The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
One of my favourite words for the release of negatively charged nano dust from the rocky/stoney nucleus “Coulomb Explosion” which is more or less the “patched charge” model of M.Horanyi

Utter nonsense. Otherwise we'd see it at asteroids. We don't. Therefore you fail again. No model, no mechanisms, no science, no evidence.
 
Which one in particular?

The one were your are shown to be ignorant on how an electric field can divert the solar wind?

That would be the best one.

Or was it the new paper backing A’Hearns statement that out understanding is evolving toward rock.

Or that the sublimation model is becoming untenable.

Rubbish. An electric field is not diverting the solar wind. No rock ever detected at comets, and sublimation is seen.
 
But science is evolving toward the electric comet and I’m more than patient enough to bide my time and just highlight the latest papers saying as such.

No, it is not. The electric comet woo is thoroughly debunked. Not that it needed to be. It has nothing to do with science.
 
Thanks indagtor
YOUR ASSIGNMENT!

Michael A'Hearn, along with several other "competent" scientists, wrote a paper several years ago that actually discusses the probability of "ROCK" being found in comets! This paper is real. It does exist.

Using your favourite search engine, find this specific journal paper! A "sample" of one, if you will. When you have found it, please post a link for the class! If you need more clues than those already provided, I will post at your request. Once you have found and read (i.e., comprehended) said paper, we will discuss the mainstream implications! Remember, the internet is watching to see what you will do!

Ok A’Hearn said
What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Ok then...

This mob reckon
For very high Fnucleus values, the nucleus is highly porous and dusty with very little ice (e.g. for Fnucleus = 7, the ice content is about 7% for porosities between 68% and 80%, respectively). A variation in porosity by 1% beyond the 70% implies a steep increase in Fnucleus, leaving only a tiny fractional ice content. As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Comet 67P’s porosity is in the order of, and this is from A’Hearns paper
At smaller scales, the results from CONSERT showed that the smaller lobe (the head), at least on radio-wave paths from the orbiter to the lander, was relatively homogeneous on a scale of tens of metres, i.e. that there were no large (more than 10m) voids and no obvious changes in porosity in the bulk of the head. The results also showed that it was extremely porous (75 85%), although the outermost layer (approx. 5–10m, the resolution limit of CONSERT with a 3m wavelength) was likely somewhat denser, i.e. lower in porosity than the bulk, and that the dust/ice ratio was 0.4 to 2.6 by volume [42,43]. The combination of CONSERT data with data from SESAME on Philae confirms that the outermost metre is less porous than the bulk of the head [44]. The range of dust/ice ratios by volume might be barely consistent with the ratio of refractories to volatiles cited above (6, by mass) if the density of the dusty particles is sufficiently high, but this does highlight the large uncertainties in this most basic of parameters.
Comets: looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

So he might of jumped the gun on mostly rock. Looks like he actually should have said mostly stoney, like an asteroid. :D

What kind of mainstream scientist are you indagator?
 
Last edited:
So yeah nah, looks like A’Hearns understanding was evolving.

Maybe yours should too.

Just saying. :)
 
So yeah nah, looks like A’Hearns understanding was evolving.

Maybe yours should too.

Just saying. :)

No, it was not. There has never been any rock detected at a comet. And if comets are just like asteroids, why aren't they outgassing, and why do they have much higher densities?
 
No, it was not. There has never been any rock detected at a comet. And if comets are just like asteroids, why aren't they outgassing, and why do they have much higher densities?

I don’t know.

But would be interested in finding out. :thumbsup:

Maybe a mainstream scientist like Indagator might like to help?

We would need a few mainstream peer reviewed papers on electric field strengths at comets and asteroids.

I could go dig out the Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley HARRI LAAKSO

This can be explained better by the latter model because strongly charged dust particles can stream within the rays.

The presence of this magnetic structure led to the formation of the current layer at 0709 UT, the thickness of which was about 7000 km (see Plate 5). Our measurements cover only the farst current layer crossing displayed in Plate 5. The cold electron density increases much faster than expected, reaching its saturation level after 1 min. A sudden burst of energetic ions (>40 keV) was also measured be- tween the discontinuities given above [Somogyi et al., 1986]. Corresponding to the rising electron density, the dc electric field increases rapidly but does not exceed the saturation level. According to these measurements, the total potential drop over the boundary is of the order of 135 kV.

So jonesdave116’s view of a comets electric field as some sort of pith ball electrostatic primary school experiment maybe a little to simplistic.

So that’s Halley, now for an asteroid. You pick a paper, jonesdave116 or Indagator and we’ll compare.

Is that a fair call?
 
Last edited:
Jonesdave116, what’s your take on this...

For very high Fnucleus values, the nucleus is highly porous and dusty with very little ice (e.g. for Fnucleus = 7, the ice content is about 7% for porosities between 68% and 80%, respectively). A variation in porosity by 1% beyond the 70% implies a steep increase in Fnucleus, leaving only a tiny fractional ice content. As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.


So if the dust
The CONSERT experiment (Kofman et al., 2015) determined the permittivity of the interior at the Philae landing site on the “head” of the nucleus. The permittivity of 1.27 was used to derive a volumetric dust-to-ice ratio of 0.4 … 2.6 and a porosity of 75% … 85%. The material density range of carbonaceous chondrites is 2700 kg/m³ to 3100 kg/m³ at an average of 2900 kg/m³. This covers the upper density range considered by Pätzold et al. (2016). The volumetric dust-to-ice ratio Fvolume is given by . So, for a range of 3 < Fnucleus < 7, a range of 1.2 < Fvolume < 2.6 is derived, in excellent agreement with CONSERT. Herique et al. (2016) extended the range of dust material to 2000 - 3500 kg/m3. This would cover fully the density considerations of RSI and CONSERT. Fulle et al. (2016) examined the dust particle material composition encountered in space. Estimating the microporosity of the dust particles and a filling factor, the material density of compacted dust particles is found to be kg/m3. This was updatet to kg/m3 (Fulle et al., 2017) which is a shift towards a higher compacted average dust material density but it covers essentially the same density range as in Fulle et al. (2016) and it fully includes the densities assumed by Pätzold et al. (2016), Kofman et al. (2015) and Herique et al. (2016).

And

CONCERT found that
a porosity of 75% … 85%.

How does that stack up against
As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

???????


I think A’Hearn’s statement, with some of the latest data in hand, maybe on the money.

(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4]
Comets: looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

Indagators assertion that the above was not a peer reviewed paper is just a weak cop out and kick in the face for A’Hearn.

His understanding was evolving.


Next problem will be how does a comet that MOSTLY VACUUM have the structural integrity to display the diverse landforms it does.
 
Last edited:
I don’t know.

But would be interested in finding out. :thumbsup:

Maybe a mainstream scientist like Indagator might like to help?

We would need a few mainstream peer reviewed papers on electric field strengths at comets and asteroids.

I could go dig out the Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley HARRI LAAKSO





So jonesdave116’s view of a comets electric field as some sort of pith ball electrostatic primary school experiment maybe a little to simplistic.

So that’s Halley, now for an asteroid. You pick a paper, jonesdave116 or Indagator and we’ll compare.

Is that a fair call?

No, you are talking crap again. You have been given the field strengths at asteroids and inactive comets, and the strengths at active comets. No comparison. And whatever Laakso did or didn't see, was nowhere near the nucleus. For the one millionth time - the ions matched the velocity of the neutrals in the DC at Halley, and all the electrons were cold. Which part of that are you unable to understand?
 
Jonesdave116, what’s your take on this...




So if the dust

And

CONCERT found that

How does that stack up against The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

???????


I think A’Hearn’s statement, with some of the latest data in hand, maybe on the money.

Comets: looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

Indagators assertion that the above was not a peer reviewed paper is just a weak cop out and kick in the face for A’Hearn.

His understanding was evolving.


Next problem will be how does a comet that MOSTLY VACUUM have the structural integrity to display the diverse landforms it does.


More disgraceful and deceitful lying about what A'Hearn meant. Get a life. No rock has ever been detected at a comet. Stop lying. Getting sick of it.
 
You know, I think Indagator (and many before him) is onto something.

Step back a minute, and read almost any of Sol88's posts (the ones on A'Hearn are particularly good examples).

What do you see?

Words, but no numbers or equations etc.

How is the case for the EC presented, using these words?

I submit that it's essentially the same as that of a deeply religious person trying to interpret what, to them, is a sacred book/work, to support some political/social position/notion: snippets, many out of context, strung together to paint a coherent whole.

In Sol88's case, the glaring failures of this approach have been repeatedly pointed out (thanks RC, jd, Indagator, tusenfem, ...).

But Sol88 is unmoved.

Because, to him, this has nothing to do with science; rather, it's about defending a religious position.

And, oddly (not!), EC Central (thunderdolts) has almost zero discussion of anything like an EC. Almost as if they are ashamed to mention it. :p
 
Maths?

I could give you numbers that prove pink unicorns, flying elephants or indeed dark matter and black holes!

At this stage, I’m just going for...

Do you believe that ambipolar electric fields are in operation at comets?

I think we’ve past the whole mainstream denial of CHARGE SEPRATION in space plasma....maybe not though.
 
<snipped for brevity>
And, oddly (not!), EC Central (thunderdolts) has almost zero discussion of anything like an EC. Almost as if they are ashamed to mention it. :p

Yep. You go back to the start of that 67P thread on dunderdolts, and it was quite active, with various posters. I remember one particular poster callied 'Viscount Aero' being particularly vocal about what would and wouldn't be seen. Hasn't been on there for yonks! The only people left are the True Believers. Hallelujah!
The same thing happened on the Rosetta Blog, where I used to post. Loads of the buggers around early on - none left by the end. Evidence kind of does that to you.
 
Do you believe that ambipolar electric fields are in operation at comets?

Irrelevant. If you think it is relevant, then spell out what you think these **** weak fields are doing. You have had plenty of opportunity, so get on with it. Or.....................
 
More disgraceful and deceitful lying about what A'Hearn meant. Get a life. No rock has ever been detected at a comet. Stop lying. Getting sick of it.

Change of description,not ROCK but STONEY!

Highly porous but stoney with no ice.

That’s the end of the dirtysnowball.

Mainstream need another model for comets.

Won’t be the Electric Comet :rolleyes:
 
Change of description,not ROCK but STONEY!

Highly porous but stoney with no ice.

That’s the end of the dirtysnowball.

Mainstream need another model for comets.

Won’t be the Electric Comet :rolleyes:

Oh dear. More outright lying. Is that all you've got left? Tell us - what planetary surface do you think this comet was blasted off by impossible electric woo? How does that planet's surface match 67P's? Stop talking crap, and give us your idiotic model.
 
Irrelevant. If you think it is relevant, then spell out what you think these **** weak fields are doing. You have had plenty of opportunity, so get on with it. Or.....................

And that’s why everyone of those posters gave up, can’t discuss with crusaders like jonesdave116.

Won’t acknowledge the bleeding obvious.

Won’t let go of an old model, even when new data and new papers cast serous doubt on an existing model.
 
And that’s why everyone of those posters gave up, can’t discuss with crusaders like jonesdave116.

Won’t acknowledge the bleeding obvious.

Won’t let go of an old model, even when new data and new papers cast serous doubt on an existing model.

Nope, no doubt has been thrown on it. You are lying again. As usual. It is all you have left. Your religion is dead. You need a new one. Try astrology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom