jonesdave116
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2015
- Messages
- 6,222
Some more idiocy:
So, this H2O vapour, which is somehow disocciated from hydrated silicates, at lord knows what temperature, is somehow in a state to "spontaneously" form ice grains? Dear me, where did you get this rubbish, Sol? As if I couldn't guess! The temperatures required to melt silcate grains are almost certainly going to also leave H and O separated. And rather warm! Why would they form ice?
Added to this is the fact that you already have H2O in the coma prior to the impact at Tempel 1 (and at every other comet). Why isn't that H2O "spontaneously" forming ice grains? Under the much more benign conditions of it not being as hot as hell? Why do we see dirty great chunks of ice around Hartley 2, as well as water vapour? Why do we see lots of water vapour around 67P, but little in the way of ice grains?
Still, I guess if you can believe that Earth used to orbit Saturn, that Venus can do handbrake turns around the solar system, and that comets were blasted off of Earth by electrical woo, then all that is probably no problem for EU wooists!
.......into h2o vapour which spontaneously forms elongated water ice of 1um.
So, this H2O vapour, which is somehow disocciated from hydrated silicates, at lord knows what temperature, is somehow in a state to "spontaneously" form ice grains? Dear me, where did you get this rubbish, Sol? As if I couldn't guess! The temperatures required to melt silcate grains are almost certainly going to also leave H and O separated. And rather warm! Why would they form ice?
Added to this is the fact that you already have H2O in the coma prior to the impact at Tempel 1 (and at every other comet). Why isn't that H2O "spontaneously" forming ice grains? Under the much more benign conditions of it not being as hot as hell? Why do we see dirty great chunks of ice around Hartley 2, as well as water vapour? Why do we see lots of water vapour around 67P, but little in the way of ice grains?
Still, I guess if you can believe that Earth used to orbit Saturn, that Venus can do handbrake turns around the solar system, and that comets were blasted off of Earth by electrical woo, then all that is probably no problem for EU wooists!
