The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
My new model?

Ok then, comets are stony objects discharging in the solar plasma!

There it is the new model. :D

ah good.

So, how come this solar plasma is electric AND accelerates positive and negative particles in the same direction?
And at the same time ONLY discharges comets and not all the other rocky objects moving trough it (like, say, the moon?)

Until you get that bit mathematically sorted you have no model, only bad fantasy.

Do get back to us once you have that done?
 
ah good.

So, how come this solar plasma is electric AND accelerates positive and negative particles in the same direction?
And at the same time ONLY discharges comets and not all the other rocky objects moving trough it (like, say, the moon?)

Until you get that bit mathematically sorted you have no model, only bad fantasy.

Do get back to us once you have that done?

Electric curcuits, electric fields.

You know everything not mainstream. :D

Are there electric currents in space plasmas, ls?
 
As I’ve said all along...



The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications Martin Pätzold et al

Oh, how do feel champ?

Science evolving :eye-poppi

And that paper is somewhat trumped by Fulle's paper;

The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets
Fulle, M. et al.
https://oro.open.ac.uk/57539/1/57539.pdf

Patzold's paper makes a rather unlikely statement that every measurement of the gas production is hugely overestimated. These have been measured by various teams, using various models. Including ground-based estimates from previous apparitions, as well as the current one. For all of them to be wrong is highly unlikely. More likely is that they have underestimated the fall-back mass and /or the contribution to the coma of sublimating grains in the material ejected, as pointed out by Fulle. And Patzold does not appear to have considered the implications of a far lower outgassing rate on the observed plasma environment.
 
ah good.

So, how come this solar plasma is electric AND accelerates positive and negative particles in the same direction?
And at the same time ONLY discharges comets and not all the other rocky objects moving trough it (like, say, the moon?)

Until you get that bit mathematically sorted you have no model, only bad fantasy.

Do get back to us once you have that done?


Serious question for you, Lukrakk_Sisser do you think Martin Pätzold paper has any bearing on A’Hearns statement quoted below?

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].
 
And that paper is somewhat trumped by Fulle's paper;

The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets
Fulle, M. et al.
https://oro.open.ac.uk/57539/1/57539.pdf

Patzold's paper makes a rather unlikely statement that every measurement of the gas production is hugely overestimated. These have been measured by various teams, using various models. Including ground-based estimates from previous apparitions, as well as the current one. For all of them to be wrong is highly unlikely. More likely is that they have underestimated the fall-back mass and /or the contribution to the coma of sublimating grains in the material ejected, as pointed out by Fulle. And Patzold does not appear to have considered the implications of a far lower outgassing rate on the observed plasma environment.

So the mainstream don’t know what there doing? Brilliant!

Decent in the ranks. :thumbsup:

The dust was measured sampled at more than one comet!

And it’s density confirmed, the RSI experiment told you the comet was extremely porous, the rest is pure mainstream science.

Comets are stony with no ice. :D

Poor jonesy.
 
So the mainstream don’t know what there doing? Brilliant!

Decent in the ranks. :thumbsup:

The dust was measured sampled at more than one comet!

And it’s density confirmed, the RSI experiment told you the comet was extremely porous, the rest is pure mainstream science.

Comets are stony with no ice. :D

Poor jonesy.

Idiotic nonsense. Ice is observed. How many times are you going to lie about this? No rock, no stone. Just dust.
 
So far so good for the electric comet.

As the mainstream are now realising.

Happy to wait and see if the statement
From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates.
comes to fruition.
 
So far so good for the electric comet.

As the mainstream are now realising.

Happy to wait and see if the statement comes to fruition.

Not going to happen. As I said, Fulle's paper is likely to be closer to the mark. I suspect discussions may be taking place. And Patzold's paper does nothing for the failed EC woo. It still fails.
 
You mean the non-existent field at Halley? How would it do that?

Yawn, why bother Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

You don’t think they do anything any way.

Only an idiot would deny the bleeding obvious.

Electric fields and there associated curcuits.

Can’t happen in an ideal perfectly conducting plasma. :D
 
Yawn, why bother Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

You don’t think they do anything any way.

Only an idiot would deny the bleeding obvious.

Electric fields and there associated curcuits.

Can’t happen in an ideal perfectly conducting plasma. :D

Word salad. Where is the field at Halley? Why are the electrons cold? What significance do you think that has? Have you got any science to discuss at all? (rhetorical)
 
Serious question for you, Lukrakk_Sisser do you think Martin Pätzold paper has any bearing on A’Hearns statement quoted below?

No, this is not a model.

YOU claim that there are invisible space electric fields.

I know enough about electricity to claim that positive and negative charges move in opposite directions in any electric field.

In space we do not see this and there have been enough measurements to claim this as fact.

Therefore YOUR invisible space electric field does not comply with nature as observed.
And until you can explain how that works you have no model.
You can keep harping on unimportant minutiae to avoid having to answer that, but until you fix this glaring problem in your fantasy it will never ever become a model.
 
Do we observe negatively charged dust from the nucleus of 67p?

Do we observe ions from 67P?

Work it out, I’ll wait.

:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom