I would agree to an extent, although I feel the founding principles are firmly based on Velikovsky's woo*. That, of course, morphed into Talbott's Saturnist woo, which is around the time that he and Thornhill became the gruesome twosome. Everything they believe and promote is based on that fundamental, unscientific, physics defying nonsense.
Hence the electric comet needing to be rock, because they say it was blasted off a planet by a giant thunderbolt (lol), most likely at the time Earth was orbiting Saturn and/or Venus was performing handbrake turns around the solar system. This being due to Venus coming within spitting distance of Earth and Mars, causing the aforementioned non-existent thunderbolt.
It can also be traced back to the nonsense entitled 'Cosmos Without Gravitation', by the uber-loon Velikovsky. It is why Thornhill, armed with his BSc, wants to overturn everything we know about gravity, and turn it into some sort of EM effect. Constant G screws up his Saturn, Venus and comet fairy tales. He knows it breaks the laws of physics, so this incompetent tool is going to rewrite said laws (lol).
And then we have Scott, who tries to resurrect Juergens' stupid electric Sun idea, and makes a complete arse of himself in the process. I'm not sure when Scott threw in his hand with this **** fest of woo.
All the stuff about Birkeland and Alfven is just to try to make it appear that there is some sort of scientific foundation to their nonsense.
It is hilariously sad that apparently sane people have fallen for this crap. One can only invoke extreme scientific illiteracy in mitigation for them.
*
https://web.archive.org/web/19980615054946/http://www.marmsweb.com/euniverse.html