tusenfem
Illuminator
- Joined
- May 27, 2008
- Messages
- 3,306
You make it TOO easy, tusenfem.![]()
Apparently, looking at your answers
There are field aligned currents as you stated above where MHD breaks down, also so stated above....
Where did I claim that?
Where do the circuits go? Say the one in the tail of the comet, just for an instance.
Monaco?
Have you developed the NEW findings from Rosetta yet wrt the PLASMA environment?
All my papers are about the plasma environment. Read them and learn.
And how that stacks up against the EXPECTED findings from a snowydirtball sublimating in the gentle warmth of the Sun.
Sublimation seems to work just fine.
First spacecraft/s past a comet proved the Whipple model incorrect.
No, you don't understand the scientific model. There were no in-situ data when Whipple tried to explain the non-keplerian motion of Comet 2P/Encke and he wrote up (please read and remember this time):
Whipple 1950 said:The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH4, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room emperature,
combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K). Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material.
This then became known as "dirty snowball" and indeed the flyby by 1P/Halley by Giotto, and the picture of the nucleus (which was never ever before able to be seen) showed a more "rocklike" structure than a "snowball" like, and thus people started to say a "snowy dirtball".
All the basics of Whipple are correct (otherwise he would not have been able to explain the non-keplerian motion of comets), the details have changed and will change because we become more and more in-situ observations.
This is clearly where you have a problem. You think that one person just claimed something in the 1950s and thus we must take that at face value and cannot change or develop on it any further. That is exactly where your hero Alfven warned about, when people without thinking started to use his frozen-in condition of the magnetic field in the plasma in every situation, which obviously cannot be done.
Now to close:
Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.

