Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Unthinking parroting of the SAFIRE delusions about the Sun

SAFIRE on the other hand ...
19 March 2018: Unthinking parroting of the SAFIRE delusions about the Sun.
Their ignorant delusion that the corona is double layers. He lies that there is any empirical results about the Sun from SAFIRE. Propaganda videos on the deluded Thunderbolts cult YouTube channel are not empirical results. An insanely deluded PDF is not empirical results.
 
Last edited:
my current sheets hwve nothing to do with electric fields nor double layers, but all with curl B


Ohhh, like this
5 Harris and co.
In a region where oppositely directed magnetic fields meet, a current sheet will be generated, by necessity of Ampere’s law:


This situation often occurs in space physics, e.g. in planetary magnetotails, or in nested magnetic field draping. Harris [1962] published an analytical model for the magnetic field B(z) and plasma pressure p(z) profile given by:

Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk

"your"" current sheets must be special, much like the author of some papers. Good book to read

Electric currents are fundamental to the structure and dynamics of space plasmas, including our own near-Earth space environment, or “geospace.”This volume takes an integrated approach to the subject of electric currents by incorporating their phenomenology and physics for many regions in one volume. It covers a broad range of topics from the pioneers of electric currents in outer space, to measurement and analysis techniques, and the many types of electric currents.

Not just oppositely directed magnetic fields meeting!
 
Last edited:
the problem is not that we cannot heat the corona, there are many processes that are at work, there does, imho, not seem to be one specific process.
there are nanoflares, ohmic heating, alfvén waves, shock waves ...
of course everyone wants their pet theory to be the main one
the sun generates more than enough energy to heat the corona, so the question should be why is the corona so cold!

So which process to you ascribe to being able to HEAT the corona to a HOTTER temperature than the thing (Photosphere) supplying the HEAT?

:D

curl b again???
 
So which process to you ascribe to being able to HEAT the corona to a HOTTER temperature than the thing (Photosphere) supplying the HEAT?

:D

curl b again???

Sol; give up. It is more than bleedin' obvious that you haven't got a clue about plasma physics, yes? Neither has anybody else attached to your cult. You are not represented within the scientific literature. You are a waste of space. N'est-ce pas? Why on Earth would anybody take you prawns seriously? Please, give me a reason. Nope? Right, let's carry on without the tosspot brigade. Happy days!
Anybody with an IQ above that of a trilobite like to add anything? No...that does not mean you, Sol.
 
Abysmal ignorance about comets is extended to the Sun

So which process to you ascribe to being able to HEAT the corona to a HOTTER temperature than the thing (Photosphere) supplying the HEAT?
19 March 2008: Abysmal ignorance about comets is extended to the Sun.

The coronal heating problem and the empirically supported solutions.
A way to think about this (for people that have not swallowed the Thunderbolts Kool-Aid!) is that the magnetic field of the Sun provides mechanisms for "heat pumps" that transfer more heat from the photosphere into the corona than expected from radiative transfer.
 
Last edited:
Once and for all and we can all agree on this

Unsolved problem in physics:
Why is the Sun's corona so much hotter than the Sun's surface?
(more unsolved problems in physics)
wiki

The coronal heating problem in solar physics relates to the question of why the temperature of the Sun's corona is millions of kelvins higher than that of the surface. The high temperatures require energy to be carried from the solar interior to the corona by non-thermal processes, because the second law of thermodynamics prevents heat from flowing directly from the solar photosphere (surface), which is at about 5800 K, to the much hotter corona at about 1 to 3 MK (parts of the corona can even reach 10 MK).

So unfortunately for the likes of jd116 and ziggurat I understand there is a problem for the mainstream and there is NOT problem for the ELECTRIC SUN.

Or are you mob going to twist my words again just for sh&%s n giggles?

Just so there is no confusion, the ELECTRIC SUN is powered externally so therefore the corona is the hottest.

if it were to be P n P chain powered well.... you have a problem with the measured temperatures, as stated.

Between the photosphere and the corona, is the thin region through which the temperature increases known as the transition region. It ranges from only tens to hundreds of kilometers thick. Energy cannot be transferred from the cooler photosphere to the corona by conventional heat transfer as this would violate the second law of thermodynamics. An analogy of this would be a light bulb raising the temperature of the air surrounding it to something greater than its glass surface. Hence, some other manner of energy transfer must be involved in the heating of the corona.
wiki

Not a problem for the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE. :)
 
So which process to you ascribe to being able to HEAT the corona to a HOTTER temperature than the thing (Photosphere) supplying the HEAT?

What's hotter, your wall socket or your electric burner while cooking? Your burner. How can heat flow from your wall socket to your burner? Well, it can't. And it doesn't. Energy flows from your wall socket to your burner, not heat. Energy comes in many forms besides heat. And it gets turned into heat inside the burner, not inside the wall socket.

Again, you're failing at the level of basic thermodynamics, independent of any model of the sun.
 
Repeated lie that coronal heating is not a problem for the electric sun

19 March 2018: Repeated lie that coronal heating is not a problem for his deluded externally powered electric sun when the existence of the Sun is a problem :eye-poppi!.

No acknowledgement that he knows basic facts about the Sun (it is not a white dwarf as predicted by the electric sun).
Electric Sun delusions and lies from Sol88.
He lies twice by quote mining Wikipedia: The coronal heating problem and the empirically supported solutions. ( the solar heating problem is more which solution or solutions will emerge as evidence is collected).

+ the insane delusion that no fusion at all is happening in the Sun when we have detected the predicted neutrino flux ("powered externally")?
Sol88 do you have that delusion as well??

For others:
The detection of neutrinos from the p-p chain reaction (2015) that should only happen in the core of the Sun.
Neutrino produced in a chain of nuclear reactions in the Sun starting from the fusion of two protons, for the first time has been detected in a real-time detector in spectrometric mode. The unique properties of the Borexino detector provided an oppurtunity to disentangle pp-neutrino spectrum from the background components. A comparison of the total neutrino flux from the Sun with Solar luminosity in photons provides a test of the stability of the Sun on the 10 5 years time scale, and sets a strong limit on the power production in the unknown energy sources in the Sun of no more than 4\% of the total energy production at 90\% C.L.

The reason that the proton–proton chain reaction should only happen in the core of the Sun is the requirement for sustained temperature and pressure.
This first step is extremely slow because the positron emission of the diproton to deuterium is extremely rare (the vast majority of the time, the diproton decays back into two hydrogen-1 unbound protons through proton emission). This is because the emission of the positron is brought about by the weak nuclear force, which is immensely weaker than the strong nuclear force and the electromagnetic force.

The half-life of a proton in the core of the Sun before it is involved in a successful proton–proton fusion is estimated to be about one billion years, even at the extreme pressures and temperatures found there.
So the already deluded electric sun has to include a mechanism lasting long enough for that first step to happen, e.g. a billon protons at ~14 million degrees with a density of water for maybe a year :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
What's hotter, your wall socket or your electric burner while cooking? Your burner. How can heat flow from your wall socket to your burner? Well, it can't. And it doesn't. Energy flows from your wall socket to your burner, not heat. Energy comes in many forms besides heat. And it gets turned into heat inside the burner, not inside the wall socket.

Again, you're failing at the level of basic thermodynamics, independent of any model of the sun.

and


what type of energy is that Ziggurat?
 
and


what type of energy is that Ziggurat?

For the purposes of my point about thermodynamics, it doesn't matter. That is, in fact, the entire point. Thermodynamics places hard limits on ALL types of energy, limits which you're apparently in denial about.

There is no getting around thermodynamic limits.
 
Nearly said it ay, Ziggurat.

Go on say it, what type of energy heats the corona to temperatures HIGHER than the photosphere.

This will be interesting....:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Ohhh, like this

Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk

"your"" current sheets must be special, much like the author of some papers. Good book to read



Not just oppositely directed magnetic fields meeting!

If it is a good book to read, than maybe you should actually READ it.
Oh okay, it's not out yet (another paper I am waiting for to appear), but try Kivelson & Russell, introduction space physics, and actually try to learn some plasma physics.
My current sheets are normal Harris current sheets, created by curl B, but as you don't seem to know Maxwell's equations, it probably means nothing to you.
And of course there are also other ways of creating currents, e.g. through the shear motion of the footpoints of a magnetic loop on the Sun..

This is all very basic and simple plasma physics and/or electrodynamics. How can you be an EC proponent when you don't even know the basics of the theories on which the EC nonsense is supposed to be based?

It's mind boggling.
 
Including everybody’s favourite, field aligned currents.

Or

As we all know and love BIRKELAND CURRENTS.

How are they produced?

Does ideal MHD hold for Birkeland currents?

Tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
Repeat, the is NO coronal heating problem in the ELECTRIC SUN and the laws of thermodynamics hold.

Wrong. The electric sun fails on every level. Where are your neutrinos coming from? Neutrinos that can only come from fusion? Well, I'll tell you; Scott has the fusion happening in a z-pinch in a non-existent double layer in the chromosphere. Now go away and figure out why the very fact that you evolved (unfortunately) shows that to be impossible. Hint; gamma.
 
As we all know and love BIRKELAND CURRENTS.

How are they produced?

Does ideal MHD hold for Birkeland currents?

There are, as usual, various processed which produce field aligned currents.

Is there any reason you can come up with why ideal MHD would (not) hold for Birkeland currents?

Do you actually know what (ideal) MHD is, and what the restricting parameters are for (ideal) MHD, and do you think that field aligned currents are affected by that?

Does your question actually make sense?
 
Wrong. The electric sun fails on every level. Where are your neutrinos coming from? Neutrinos that can only come from fusion? Well, I'll tell you; Scott has the fusion happening in a z-pinch in a non-existent double layer in the chromosphere. Now go away and figure out why the very fact that you evolved (unfortunately) shows that to be impossible. Hint; gamma.


Not only that, if you take the beloved Juergens' model of the electric sun, and you just look at what happens with the interplanetary magnetic field, as I calculated here for realistic parameters you find that the field near the Earth would be on the order of Teslas instead of the measured nanoTeslas. It's only like 9 orders of magnitude wrong.
 
Not only that, if you take the beloved Juergens' model of the electric sun, and you just look at what happens with the interplanetary magnetic field, as I calculated here for realistic parameters you find that the field near the Earth would be on the order of Teslas instead of the measured nanoTeslas. It's only like 9 orders of magnitude wrong.

Indeed. EU-ists however, might prefer Thornhill's model. I'm not sure where Thornhill sets out this 'model', and have been trying to find out (if anybody knows, please post a link). However, Tom Bridgman has obviously seen it somewhere, as he tears it to shreds, here:
http://dealingwithcreationisminastr...09/death-by-electric-universe-iv-z-pinch.html

And, among other problems, we see the same one as Tusenfem has noted for Scott's/ Juergen's 'model'. That is, a magnetic field that is ~ 1 billion times that measured. It's funny how these people want to base the universe on EM, yet seem incapable of understanding either E or M!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom