The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mostly ice or mostly consolidated refractory dust?

Nothing to do with your failed woo. That says no ice, and planetary rock. The Tempel 1 impact blew a hole in the comet that shows it not to be rock. As do subsequent observations. It also ejected thousands of tonnes of solid ice. Game over. 4th July 2005. Why are you still here?
 
An obviously insane delusion from Sol88 about a paper on field draping at 67P

Good to see another paper confirming some of my prediction.
Sol88's demented cult's electric comet dogma has no predictions, just ~50 year old fantasies with added insane delusions.

Sol88 is so insanely ignorant about physics that Sol88 cannot make any predictions by himself. Sol88 has over a decade of pathetic "drinking in the Kool-Aid" of his cult but anyone who knows any physics sees that the cult is insane about comets. Sol88 has been spewing out insane delusions about textbook physics, e.g. an insane delusion that there are double layers at comets (turbulence makes them impossible, Debye length makes his lies about seeing them insanely ignorant). Sol88's persistent insanity that writing "electric field" is a prediction. etc.

What makes Sol88's delusion insane is that we can search this thread for 'draping 67P' :jaw-dropp! That finds no predictions from Sol88.
 
Well pretty simple really. Comets are a electrical/plasma phenomena.

So I EXPECT your paper to contain confirmation of this FACT.

So we’ll see.
 
Well pretty simple really. Comets are a electrical/plasma phenomena.

So I EXPECT your paper to contain confirmation of this FACT.

So we’ll see.
 
Well pretty simple really. Comets are a electrical/plasma phenomena.

So I EXPECT your paper to contain confirmation of this FACT.

So we’ll see.

Lol. Why? Why aren't asteroids an 'electrical/ plasma phenomenon'? Whatever the hell that is.
You need a radial electric field from the Sun. Impossible, and never measured. You need elliptical orbits within the non-existent field to cause electrical woo. But only at comets, and not at highly eccentric asteroids.
You need EDM (lol). Didn't happen. Cannot happen.
You need the jets to be discharges (lol). They demonstrably aren't.
You need the light from the cometary coma to be a glow discharge! (double lol). It isn't. Just sunlight reflected from dust (and sometimes ice).
You need the comet to have been blasted off a planet. It demonstrably is not. No rock anywhere to be seen.
You need no ice. There is tonnes of it.
You need the solar wind to make OH, which scientists can then mistake for H2O. Despite knowing that it most definitely is H2O since 1986.

That is what counts as a complete and utter failure. A failure that you haven't dealt with. And cannot deal with, due to it being not being based on any valid science - merely the mythology-based ramblings of scientifically illiterate Velikovskians. It is not now, nor ever has been, anything to do with science.
 
Lol. Why? Why aren't asteroids an 'electrical/ plasma phenomenon'? Whatever the hell that is.
You need a radial electric field from the Sun. Impossible, and never measured. You need elliptical orbits within the non-existent field to cause electrical woo. But only at comets, and not at highly eccentric asteroids.
You need EDM (lol). Didn't happen. Cannot happen.
You need the jets to be discharges (lol). They demonstrably aren't.
You need the light from the cometary coma to be a glow discharge! (double lol). It isn't. Just sunlight reflected from dust (and sometimes ice).
You need the comet to have been blasted off a planet. It demonstrably is not. No rock anywhere to be seen.
You need no ice. There is tonnes of it.
You need the solar wind to make OH, which scientists can then mistake for H2O. Despite knowing that it most definitely is H2O since 1986.

That is what counts as a complete and utter failure. A failure that you haven't dealt with. And cannot deal with, due to it being not being based on any valid science - merely the mythology-based ramblings of scientifically illiterate Velikovskians. It is not now, nor ever has been, anything to do with science.
You cannot hide the fact that, like Sol88, these folks are actually anti-science, not pseudoscience. Their goal is to replace science with worship of the Thunderbolt Gods. :p
 
Lol. Why? Why aren't asteroids an 'electrical/ plasma phenomenon'? Whatever the hell that is.
You need a radial electric field from the Sun. Impossible, and never measured. You need elliptical orbits within the non-existent field to cause electrical woo. But only at comets, and not at highly eccentric asteroids.
You need EDM (lol). Didn't happen. Cannot happen.
You need the jets to be discharges (lol). They demonstrably aren't.
You need the light from the cometary coma to be a glow discharge! (double lol). It isn't. Just sunlight reflected from dust (and sometimes ice).
You need the comet to have been blasted off a planet. It demonstrably is not. No rock anywhere to be seen.
You need no ice. There is tonnes of it.
You need the solar wind to make OH, which scientists can then mistake for H2O. Despite knowing that it most definitely is H2O since 1986.

That is what counts as a complete and utter failure. A failure that you haven't dealt with. And cannot deal with, due to it being not being based on any valid science - merely the mythology-based ramblings of scientifically illiterate Velikovskians. It is not now, nor ever has been, anything to do with science.

New papers baby new papers.

Even A’Hearn was evolving.

You’re stuck in the past.

The future is the electric comet.

We have rock, we have electric fields, we have electric currents.
 
New papers baby new papers.

Even A’Hearn was evolving.

You’re stuck in the past.

The future is the electric comet.

We have rock, we have electric fields, we have electric currents.

Nope, you have precisely nothing. You don't need fields or currents. I outlined what you need. You failed. If you believe otherwise, point to the detections of rock, EDM (lol), discharges, glow discharges, solar wind that went missing for 8 months creating OH, radial electric fields, eccentric asteroids outgassing H2O, etc, etc. You have nothing. No papers give any support whatsoever to your impossible, unscientific woo. They falsified it long before Rosetta got to 67P. You just didn't know that because your high priests conveniently forgot to mention them!
A decade and a half, and still batting zero. Some achievement that!
 
je suis venu te dire que je m'en vais

cute, how you think you know the content of non-published papers, though

Unusually high magnetic fields in the coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko during its high-activity phase

When does the paper get released?


Poor jonesy still in denial.

Can’t even engage me on the suprathermal electron population at 67P.
 
Nope, you have precisely nothing. You don't need fields or currents. I outlined what you need. You failed. If you believe otherwise, point to the detections of rock, EDM (lol), discharges, glow discharges, solar wind that went missing for 8 months creating OH, radial electric fields, eccentric asteroids outgassing H2O, etc, etc. You have nothing. No papers give any support whatsoever to your impossible, unscientific woo. They falsified it long before Rosetta got to 67P. You just didn't know that because your high priests conveniently forgot to mention them!
A decade and a half, and still batting zero. Some achievement that!


Do you even know what a suprathermal electron is, jonesdave116?

:rolleyes:


What’s giving them the energy to leave the potential well?
 
Unusually high magnetic fields in the coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko during its high-activity phase

When does the paper get released?


Poor jonesy still in denial.

Can’t even engage me on the suprathermal electron population at 67P.

What is the point? You do not understand the science, and it has nothing to do with the complete failure of your woo. As pointed out above. And numerous other times. This thread is about the dumb electric comet nonsense. It has demonstrably failed. That is what you need to deal with. Why do you still believe this after the lies of Thornhill were exposed at Tempel 1? Thousands of tonnes of ice ejected, and a surface that is quite obviously not rock. And his lies about H2O were exposed 20 years before he wrote his fiction, by the findings at Halley by the KAO, Vega and Giotto? How is it possible to have not known about these things before making stupid claims that there was no ice, no H2O, and the comet was composed of rock? How is it possible to be conned by the claim of the solar wind creating OH, when it was known since 1986 that the solar wind wasn't even reaching the nucleus?
In short, how much ignorance of the subject is necessary in order to believe in the scientifically impossible, mythology-based nonsense that is the electric comet? And why on Earth would anybody with even a rudimentary knowledge of the subject area believe such idiocy? After all, no scientists have contributed to this execrable nonsense.
 
Certainly not an ambipolar field that is pointed in the wrong direction! Lern to scienz.

Point is you don’t know? Or that you just contradicted yourself?

Can the electrons escape the ambipolar electric field or not jonesdave116?

Or are you stating NO electrons can escape the ambipolar electric field?

Do you even know what you are talking about or just out for a troll?

Do you even know scienz outside the dogma of the Dirtysnowball model?

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
What is the point? You do not understand the science, and it has nothing to do with the complete failure of your woo. As pointed out above. And numerous other times. This thread is about the dumb electric comet nonsense. It has demonstrably failed. That is what you need to deal with. Why do you still believe this after the lies of Thornhill were exposed at Tempel 1? Thousands of tonnes of ice ejected, and a surface that is quite obviously not rock. And his lies about H2O were exposed 20 years before he wrote his fiction, by the findings at Halley by the KAO, Vega and Giotto? How is it possible to have not known about these things before making stupid claims that there was no ice, no H2O, and the comet was composed of rock? How is it possible to be conned by the claim of the solar wind creating OH, when it was known since 1986 that the solar wind wasn't even reaching the nucleus?
In short, how much ignorance of the subject is necessary in order to believe in the scientifically impossible, mythology-based nonsense that is the electric comet? And why on Earth would anybody with even a rudimentary knowledge of the subject area believe such idiocy? After all, no scientists have contributed to this execrable nonsense.

:D

comet was composed of rock? No comets are mostly rock not composed of it. There composed mainly of vacuum.

(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].


I didn’t say it, Michael F. A’Hearn did. I thought he had written many more peer reviewed papers than me.

Seems both you and rc get your knickers all bunched up every time he says rock?
 
Last edited:
Certainly not an ambipolar field that is pointed in the wrong direction! Lern to scienz.

That’s not fair. We all know that Sol88 cannot.

But that’s not the point ... he’s not here to discuss science; he’s here to promote anti-science! :p
 
That’s not fair. We all know that Sol88 cannot.

But that’s not the point ... he’s not here to discuss science; he’s here to promote anti-science! :p

are you more cleverer than jonesy?

Suprathermal electrons, GO.

:rolleyes:

Jonesdave116 says no electrons/negatively charged dust can leave the nucleus therefore no stoopid electric comet.

But we observe and measure this very fact that jonesdave116 seems completely oblivious too.

The dust arrives in bursts or showers, how, if nothing negatively charged at all can escape the nucleus???? Very confusing.

:D
 
Last edited:
Point is you don’t know? Or that you just contradicted yourself?

Can the electrons escape the ambipolar electric field or not jonesdave116?

Or are you stating NO electrons can escape the ambipolar electric field?

Do you even know what you are talking about or just out for a troll?

Do you even know scienz outside the dogma of the Dirtysnowball model?

:rolleyes:

Oh dear! I've told you before - leave this plasma physics stuff alone. You are out of your depth. Of course they can bloody escape! What would happen if they didn't? The field would reverse, and electrons would be accelerated and ions retarded! How difficult can this be?
What is the charge on a cold electron? What is the charge on a suprathermal electron? Where do the suprathermal electrons come from? Hint; not the solar wind.
Until you have even a basic understanding of the subject, there is no point having any discussion about it. I would suggest lifting the veil of your undoubted ignorance by starting with this paper;

Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/2016JA022610

In particular, sections 5 & 6. If you can't understand that, then there is no hope for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom