The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Haser model has been modified over the years. Essentially it a good model when observing comets from afar. It relies on the use of the lifetime of H2O before it is dissociated into OH and H. It uses a spherical distribution which, when taking measurements from afar, is perfectly valid, as the distances from the nucleus where measurements are made is sufficient for the coma to have evened out. The measurements at 67P were much closer to the nucleus, and various methods were used. The measured production rates all exceeded the estimates from the previous perihelion observations, suggesting that the Haser model was slightly underestimating the production rate. Not by much, though, showing that it is a valid model.
Good post, jonesdave116.

In case we get repeated stupidity from Sol88: The production rate from the Haser model is the production rate of daughter products from the parent found by plugging in the production rate of the parent Q. Q is not known and has to be measured.

A re-evaluation of the Haser model scale lengths for comets
"Q is the production rate of the parent" and is one of 3 unknowns in the model (the other 2 are parent and daughter reciprocal scale lengths).
 
How the hell would an electric field stop the solar wind? Probably already asked. Total woo.

Deflection is the word you’re looking for, not stoping.

Is the solar wind being slowed at all? Like in the sublimation model of “mass loading”?
 
Yes, at a relatively low activity comet there appears to be a correlation with electron-neutral collisions, as well. Hey, we learned something! It does not appear to operate at a higher activity comet, such as Halley. All the ions in the DC were at the neutral velocity, and all the electrons were cold.


Yay! We learned something :thumbsup:


Ion-neutral collisions were once thought to be very important for the mass loading model but we’ve learned it’s now of
limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling
and that the ambipolar electric field is
non-negligible ambipolar electric field

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

:D

Real science evolving their understanding.
 
Last edited:
Usual lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity

We learned something....
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies.

Sol88 has not learned anything about physics or comets for at least 12 years.
What we (the other posters in this thread) have learned is some mainstream ices and dust comet physics:
Yes, at a relatively low activity comet there appears to be a correlation with electron-neutral collisions, as well. Hey, we learned something! It does not appear to operate at a higher activity comet, such as Halley. All the ions in the DC were at the neutral velocity, and all the electrons were cold.
Nothing to do with Sol88's electric comet insanity.

What we (the other posters in this thread) have known for at least months is that comet comae have ambipolar electric fields for the basic reason that space plasmas will have them.
What we (the other posters in this thread) have known for at least weeks is that a paper has the phrase "non-negligible ambipolar electric fields" and Sol88 is insanely obsessed with those words and his lie that it is part of the electric comet insanity.
 
Last edited:
Good news, reality check. Well done mate.

Glad we are over the whole charge separation and electric field shamozel.

Very happy to see your understanding evolve just like A’Hearn’s!



Could do me a favour and update your list?
 
Deflection is the word you’re looking for, not stoping.

Is the solar wind being slowed at all? Like in the sublimation model of “mass loading”?

Irrelevant. An electric field will not deflect the solar wind. Stop talking nonsense.
 
Yay! We learned something :thumbsup:


Ion-neutral collisions were once thought to be very important for the mass loading model but we’ve learned it’s now of and that the ambipolar electric field is

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

:D

Real science evolving their understanding.

Mass loading is nothing to do with ion-neutral collisions. Stop talking nonsense.
 
Very happy to see your understanding evolve just like A’Hearn’s

Quit lying. Comets are dust and ice and organics, with a high porosity. And a density far less than water. Ergo, your model failed.
 
Should investigate, jonesdave116?

I reckoning it would be acting the same as the double layers I’ve been predicting at comets since the start of this thread.

Let’s have a look at what electric fields and more specifically what double layers can do with charged particles.
 
Should investigate, jonesdave116?

I reckoning it would be acting the same as the double layers I’ve been predicting at comets since the start of this thread.

Let’s have a look at what electric fields and more specifically what double layers can do with charged particles.

Complete load of tosh. No DLs seen. No mechanism, no science, no evidence. And nobody gives a toss what an unqualified wooist reckons.
 
Do you believe there is a NON negligible ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Sounds like your a doubting Thomas still.
 
What’s happens to the charged particles meeting the electric field from the suns direction?
 
Do you believe there is a NON negligible ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Sounds like your a doubting Thomas still.

It is a complete irrelevance. It has nothing to do with your failed woo. And wasn't seen at Halley.
 
Go read the bloody papers instead of asking irrelevant questions on here.

It’s actually a rhetorical question. This was observed and measured.

Shall we dig out the papers and have a look?


More than happy to wheel out Decca’s paper, again?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom