Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yada, yada, yada. More unadulterated tripe. In case you hadn't noticed, there are no double layers. Duh. In case you had further failed to notice, there are no solar wind ions anywhere within cooee of the nucleus for long periods. Learn to read. The idiotic, impossible model you and the idiot Thornhill support gets you zero water. That isn't what is found is it? Give up. You are too scientifically illiterate to even have a sensible conversation with. Your posts are a complete joke, and an embarrassment. You've seriously lost the plot since this lunatic, unscientific rubbish failed completely to deliver. I'm almost thinking that you were stupid enough to actually believe it! But surely, nobody is that........then again.


Sorry not “double layers” but ambipolar electric fields! :rolleyes:

RIP DIRTYSNOWBALL.
 
You are another ignorant mainstream “dirtysnowballer”.

Not your fault you have trouble with critical thinking and complex processes!

Stay inside your box where it’s nice and safe.

Now back to your play doh and crayons!

Where in your “ice” is the o2 located?

Answer, you don’t know so go for the safe option and .....just don’t answer.

It’s also perfectly fine to say “I don’t know”

The O2 is still a dirty snowball killing piece of evidence!

Along with a whole raft of other “issues” that falsify the “standard dirtysnowball’ model.

And it case you have not grasped it yet “mainstream” peer reviewed scientists are throwing doubt on the whole model.

So far when they do, they are shunned and pushed to the side. Y.Skorov is a prime ample here along with the author jd116 contacted.

There are electric fields on the surface of a comet, it’s undeniable, unless your jd16.
 
Last edited:
It's all standard Conspiracy/pseudoscience Playbook.

Keeping the thread going is a win, it makes you look like you have something worth discussing.
Misrepresenting mainstream research when it supports your case even though you reject the mainstream model.
Churn for a few weeks then reset back to points already discussed and debunked.
Mock and insult the mainstream contributors.

Points already debunked.....until a new peer reviewed mainstream paper comes out then it’s back on the table...like:

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

What’s your take swoopy on the revision needed on the assumptions employed by the cometary community?

Sublimation can not lift the observed fine dust of the nucleus of a comet! That’s a biggy ‘ol mate a real biggy!


Nuff’n I bet because you don’t know!:o
 
Last edited:
Homework for you jd116.

What model was used for the “outgassing” from 19P/Holmes? Why did Comet 17P/Holmes burst out? Nucleus splitting or delayed sublimation?
W. J. Altenhoff1, E. Kreysa1, K. M. Menten1, A. Sievers3, C. Thum2, and A. Weiss1

Another comet that killed the dirtysnowball but nothing to see here, move along

:rolleyes:

Your “ougassing” models are fantasies!
In fact the “model” for comets is ad hoc complete rubbish with no basis in reality.

No, woo boy, you are the one with a failed model with zero evidence, let alone any valid science to back it up. It is mythology based trash. Which is why nobody takes it seriously. The outgassing model has ALL the evidence, as has been repeatedly shown to you. However, your scientifically illiterate mind cannot let go of your quasi-religious beliefs in Thornhill's woo. As I've said before, scientific illiteracy is a prerequisite for believing in that garbage. Anybody that isn't, wouldn't. You prove the point perfectly.
And for your information, guess what was observed when 17P Holmes was observed after outburst? Yep, solid ice. No rock, no electric woo.
 
What model of “outgassing” does a super duper space plasma physicist use?

I would imagine it would be one that makes scientific sense, as opposed to the unadulterated crap that you religiously believe.
 
Last edited:
You are another ignorant mainstream “dirtysnowballer”.

Not your fault you have trouble with critical thinking and complex processes!

Any body else seeing the irony here? Lol. Electric comet believer? Calling anyone ignorant? Haha. Where was Saturn again, a few thousand years ago? Dear me.

Stay inside your box where it’s nice and safe.

Nope, stay with the theory that is both scientific, and has evidence to back it up. As opposed to the one that is scientifically impossible, with zero evidence.

Where in your “ice” is the o2 located?

Why don't you read the papers, woo boy? There are plenty on the possible formation of O2 within the H2O ice.

Answer, you don’t know so go for the safe option and .....just don’t answer.

Lol. More irony, anyone? Where are your DLs? Where are your discharges? Where is your rock? How are you making the water and other gases? Etc, etc. All questions that the EC loons cannot answer.


The O2 is still a dirty snowball killing piece of evidence!

Err, no it isn't. That just shows your ignorance. Yet again.

Along with a whole raft of other “issues” that falsify the “standard dirtysnowball’ model.

No, there aren't.

And it case you have not grasped it yet “mainstream” peer reviewed scientists are throwing doubt on the whole model.

No, they aren't. Please tell me with whom you have corresponded to come to that conclusion? Want me to email a few of them?

So far when they do, they are shunned and pushed to the side. Y.Skorov is a prime ample here along with the author jd116 contacted

Crap. It is quite obvious what Skorov thinks is happening, and I've posted the link to it numerous times. As for Giapis, it is obvious that their model doesn't work. As he himself admits. Can't get the quantities, can't figure out a way past the DCBL. It is dead.

There are electric fields on the surface of a comet, it’s undeniable, unless your jd16.

Really? And the evidence for this is....? And what are they supposed to be doing, hmmm?
 
Last edited:
Points already debunked.....until a new peer reviewed mainstream paper comes out then it’s back on the table...like:



What’s your take swoopy on the revision needed on the assumptions employed by the cometary community?

Sublimation can not lift the observed fine dust of the nucleus of a comet! That’s a biggy ‘ol mate a real biggy!


Nuff’n I bet because you don’t know!:o

Rinse and repeat. I'm beginning to think you really do have Alzheimer's. Already answered multiple times by linking to Skorov's own papers. Try reading, if that is within your skillset. Beginning to doubt that.
 
Jd116, take a breath and focus.

I can’t recall inany of my post about the origin of comets that’s beyond the scope being discussed here.

Skorov threw down the challenge sublimating “ICE” can not do what mainstream assumed it did.

The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Away out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Focus.

Forget centrifugal “spin up” introduces MORE problems for the mainstream.

I’d assume the model Tusenfem would use, would be based of the dust gas ratio, throws a spanner in that little endeavour!
 
Last edited:
Anyway, leaving the woo merchants behind, there is a newish paper on thermal crack polygons recently published. These are known to occur on Earth and Mars. They only ever occur in the presence of near-surface ice in those places. There are thousands of them on 67P. Unfortunately, the paper is paywalled.

Meter-scale thermal contraction crack polygons on the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Auger, A.-T. et al.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0019103516300410

And a somewhat earlier conference abstract on the same subject:
Meter-scale thermal contraction crack polygons on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Auger, A.-T. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2015DPS....4750003A

All of which tells us something that we already knew or inferred - that the ice is close to the surface; that there is a sintered layer close to the surface; and that the tensile strength of the material is not high. Don't you love it when various lines of evidence dovetail like this? :)
 
Jd116, take a breath and focus.

I can’t recall inany of my post about the origin of comets that’s beyond the scope being discussed here.

Skorov threw down the challenge sublimating “ICE” can not do what mainstream assumed it did.



Focus.

Forget centrifugal “spin up” introduces MORE problems for the mainstream.

I’d assume the model Tusenfem would use, would be based of the dust gas ratio, throws a spanner in that little endeavour!

Right, fine. I'll email Skorov. Happy now? No, because you'll just call him a mainstream lackey when he repeats what he has already said in his papers. Got any questions that you haven't got the cojones to ask him personally, before I send the email? Try to make them intelligent.
 
Why did Comet 17P/Holmes burst out?
Nucleus splitting or delayed sublimation?


Molecular production rates. Production of gas-phase molecules is responsible for all the cometary activity. It is pre- dominantly the cometary wind of the H2 O molecules, which lifts the dust particles from the nucleus, so a correlation between H2O and dust production is expected. Usually the production of dif- ferent molecules shows a fixed ratio, so that one can, e.g., pre- dict the H2 O production rate from HCN observations. Not so for comet Holmes! Figure 1 shows that H2O production, observed with the SWAN satellite, lasts at least for a month as does the enhanced mm continuum emission, while e.g. the spectral lines of HCN, CO, NH3 (Drahus et al. 2007; Biver et al. 2008; Menten 2007) had a big signal at the start, which apparently petered out dramatically after 3 days, as shown in Fig. 1

Throw a spanner in those calculations as well!

House of cards, with wind picking up!
 
Right, fine. I'll email Skorov. Happy now? No, because you'll just call him a mainstream lackey when he repeats what he has already said in his papers. Got any questions that you haven't got the cojones to ask him personally, before I send the email? Try to make them intelligent.

Yeah, that’d be great, cheers.

“COULD strong surface electric fields be responsible for ejection of fine dust into the coma”

See what he reckons, ay? :thumbsup:
 
Rinse and repeat. I'm beginning to think you really do have Alzheimer's. Already answered multiple times by linking to Skorov's own papers. Try reading, if that is within your skillset. Beginning to doubt that.

Already explained it's a standard tactic.
Beat you down until you give up then declare victory.
 
Already explained it's a standard tactic.
Beat you down until you give up then declare victory.

:p

Beats captain swoop and jd116 down on that comets are ROCKS! :D

Btw this is a new paper by the peer reviewed mainstream method.

Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase M. Knapmeyer a , ∗, H.-H. Fischer b , J. Knollenberg a , K.J. Seidensticker a , K. Thiel c , W. Arnold d , e , C. Faber a , D. Möhlmann a , 1

Taking together the evidence from MUPUS, CIVA, ROLIS, CON- SERT, and SESAME, as well as the results of the KOSI experiments, we find that all these instruments, on a set of nested length scales from millimeters to tens of meters, are consistent with a structure of a body that has a thin, consolidated shell around a less rigid interior.

non-penetration of MUPUS only. [m5G; December 22, 2017;9:29 ] The constructive and detailed comments of two anonymus re- viewers are gratefully acknowledged. Brigitte Knapmeyer-Endrun, Max-Planck Institute for Solar Sys- tem Research, Göttingen, commented on earlier versions of the manuscript and helped increasing its readability. 2. Layer B : a rigid layer with a thickness of at least 10 cm, but possibly even 50 cm thickness. The arrival times we analyzed result from the properties of this layer. Assuming a density be- tween 515 kg m −3 and 1635 kg m −3 , we find a shear modu- lus between 3.6 MPa and 346 MPa, a Young’s modulus between 7.2 MPa and 980 MPa, and a bulk porosity below 0.74.

For the evaluation, we consider only those compositions in which shear wave velocity is between V S, low and V S, max . Following the literature discussed in Section 2 , we exclude com- positions with densities outside of 515 ≤ ρ ≤1635 kg m −3 (30) i.e. below the 3 σ lower bound for the comet’s bulk density after Pätzold et al. (2015) or above the upper limit of particle densities according to Fulle et al. (2016) .

So again the above paper is humstrung based on the assumptions of a light fluffy nucleus!



How about emailing them as well jd116 and tell to use the full measured range of dust densities?

Rosetta dust collectors are sampling both very pristine fluffy aggregates and compact particles with a bulk density from 800 to $3\times {{10}^{3}}$ kg m−3 (Rotundi et al. 2015) and coming from the inner solar system.
DENSITY AND CHARGE OF PRISTINE FLUFFY PARTICLES FROM COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO


And I’m still calling ROCK!

So yeah
Churn for a few weeks then reset back to points already discussed and debunked.
captain swoop

It’s an open ended debate and NOTHING is settled.

Care to discuss, captain swoop?
 
Last edited:
THE FRIABLE SPONGE MODEL OF A COMETARY NUCLEUS M. Horanyi,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 T. E. Cravens,2 A. Korosmezey,1 K. Kecskemety,1 A. F. Nagy,2 AND K. SZEGO1

ABSTRACT
The mantle/core model of cometary nuclei, first suggested by Whipple and subsequently developed by Mendis and Brin, is modified and extended in this paper. New terms are added to the heat conduction equation for the mantle, which is solved in order to obtain the temperature distribution in the mantle and the gas production rate as a function of mantle thickness and heliocentric distance. These results are then combined with some specific assumptions about the mantle structure (the friable sponge model) in order to make predictions for the variation of gas production rate and mantle thickness as functions of heliocentric distance for different comets. In an Appendix we present a solution of the time-dependent heat conduction equation in order to check some of our assumptions.

Interesting in the above post about the MUPUS findings, don’t ya think jd116?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that’d be great, cheers.

“COULD strong surface electric fields be responsible for ejection of fine dust into the coma”


See what he reckons, ay? :thumbsup:

Not his area. All he would do is refer me to experts in the field. Therefore you would be better off asking that question of the likes of;

Xu.Wang at colorado.edu
Mihaly.Horanyi at colorado.edu
tom.nordheim.10 at ucl.ac.uk

Horanyi and Wang seem to be at the forefront of the latest dust levitation studies coming out of Boulder. We have discussed their work on here before. You might also look for Eberhard Grun, who has also been part of that group, but is officially retired.
I would warn you that all except Wang have been authors on one or more papers about 67P. None of them have so far suggested electrostatic dust lifting to solve Skorov's problems.
Furthermore, as also previously discussed, why is this happening at comets, but not asteroids?
Something else I would throw in the mix is that the dust, by definition, has to be charged. What is happening when that charged dust reaches the diamagnetic cavity boundary, and the piled-up IMF? I'm no expert, but how is it getting beyond the DCBL to be detected by the spacecraft? Or is it losing charge above the envisaged plasma sheath? Can this plasma sheath even exist when the DC has formed? Will the grain have sufficient velocity to escape the comet, or will it just float back down?
Another thing to ponder is if the electrostatic force is sufficient to overcome the same cohesive forces that Skorov notes cannot be overcome by sublimation. I would say possibly not, as per fig. 1 in this conference abstract:

Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets
Hatzell, C. M. & Carter, D.
https://www.epj-conferences.org/articles/epjconf/pdf/2017/09/epjconf162466.pdf

(Hartzell was formerly with Wang & Horanyi at Boulder, and is somebody else that might be worth asking.)

So, I would say that the electrostatic model has more problems than sublimation for lifting these smaller grains, and that fragmentation of larger grains within the coma is far more likely.
 
It’s an open ended debate and NOTHING is settled

No, it isn't. As far as I can see there are only one or two people on the planet who still believe in this idiotic woo. It is no more a debate than astrology, which has far more adherents.
And the paper you stupidly quoted (Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase) is the same one whose abstract I have linked umpteen times to show the what CASSE/ SESAME observed was consistent with the low strength of a porous ice surface, and nowhere near that of rock!!! How stupid can you be? Why don't you read these damned things when they are first linked, instead of embarrassing yourself like this? To wit:

The abstract I've linked a squillion times:

Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmeyer, M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K

....this velocity translates into a shear modulus of the comet material of at least 3.2 MPa. Shear modulus scales with velocity squared, so when taking into account the formal uncertainties arising from the arrival time inversion, the shear modulus may easily be as large as 10 MPa. This is still low compared to solid rock or monocrystalline ice, but is compatible with highly porous materials.

I've almost learned that passage by heart, I've had to paste it that often. Now, let's have a butcher's at what Knapmeyer says in the full paper you mentioned;

The SESAME/CASSE instrument listening to the MUPUS PEN insertion phase on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Knapmeyer, M. et al
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094576516301643

Taking together the evidence from MUPUS, CIVA, ROLIS, CONSERT, and SESAME, as well as the results of the KOSI experiments, we find that all these instruments, on a set of nested length scales from millimeters to tens of meters, are consistent with a structure of a body that has a thin, consolidated shell around a less rigid interior.

And is also consistent with what was seen at Tempel 1, and the cliffs at 67P after collapses. So no rock anywhere to be seen, no debate to be had. This was all settled in 2005 at Tempel 1. Rock is a non-starter.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom