Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
interesting, so the discussion is still going on

Evidently, although lord knows what about. The mechanism isn't just a little way short of explaining the quantities, it is many orders of magnitude short. And then there is the problem of the DC. As he freely admits, they hadn't considered that (why not?), and I can see no way of their already inadequate model overcoming that hurdle. The suggestion of the O2 coming from interactions between water ions and the spacecraft is an absolute non-starter.
 
Layered or nucleated? One can ONLY assume from ANY of the Rosetta or Philae data returned on how the “ice” (remember ALL the other molecules detected as well) is structured and that must by the same definition “reside” within the other????

Dirtysnowball straight up there brother! :thumbsup:

If the O2 is being MADE.....why not water? Your argument, of not enough H+ MEASURED is getting weaker. :boggled:

Changes the game somewhat.

Firstly, O2 is not being made. Unless you can tell us how this is happening? And how it produces the quantities seen. So that is dead in the water.
Secondly, the water is not being 'made'. That is an idiotic suggestion, when we can see the bloody ice from which it originates! Remember those papers? I guess I only posted them a few dozen times. Tempel 1, solid ice excavated? Hartley 2, dirty great chunks of it floating around? We don't need any idiotic, pseudoscientific woo to explain the origin of water production. We've seen it.
Thirdly, not all the ice is bound up within other ice. Nobody said it was. That is why there is an anisotropic distribution seen at comets between the location of H2O and CO2 outgassing. There has been at least one paper on this, where they looked for correlations between outgassed species.
So no, the game hasn't changed. The EC model is still batting zero, and will continue to do so , as predicted, due to it being based on mythological woo, rather than actual science.
 
Last edited:
The MONEY is still on INTENSE electric fields!

Whata reckon Tusenfem?

Which have been measured where, exactly? And are being caused by what, exactly? And are doing what, exactly?
Time to put up or shut up. My preference would be for the latter, although I suspect I'll get neither.
 
Like...forbidden oxygen lines?

Forbidden oxygen lines at various nucleocentric distances in comets doi 10.1051/0004-6361/201424403

Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko

Still cart before horse though, it’s making h20, co,co2,o2...etc

Interesting to note we do not use photo dissociation here on earth.

Electron beam ion trap

Whut? Maybe that post makes sense in your universe, but not in this one. What have forbidden oxygen lines got to do with the price of fish? Whatever "it" may be, it is not making anything. As already explained, and linked to dozens of times, the CO2 and H2O ice has been seen. You have absolutely zero mechanism for explaining them. Which is why you never can.
I've always considered that one would need to have an astonishing level of scientific illiteracy to even be tempted by EU woo; you are merely proving my point.
 
Which have been measured where, exactly? And are being caused by what, exactly? And are doing what, exactly?
Time to put up or shut up. My preference would be for the latter, although I suspect I'll get neither.

If I recall my play books the solar winds will now be referenced, or Peratt and some EU nonsense
 
Whut? Maybe that post makes sense in your universe, but not in this one. What have forbidden oxygen lines got to do with the price of fish? Whatever "it" may be, it is not making anything. As already explained, and linked to dozens of times, the CO2 and H2O ice has been seen. You have absolutely zero mechanism for explaining them. Which is why you never can.
I've always considered that one would need to have an astonishing level of scientific illiteracy to even be tempted by EU woo; you are merely proving my point.

Not really the sharpest tool in the shed, jd116!

There is not enough H+ in your books because mainstream use the HASER MODEL
(2. Chemistry-Emission Coupled Model
The purpose of this section is to describe the chemistry-emission coupled model for 67P. We use the spher- ically symmetric expansion model of Haser [1957] to estimate the number densities ni(r) of the ith parent species at a cometocentric distance r from the nucleus. The water production rate from the surface of 67P near perihelion has been estimated at 4 × 1027 s−1 for July 2015, while the velocity of the escaping volatiles has been measured to be 700 m s−1 using the data of the Comet Pressure Sensor, part of the ROSINA experi- ment. We consider the primary volatile elements detected by the ROSINA/DFMS spectrometer, H2O, CO2, CO, and O2.

And it’s WRONG

Therefore nowhere near the water production that the Haser model comes up with, so yeah bang on the money again jd116. There are not enough protons to go round... ;)

So if you are using the wrong model....:blush:

On earth we use a 200kv potential difference to obtain the forbidden atomic oxygen and hydrogen in space we use photo dissociative processes!

Cart before the horses again! :mad:

Nature can do it the easy way or the hard way...

The evidence for electric fields is irrefutable!
 
C and O from the refractory material (rock) from the nucleus and H from the solar wind, simple stupid it is...
 
Not really the sharpest tool in the shed, jd116!

There is not enough H+ in your books because mainstream use the HASER MODEL

And it’s WRONG

Therefore nowhere near the water production that the Haser model comes up with, so yeah bang on the money again jd116. There are not enough protons to go round... ;)

So if you are using the wrong model....:blush:

On earth we use a 200kv potential difference to obtain the forbidden atomic oxygen and hydrogen in space we use photo dissociative processes!

Cart before the horses again! :mad:

Nature can do it the easy way or the hard way...

The evidence for electric fields is irrefutable!

What complete and utter tripe! No, they are not using the Haser model. You were prattling on in your usual idiotic fashion about that previously. And I linked to the model they are using. Remember? Alzheimer's playing up again, is it? And there is zero evidence for any electric fields near the nucleus. Please link to it.
Forbidden lines, for the hard of thinking, are 'forbidden' only in the sense that on Earth, with a thick atmosphere, an atom or molecule will collide with another before those lines can occur. That is NOT the case in a near vacuum. Either on Earth or in space. Less collisions, see? Stop trying to make out that you understand things that you patently don't.
And no, H+ from the solar wind is not going to combine with anything to make water. Is it? Too fast see. Not only that, genius, but there is no sodding O- to combine with! Do the maths, Einstein. Not enough + too fast + nothing = sod all. Not difficult, eh?
 
Last edited:
And, to add to the previous; we know where the water comes from; ice, as observed. Multiple times. And we know how much H+ is getting into the DC, don't we? And yet there is shed loads of water still coming off the comet. Strange, eh? Talk about delusional. How dead does this idiocy have to be before Sol realises that its corpse is stinking the place out?
 
Last edited:
Right, here we go again, for those with the memory of a brain damaged firefly;

Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an empirical model and a multi-instrument study
Hansen, K. C. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S491/2672995

So, about 3.5 x 1028 mol/s (~1000 l/s).
And, going from memory of a previous calculation made for 3 AU, and adjusting for increased solar wind density at 1.25 AU, and greater outgassing at that distance; Wal's and Sol's H+ impossible fantasy will give us ~ 1 billionth of that, assuming every H+ ion jams on the anchors to attain speeds at which it could combine with...........something or other, and then goes on to create water. We'll ignore the fact that the highest production occurs when the solar wind H+ is getting nowhere near the comet. So, yeah. Great model!
 
Last edited:
Right, here we go again, for those with the memory of a brain damaged firefly;

Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an empirical model and a multi-instrument study
Hansen, K. C. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S491/2672995

The water production rate as a function of heliocentric distance provides an important constraint on the rate and method of water sublimation from the comet and hence important information about the sub-surface.



So, about 3.5 x 1028 mol/s (~1000 l/s).
And, going from memory of a previous calculation made for 3 AU, and adjusting for increased solar wind density at 1.25 AU, and greater outgassing at that distance; Wal's and Sol's H+ impossible fantasy will give us ~ 1 billionth of that, assuming every H+ ion jams on the anchors to attain speeds at which it could combine with...........something or other, and then goes on to create water. We'll ignore the fact that the highest production occurs when the solar wind H+ is getting nowhere near the comet. So, yeah. Great model!

Ions jamming on anchors is achieved thru “double layers” depending which side the + side is and if you did not already know WILL accelerate them on the otherside!!!!

Along with the FACT that the very outer Double Layer should be -negative ATTRACTING a lot she’d load more H+ than pissy little nucleus!

Well why don’t you email G. Cessateur and tell them to talk to Kenneth C. Hansen?

2 DERIVATION OF AN EMPIRICAL COMA MODEL

Comet 67P/CG's water coma exhibits a complex, non-uniform distribution that varies in time due to both the rotation of the comet as well as the orbital motion of the comet. While Rosetta presents a large step forward in sampling that distribution, it cannot measure the water distribution at all locations at all times. For this reason, the interpretation of Rosetta measurements requires the use of models. These models can be as simple as assuming a spherically symmetric, uniformly expanding coma (Haser 1957) or as sophisticated as Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) models of the 3D neutral gas coma using an accurate shape model (Bieler et al. 2015; Fougere et al. 2016a,b). The value of a simple, analytic model such as Haser (1957) is both its ease of application as well as the ease with which intuition can be applied to its use. However, with a shape as complex as that of the nucleus of 67P/CG, it is clear that a simple spherical model is not sufficient.
G. Cessateur has still got the cart before the horse!!!

How much “ice” do we YOU need to be exposed and sublimating to satisfy the peak in Water production?
The peak of water production occurs 18–22 d after perihelion with peak production of (3.5 ± 0.5) × 1028 molecules s−1.

Simple stupid can see the comet is not following ANY of the models!

Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Kenneth C. Hansen

2. Chemistry-Emission Coupled Model
The purpose of this section is to describe the chemistry-emission coupled model for 67P. We use the spher- ically symmetric expansion model of Haser [1957] to estimate the number densities ni(r) of the ith parent species at a cometocentric distance r from the nucleus. The water production rate from the surface of 67P near perihelion has been estimated at 4 × 1027 s−1 for July 2015, while the velocity of the escaping volatiles has been measured to be 700 m s−1 using the data of the Comet Pressure Sensor, part of the ROSINA experi- ment. We consider the primary volatile elements detected by the ROSINA/DFMS spectrometer, H2O, CO2, CO, and O2.

Chemistry emission model?? Interesting
 
Last edited:
The detection of O2, as discussed by Bieler et al. [2015], will have an impact on the production rate of the atomic states O(1 D) and O(1 S). The ROSINA/DFMS instrument on board Rosetta has indeed detected the presence of O2 in high quantity, with an abundance relative to water of 3.80 ± 0.85%, which puts this volatile in an abundance range comparable to that of CO2. An average O2 abundance of 4%, as measured in July 2015, will be considered in the following.
Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Correspondence to:
G. Cessateur, [email protected]

Interesting!

Some how’s that picture you are paint jd116, on how the “ice” may contain all this guff? Like as if in a dirtysnowball.

Somewhere down there under all the “dust”!

Key Points:
• The presence of O2 within 67P’s atmosphere increases significantly the red line emission
• Estimations of CO2 abundances based on the G/R ratio should be revised due to the O2 presence
• Space weather phenomena such as solar flares have an impact on the comet photochemistry

Space weather!!!

Electric Sun here we come!
 
Last edited:
Ions jamming on anchors is achieved thru “double layers” depending which side the + side is and if you did not already know WILL accelerate them on the otherside!!!!

Along with the FACT that the very outer Double Layer should be -negative ATTRACTING a lot she’d load more H+ than pissy little nucleus!

Well why don’t you email G. Cessateur and tell them to talk to Kenneth C. Hansen?



G. Cessateur has still got the cart before the horse!!!

How much “ice” do we YOU need to be exposed and sublimating to satisfy the peak in Water production?

Simple stupid can see the comet is not following ANY of the models!

Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Kenneth C. Hansen



Chemistry emission model?? Interesting


Yada, yada, yada. More unadulterated tripe. In case you hadn't noticed, there are no double layers. Duh. In case you had further failed to notice, there are no solar wind ions anywhere within cooee of the nucleus for long periods. Learn to read. The idiotic, impossible model you and the idiot Thornhill support gets you zero water. That isn't what is found is it? Give up. You are too scientifically illiterate to even have a sensible conversation with. Your posts are a complete joke, and an embarrassment. You've seriously lost the plot since this lunatic, unscientific rubbish failed completely to deliver. I'm almost thinking that you were stupid enough to actually believe it! But surely, nobody is that........then again.
 
Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Correspondence to:
G. Cessateur, [email protected]

Interesting!

Some how’s that picture you are paint jd116, on how the “ice” may contain all this guff? Like as if in a dirtysnowball.

Somewhere down there under all the “dust”!



Space weather!!!

Electric Sun here we come!

Yawn. Utter irrelevance, yet again. Lay off the kool-aid, you are making no sense whatsoever. As usual.
 
It's all standard Conspiracy/pseudoscience Playbook.

Keeping the thread going is a win, it makes you look like you have something worth discussing.
Misrepresenting mainstream research when it supports your case even though you reject the mainstream model.
Churn for a few weeks then reset back to points already discussed and debunked.
Mock and insult the mainstream contributors.
 
Yada, yada, yada. More unadulterated tripe. In case you hadn't noticed, there are no double layers. Duh. In case you had further failed to notice, there are no solar wind ions anywhere within cooee of the nucleus for long periods. Learn to read. The idiotic, impossible model you and the idiot Thornhill support gets you zero water. That isn't what is found is it? Give up. You are too scientifically illiterate to even have a sensible conversation with. Your posts are a complete joke, and an embarrassment. You've seriously lost the plot since this lunatic, unscientific rubbish failed completely to deliver. I'm almost thinking that you were stupid enough to actually believe it! But surely, nobody is that........then again.

Homework for you jd116.

What model was used for the “outgassing” from 19P/Holmes? Why did Comet 17P/Holmes burst out? Nucleus splitting or delayed sublimation?
W. J. Altenhoff1, E. Kreysa1, K. M. Menten1, A. Sievers3, C. Thum2, and A. Weiss1

Another comet that killed the dirtysnowball but nothing to see here, move along

:rolleyes:

Your “ougassing” models are fantasies!
In fact the “model” for comets is ad hoc complete rubbish with no basis in reality.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom