The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Neutral atoms of h2o!
As he has been told hundreds of times: Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

The presence of neutral H2O supports the mainstream ices and dust comet

The presence of neutral H2O does not make comets into rock blasted from rocky planets by electric discharges between planets or the rest of the insanity of the electric comet. Deluded fantasies that make no actual predictions about H2O at comets or anything abut comets.
When the deluded authors try to make predictions for Deep Impact, they lie about them being confirmed for 14 years :eye-poppi!
When the deluded authors try to make predictions for Rosetta and 67P, they make up lies and delusions that have been on their blog for almost 5 years :jaw-dropp!
From 29 July 2014
  1. A lie of a confirmed "spectacular, sharply ‘spark machined’ surface" prediction.
    This is 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko with varied terrains of dusty plains, cliffs, pits, craters, etc.
    No evidence of the insane delusion of a ‘spark machined’ surface.
  2. A "“sublimating ices” model of comets would predict" lie about the surface.
    Varied terrains of dusty plains, cliffs, pits, craters, etc. is whet the mainstream ices and dust model predicts and found on visited comets such as Tempel 1 (the Deep Impact mission they lie about).
  3. Abysmal ignorance of relying on "published artistic visualizations" of 67P.
  4. An unexpected "double-lobed form of the nucleus, similar to the observed forms of so many comets and asteroids" lie.
    We know of 69 asteroids, 8 trans-Neptunian objects, and 6 comets that may be contact binaries. 67P is definitely "double-lobed". 19P is more peanut shaped. Contact binaries are not unexpected in mainstream astronomy. The mainstream has physically valid mechanisms to form them. Asteroids are irrelevant to real comets but does emphasize the electric comet insanity.
  5. A vague "none expects substantial water-ice either on or below the surface of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko" delusion.
    Of course, deluded and ignorant people will make up vague fantasies about comets! In the real world, "substantial" water-ice was detected the surface of 67P. Detecting the daughter products of sublimating water-ices is evidence of "substantial" water-ices below the .surface of 67P.
  6. A lie that Rosetta should find "subsurface ice at the sources of the jets".
    Rosetta could not magically look through surface layers to subsurface ices. Rosetta data could be used to trace jets back to areas. We were lucky enough to image jets emerging from the sides of pits.
  7. A lie that Rosetta could detect interstellar dust.
  8. A lie that Rosetta could detect "minerals on the nucleus that are typical of planetary surfaces".
  9. A delusion of "plasma jet activity".
  10. A delusion of "Measurable retreat of active cliff regions in the wake of this activity"
  11. A delusion of "unexpected electric fields within the coma".
  12. An insane delusion of these electric fields disrupting the lander and a "diffuse plasma discharge".
 
Last edited:
Yawn...

Dude you are still busy whith Whipple’s 1950’s model :deadhorse

Seems strange because in your above post you harp on about the Dirtysnowball and electric fields/currents/double layers like they where just an over sight by Whipple and you can just slip them in down the back where no one will notice. :confused: :mad:

In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear. While activity from “cliffs” has been observed by Rosetta (Vincent et al. 2016a;Pajolaetal.2017b), it remains difficult to prove that it dominates the emission.
Cometary Dust

No longer tenable. :boggled:

I happened to going thru this paper today after reading The footprint of cometary dust analogues: II. Morphology as a tracer of tensile strength and application to dust collection by the Rosetta spacecraft L. E. Ellerbroek1, B. Gundlach2, A. Landeck2, C. Dominik1, J. Blum2, S. Merouane3, M. Hilchenbach3, H. John3 H. A. van Veen4

With Blum in the mix, I thought, this should be a quality paper...:confused: :(

Ummmmm....why no mention the dust is charged as per
4 Physical Properties of Dust Particles 4.1 Morphology

The morphology of dust particles describes their structure and shape and how these emerge from the characteristics of the particle’s components. It is crucial to investigate as it is a key property to understand basic parameters of comets, such as porosity, strength and thermal properties.

And

4.5 Charged Dust

The amount of electric charge collected by fluffy and sub-µ m dust particles affects their motion in comae and tails and their lifetime against electrostatic fragmentation. The Rosetta mission provided the first direct evidence for the presence of electrically charged dust particles in a coma.

This means that in the solar wind a particle of 1 µm size can have about 10^4 extra electrons. Based on our experience with mesospheric dust charging at Earth it can be assumed that most of the extra electrons are deep inside the dust particle and they can electrostatically disrupt fluffy, highly friable dust particles (Hill and Mendis 1981). An updated version (Mendis and Horányi 2013)predicts that a 10−19 kg particle can be electrostatically disrupted if its tensile strength is less than about 0.5 MPa.

Don’t these people talk?

Each to important?
 
Last edited:
How the actual **** is this still going? Seriously, can the mods put this nonsense out of its misery? The only EC proponent is going round and round in circles without a hint of ever learning a thing. Good grief. Four threads, heading to a fifth, and we're still getting ridiculous posts like "mostly rock then?" as though it hasn't been thoroughly addressed thousands of times already.

Just a hit and run then, jond?

Got a ripper for you to put me out of my misery, as the only ELECTRIC COMET proponent here.

However, this assumption is surprisingly simple to challenge.


So let’s challenge it, ay?

In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear. While activity from “cliffs” has been observed by Rosetta (Vincent et al. 2016a;Pajolaetal.2017b), it remains difficult to prove that it dominates the emission. The relationship of the uppermost (optically visible) surface to icy material just below the surface and the means of releasing the dust component remains a subject of speculation. Outburst phenomena are of interest as a means of lifting large chunks of material but it appears proven that the outbursts observed and quantified at 67P/C-G do not dominate the total visible particle emission of the comet. The exact mechanism is unknown and multiple mechanisms cannot be ruled out.
Cometary Dust

As spelled out here

Again...

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Away out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Whipple’s model is the most common model. The Dirtysnowball.

Got some problems, fatal for the model and even the crusaders here say the same but .... stick to it like flys on poo.

Why?

That’s why it goes round and round with no end...

:rolleyes:

Comets are not mostly ice with sublimation as the main driver for gas and dust release...the Dirtysnowball.

This is the mainstream model that most scientists are trying to fit to the latest data.

The other pseudo scientific model is the ELECTRIC COMET model.

This has comets as mostly rock with electrical forces as the dominant gas and dust release.
 
Last edited:
PS

this is not terrestrial rock but cometary rock, where the bulk density of the nucleus is half that of water...


But interestingly, the charged dust we observe and measure, comming from the nucleus is closer to that of terrestrial rocks density.

Anywhoo, there is tons and tons of ice down there somewhere, as I’m sure jonesdave116 can tell you, this ice I assume is similar to terrestrial ice in its density of 1g/cm3, or there abouts.

You could listen to some crack pot non clever type, like me, or just go to a peer reviewed mainstream paper.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Implications you may ask? For who’s model, mainstream or electric comet?
 
Last edited:
Don’t know why jonesdave116 wastes his time of other forums trying to “defend” the mainstream, when he should concentrate has hard as he can here to stop the electric comet hypothesis becoming the new and surprising mainstream model of comets.

This in course would have to question the nebula collapse theory, one would wonder, which of in course entails the Sun being a thermonuclear bomb about half way through its rather unremarkable life.

And so on and so forth till, in the mainstream side of things, you run right up the clacker of a singularity.... ouch!
 
Don’t know why jonesdave116 wastes his time of other forums trying to “defend” the mainstream, when he should concentrate has hard as he can here to stop the electric comet hypothesis becoming the new and surprising mainstream model of comets.

There is no electric comet hypothesis. There is a bunch of totally debunked junk in a poster presentation. It fails. 100%.
 
PS

this is not terrestrial rock but cometary rock, where the bulk density of the nucleus is half that of water...


But interestingly, the charged dust we observe and measure, comming from the nucleus is closer to that of terrestrial rocks density.

Anywhoo, there is tons and tons of ice down there somewhere, as I’m sure jonesdave116 can tell you, this ice I assume is similar to terrestrial ice in its density of 1g/cm3, or there abouts.

You could listen to some crack pot non clever type, like me, or just go to a peer reviewed mainstream paper.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Implications you may ask? For who’s model, mainstream or electric comet?


There is no electric comet 'model'. Just a bunch of failed junk on a woo site. Supported only by scientifically illiterate wooists. No science, no mechanisms. No evidence.
And there is plenty of evidence for ice. You continually refuse to address it, as it contradicts your religious beliefs.
 
Just a hit and run then, jond?

Got a ripper for you to put me out of my misery, as the only ELECTRIC COMET proponent here.




So let’s challenge it, ay?

Cometary Dust

As spelled out here

Again...



Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Whipple’s model is the most common model. The Dirtysnowball.

Got some problems, fatal for the model and even the crusaders here say the same but .... stick to it like flys on poo.

Why?

That’s why it goes round and round with no end...

:rolleyes:

Comets are not mostly ice with sublimation as the main driver for gas and dust release...the Dirtysnowball.

This is the mainstream model that most scientists are trying to fit to the latest data.

The other pseudo scientific model is the ELECTRIC COMET model.

This has comets as mostly rock with electrical forces as the dominant gas and dust release.

More lies and strawmen. When lying is all you've got left, you know that you have lost.
 
Yawn...

Dude you are still busy whith Whipple’s 1950’s model :deadhorse

Seems strange because in your above post you harp on about the Dirtysnowball and electric fields/currents/double layers like they where just an over sight by Whipple and you can just slip them in down the back where no one will notice. :confused: :mad:

Cometary Dust

No longer tenable. :boggled:

I happened to going thru this paper today after reading The footprint of cometary dust analogues: II. Morphology as a tracer of tensile strength and application to dust collection by the Rosetta spacecraft L. E. Ellerbroek1, B. Gundlach2, A. Landeck2, C. Dominik1, J. Blum2, S. Merouane3, M. Hilchenbach3, H. John3 H. A. van Veen4

With Blum in the mix, I thought, this should be a quality paper...:confused: :(

Ummmmm....why no mention the dust is charged as per

And





Don’t these people talk?

Each to important?

What has charged dust got to do with anything? Your woo has failed. 100%. How about actually dealing with that, instead of going off on a totally irrelevant Gish-gallop?
 
There is no electric comet 'model'. Just a bunch of failed junk on a woo site. Supported only by scientifically illiterate wooists. No science, no mechanisms. No evidence.
And there is plenty of evidence for ice. You continually refuse to address it, as it contradicts your religious beliefs.

This paper?

DeepImpact:ExcavatingCometTempel1

M.F.A’Hearn,1*M.J.S.Belton,2W.A.Delamere,3J.Kissel,4K.P.Klaasen,5L.A.McFadden,1K.J.Meech,6H.J.Melosh,7P.H.Schultz,8J.M.Sunshine,9P.C.Thomas,10J.Veverka,10D.K.Yeomans,5M.W.Baca,9I.Busko,11C.J.Crockett,1S.M.Collins,5M.Desnoyer,10C.A.Eberhardy,8C.M.Ernst,8T.L.Farnham,1L.Feaga,1O.Groussin,1D.Hampton,12S.I.Ipatov,1J.-Y.Li,1D.Lindler,13C.M.Lisse,1,14N.Mastrodemos,5W.M.OwenJr.,5J.E.Richardson,7,10D.D.Wellnitz,1R.L.White11

Are you sure you want to hang your hat on this paper?

Because the nucleus also has little thermal inertia,this activity must be driven by material that is near the surface. We suspect that such activity maybe common on other comets, but there are not sufficient data for any other comets to confirm this presumption

Would you like to embarrass you again jonesdave116? We now have sufficient data that makes this presumption totally incorrect.

:confused:

Stop moving the goal posts and you’ll see your ice is all assumptions, as they thought comets were composed mostly of ice...

Overtime, and from this paper the PI’s understanding had been EVOLVING toward mostly rock.
 
Last edited:


This paper?

DeepImpact:ExcavatingCometTempel1

M.F.A’Hearn,1*M.J.S.Belton,2W.A.Delamere,3J.Kissel,4K.P.Klaasen,5L.A.McFadden,1K.J.Meech,6H.J.Melosh,7P.H.Schultz,8J.M.Sunshine,9P.C.Thomas,10J.Veverka,10D.K.Yeomans,5M.W.Baca,9I.Busko,11C.J.Crockett,1S.M.Collins,5M.Desnoyer,10C.A.Eberhardy,8C.M.Ernst,8T.L.Farnham,1L.Feaga,1O.Groussin,1D.Hampton,12S.I.Ipatov,1J.-Y.Li,1D.Lindler,13C.M.Lisse,1,14N.Mastrodemos,5W.M.OwenJr.,5J.E.Richardson,7,10D.D.Wellnitz,1R.L.White11

Are you sure you want to hang your hat on this paper?



Would you like to embarrass you again jonesdave116? We now have sufficient data that makes this presumption totally incorrect.

:confused:

Stop moving the goal posts and you’ll see your ice is all assumptions, as they thought comets were composed mostly of ice...

Overtime, and from this paper the PI’s understanding had been EVOLVING toward mostly rock.

More lying.

The comet’s outer layer is composed of 1- to 100-micrometer fine particles with negligible strength (<65 pascals)

Sounds like no rock I have ever heard of.

This is a good indication that the thermal inertia is low. The maximum temperature of 326 +/- 6 K is in excellent agreement with the subsolar point temperature of 325 K for a standard thermal model with no beaming factor(11). This agreement is another argument for a low thermal inertia, most probably lower than 100 MKS (MKS = W/K/m2/s1/2)

Sounds like no rock I have ever heard of.

Then there was the crater size. Couldn't have been made in any rock I have ever heard of.

Then there was the detection of thousands of tonnes of solid ice ejected by the impact into what seems like no rock that I have ever heard of.
 
Last edited:
Outgassing induced acceleration of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
T. Kramer & M. Läuter
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1902.02701.pdf

An entirely independent determination of the gas production for 67P has been performed by Läuter et al. (2019) by analyzing the in-situ data of the Double Focusing Mass Spectrometer (DFMS) of the Rosetta Orbiter Spectrometer for Ion and Neutral Analysis (ROSINA). The non-gravitational acceleration by Eqs. (13) shows a remarkable agreement to the ROSINA derived water production QH2O(r) of 67P from Läuter et al. (2019), Fig. 3, with gas velocity vgas, av= 480 m/s.

Amazing. All this ice that doesn't exist is providing pretty much exactly the force required to explain the non-gravitational acceleration!
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Yawn......
As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

Usual stupidity about charged dust (a persistent delusion that is not one of the insanities of the electric comet).

The cometary double layers delusion pops up yet again (not part of the insanity in the electric comet theory and physically impossible).

Lies about an imaginary "Whipple's model". Sceince did not stop in the 1950's :jaw-dropp! The modern comet model is more than Whipple's 1950's model.

Lies about things being fatal for the modern comet model.

A persistent "Comets are not mostly ice with sublimation as the main driver for gas and dust release..." lie because he has been told many times that 70 years of evidence is that comets have sublimation as the main driver for gas and dust release :jaw-dropp!
Whether comets are mostly ices or 16-50% ices is irrelevant.

Utter stupidity that models should be fit to data when that is what science does :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Lies about the insanity of the electric comet theory

this is not terrestrial rock...
Lies about the insanity of the electric comet theory which is that comets are at least partly terrestrial rock insanely blasted from the Earth and other rocky planets in insane electrical discharges between planets, the insanity of jets being electrical discharges, insane EDM cleaning comet surfaces so that even more insanely they are clean (none of the detected dust!).
 
But interestingly, the charged dust we observe and measure, comming from the nucleus is closer to that of terrestrial rocks density.
An "interestingly" delusion and "closer to" lie.
We expect and find that cometary dust grains have similar density and composition as asteroids because they have the same origin - the early solar system :jaw-dropp!
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

... this ice I assume is similar to terrestrial ice in its density of 1g/cm3, or there abouts.
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.
It is insane to think that comets are made of solid water ice (or solid rock the electric comet insanity) when their densities have been measured to be an average of ~0.6 g/cc.

As he has acknowledged in several posts, comets are highly porous. Their interior is made of grains of H2O, CO2, CH4 ices and dust stuck together.
 
Last edited:
I'll just leave this here;

snowstorm_strip.jpg
 
Poor old Sol is well beyond his pay grade with this stuff. He wants a putative ambipolar field to explain all sorts of EC woo. Including his rather deranged continued claims of charged dust. However, the field, if it exists, is pointing the wrong way to accelerate negatively charged dust. He has been asked umpteen times to explain this, and can't. We are left with lying and strawmen. Thread should be put out of its misery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom