The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A insane and lying question to derail from him calling M. A'Hearn insane ...

Are you calling M.A'Hearn stupid?
A insane and lying question to derail from him calling M. A'Hearn insane enough to believe that comets are actual rocks as in Sol88's electric comet insanity.

M. A'Hearn was an intelligent, rational astronomer , e.g. SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) has 1150 abstracts with A'Hearn, Michael F. as an author!

Sol88 accuses an intelligent, rational astronomer of being insane yet again
Insane "HIGH PRIEST" rant, lies and insults to detail from his electric comet insanity.
Repeats his insane accusation of A’Hearn believing that comets are actual ROCK as in his electric comet insanity [fourth time].
 
Last edited:
Quotes the deranged liar Wal Thornhill being deluded and lying

It's not irrelevent except by those that wish to suppress instead of evolve!
Quotes the deranged liar Wal Thornhill being deluded and lying :eye-poppi!

This is Thornhill lying about having "quite specific predictions".
This is Thornhill lying about having "satisfied" predictions.
This a deranged Thornhill thinking that his cult has a model of comets that science would be interested in.
This a deranged Thornhill thinking that dogma overwhelming known only within his cult would cause a rethink of actual sceince..
This is a paranoid Thornhill complaining about an imaginary "monoculture". The reason that no astronomer believes in comets being rocks is the overwhelming physical evidence that comets are dust and ices :eye-poppi! Add the rest of the electric comet insanity and only ignorant and/or deluded people would believe in it.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
 
Last edited:
"Institutionalized science is a dead end" delusion and insane lies

Institutionalized science is a dead end.
"Institutionalized science is a dead end" delusion and insane lies to derail from his electric comet insanity

Sceince works. We hare a successful and improving understanding of comets.

Everyone here has told him what the composition of comets is (dust and ices).
 
And the above paper should have been where even the truly brainwashed acolytes of the electric comet woo, such as Sol, should have binned it.

Along with;

Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2012/06/aa18718-11.pdf

From the abstract;



Along with;

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet 9P/Tempel 1
Schulz, R. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2006/12/aahi281.pdf

From the abstract;


I like that but why do asteroids have more water than comets?

Wet Asteriods

When mainstream get that little problem sorted perhaps we can discuss that comets are rocky bodies.
 
None of the ideas behind the EC have any validity, the electrical charges needed to produce the effects are absent.
The density of comets blatantly show they are not asteroids in anyway.

But it is like wrestling an evangelical, you get covered in mud and they claim victory

nOOb.

You do realise we are now talking electric curcuit theory wrt comets?


See you again in a few more pages. :rolleyes:
 
I like that but why do asteroids have more water than comets?

Wet Asteriods

When mainstream get that little problem sorted perhaps we can discuss that comets are rocky bodies.
And this is relevant to your Electric Comet idea, how exactly?

When may we expect you to even start presenting a scientific case for your idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?
 
Thanks, jd, you spotted an ambiguity I didn't catch. I meant it was the foundation that sustains the EC; if all else fails they invoke a CT that can't be disproven. But your interpretation is the one most people would assume.

Thanks for the history lesson. You filled in some gaps in my understanding of how the EC got to its present lamentable and laughable state.

X-wind, Grand tack, Nice

Handbrake turns indeed.

How did the refractory minerals end up in the very icy comet Wild2?

Ha ha joker!
 
nOOb.

You do realise we are now talking electric curcuit theory wrt comets?


See you again in a few more pages. :rolleyes:
"electric curcuit [sic] theory wrt comets" :confused:

Is this yet another impossible thing you dreamed up before breakfast? Without the benefit of even basic physics, let alone plasma physics?
 
X-wind, Grand tack, Nice

Handbrake turns indeed.

How did the refractory minerals end up in the very icy comet Wild2?

Ha ha joker!
Yet another trolling attempt to derail this thread?

You know, we're supposed to be discussing the scientific case for your Electric Comet idea, remember?
 
And this is relevant to your Electric Comet idea, how exactly?

When may we expect you to even start presenting a scientific case for your idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?

Comets and Asteroids are a continuum!


Not distinct objects. Unlike the old idea that comets were mostly ice and asteroids are mostly rock.
 
Yet another trolling attempt to derail this thread?

You know, we're supposed to be discussing the scientific case for your Electric Comet idea, remember?

No you need more than one model to test and compare.

Gravity only has been shown to be inadequate.
 
JeanTate said:
Sol88 said:
I like that but why do asteroids have more water than comets?

Wet Asteriods

When mainstream get that little problem sorted perhaps we can discuss that comets are rocky bodies.
And this is relevant to your Electric Comet idea, how exactly?

When may we expect you to even start presenting a scientific case for your idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?
Comets and Asteroids are a continuum!


Not distinct objects. Unlike the old idea that comets were mostly ice and asteroids are mostly rock.
IOW, no relevance at all.

Or, in plain English, more trolling, perhaps in an attempt to divert readers from the fact that, so far, you have failed to present a scientific case for your idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?
 
Does your reply mean that you have no intention of doing any quantitative analyses of relevant data, on the composition of comets, say?

That you have no intention of learning enough basic plasma physics to undertake your own, quantitative, analyses of data relevant to the “Electric” part of your idea?

Can’t do it.


Common sense and life experience counts as well.

Pure theoretical physics is nothing more than farietales and fiction.

But I digress.


SAFIRE have already had a win and my money’s on them PROVING with peer review papers and the data returned from Parker solar probe.

So unfortunately for me SAFIRE will prove the Sun has a radial electric field not the other way round.

Not that I could prove it any way, not with out the E=MC2 type Majik equation.
 
JeanTate said:
Sol88 said:
X-wind, Grand tack, Nice

Handbrake turns indeed.

How did the refractory minerals end up in the very icy comet Wild2?

Ha ha joker!
Yet another trolling attempt to derail this thread?

You know, we're supposed to be discussing the scientific case for your Electric Comet idea, remember?
No you need more than one model to test and compare.

Gravity only has been shown to be inadequate.
Been there, done that, got the T-shirt (it says "Sisyphus had is easy").

Everyone who reads posts in this thread knows that a core part of your idea is the logical fallacy False Dichotomy (it has other names too).

But even we accept your unscientific belief, it still doesn't work! :jaw-dropp

Why not? Because, so far, you have presented nothing which resembles a model, as in an "Electric Comet model".

So, instead of more trolling, why not roll up your sleeves and work on presenting a scientific case for your Electric Comet idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?
 
So more than happy to bide my time (‘cos I’m just a interested lay person with no maths skills at all) and watch while the mainstream have no choice but to come up with a new model to be able to reconcile the data from Rosetta.
 
JeanTate said:
Does your reply mean that you have no intention of doing any quantitative analyses of relevant data, on the composition of comets, say?

That you have no intention of learning enough basic plasma physics to undertake your own, quantitative, analyses of data relevant to the “Electric” part of your idea?
Can’t do it.
Thank you for your frank admission.

Common sense and life experience counts as well.

Pure theoretical physics is nothing more than farietales and fiction.

But I digress.


SAFIRE have already had a win and my money’s on them PROVING with peer review papers and the data returned from Parker solar probe.

So unfortunately for me SAFIRE will prove the Sun has a radial electric field not the other way round.

Not that I could prove it any way, not with out the E=MC2 type Majik equation.
Good.

So now we can ask the Admins/Mods to either close this thread or move it somewhere else, so no one can possibly be confused that it's about science.
 
Been there, done that, got the T-shirt (it says "Sisyphus had is easy").

Everyone who reads posts in this thread knows that a core part of your idea is the logical fallacy False Dichotomy (it has other names too).

But even we accept your unscientific belief, it still doesn't work! :jaw-dropp

Why not? Because, so far, you have presented nothing which resembles a model, as in an "Electric Comet model".

So, instead of more trolling, why not roll up your sleeves and work on presenting a scientific case for your Electric Comet idea? You know, what this thread is supposed to be about?

Are you looking for some equation or some thing or something along the lines of Whipples “model”?

Because “Comets are rocky bodies discharging in the solar plasma flow” is not as technical as “A comet is an icy small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing. This produces a visible atmosphere or coma, and sometimes also a tail.”

You tell m the difference sweet pea.
 
Thank you for your frank admission.


Good.

So now we can ask the Admins/Mods to either close this thread or move it somewhere else, so no one can possibly be confused that it's about science.


Are you interested in talking plasma curcuit theory?

Or dummy spit and get your knickers all bunch up?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom