Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some more idiocy:

.......into h2o vapour which spontaneously forms elongated water ice of 1um.

So, this H2O vapour, which is somehow disocciated from hydrated silicates, at lord knows what temperature, is somehow in a state to "spontaneously" form ice grains? Dear me, where did you get this rubbish, Sol? As if I couldn't guess! The temperatures required to melt silcate grains are almost certainly going to also leave H and O separated. And rather warm! Why would they form ice?
Added to this is the fact that you already have H2O in the coma prior to the impact at Tempel 1 (and at every other comet). Why isn't that H2O "spontaneously" forming ice grains? Under the much more benign conditions of it not being as hot as hell? Why do we see dirty great chunks of ice around Hartley 2, as well as water vapour? Why do we see lots of water vapour around 67P, but little in the way of ice grains?
Still, I guess if you can believe that Earth used to orbit Saturn, that Venus can do handbrake turns around the solar system, and that comets were blasted off of Earth by electrical woo, then all that is probably no problem for EU wooists!
 
Right, well, I've looked at Sol's last post and tried to make sense of what he was quoting in terms of what relevance it actually had to what he (or whoever) was trying to say. Can't say I'm totally clear on that still! However, here is a translation for those who may be having trouble understanding the papers by Sunshine and Melosh, and the sequence of events:
First off, there is an impact! This is at about 30 degrees from the horizontal, and at ~ 10 km/s. After that, the surface and near surface layers are ejected at high velocity downrange. This is very hot material, and appears to be molten. It could be silicates, or it could be carbon from organics. This hot plume contains signatures of H2O, CO2 and organics. The signatures are consitent with this material being at temperatures of ~ 1000-2000 K. Wayyyyyyy too hot for ice to form. And it doesn't. This material is possibly from the surface down to 1-2m. The hot water vapour shows that there was ice within this surface/ near surface material. So, that little lot toddles off downrange, and then we have .......................................... a two component plume, consisting of dust and water ice, as seen due to absorption in the IR spectra. The dust in the plume spreads out laterally, whereas the ice is collimated. Based on the shadow of the plume, as well as exhaustive testing done in the lab at the NASA Ames vertical gun range, by Pete Scultz, the ice-rich component is an almost vertical, low velocity ejecta cloud, and is likely to be from the deepest penetration depth of the impact. The dust is from shallower depths, and spreads laterally.
So, the upshot of this is that any H2O liberated from hydrated silicate grains, in Sol's (or whoever's) bizarre scenario, is well downrange when the ice is ejected. And is vapour. And is too hot to do anything. The ice ejected in the near vertical column is cold. Obviously. Too cold to have been due to the strange story that Sol (or whoever) has cobbled together in desperation. It really isn't that hard to understand if you actually read the paper carefully.

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Sunshine, J. et al.
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5abd/57ce43924466abb4c4f3bca01f2a50dd12a3.pdf
 
Last edited:
And I already pointed out to you that he believes the smaller grains must come from the disintegration of larger grains:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12151504&postcount=1312

To add to that I just emailed him, and said:



To which he replied:



I'm not sure what happened to b), but he's probably busy! Happy to take an image of the emails and post them. No point, though, as Sol will then label Skorov as a mainstream lackey, or words to that effect.
In summary; let's forget the Skorov papers as being anything to do with EU woo. Next.

In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical
parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation
of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding
to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Maybe you are correct, Skorov paper may not have ANYTHING at all to do with the ELECTRIC COMET

but

it is FATAL to the dirtysnowball!

as has been mention in more papers than Skorov's alone. :D

A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix
is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993)
and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff
& Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading
results: they should be repeated assuming a refractorymatrix, which
has micro-properties far from ices.
The larger the dust-to-water
ratio, the larger the porosity required to fit the observed nucleus
bulk density.
Unexpected and significant findings in comet
67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
 
whiiiiich gets us straight back to.....
Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depthsexcavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1 ± 1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory impurities.

So AGAIN since no one here can tell me, 'cos this dumb arse can't read, it's pure ice under a dirty ice layer????

So how would this ice look?

Bet you JD116, Tusenfem and any other armchair scientist can tell the lurkers here.

Just copy the paragraph were it tells me how this pure ice is structured, i'll wait.
 
Maybe you are correct, Skorov paper may not have ANYTHING at all to do with the ELECTRIC COMET

but

it is FATAL to the dirtysnowball!

as has been mention in more papers than Skorov's alone. :D

Unexpected and significant findings in comet
67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Errr, no, that just proves that you haven't taken the slightest notice of anything discovered on this mission or others. I'm getting tired of your wilful ignorance, meaning we have to post the same things, time after time after time after time. Go away, and pollute another forum. Better still, learn to read.
There is ice. Plenty of it. As proven multiple times. Get over it.
 
So AGAIN since no one here can tell me, 'cos this dumb arse can't read, it's pure ice under a dirty ice layer????

So how would this ice look?

Yet again proving my point about how pointless this thread now is! What do you expect micron and sub-micron sized ice grains to look like? Garden peas? This is a pointless waste of time, trying to explain things to somebody who has neither the knowledge, nor the desire to acquire the knowledge, to understand what is being discussed. Yet still has the belief that he can single-handedly overthrow extremely well attested science. Go back to your mythology nonsense, science is not for you. You have a religious belief in something, and cannot let it go. As bad as a creationist.
 
A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Learn to read, woo boy:

we can not explain the removal of small particles consistently,

at the same time we can admit their secondary origin, but we can
not firmly prove this
 
Yet again proving my point about how pointless this thread now is! What do you expect micron and sub-micron sized ice grains to look like? Garden peas? This is a pointless waste of time, trying to explain things to somebody who has neither the knowledge, nor the desire to acquire the knowledge, to understand what is being discussed. Yet still has the belief that he can single-handedly overthrow extremely well attested science. Go back to your mythology nonsense, science is not for you. You have a religious belief in something, and cannot let it go. As bad as a creationist.

I’d expect it would be solid ice, all those micron and sub micron ice grains compressed together.

Or it highly porous

Which is it jd116?


Answer is you don’t know!
 
Right, well, I've looked at Sol's last post and tried to make sense of what he was quoting in terms of what relevance it actually had to what he (or whoever) was trying to say. Can't say I'm totally clear on that still! However, here is a translation for those who may be having trouble understanding the papers by Sunshine and Melosh, and the sequence of events:
First off, there is an impact! This is at about 30 degrees from the horizontal, and at ~ 10 km/s. After that, the surface and near surface layers are ejected at high velocity downrange. This is very hot material, and appears to be molten. It could be silicates, or it could be carbon from organics. This hot plume contains signatures of H2O, CO2 and organics. The signatures are consitent with this material being at temperatures of ~ 1000-2000 K. Wayyyyyyy too hot for ice to form. And it doesn't. This material is possibly from the surface down to 1-2m. The hot water vapour shows that there was ice within this surface/ near surface material. So, that little lot toddles off downrange, and then we have .......................................... a two component plume, consisting of dust and water ice, as seen due to absorption in the IR spectra. The dust in the plume spreads out laterally, whereas the ice is collimated. Based on the shadow of the plume, as well as exhaustive testing done in the lab at the NASA Ames vertical gun range, by Pete Scultz, the ice-rich component is an almost vertical, low velocity ejecta cloud, and is likely to be from the deepest penetration depth of the impact. The dust is from shallower depths, and spreads laterally.
So, the upshot of this is that any H2O liberated from hydrated silicate grains, in Sol's (or whoever's) bizarre scenario, is well downrange when the ice is ejected. And is vapour. And is too hot to do anything. The ice ejected in the near vertical column is cold. Obviously. Too cold to have been due to the strange story that Sol (or whoever) has cobbled together in desperation. It really isn't that hard to understand if you actually read the paper carefully.

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Sunshine, J. et al.
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5abd/57ce43924466abb4c4f3bca01f2a50dd12a3.pdf

Could be either? Could also be hydrated silicates.

Spectra look very similar...
Results. Both the color temperature of the grains in the ejecta cloud (375 ± 5 K) and their size distribution show that a large quantity of submicron grains were ejected by the impact. The velocity of the smallest grains is 230 m s−1, with a power index for the size dependence of 0.3−0.5, in agreement with gas loading. The total mass of dust is (0.7−1.2) × 105 kg for grain sizes 0.1−1 μm and (0.5−2.1) × 106 kg for sizes 0.1−100 μm. A sustained production of water is observed, which can be explained by the sublimation of pure ice grains with sizes less than 1 μm and comprising a mass of ice of (0.8−1.8) × 107 kg. The contribution of dirty ice grains to the ice budget is negligible. Assuming that water was essentially produced by icy grains present in the ejecta cloud, our measurements suggest a very high ice-to-dust ratio of about 10 in the excavated material, which greatly exceeds the gas-to-dust production rate ratio of ∼0.5 measured for the background coma. Alternately, if a large amount of material felt back to the surface and sublimated, ice-to-dust ratios of 1−3 are not excluded. A better understanding of the cratering event on 9P/Tempel 1 is required to disentangle between the two hypotheses. Evidence for grain fragmentation in the ejecta cloud is found in the data. The pre-impact water production rate is measured to be (4.7 ± 0.7) × 1027 mol s−1.
Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event

Assumed to be ice sublimating in the coma as evidence for water ice under the surface????

There was more dust than ice..
 
Last edited:
I’d expect it would be solid ice, all those micron and sub micron ice grains compressed together.

Or it highly porous

Which is it jd116?


Answer is you don’t know!

What does it matter what I know? It was ice, you loon.
 
Could be either? Could also be hydrated silicates.

Spectra look very similar...

So what? It has nothing whatsoever to do with the ice grains seen at Tempel 1, or Hartley 2, or 17P Holmes, or Hale-Bopp, or 67p. Does it? That there is ice in the coma, on the surface and below the surface, is 100% proven. This whole conversation is pointless. Go away, and talk to people who think dinosaurs were too heavy, and couldn't exist unless gravity was less in the past! That is more up your street, I would have thought.
 
A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Learn to read, woo boy:

Learning learning reading and reading

The strong correlation between the water ice, dust, and CO2 spatial distribution supports the concept that CO2 gas drags the water ice and dust grains from the nucleus. Once in the coma, the water ice begins subliming while the dust is in a constant outflow.
Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet 103P/Hartley 2 Silvia Protopapaa, Jessica M. Sunshinea, Lori M. Feagaa, Michael S. P. Kelleya, Michael F. A’ Hearna, Tony L. Farnhama, Olivier Groussinb, Sebastien Bessea,c, Fre ́de ́ric Merlind, Jian-Yang Lie

Then does some more learnings and readings...

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1, and H. U. Keller2

Then jd116 has a sooky la la moment :blush:

Still waiting on b: jd116?
 
Last edited:
So what? It has nothing whatsoever to do with the ice grains seen at Tempel 1, or Hartley 2, or 17P Holmes, or Hale-Bopp, or 67p. Does it? That there is ice in the coma, on the surface and below the surface, is 100% proven. This whole conversation is pointless. Go away, and talk to people who think dinosaurs were too heavy, and couldn't exist unless gravity was less in the past! That is more up your street, I would have thought.

Surface ice....:p

We saw shed loads!!!:D
 
Surface ice....

We saw shed loads!!!

Ohhh Jesus, here we go again (aside to the audience: see what I mean about this being pointless?).
There is subsurface ice. As pointed out numerous times. Deal with the evidence instead of talking crap. It's getting boring.
 
What’s your knowledge of hydrated silica, jd116?

3.1.2. Spectral Identifications

[22] We also analyzed this province spectrally, and thermal spectroscopy shows that the predominant regional surface composition near the depression is basaltic, dominated by the presence of plagioclase and pyroxene. Additionally, most of the depression floor, walls and knobs are consistent with a surface of basaltic composition based on interpretation of THEMIS spectral data. We find isolated plagioclase- and quartz-bearing mineral exposures in units previously described and interpreted as granitoid/quartzofeldspathic [Bandfield et al., 2004a; Bandfield, 2006]. The specific identification of crystalline quartz has been positively identified with TES by observing a diagnostic absorption feature at 20 microns that uniquely matches the position and shape of quartz, instead of the more poorly crystalline silica polymorphs (opal-A and opal-CT) [Bandfield et al., 2004a]. The quartz-bearing surfaces are spatially coincident with light-toned deposits along the northwestern rim of the depression and within isolated locations on the depression floor.

[23] In addition to thermal spectroscopy, we also analyzed the province in the near-infrared with CRISM. The spectra display clear absorptions at 1.4 and 1.9 μm, and a broad 2.21 μm feature associated with deposits on the floor of the depression. These features are most consistent with the presence of hydrated silica, such as opal (Figure 3c). Previous work on Martian hydrated silica have noted that the location of the 1.4 μm band will shift to 1.38–1.39 μm as water is lost under desiccating conditions [Milliken et al., 2008] or that the location of the 1.4 μm band will shift to longer wavelengths for more crystalline phases (M. S. Rice et al., Reflectance spectra diversity of silica-rich materials: Sensitivity to environment and implications for detections on Mars, manuscript in preparation, 2012). Because the band centers of our 1.4 μm feature are located at ∼1.42–1.43 μm, this would suggest that either this silica is more hydrated or crystalline than elsewhere on the planet. In this spectrum, and many other spectra collected for this study, we also see an absorption at 2 μm that is attributed to an incomplete removal of atmospheric CO2 during the correction; because of this, we ignore this feature in all of our analyzed spectra. We also detect a separate mineral phase in small exposures (5–10 pixels) within the layered knobs in the southwest, with absorption features at 1.4 and 1.9 μm, and additional features at 2.31 and 2.39 μm, consistent with a Mg-bearing clay, possibly saponite (Figure 3d). The phyllosilicate exposures are not resolvable with visible imagery, because there is no HiRISE coverage over the layered knobs. CTX images are available over the knobs, but do not offer sufficient resolution to resolve individual exposures.
. Geology of quartz and hydrated silica-bearing deposits near Antoniadi Crater, Mars

So could be molten silica or carbon or hydrated silica or pink faries with gossamer wings for all the mainstream know!

Something about comets being blasted from planets...
 
Last edited:
Ohhh Jesus, here we go again (aside to the audience: see what I mean about this being pointless?).
There is subsurface ice. As pointed out numerous times. Deal with the evidence instead of talking crap. It's getting boring.

How much surface ice on the nucleus of Hartley 2, jd116?
 
What’s your knowledge of hydrated silica, jd116?

. Geology of quartz and hydrated silica-bearing deposits near Antoniadi Crater, Mars

So could be molten silica or carbon or hydrated silica or pink faries with gossamer wings for all the mainstream know!

Something about comets being blasted from planets...


Better than your knowledge of just about everything, I would say. Why do you think I wrote this very recent post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12212901&postcount=1636 ????

It was so people of limited intellect could understand that whatever the molten material was, it was nowhere near the ice in space or time. Read it again. Take one word at a time. Would you like me to draw a piccy?
 
What’s your knowledge of hydrated silica, jd116?

. Geology of quartz and hydrated silica-bearing deposits near Antoniadi Crater, Mars

So could be molten silica or carbon or hydrated silica or pink faries with gossamer wings for all the mainstream know!

Something about comets being blasted from planets...


So, many varities of mineral dust, none of which, given the measured bulk density and porosity, are rock. Thanks for the info, Sol!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom