Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
What’s the world coming to, Sol88? :confused:

A student of Alfven writes a paper that totally shreds Thornhill’s, Talbott’s, and Scott’s work on the ELECTRIC SUN and the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE. Sad.

I must say, though, that I’m surprised you, of all people, would cite it ... don’t you know just how devastating a critique of the EU it is?


Feel free to back it up, quote the section where this is stated.
 
Did SAFIRE measure the temperature of what's under the photosphere?



No, it most definitely isn't.

Yes they did and it was cooler than the photosphere. So the moanstream have a coronal heating problem!!!! :D

The electric sun does not. Could not be any more simpler. :rolleyes:
 
Did SAFIRE measure the temperature of what's under the photosphere?



No, it most definitely isn't.

If SAFIRE’s finding are repeatable independently would you accept their findings?

I’d like to repete the experiment where moanstream tested their hypothesis on nucleus fusion?

Are you able to point me to the experiment where they tested their theory?
 
Last edited:
If SAFIRE’s finding are repeatable independently would you accept their findings?

I’d like to repete the experiment where moanstream tested their hypothesis on nucleus fusion?

Are you able to point me to the experiment where they tested their theory?

Apart from all the experiments done in particle accelerators or the nuclear fusion reactor setups?

The tests are called hydrogen bombs, you might have heard of them.

And no, you do NOT believe in empirical science, because if you did you would not be promoting the electric comet nonsense. After all, spacecraft function and have never noticed anything that that inane theory predicts.
You keep hand waving that fact away and focus on minutiae to ignore the gaping holes and unproven assertions in the guesswork.
 
Apart from all the experiments done in particle accelerators or the nuclear fusion reactor setups?

The tests are called hydrogen bombs, you might have heard of them.

And no, you do NOT believe in empirical science, because if you did you would not be promoting the electric comet nonsense. After all, spacecraft function and have never noticed anything that that inane theory predicts.
You keep hand waving that fact away and focus on minutiae to ignore the gaping holes and unproven assertions in the guesswork.

Oh dear :blush:

Particle accelerators? Mmmmmm....interesting , tell me more. How do they accelerate particles using a hydrogen bomb?

Vega 1 and 2 detected the electric comet back in the 80’s but the moanstream have their craniums wedged so firmly...

Have a look at the current when the dust impacts start! :cool: tops of scale!
 
Apart from all the experiments done in particle accelerators or the nuclear fusion reactor setups?

The tests are called hydrogen bombs, you might have heard of them.

And no, you do NOT believe in empirical science, because if you did you would not be promoting the electric comet nonsense. After all, spacecraft function and have never noticed anything that that inane theory predicts.
You keep hand waving that fact away and focus on minutiae to ignore the gaping holes and unproven assertions in the guesswork.

How's the Tokamak comming along. Any breakthroughs in the last 60 years or so?

SAFIRE on the other hand have been going from 2012 or so... with tremendous progress!
 
Last edited:
Yes they did and it was cooler than the photosphere. So the moanstream have a coronal heating problem!!!! :D

The electric sun does not. Could not be any more simpler. :rolleyes:


"A copper ball with an electric cord attached behaves just like the Sun."

Nothing to see here, folks, just more looks-like-a-bunny astrophysics. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
If SAFIRE’s finding are repeatable independently would you accept their findings?

I’d like to repete the experiment where moanstream tested their hypothesis on nucleus fusion?

Are you able to point me to the experiment where they tested their theory?


Another feeble attempt to shift the burden. SAFIRE is nothing more than the Thunderbolts gang trying to make the EU look sciency for their punters.
 
So, according to Jean Tate, who knows what she's talking about:
A student of Alfven writes a paper that totally shreds Thornhill’s, Talbott’s, and Scott’s work on the ELECTRIC SUN and the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE. Sad.

I must say, though, that I’m surprised you, of all people, would cite it ... don’t you know just how devastating a critique of the EU it is?

According to Sol88, who doesn't:
Feel free to back it up, quote the section where this is stated.

I have already quoted some of this paper before, although not in this thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11713572&postcount=877

RECONNECTION
A special kind of violation of the frozen field condition is the process of reconnection. In the classic review article by Vasyliunas (1975) reconnection was defined as “the process whereby plasma flows across a surface separating regions containing topologically different magnetic field lines” (cf. also Priest and Forbes, 2000). But change of connectivity between plasma elements is possible without a separator. Independently of topology, two elements of plasma that are at one instant of time on a common magnetic field line can be on different magnetic field line at another instant, if the condition given above is satisfied somewhere between the plasma elements. This more general definition of reconnection was proposed by Schindler et al. (1988) and Hesse and Schindler (1988) and further elaborated by Birn et al.(1997), but the term reconnection is commonly used for reconnection at a separatrix.
Reconnection is considered to be one of the most important phenomena in cosmic plasma, as a means of topology change and energy release. In the Earth’s magnetosphere, reconnection takes place both at the magnetopause and in the tail current sheet. In addition, local reconnection of limited strands of magnetic flux, so-called flux transfer events, are also common (Le et al. 2008).
The reconnection events in the geomagnetic tail that are associated with magnetospheric substorms have many similarities to the fast energy release that takes place in solar flares (Lin et al., 2008). In the magnetosphere, the phenomenon can be studied empirically in great detail by means of in situ measurements (Paschmann, 2008). The value of this for understanding solar flares and other kinds of energy release in cosmic plasmas can hardly be exaggerated. Reconnection is an extremely complicated phenomenon, and this makes it even more important to have actual measurements to guide theoretical work. One reason for complexity is that reconnection involves coupling between widely different spatial scales,from system-scale structure through ion scales and down to electron scales. Therefore, multipoint measurements are essential. Multipoint measurements are at present being made with the still operational Cluster satellites and the more recent five satellites of the THEMIS project. For example, Cluster observations showed that the extent of the electron diffusion region can far exceed what is expected from simulations (Phan et al., 2007) Substantial further progress can be expected from another four-spacecraft mission, Magnetospheric Multiprobes, which has recently been approved by NASA.
Due to the widely different spatial scales involved in reconnection, a major advance would be simultaneous multipoint measurements on each of the three spatial scales. Such a project, called Cross Scale, is part of ESA’s long term plan Cosmic Vision. It involves 10 or 12 satellites forming tetrahedrons on each scale. For the Cross scale mission, reconnection studies is only one of its purposes. It will, if it realized, be a formidable tool for studying many other space plasma phenomena. This is in particular true for two phenomena, namely collisionless shocks and turbulence. Both of these are of fundamental importance in cosmic plasmas and both are prominent in the magnetosphere and in accessible regions of the solar wind.

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
Falthammar, C-G.
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:484042/FULLTEXT01.pdf

Now, please tell me which part of that doesn't **** all over the idiotic electric universe woo?
 
Last edited:
How's the Tokamak comming along. Any breakthroughs in the last 60 years or so?

SAFIRE on the other hand have been going from 2012 or so... with tremendous progress!

Yep. At showing the world what happens when you stick a squillion volts through a metal sphere. Yippee. A complete irrelevance. And will be treated as such by real science.
 
Vega 1 and 2 detected the electric comet back in the 80’s.........

Nope. However, one of them did detect the H2O that Thornhill was still lying about not being there 20 years later. Mind you, it had been definitively detected a little while earlier by the Kuiper Airborne Observatory.
 
Assuming “ideal” MHD?

Who is assuming ideal MHD, and where? Alfven knew very well that comets were composed of ice, and that the Sun was powered by nuclear fusion. So what are you on about?
 
I’d like to repete the experiment where moanstream tested their hypothesis on nucleus fusion?

Nuclear fusion produces neutrinos. Nothing else can do it. Therefore it was predicted that the Sun would emit neutrinos prior to us ever detecting them. It also predicted the energy levels of those neutrinos, given that we expect the vast majority to come from the first step in the p-p chain. Those predictions have been borne out to a very high degree. Electric sun ideas have been falsified all along the line, and are just word salad with no real science.
 
Ummm...wtf???

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
C.-G. Fälthammar

Your idealized models are to make the maths SIMPLE for you to be able to actually do the maths!!!! but they are not reality, the plasma is too tricky for your mathamagics :D

Indeed wtf, because, as usual you don't answer my questions, but come up with vaguely related random quotes.

So, once more:
Is there any reason you can come up with why ideal MHD would (not) hold for Birkeland currents?
Do you actually know what (ideal) MHD is, and what the restricting parameters are for (ideal) MHD, and do you think that field aligned currents are affected by that?

Indeed, field aligned electric fields cannot exist in ideal MHD (do you know why?), but does that mean that field aligned currents cannot exist in ideal MHD (if yes, why not, if no why?).

You have a completely twisted idea of what plasma physicists are doing (unsurprisinly), you really think we are still in the 1950s/60s around the birth of Alfven's MHD, and we have not developed any further. Well, that is also not surprising, as you keep on insisting that we still assume Whipple's 1950s model for a comet.

I guess I can only come to the conclusion that YOU Sol88 were not borne in 1988 but actually are from the 1950s and you have not developed any further.
 
Yes they did and it was cooler than the photosphere.

No, they did not. They cannot. Because the photosphere is opaque, and you cannot see through opaque things. Because, duh, that's the definition of opaque.

So the moanstream have a coronal heating problem!!!! :D

The electric sun does not. Could not be any more simpler. :rolleyes:

You think you've solved one imagined problem, but have simply replaced it with a far larger and more fundamental violation of thermodynamics.
 
Another feeble attempt to shift the burden. SAFIRE is nothing more than the Thunderbolts gang trying to make the EU look sciency for their punters.


Ok :thumbsup:

I understand your position, empirical science is the poor cousin to theoretical mathamagical “science”!

It states in their (SAFIRE) opening statement, the premise is different (THe Sun is externally powered) and they are going to emperically test it in reapetabe experiments with measured data and mathematics.

If they are wrong, they are wrong and this will be empirical science, real science. On the other hand we have black holes, neutron stars, dark energy, dark matter, Father Christmas and the Easter bunny.

And none of them can you do empirical science on!

So go for it I say :) thumbs up and well done to the SAFIRE team.
 
Last edited:
Indeed wtf, because, as usual you don't answer my questions, but come up with vaguely related random quotes.

So, once more:
Is there any reason you can come up with why ideal MHD would (not) hold for Birkeland currents?
Do you actually know what (ideal) MHD is, and what the restricting parameters are for (ideal) MHD, and do you think that field aligned currents are affected by that?

Indeed, field aligned electric fields cannot exist in ideal MHD (do you know why?), but does that mean that field aligned currents cannot exist in ideal MHD (if yes, why not, if no why?).

You have a completely twisted idea of what plasma physicists are doing (unsurprisinly), you really think we are still in the 1950s/60s around the birth of Alfven's MHD, and we have not developed any further. Well, that is also not surprising, as you keep on insisting that we still assume Whipple's 1950s model for a comet.

I guess I can only come to the conclusion that YOU Sol88 were not borne in 1988 but actually are from the 1950s and you have not developed any further.

You make it TOO easy, tusenfem. ;)

There are field aligned currents as you stated above where MHD breaks down, also so stated above....

Where do the circuits go? Say the one in the tail of the comet, just for an instance. :D

Have you developed the NEW findings from Rosetta yet wrt the PLASMA environment?

And how that stacks up against the EXPECTED findings from a snowydirtball sublimating in the gentle warmth of the Sun.

First spacecraft/s past a comet proved the Whipple model incorrect.
 
Last edited:
Anyways.................. to get back to comets, albeit non-electrical ones, there was a paper that drew my attention that was recently published:

Electron acceleration by wave turbulence in a magnetized plasma
Rigby, A. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-018-0059-2

From the paper:

Here we show the results from an experiment where a laser-produced plasma flow impacts on a magnetized sphere (see Fig. 1). This mimics, for example, the interaction of the solar-wind plasma with a comet, an environment where excess X-ray generation by accelerated electrons has been observed.

The reason it drew my attention is that I was under the impression that the 'mystery' of X-ray production at comets was no longer a mystery, and hadn't been for some time. There has been a fair bit in the scientific literature about this since the initial discovery at comet Hyakutake in 1996. For instance:

MEASUREMENT OF CHARGE EXCHANGE AND X-RAY EMISSION CROSS SECTIONS FOR SOLAR WIND–COMET INTERACTIONS
Greenwood, J. B. et al.
https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/14080/00-0480.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

The mechanism appeared to be pretty much confirmed by the observations from Chandra and SWIFT of the impact at Tempel 1 in 2005:

SWIFT X-RAY TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Willingale, R. et al.
https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/publist/Willingale_ApJ_649_541_2006.pdf

and;

Chandra observations of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact campaign
Lisse, C. M. et al.
http://ftp.astro.umd.edu/pub/lisse/xrays/final_proof_YICAR8214_cml_comments_18jul2007.pdf

So, what to make of this new paper? Were they unaware of the strength of the evidence favouring the CX model? Have they discovered something new? I can't comment on the plasma physics involved, but it would appear that they have the X-ray action happening around the bow shock region, and it would appear that actual observation puts it somewhat closer in:

Spectral analysis of the Chandra comet survey
Bodewits, D. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full/2007/27/aa7410-07/aa7410-07.right.html

Perhaps their experimental findings have some relevance for other astronomical objects, but I'm not sure about the application to comets.
 
Last edited:
No, they did not. They cannot. Because the photosphere is opaque, and you cannot see through opaque things. Because, duh, that's the definition of opaque.



You think you've solved one imagined problem, but have simply replaced it with a far larger and more fundamental violation of thermodynamics.

They stuck a probe in it and measured it. Didn’t have to look thru anything!

They also found some thing very interesting when they vaporised the Tungsten probe tip... ;)
 
I understand your position, empirical science is the poor cousin to theoretical mathamagical “science”!

Empirical science: fusion is proposed as the energy source for the Sun. Fusion produces neutrinos of various energies from the p-p chain. So, we ought to see them in the correct quantities at the correct energy levels. Build experiments to test the aforesaid. Detect the neutrinos at the predicted rate, and predicted energy levels. Game over.

Unempirical science: Predict that the Sun is powered electrically from an incoming current. Fail to find current, which should stick out like sore thumb. Realise that only fusion can produce neutrinos. Propose that it is happening due to z-pinch in DL in the chromosphere. Forget that this will kill us all with the gamma radiation that we don't detect. Build metal ball and put a gazillion volts through it. Irrelevant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom