Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
You make it TOO easy, tusenfem. ;)

Apparently, looking at your answers

There are field aligned currents as you stated above where MHD breaks down, also so stated above....

Where did I claim that?

Where do the circuits go? Say the one in the tail of the comet, just for an instance.

Monaco?

Have you developed the NEW findings from Rosetta yet wrt the PLASMA environment?

All my papers are about the plasma environment. Read them and learn.

And how that stacks up against the EXPECTED findings from a snowydirtball sublimating in the gentle warmth of the Sun.

Sublimation seems to work just fine.

First spacecraft/s past a comet proved the Whipple model incorrect.

No, you don't understand the scientific model. There were no in-situ data when Whipple tried to explain the non-keplerian motion of Comet 2P/Encke and he wrote up (please read and remember this time):

Whipple 1950 said:
The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH4, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room emperature,
combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K). Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material.

This then became known as "dirty snowball" and indeed the flyby by 1P/Halley by Giotto, and the picture of the nucleus (which was never ever before able to be seen) showed a more "rocklike" structure than a "snowball" like, and thus people started to say a "snowy dirtball".

All the basics of Whipple are correct (otherwise he would not have been able to explain the non-keplerian motion of comets), the details have changed and will change because we become more and more in-situ observations.

This is clearly where you have a problem. You think that one person just claimed something in the 1950s and thus we must take that at face value and cannot change or develop on it any further. That is exactly where your hero Alfven warned about, when people without thinking started to use his frozen-in condition of the magnetic field in the plasma in every situation, which obviously cannot be done.

Now to close:
Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.
 
Empirical science: fusion is proposed as the energy source for the Sun. Fusion produces neutrinos of various energies from the p-p chain. So, we ought to see them in the correct quantities at the correct energy levels. Build experiments to test the aforesaid. Detect the neutrinos at the predicted rate, and predicted energy levels. Game over.

Unempirical science: Predict that the Sun is powered electrically from an incoming current. Fail to find current, which should stick out like sore thumb. Realise that only fusion can produce neutrinos. Propose that it is happening due to z-pinch in DL in the chromosphere. Forget that this will kill us all with the gamma radiation that we don't detect. Build metal ball and put a gazillion volts through it. Irrelevant.


Well the SAFIRE team are doing empirical science, so you can do your song and dance but that’s what they are doing.

Not therotical science with mathamajical constructs or flavour changing neutrinos with no way to falsify the theoretical fairy dust.

Why not refire up the debate into the neutrino problem and whilst at it gravity wave detection!!! :boggled:

Or are we back on topic, jd116?

The ELECTRIC COMET. :thumbsup:
 
Why not refire up the debate into the neutrino problem and whilst at it gravity wave detection!!
There is no debate on either of those topics. They are a done deal, near as makes no difference.
 
Apparently, looking at your answers



Where did I claim that?



Monaco?



All my papers are about the plasma environment. Read them and learn.



Sublimation seems to work just fine.



No, you don't understand the scientific model. There were no in-situ data when Whipple tried to explain the non-keplerian motion of Comet 2P/Encke and he wrote up (please read and remember this time):



This then became known as "dirty snowball" and indeed the flyby by 1P/Halley by Giotto, and the picture of the nucleus (which was never ever before able to be seen) showed a more "rocklike" structure than a "snowball" like, and thus people started to say a "snowy dirtball".

All the basics of Whipple are correct (otherwise he would not have been able to explain the non-keplerian motion of comets), the details have changed and will change because we become more and more in-situ observations.

This is clearly where you have a problem. You think that one person just claimed something in the 1950s and thus we must take that at face value and cannot change or develop on it any further. That is exactly where your hero Alfven warned about, when people without thinking started to use his frozen-in condition of the magnetic field in the plasma in every situation, which obviously cannot be done.

Now to close:
Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.

Well the jets are not powered via subsurface pressure chambers of “gas” rocketing the nucleus in non keperlerian motion when the same affect is happening to the Rosetta probe.

And the mainstream interpret that as 533kg/m3 for ROCK.
 
Well the SAFIRE team are doing empirical science, so you can do your song and dance but that’s what they are doing.

Yes. The empirical science of what happens when you plug a metal ball into the mains. Of no relevance whatsoever to the Sun.
 
And the mainstream interpret that as 533kg/m3 for ROCK.

No interpretation needed. That is a measurement. As was Philae and Rosetta's descent to the comet, and the orbital characterisitics of large objects around the comet.
 
Anyways.................. to get back to comets, albeit non-electrical ones, there was a paper that drew my attention that was recently published:

Electron acceleration by wave turbulence in a magnetized plasma
Rigby, A. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-018-0059-2

From the paper:

The reason it drew my attention is that I was under the impression that the 'mystery' of X-ray production at comets was no longer a mystery, and hadn't been for some time. There has been a fair bit in the scientific literature about this since the initial discovery at comet Hyakutake in 1996. For instance:

MEASUREMENT OF CHARGE EXCHANGE AND X-RAY EMISSION CROSS SECTIONS FOR SOLAR WIND–COMET INTERACTIONS
Greenwood, J. B. et al.
https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/14080/00-0480.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

The mechanism appeared to be pretty much confirmed by the observations from Chandra and SWIFT of the impact at Tempel 1 in 2005:

SWIFT X-RAY TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Willingale, R. et al.
https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/publist/Willingale_ApJ_649_541_2006.pdf

and;

Chandra observations of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact campaign
Lisse, C. M. et al.
http://ftp.astro.umd.edu/pub/lisse/xrays/final_proof_YICAR8214_cml_comments_18jul2007.pdf

So, what to make of this new paper? Were they unaware of the strength of the evidence favouring the CX model? Have they discovered something new? I can't comment on the plasma physics involved, but it would appear that they have the X-ray action happening around the bow shock region, and it would appear that actual observation puts it somewhat closer in:

Spectral analysis of the Chandra comet survey
Bodewits, D. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full/2007/27/aa7410-07/aa7410-07.right.html

Perhaps their experimental findings have some relevance for other astronomical objects, but I'm not sure about the application to comets.

I will have to read it, to find out what "strong" magnetic field is, ah I found it, the sphere has 7 kGauss surface field! The strongest magnetic field found in space at a comet is 270 nT which is 2.7 mGauss, so I am dubious about their interplation, but like I said I need to read it better.

Apart from that the X-ray spectrum from comets is well correlated to high-ionization states of solar metals, and I am not sure if you can get those frequencies with an electron beam.

grr now I need to find the time to read this, whilst working on complicated plasma physics equations.
 
Yes. The empirical science of what happens when you plug a metal ball into the mains. Of no relevance whatsoever to the Sun.

Have a theory, build an experiment, test it, independently repete the experiment.

Case closed :D

SAFIRE are the first team I could find that are doing this kind of experimentation. So how would you know what they’ll find jd116?

Go build an experiment that can change the flavour of neutrinos and get back to me! ;)
 
Well the jets are not powered via subsurface pressure chambers of “gas” rocketing the nucleus in non keperlerian motion when the same affect is happening to the Rosetta probe.

And the mainstream interpret that as 533kg/m3 for ROCK.

what "affect" is happening to Rosetta

And
Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.
 
Have a theory, build an experiment, test it, independently repete the experiment.

Nope. Have a silly idea that is scientifically impossible; find zero evidence for it; build irrelevant experiment. Dead.
 
Apparently, looking at your answers



Where did I claim that?



Monaco?



All my papers are about the plasma environment. Read them and learn.



Sublimation seems to work just fine.



No, you don't understand the scientific model. There were no in-situ data when Whipple tried to explain the non-keplerian motion of Comet 2P/Encke and he wrote up (please read and remember this time):



This then became known as "dirty snowball" and indeed the flyby by 1P/Halley by Giotto, and the picture of the nucleus (which was never ever before able to be seen) showed a more "rocklike" structure than a "snowball" like, and thus people started to say a "snowy dirtball".

All the basics of Whipple are correct (otherwise he would not have been able to explain the non-keplerian motion of comets), the details have changed and will change because we become more and more in-situ observations.

This is clearly where you have a problem. You think that one person just claimed something in the 1950s and thus we must take that at face value and cannot change or develop on it any further. That is exactly where your hero Alfven warned about, when people without thinking started to use his frozen-in condition of the magnetic field in the plasma in every situation, which obviously cannot be done.

Now to close:
Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12226390&postcount=1874

So all that smarts and the best you can come with is the electric currents in the tail of the comet go to Monaco????

There is an electric circuit and MHD doe not apply, full stop!

Oh oh oh and DOUBLE LAYERS!!!!

As found by Vega 1 & 2 and repeorted by H.Laskko

PotentiL DROP OF 145Kv!!! and. Or just one boundary with a potential drop but several, just like SAFIRE are finding in their investigation into double layers.

Are their any double layers in space or only in the lab , tusenfem?
 
Already been done. Try to keep up.

Reference? All it bs!

Through the 1970s, it was widely believed that neutrinos were massless and their flavors were invariant. However, in 1968 Pontecorvo proposed that if neutrinos had mass, then they could change from one flavor to another.[7] Thus, the "missing" solar neutrinos could be electron neutrinos which changed into other flavors along the way to Earth, rendering them invisible to the detectors in the Homestake Mine and contemporary neutrino observatories.
wiki

Just change the premise???

Do some tricky math and viola problem goes away!
 
Are their any double layers in space or only in the lab , tusenfem?

And of what relevance are they? Are they supposed to create the EDM (LOL) that failed to matrialise? What do you want them to do? Turn H+ into H2O? Make rock appear to be icy dust? Please do explain.
 
Last edited:

wow quote and link

So all that smarts and the best you can come with is the electric currents in the tail of the comet go to Monaco????

yeah, I am that kind of guy.

There is an electric circuit and MHD doe not apply, full stop!

Wow, Alfven would be rather surprised at this claim.
So, you basically don't know what MHD is, and neither do you know its relationship to circuit modeling of plasma, *SAD*

Oh oh oh and DOUBLE LAYERS!!!!

ohh, squirrel ........

As found by Vega 1 & 2 and repeorted by H.Laskko

PotentiL DROP OF 145Kv!!! and. Or just one boundary with a potential drop but several, just like SAFIRE are finding in their investigation into double layers.

First of all, it is LAAKSO, secondly, Harri does not really believe his own claim in that paper, as has been pointed out to you numerous times.
No idea what a "PotentiL" is and "145 Kv" does not make any physical sense

Are their any double layers in space or only in the lab , tusenfem?

As the wiki on double layers is basically the introduction of my PhD thesis, I guess you know the answer.

Please explain what (ideal) MHD means and whether that ex/includes field aligned currents.
 
They stuck a probe in it and measured it. Didn’t have to look thru anything!

They also found some thing very interesting when they vaporised the Tungsten probe tip... ;)

Nobody stuck a probe in the sun.
 
Oh dear :blush:

Particle accelerators? Mmmmmm....interesting , tell me more. How do they accelerate particles using a hydrogen bomb?

Vega 1 and 2 detected the electric comet back in the 80’s but the moanstream have their craniums wedged so firmly...

Have a look at the current when the dust impacts start! :cool: tops of scale!

Yeah, that answer is so idiotic I don't even know how to respond.

Oh and using emoticons to try and have a scientific discussion does not actually give a professional impression. In fact, it comes across as the childish attempt of someone failing to give any actual proof.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom