The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insanity about mainstream comets irrelevant to his demented cult's dogma about comets.

Sol8's usual insanity, lies about mainstream working science and insane lies abut his demented cults dogma. Sol8's electric comet insanity is a set of ignorant delusions. Sol88's cult has similar delusions about how stellar systems form.

The Nebular hypothesis uses the real universe and working physics to show how stellar systems are created from the collapse of gas clouds.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insanity about mainstream comets irrelevant to his demented cult's dogma about comets.

Sol88's usual insane lies about clear English.
Rock comet
A rock comet is a rare type of small Solar System body that exhibits features of both a comet and an asteroid, mainly in that it outgasses material primarily made up of grains of rock.
Rock comets, unlike other comets, which outgas primarily ice, have a nucleus made of rock. As a result, their outgassing can be unpredictable.
We have found 2 of these objects. Their mainly dust outgassing are explained by real physics. Sol88 insiatiy is that all comets are these rare objects.
 
You really are dense, aren't you? The electrons are not being accelerated. The ions are. The effect of the field is to maintain quasi-neutrality. So, any claims that negatively charged anything are being ACCELERATED is plain wrong, and stupid into the bargain. Learn to read.

We agree the dust is negatively charged as per, 4.5 Charged Dust I hope?

Anywhoo



With the help of the simulations it is possible to study effects of isolated processes, as demonstrated above, or a special combination of two or more processes on the dust outflow behaviour. This can help in the future with the differentiation between processes at work in the “acceleration region” where we observe deviations from 1j/r outflow behaviour. By studying effects of sublimation or fragmentation in the same manner as we studied the effects of acceleration on the azimuthal average in this paper it can help to determine the specific scale lengths of physical processes and thereby with the interpretation of results from data analysis.

On deviations from free-radial outflow in the inner coma of comet 67P



Reckon there’s your problem :rolleyes:

Sublimation, needs ice(volatiles) last I heard. Not the ice over on Tempel 1but the ice we don’t see at 67P. :blush:

As for the rest of it, the dust and suprathermal seem to be doing some things jonesdave116 says cannot happen because the ambipolar electric fields sign is the wrong way?

So what’s missing jd116?
 
Last edited:
We agree the dust is negatively charged as per, 4.5 Charged Dust I hope?

Anywhoo





On deviations from free-radial outflow in the inner coma of comet 67P



Reckon there’s your problem :rolleyes:

Sublimation, needs ice(volatiles) last I heard. Not the ice over on Tempel 1but the ice we don’t see at 67P. :blush:

As for the rest of it, the dust and suprathermal seem to be doing some things jonesdave116 says cannot happen because the ambipolar electric fields sign is the wrong way?

So what’s missing jd116?

Oh dear. More lies and idiocy! The ice at Tempel 1 killed your woo in 2005. Why are you still here? And ice is most definitely observed at 67P, so you can quit with the lying. And I just explained, in terms a 12 year old could understand, why the ambipolar field cannot accelerate dust. And no, why would it be all be charged that close to the nucleus? And much of it is far too massive to be affected by an electric field. Especially one that is pointed the wrong way! Lern to scienz.
You are the one with the problems - no science, no mechanisms, no evidence. A 'model' that has failed 100%. Deal with it, instead of continually displaying your ignorance on here.

Oh, and no ice = no suprathermal electrons. They are not of solar wind origin, so where are you getting them from? Duh!
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

So what’s missing jd116?
The answer as it has been for years is: Any relevance to Sol88's demented cult's dogma of electric comets :jaw-dropp!

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insane lies about no ice found at comets.
Sol88's usual insane lies about mainstream ices and dust comet papers.
Sol88's new insanity of editing a mainstream ices and dust comet paper.

On deviations from free-radial outflow in the inner coma of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
6. Discussion and conclusions
...
With the help of the simulations it is possible to study effects of isolated processes, as demonstrated above, or a special combination of two or more processes on the dust outflow behaviour. This can help in the future with the differentiation between processes at work in the “acceleration region” where we observe deviations from 1/r outflow behaviour. By studying effects of sublimation or fragmentation in the same manner as we studied the effects of acceleration on the azimuthal average in this paper it can help to determine the specific scale lengths of physical processes and thereby with the interpretation of results from data analysis.
This paper has 12 instances of the word sublimation! The paper is about the inner coma so this is sublimation of icy dust grains in the inner coma as explicitly stated in the abstract ("sublimation of icy dust particles after ejection from the surface").
 
Last edited:
Oh dear. More lies and idiocy! The ice at Tempel 1 killed your woo in 2005. Why are you still here? And ice is most definitely observed at 67P, so you can quit with the lying. And I just explained, in terms a 12 year old could understand, why the ambipolar field cannot accelerate dust. And no, why would it be all be charged that close to the nucleus? And much of it is far too massive to be affected by an electric field. Especially one that is pointed the wrong way! Lern to scienz.
You are the one with the problems - no science, no mechanisms, no evidence. A 'model' that has failed 100%. Deal with it, instead of continually displaying your ignorance on here.

Oh, and no ice = no suprathermal electrons. They are not of solar wind origin, so where are you getting them from? Duh!


They are not of solar wind origin, so where are you getting them from?

:D

Happily ignores
What's your take on ALICE and the detection that 67P is IMMERSED in a charged nano dust environment?

So simple even the 12yr old gets it!

You really do only have Tempel 1 as your defence, so so sad.

Anyway these raft of new papers going to really get your back up. That's my prediction.

Electron acceleration at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Cant happen can it jonesdave116?

and my absolute itching to read favorite; RPC-MIP observations at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko explained by a model including a sheath and two populations of electrons
G. Wattieaux, N. Gilet, P. Henri, X. Vallières, L. Bucciantini

Double layers here we come! :D

Real scienz here we come!
 
Last edited:
What's your take on ALICE and the detection that 67P is IMMERSED in a charged nano dust environment?

What the hell has that got to do with anything? Lol.We are talking about suprathermal electrons. Take a course in comprehension.

You really do only have Tempel 1 as your defence, so so sad

Liar. How many times are you going to lie? You are pathetic. Tempel 1 killed your woo. However, we have ice at Hartley 2, 67P, Catalina, Hale-Bopp, 17P Holmes, et al. I do not need a defence, woo boy. This is about the completely failed ec woo, which you are supposed to be defending, and can't, due to having no evidence, no science and no mechanisms. Your woo has failed. Get over it.

Anyway these raft of new papers going to really get your back up. That's my prediction.

And you have predicted nothing correctly so far, and do not have the qualifications, knowledge, nor intellect to understand the papers when they do come out. That is why you appear to be the only person left on the planet who is still conned by this woo.

Cant happen can it jonesdave116?

Liar. Read the literature. And I have never said any such thing. I said that your idiotic claim that an ambipolar field, pointing in the wrong direction, could accelerate electrons outward. Any idiot can see that. It isn't my fault that you can't. Like I said - you need to stay away from plasma physics, as you are totally out of your depth;

Double layers here we come!

Lol. Case in point.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insane lies about comets. We have detected ices around comets. Tempel 1 and 67P are where we have detected subsurface ices from Deep Impact and surface ices on Tempel 1 and 67P.

Sol88's usual insane lies abut double layers at comets.

Sol88's usual insults of astronomers who would never write a paper that states the impossibility of double layers at comets.
 
What the hell has that got to do with anything? Lol.We are talking about suprathermal electrons. Take a course in comprehension.



Liar. How many times are you going to lie? You are pathetic. Tempel 1 killed your woo. However, we have ice at Hartley 2, 67P, Catalina, Hale-Bopp, 17P Holmes, et al. I do not need a defence, woo boy. This is about the completely failed ec woo, which you are supposed to be defending, and can't, due to having no evidence, no science and no mechanisms. Your woo has failed. Get over it.



And you have predicted nothing correctly so far, and do not have the qualifications, knowledge, nor intellect to understand the papers when they do come out. That is why you appear to be the only person left on the planet who is still conned by this woo.



Liar. Read the literature. And I have never said any such thing. I said that your idiotic claim that an ambipolar field, pointing in the wrong direction, could accelerate electrons outward. Any idiot can see that. It isn't my fault that you can't. Like I said - you need to stay away from plasma physics, as you are totally out of your depth;



Lol. Case in point.

Just so we are clear, jonesdave116, there is a mechanism accelerating negatively charged dust and electrons off 67P’s surface?

Or

The ambipolar electric field points the wrong way and NO negatively charged dust or electrons can be accelerated off 67P’s nucleus?

Your kinda wishy washy again, jd116.

stay away from plasma physics, as you are totally out of your depth;
because the maths to hard for you?
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insanity of demented, irrelevant questions.

Sol88's usual insane lies about comets - no "negatively charged dust and electrons" have been detected being ejected from the surface of any comet :jaw-dropp. The mainstream mechanism proposed to eject ice and dust grains electrostatically only works before a shielding coma forms. Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data and other papers are about negatively charged dust and ice grains and electrons defected in the coma of 67P.

Sol88's usual insane lies about and insults of posters.
jonesdave116's post is about the demented dogma of electric comets and the abysmal ignorance that Sol88 is displaying: I said that your idiotic claim that an ambipolar field, pointing in the wrong direction, could accelerate electrons outward. Sol88 has been insanely ignorant of textbook physics for maybe decades, e.g. the several ways that comet density is measured to be less than water and much less than asteroids that his demented cult's electric comet insiatiy demands. It is Sol88 that needs to stay away from all physics [and mathematics and even basic arithmetic (0.6 is not 3.0!)], as he is totally out of his depth.

Sol88's idiocy also includes that any elections are accelerated outward. Rosetta detected low, medium and high energy electrons, not what directions they were going.
As jonesdave116 has stated many times, Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data states that an ambipolar electric field accelerates electrons inward.
The suprathermal electron distribution can have solar wind origin or can be produced by photoionization, or it can be accelerated inward through various processes such as ambipolar electric field.
...
5 Ambipolar Electric Field and Quasi‐neutrality
... External solar wind electrons are accelerated inward (roughly toward the nucleus) by this potential structure and have their energies enhanced by ~ eΔVpol. The motional electric field (E = ue × B) contribution to E from the GOL is also undoubtedly altered from its unperturbed solar wind value by the interaction with the comet.
 
Last edited:
Just so we are clear, jonesdave116, there is a mechanism accelerating negatively charged dust and electrons off 67P’s surface?

Or

The ambipolar electric field points the wrong way and NO negatively charged dust or electrons can be accelerated off 67P’s nucleus?

Your kinda wishy washy again, jd116.

stay away from plasma physics, as you are totally out of your depth;
because the maths to hard for you?

Huh? The dust is mostly uncharged! It is lifted from the surface by the sublimating volatiles! Dust can become charged in the coma. If it has very little mass, and a reasonable charge, it can then be accelerated by the solar wind electric field. It cannot be accelerated by an ambipolar field that is retarding electrons!
Ditto, the electrons are not being accelerated from the surface by an electric field! Due to them not existing. They are electrons that have been knocked off of the neutrals that are the sublimation products, mostly water and carbon dioxide, as they reach the coma due to photo-ionisation for the most part. Which leaves (mostly) neutrals, with some percentage of ions and electrons. And then you get into the complicated stuff as described by Deca and others. The electrons created are escaping more rapidly than the ions. This cannot happen if quasi-neutrality is to be maintained. Therefore an ambipolar field springs into existence, which acts to retard the electrons and accelerate the ions, thereby maintaining quasi-neutrality. Simples. At least I thought it was!
 
^^^^

Cheers Jonesdave116.

Clears that up, now for the new papers, see who's on the money.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's insanity that any new mainstream ices and dust comet papers will support his demented cult's electric comet dogma.

Sol88's usual lies about posts - jonesdave116 explained why Sol88's posts about comets were deluded, e.g. dust becomes charged in the coma, not a delusion of on the surface.
 
Last edited:
^^^

If you say so...

4 Conclusions

We performed simple simulation of Philae on 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko using generic parameters for the comet composition that would have to be re.ned using the results of the ongoing experiments to accurately model the environment of Philae. Nonetheless, our purpose was to investigate the e.ect of the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on their interaction with Philae. We showed that even if the dominant dust production mechanism is the ejection of neutral dust caused by the sublimation of volatile material in the soil, the subsequent charging of the dust increased the dust collection by about an order of magnitude. This is an important e.ect that should be taken into account to interpret Philae's dust measurements.
SIMULATION OF THE ELECTROSTATIC CHARGING OF PHILAE ON 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO AND OF ITS INTERACTION WITH THE DUSTS.


for context
It is lifted from the surface by the sublimating volatiles! Dust can become charged in the coma.
jonesdave116
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's insanity that the spacecraft Philae was a comet :jaw-dropp!

Sol88's usual insane lies about science - there is none of his cult's demented dogma on comets in that paper.

Sol88's usual insane lies abut posts. jonesdave116 was correct and supported by this paper. Dust is lifted by sublimation ("soil outgassing"). That dust is charged in the coma ("the dust grains charge electrostatically in the ambient plasma"). The paper has 2 additional mainstream mechanisms of "micro-meteorite impacts" and "electrostatic charging".

Simulation of the electrostatic charging of Philae on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and of its interaction with the dusts.
ROSETTA's probe Philae landed on a dust covered soil. This dust may be ejected from the ground through many mechanisms (other than spacecraft landing) : micro-meteorite impacts, electrostatic charging and soil outgassing. In any cases, the dust grains charge electrostatically in the ambient plasma and this charge impacts the dust interaction with the spacecraft, which is itself differentially charged due to its partial exposure to the solar UV light. Using the DUST addition to the Spacecraft-Plasma Interaction Software (SPIS) routinely used to compute the charge state of the spacecraft surfaces, we simulate the electrostatic charging of Philae as well as its dust environment. SPIS-DUST allows one to compute the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on the ground and in the plasma, and to model their ejection and their recollection by the probe. We simulated one cometary day of the Philae environment at different distances from the sun to observe the variation of the dust collection with Philae's local time.
This is Philae being charged by the solar wind, dust grains being charged by UV light and a simulation of the resulting interaction that collected dust on Philae.
 
Last edited:
Glad that clears that up. :rolleyes:


Philae is a comet... :D


Good one rc.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom