The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
You get shown papers that shatters your world view and a tantrum will ensue
.

No, you LIAR, you haven't shown a single paper where rock has been detected. We are still waiting. A'Hearn referenced his remark, and the two references do not detect anything other than dust. How pathetic it is when your impossible model is shown to be the crap we knew it all was, that you have to keep banging on about non-existent things to try to make some sort of point. You lost, woo boy. The idiot Thornhill was wrong. No rock, no discharges. Now start presenting some evidence, or ST*U.
 
Last edited:
Thank you jt!

Question for you what is the mainstream cometary model? Do you know or just here for the occasional drive by trolling?
In this thread, my focus is on your Electric Comet idea. I intend to try to keep you focused on that too.

Sadly, I think what several others have said is right... this thread does not, any longer, belong in a board about science.

<stuff irrelevant to Sol88’s Electric Comet idea snipped>
 
You could start by downloading some data and doing your own analyses. Or you could sign up for an online course in basic physics, and work your way to a basic understanding of plasma physics. Had you done either of those things 12 years ago, we might now be having an intelligent discussion.


How about you not use the logical fallacy, Argument from Authority?

As I have already said, the relevant data are consistent with at least some comets being “mostly space”. This is inconsistent with your Electric Comet idea. You think otherwise? Do the analyses to show it!

Why?

Institutionalized science is a dead end.

For instace ask um, i dont know say a SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSACIST what the composition of comets is?

Just ask a very basic question such as um.. i dont know, (c) What are comets made of?

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Nevertheless, there is still considerable uncertainty about even this basic parameter, not least of which is that most measurements are subject to selection effects in removing refractories from the nucleus to the coma, where they are observed as dust.

See what kinda of answer you get. :rolleyes:

Prediction you wont because it's not a SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSICIST job!

And there in a nut shell you have the problem that even Alfven commented on.


So the PROBLEM IS institutionalized science. Not great paradigm changes have EVER come from institutionalized science just the repeat of DOGMA and blind faith!

Almost religious like. ;)
 
Why?

Institutionalized science is a dead end.

For instace ask um, i dont know say a SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSACIST what the composition of comets is?

Just ask a very basic question such as um.. i dont know, (c) What are comets made of?



See what kinda of answer you get. :rolleyes:

Prediction you wont because it's not a SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSICIST job!

And there in a nut shell you have the problem that even Alfven commented on.


So the PROBLEM IS institutionalized science. Not great paradigm changes have EVER come from institutionalized science just the repeat of DOGMA and blind faith!

Almost religious like. ;)

Pathetic, conspiracist word salad. Lol. Can't do science, can you, woo boy? Only faith. Pathetic.
 
I take it you read DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh ?
I take it that you have yet to show any quantitative evidence that comets are ROCK.

I also take it that you have done essentially nothing in the way of plasma physics based quantitative analyses of data relevant to the “Electric” part of your Electric Comet idea.

When do you plan to start doing either, may I be so bold as to ask?
 
So the PROBLEM IS institutionalized science. Not great paradigm changes have EVER come from institutionalized science just the repeat of DOGMA and blind faith!

Too useless to do the analysis, being incapable of understanding it, he resorts to idiotic conspiracist whining! Instruments took that data. Go find the discharges (lol) in the mag data. Instead of pretending that they are there. Go find the rock from any number of instruments that would see it. Instead of lying about it being there. Simple. If you can't or won't do that, what is the point in carrying on posting here? You lost. Get over it like a man, instead of behaving like a spoilt child. Grow a pair.
 
<stuff not relevant to Sol88’s Electric Comet idea snipped >
Does your reply mean that you have no intention of doing any quantitative analyses of relevant data, on the composition of comets, say?

That you have no intention of learning enough basic plasma physics to undertake your own, quantitative, analyses of data relevant to the “Electric” part of your idea?
 
I take it you read DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh ?

Which is two lines from a conference oral. Where is the data in a real paper? And what relevance has it to the EC idiocy?
 
The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Jessica M. Sunshine, Olivier Groussin, Peter H. Schultz, Michael F. A’Hearn, Lori M. Feaga, Tony L. Farnham, Kenneth P. Klaasen
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5abd/57ce43924466abb4c4f3bca01f2a50dd12a3.pdf

Abstract
The Deep Impact flyby spacecraft includes a 1.05 to 4.8 μm infrared (IR) spectrometer. Although ice was not observed on the surface in the impact region, strong absorptions near 3 μm due to water ice are detected in IR measurements of the ejecta from the impact event. Absorptions from water ice occur throughout the IR dataset beginning three seconds after impact through the end of observations, ∼ 45 min after impact.
Spatially and temporally resolved IR spectra of the ejecta are analyzed in conjunction with laboratory impact experiments. The results imply an internal stratigraphy for Tempel 1 consisting of devolatilized materials transitioning to unaltered components at a depth of approximately one meter. At greater depths, which are thermally isolated from the surface, water ice is present. Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depths excavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1 ± 1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory impurities.
 
And the above paper should have been where even the truly brainwashed acolytes of the electric comet woo, such as Sol, should have binned it.

Along with;

Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2012/06/aa18718-11.pdf

From the abstract;

A sustained production of water is observed, which can be explained by the sublimation of pure ice grains with sizes less than 1 μm and comprising a mass of ice of (0.8 − 1.8) × 107 kg.

Along with;

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet 9P/Tempel 1
Schulz, R. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2006/12/aahi281.pdf

From the abstract;

Methods. The comet was observed with the XMM-Newton Observatory. We used the EPIC camera for X-ray imaging and the Optical Monitor for monitoring in the ultraviolet and visible spectral range.
Results. An outburst of the comet nucleus was observed as a result of the impact and the evolution of the coma was monitored in gas and dust. Our observations led to the first detection of icy grains in a comet at 1.5 AU from the Sun.
Conclusions. We showed for the first time that the material ejected from the nucleus of a comet contains icy grains, even at small heliocentric distance
 
Those previously linked papers have never been dealt with by the authors of the electric comet woo. You will find no reference to those findings, nor the veritable snowstorm around Hartley 2, on Thunderdolts, nor hollowscience. Completely ignored, as they carried on trying to sell their lunacy to the hard of thinking. This tells you everything you need to know about the EC 'model', and the people behind it. As Tim Thompson once said, the Electric Comet woo is stupid and dishonest;

The Thunderbolts / plasma universe & etc. comet pages are stupid and dishonest. They claim successful predictions that were not successful and they claim failures of standard theory that are not failures. Trust them at your own peril.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6893760&postcount=1116
 
Last edited:
Oh Oh and Wal Thornhills prediction that there would be two flashes!

No, he predicted a pre-impact flash. He was wrong. He predicted the electric woo causing the non-existent pre-impact flash would be seen in x-ray. It wasn't. He was wrong. He is still lying about it to this day. He is a liar.
And Pete Schultz has already predicted a two stage plume, with an initial weak flash, based on modelling for the impact. It pre-dated Thornhill's woo.
 
Oh Oh and Wal Thornhills prediction that there would be two flashes!
No, he predicted a pre-impact flash. He was wrong. He predicted the electric woo causing the non-existent pre-impact flash would be seen in x-ray. It wasn't. He was wrong. He is still lying about it to this day. He is a liar.
And Pete Schultz has already predicted a two stage plume, with an initial weak flash, based on modelling for the impact. It pre-dated Thornhill's woo.
I didn't realize that this exact thing (Thornhill's specific "prediction") is the topic of quite a few posts in the ancient CQ thread RC provided a link to! :jaw-dropp

You'll find that Sol88 strenuously resisted answering any questions on this; specifically, he rubbished the very idea that someone could even ask for the (detailed) reasoning (and calculations, etc) behind the prediction. IOW, about as clear an example of virulent anti-science as you could ever ask for.

One person over at CQ (Vander_L) did at least try to address this (well, the larger questions about where Thornhill's "predictions" came from, in terms of known physics), but Sol88 would have none of it.

Yet another reason for closing this thread, or at least moving it to somewhere that nothing to do with science ...
 
I would agree to an extent, although I feel the founding principles are firmly based on Velikovsky's woo*. That, of course, morphed into Talbott's Saturnist woo, which is around the time that he and Thornhill became the gruesome twosome. Everything they believe and promote is based on that fundamental, unscientific, physics defying nonsense.
Hence the electric comet needing to be rock, because they say it was blasted off a planet by a giant thunderbolt (lol), most likely at the time Earth was orbiting Saturn and/or Venus was performing handbrake turns around the solar system. This being due to Venus coming within spitting distance of Earth and Mars, causing the aforementioned non-existent thunderbolt.
It can also be traced back to the nonsense entitled 'Cosmos Without Gravitation', by the uber-loon Velikovsky. It is why Thornhill, armed with his BSc, wants to overturn everything we know about gravity, and turn it into some sort of EM effect. Constant G screws up his Saturn, Venus and comet fairy tales. He knows it breaks the laws of physics, so this incompetent tool is going to rewrite said laws (lol).
And then we have Scott, who tries to resurrect Juergens' stupid electric Sun idea, and makes a complete arse of himself in the process. I'm not sure when Scott threw in his hand with this **** fest of woo.
All the stuff about Birkeland and Alfven is just to try to make it appear that there is some sort of scientific foundation to their nonsense.
It is hilariously sad that apparently sane people have fallen for this crap. One can only invoke extreme scientific illiteracy in mitigation for them.

* https://web.archive.org/web/19980615054946/http://www.marmsweb.com/euniverse.html


Thanks, jd, you spotted an ambiguity I didn't catch. I meant it was the foundation that sustains the EC; if all else fails they invoke a CT that can't be disproven. But your interpretation is the one most people would assume.

Thanks for the history lesson. You filled in some gaps in my understanding of how the EC got to its present lamentable and laughable state.
 
None of the ideas behind the EC have any validity, the electrical charges needed to produce the effects are absent.
The density of comets blatantly show they are not asteroids in anyway.

But it is like wrestling an evangelical, you get covered in mud and they claim victory
 
I didn't realize that this exact thing (Thornhill's specific "prediction") is the topic of quite a few posts in the ancient CQ thread RC provided a link to! :jaw-dropp

You'll find that Sol88 strenuously resisted answering any questions on this; specifically, he rubbished the very idea that someone could even ask for the (detailed) reasoning (and calculations, etc) behind the prediction. IOW, about as clear an example of virulent anti-science as you could ever ask for.

One person over at CQ (Vander_L) did at least try to address this (well, the larger questions about where Thornhill's "predictions" came from, in terms of known physics), but Sol88 would have none of it.

Yet another reason for closing this thread, or at least moving it to somewhere that nothing to do with science ...

Yes, it was all to do with the comet supposedly being charged, and then discharging to the incoming impactor. He even stressed that "Copious X-rays will accompany discharges to the projectile,..."*. This is still on the TB site as a successful prediction! What Thornie didn't tell his acolytes was that Chandra and SWIFT were monitoring the comet around the time of impact, and saw zilch in x-ray, until some seconds after impact, and these were soft x-rays, at a level consistent with the freshly produced vapour CXing with the solar wind;

Chandra observations of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact campaign
Lisse, C. M. et al.
http://ftp.astro.umd.edu/pub/lisse/xrays/final_proof_YICAR8214_cml_comments_18jul2007.pdf

SWIFT X-RAY TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Willingale, R. et al.
https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/publist/Willingale_ApJ_649_541_2006.pdf

And, not only did his electrical flash fail to happen, but he wasn't even the first to predict a double flash! That was done by Pete Schultz at the NASA Ames gun lab, following impact experiments;

In this scenario (and in Scenario 1b), a three-component plume should be observed in the MRI and may allow the identification of this surface property.
i.T = 0.06 s (first frame): very weak flash.
ii.T = 1s (~17 frames): high-angle jet-like plasma plume due to cavitation and redirection back out the penetration funnel.
iii.T=1 to 20s: opaque spherical cloud forming a shadow above the
comet surface.
iv.T = 20 s to 100 s: high-angle ejecta plume extending >
10 km above the surface surrounded by a high-angle (~60?) ejecta curtain.
v.T > 200 s: advancing annulus of disturbed cometary surface near the
crater as low-velocity components return. High-angle central plume
may detach from the crater due to collapse and shut off of deep ejecta

EXPECTATIONS FOR CRATER SIZE AND PHOTOMETRIC EVOLUTION FROM THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Schultz, P. H. et al.
https://pds-smallbodies.astro.umd.e...ience_reviews/crater_size_evolutn_schultz.pdf

(Received 20 Aug 2004, accepted 10 Jan 2005)

* https://www.thunderbolts.info/tpod/2005/arch05/050704predictions.htm
 
Thanks, jd, you spotted an ambiguity I didn't catch. I meant it was the foundation that sustains the EC; if all else fails they invoke a CT that can't be disproven. But your interpretation is the one most people would assume.

Thanks for the history lesson. You filled in some gaps in my understanding of how the EC got to its present lamentable and laughable state.

Yes, it is all very weird stuff. Most of what I know about the history of it comes from Tim Thompson, who was battling these loons since the 90's.
Here is a copy of a newsgroup confrontation between Tim and the loon Thornhill, from 1998;

http://www.tim-thompson.com/grey-areas.html

Although there have been excellent debunkings of this lunacy from Tom Bridgman and Brian Koberlein, among others, nobody gave them a kicking like Tim used to, IMHO :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom