The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
:D

comet was composed of rock? No comets are mostly rock not composed of it. There They're composed mainly of vacuum.




I didn’t say it, Michael F. A’Hearn did. I thought he had written many more peer reviewed papers than me.

Seems both you and rc get your knickers all bunched up every time he says rock?

There is no rock at comets. Never seen. Please point to the detection. What was it? Granite? Sandstone? Basalt? Lol.
 
:D

comet was composed of rock? No comets are mostly rock not composed of it. There composed mainly of vacuum.




I didn’t say it, Michael F. A’Hearn did. I thought he had written many more peer reviewed papers than me.

Seems both you and rc get your knickers all bunched up every time he says rock?


Let's have a look at the abstract of the A'Hearn review paper Sol seems to quote at least once every page:

Abstract

We outline the key questions about comets that must be answered in order to understand cometary formation in the context of the protoplanetary disc and the role of comets in the formation and evolution of the solar system. We then discuss the new understanding of comets from Rosetta and from other recent advances, including work presented by others at the discussion meeting. Finally, we suggest some key directions for future projects to better address the above questions.
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2016.0261


Uh, oh! Seems A'Hearn thinks comets formed when there were no planets from which magic lightning bolts could blast chunks! And he thinks planets formed from a protoplanetary disc---EC heresy!

The review paper, as jonesdave has pointed out previously, is a review paper, not primary literature, and as such may or may not have been peer-reviewed; maybe someone here knows. Regardless, it was written by a comet scientist for other comet scientists, all of whom know from the scientific evidence that comets comprise refractory dust, not rock in the conventional meaning. A'Hearn did not anticipate (or worry about) woomongers misrepresenting his use of the term to promote their anti-science views.

As I said, jonesdave has pointed out all the above on a number of occasions and Sol will no doubt obfuscate, misrepresent or simply ignore this once again. The boat that is the electric comet idea sank immediately upon launch; I find it amusing that Sol clings desperately to what he thinks is a wooden plank when he actually has a death grip on the anchor.
 
How many times? Can you not read? Are you completely ignorant of all things scientific? Which way is the putative ambipolar field pointing? Will that accelerate negatively charged anything away from the comet? Really, how many times is it going to have to be pointed out to you before you understand? Seriously, I could have explained this to a 12 year old, just once, and the twelve year old would have got it. Why can't you? Never studied science, have you? Or maths. Or much of anything, as far as I can see.
jonedave116

Oh dear! I've told you before - leave this plasma physics stuff alone. You are out of your depth. Of course they can bloody escape! What would happen if they didn't? The field would reverse, and electrons would be accelerated and ions retarded! How difficult can this be?
What is the charge on a cold electron? What is the charge on a suprathermal electron? Where do the suprathermal electrons come from? Hint; not the solar wind.
Until you have even a basic understanding of the subject, there is no point having any discussion about it. I would suggest lifting the veil of your undoubted ignorance by starting with this paper;

Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/2016JA022610

In particular, sections 5 & 6. If you can't understand that, then there is no hope for you.



Oh, so now they can escape, along with the negatively charged dust in the jets they arrive in burst and showers. .

I mean I never doubted it but jonesdave116.... trolling happily.

So I’m glad we’ve cleared that, ay jonesdave116 :rolleyes:

Both negative AND positive can come from the nucleus.

How jonesdave116, using your electrostatic pithball model?

:D
 
Last edited:
Let's have a look at the abstract of the A'Hearn review paper Sol seems to quote at least once every page:


https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2016.0261


Uh, oh! Seems A'Hearn thinks comets formed when there were no planets from which magic lightning bolts could blast chunks! And he thinks planets formed from a protoplanetary disc---EC heresy!

The review paper, as jonesdave has pointed out previously, is a review paper, not primary literature, and as such may or may not have been peer-reviewed; maybe someone here knows. Regardless, it was written by a comet scientist for other comet scientists, all of whom know from the scientific evidence that comets comprise refractory dust, not rock in the conventional meaning. A'Hearn did not anticipate (or worry about) woomongers misrepresenting his use of the term to promote their anti-science views.

As I said, jonesdave has pointed out all the above on a number of occasions and Sol will no doubt obfuscate, misrepresent or simply ignore this once again. The boat that is the electric comet idea sank immediately upon launch; I find it amusing that Sol clings desperately to what he thinks is a wooden plank when he actually has a death grip on the anchor.


Ahhh, the old nebular collapse theory. Of course the ELECTRIC COMET call this into question.


So the Dirtysnowball is alive and well ferd?

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].


:D


We are evolving towards comets being mostly ROCK.

not dust, not ice but ROCK.

:D

Nice try though. Time to circle the wagons again.
 
Let's have a look at the abstract of the A'Hearn review paper Sol seems to quote at least once every page:


https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2016.0261


Uh, oh! Seems A'Hearn thinks comets formed when there were no planets from which magic lightning bolts could blast chunks! And he thinks planets formed from a protoplanetary disc---EC heresy!

The review paper, as jonesdave has pointed out previously, is a review paper, not primary literature, and as such may or may not have been peer-reviewed; maybe someone here knows. Regardless, it was written by a comet scientist for other comet scientists, all of whom know from the scientific evidence that comets comprise refractory dust, not rock in the conventional meaning. A'Hearn did not anticipate (or worry about) woomongers misrepresenting his use of the term to promote their anti-science views.

As I said, jonesdave has pointed out all the above on a number of occasions and Sol will no doubt obfuscate, misrepresent or simply ignore this once again. The boat that is the electric comet idea sank immediately upon launch; I find it amusing that Sol clings desperately to what he thinks is a wooden plank when he actually has a death grip on the anchor.

So, you seem pretty cluey sport. Whats your take on The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

In particular
not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of volitiles.

Which is very much what A'Hearn was say in our understanding evolving towards mostly ROCK.

(c) What are comets made of?
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].


So....Comet's minerals hint at liquid water, Scientists Gaining Clearer Picture of Comet Makeup and Origin, Composition of a Comet Poses a Puzzle for Scientists, Science NASA's crash comet made of clay

Got some more...
 
Last edited:
Ahh, I see what A'Hearn meant now.

Rock comet

Rock comets, unlike other comets, which outgas primarily ice, have a nucleus made of rock. As a result, their outgassing can be unpredictable.

Not the dirtysnowball MOSTLY ice comet but these new MOSTLY rock comets.
 
Let's have a look at the abstract of the A'Hearn review paper Sol seems to quote at least once every page:


https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2016.0261


Uh, oh! Seems A'Hearn thinks comets formed when there were no planets from which magic lightning bolts could blast chunks! And he thinks planets formed from a protoplanetary disc---EC heresy!

The review paper, as jonesdave has pointed out previously, is a review paper, not primary literature, and as such may or may not have been peer-reviewed; maybe someone here knows. Regardless, it was written by a comet scientist for other comet scientists, all of whom know from the scientific evidence that comets comprise refractory dust, not rock in the conventional meaning. A'Hearn did not anticipate (or worry about) woomongers misrepresenting his use of the term to promote their anti-science views.

As I said, jonesdave has pointed out all the above on a number of occasions and Sol will no doubt obfuscate, misrepresent or simply ignore this once again. The boat that is the electric comet idea sank immediately upon launch; I find it amusing that Sol clings desperately to what he thinks is a wooden plank when he actually has a death grip on the anchor.

Abstract

We outline the key questions about comets that must be answered in order to understand cometary formation in the context of the protoplanetary disc and the role of comets in the formation and evolution of the solar system. We then discuss the new understanding of comets from Rosetta and from other recent advances, including work presented by others at the discussion meeting. Finally, we suggest some key directions for future projects to better address the above questions.

Ah the square peg mainstream are trying to bang into a round hole! :rolleyes:

Maybe the model of the formation of the solar system should be revisited?

;)
 
jonedave116





Oh, so now they can escape, along with the negatively charged dust in the jets they arrive in burst and showers. .

I mean I never doubted it but jonesdave116.... trolling happily.

So I’m glad we’ve cleared that, ay jonesdave116 :rolleyes:

Both negative AND positive can come from the nucleus.

How jonesdave116, using your electrostatic pithball model?

:D

You really are dense, aren't you? The electrons are not being accelerated. The ions are. The effect of the field is to maintain quasi-neutrality. So, any claims that negatively charged anything are being ACCELERATED is plain wrong, and stupid into the bargain. Learn to read.
 
Ahhh, the old nebular collapse theory. Of course the ELECTRIC COMET call this into question.


So the Dirtysnowball is alive and well ferd?




:D


We are evolving towards comets being mostly ROCK.

not dust, not ice but ROCK.

:D

Nice try though. Time to circle the wagons again.

How many times, woo boy? Where is this rock? Show me the papers where it has been detected. Stop lying.
 
Ah the square peg mainstream are trying to bang into a round hole! :rolleyes:

Maybe the model of the formation of the solar system should be revisited?

;)

No need to revisit it. We can see it in action around other stars. The fine details are interesting, and there is still much to learn. The fact that planets form from disks of gas and dust around stars is observed. Learn some science. And then go away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom