not have any maths skills, you are also scientifically illiterate, and have not a jot of evidence for your faith-based idiocy, and none exists. The mission is over. The data is in. You lost. No rock, no discharges.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom