The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
OLD PAPER, SAME OLD STUPIDITY to derail from his electric comet insanity

Very interesting, especially in conjunction with
Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a
plasma environment
doi:10.1002/2013GL058268
OLD PAPER, SAME OLD STUPIDITY to derail from his electric comet insanity

This paper is about water ice grains. The new paper is about dust grains.
This paper is that water ice grains may have nonspherical shapes. The new paper is partially about the size distribution of dust grains.
 
Last edited:
An irrelevant and insane "FAIL" lie to detail from his electric comet insanity

Another FAIL for the dirtysnowball model!
An irrelevant and insane "FAIL" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity

The "dirty snowball" (which Sol88 cannot even spell correctly :p) model has been working successful for 70 years and still works. With more data we may need to rename it the "icy dirtball" model and emphasize the physics of dust on comets.

Models of Rosetta/OSIRIS 67P dust coma phase function is a success of The mainstream model of comets. We have a model of dust being fitted to actual data showing that 67P's dust contains aggregate particles (which have been detected :eye-poppi!) which may be elongated and perpendicular to the direction of the solar radiation.

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment only one occurrence of the word comet
Examples include certain of Saturn's rings [Goertz, 1989], terrestrial polar mesospheric clouds [Havnes et al., 1996], astrophysical molecular clouds [McClure et al., 2012], and comet tails [Davies et al., 1997].
 
Last edited:
Hands down, the best paper you’ve linked to so far. Well done jd116. :thumbsup:

Does not assume sublimation or that the nucleus is mostly ice.



High drama indeed. :)

This paper would be good for any lurkers unsure if electricity in space can do anything.

With the results from SAFIRE support the Electric Comet model.

There is no electric comet model that hasn't been indisputably debunked. It is an evidence-free zone. And stop lying about Ip and Mendis. I'm getting sick of your pathetic lies. Sad.
 
Hands down, the best paper you’ve linked to so far. Well done jd116.

And is pure mainstream. No double layers, no discharges, no rock. Want me to email him, chicken boy? Unfortunately for you, unlike Mike A'Hearn, Wing-Huen Ip is very much alive, and active. He would tear you a new one. Want to go for it? Give me the word, woo boy.
 
Insane delusion of mainstream papers confirming his electric comet insanity

Emperical science is faith based in your books.
Unfortunately for you and jt I’ll just kick back and post the relevant mainstream peer reviewed papers as they come out.

Confirming the electric comet.
Insane delusion that there are or will be any mainstream papers confirming his electric comet insanity.

We have 70 years of every measurement of comet density being less than that of water, etc.

What makes his delusion insane is that after at least 12 years of mindlessly parroting dogma he has not found any mainstream paper at all confirminghis electric comet insanity
insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges...

What makes his delusion insane is what is needed to confirm his insanity.
Samples of comets made of actual rock such as granite, limestone (dead sea creatures!), basalt, etc.
Electromagnetism is wrong so that the accelerated charges in discharges do not emit light.
Conservation laws are wrong to allow the insanity of planets whizzing at his cult's will around the Solar System.
etc. etc.
 
Stupid lie about tusenfem to derail from his electric comet insanity

Tusenfem spat the dummy said old mate didn’t have a curcuit and that was the end of that.. couple pages back now.
Stupid lie about tusenfem to derail from his electric comet insanity.

tusenfem wrote about what circuit theory is and does Sol88 is sticking to the insanity of actual circuits.

Simply put:
Plasma has currents. These can be represented as circuits.
Plasma has some resistivity. That can be represented as small value resistors.
Plasma has magnetic fields. They can be represented as inductors.
That is circuit theory. We throw away the ability to look at details of the plasma to get an overall picture.
 
Actually, Mendis already described comets with a circuit model in 1978. Somebody who actually understands circuit theory may wish to comment on it;

On the hydromagnetic model of comets
Mendis, D. A.
http://adsbit.harvard.edu//full/1978M&P....18..361M/0000368.000.html
Hi jonesdave116, reading the paper does not show what I consider a circuit theory to be, i.e. modeling plasma via an electronic circuit with wires, resistors, etc. There is consideration of the currents and magnetic fields involved.

It is not one of the 5 'comet circuit theory' abstracts in the database. Even 'comet circuit' just gives 69 abstracts.
 
And is pure mainstream. No double layers, no discharges, no rock. Want me to email him, chicken boy? Unfortunately for you, unlike Mike A'Hearn, Wing-Huen Ip is very much alive, and active. He would tear you a new one. Want to go for it? Give me the word, woo boy.


Good on ‘em!

Please do. :D
 
Lies about the figures in a 1978 paper mainly about modeling comet tails

Saw some figures in there they may help with the whole bulk density issue.
Lies about the figures in a 1978 paper mainly about modeling comet tails.

The paper is about comet coma and tails.
 
Stupid lie about tusenfem to derail from his electric comet insanity.

tusenfem wrote about what circuit theory is and does Sol88 is sticking to the insanity of actual circuits.

Simply put:
Plasma has currents. These can be represented as circuits.
Plasma has some resistivity. That can be represented as small value resistors.
Plasma has magnetic fields. They can be represented as inductors.
That is circuit theory. We throw away the ability to look at details of the plasma to get an overall picture.

Where’s the accelerator, ya goose.

You know the one accelerating particles, what do you call them in your wire analogy?

You forgot it.
 
Last edited:
Insanity that the number 10^8 amps is Birkeland currents, etc

10^8 amps

Birkeland currents..
Insanity that the number 10^8 amps is Birkeland currents, etc.

What the paper actually has is "I >~ 10^8 A, if l ~ 10^6 km (Ip and Mendis, 1976a)". l is the length of a neutral sheet with a current in the comet tail.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom