Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 February 2018 Sol88: Stupidity of citing the documented liar Wal Thornhill.
Found yet another lying blog entry from the deluded Wal.

Starts with the lie of "The story of the formation of the solar system from a cloud of gas and dust – and comets as the leftovers – is a work of fiction that has never predicted anything useful" . It produces a successful model of comets!

Delusions about the detection of the small amount of surface water ice on Tempel 1. That and the detected amount of water vapor is what tells us that here must be other sources of water vapor inside the comet.

Lies about comets
  • They are not exclusively from the Oort cloud.
  • It is the orbits of long-period comets that are evidence for the Oort cloud :eye-poppi!
    All long-period comets have very large orbits, on the order of thousands of AU, and appear from every direction in the sky.
  • Astronomers know lots more than "next to nothing" about comets and their origins, e.g. their densities :eye-poppi!
Wal repeats the abysmally obvious lie of successful predictions for Deep Impact.

A lie that forbidden lines are produced by atoms in intense electric fields. Forbidden emission lines are observed in space in extremely low density gases and plasmas because they have extremely low densities! A forbidden spectral line is emitted when an atom or ion in meta-stable state is left alone for long enough for it to decay and emit a photon. Collisions put the atom or ion into different, allowed states. The lower the density, the longer times between collisions and the better chance of a forbidden emission.

Gibberish of "Multiple “fountains” directed from the comet nucleus toward the Sun are used to explain them [coma]". This may be the idiotic lies that comet jets only point toward the Sun and are the only source of the coma.

Insane argument from incredulity - comet coma are enormous, nuclei are small thus a coma cannot follow a comet nucleus.

An ignorant delusion that comet coma are "essentially an electrical plasma phenomenon" after emphasizing that the coma is neutral hydrogen ("The first important thing to note about the hydrogen coma is that we are talking about neutral hydrogen atoms.").

A lie that jets are a mystery for the standard model of comets - they have been explained for over 60 years!

Idiotic insanity of "cathode arcs" eroding the surface of Io and comets.

A lie that surface heating and sublimation would "soften sharp features". That happens under gravity strong enough to make weak areas slump. The extremely weak gravity of comet nuclei means that sharp features remain "sharp".

The insanity that "two oxygen atoms, removed from water molecules by a cathode arc, would be in a sufficiently energized state to combine to form an atom of sulfur" :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
that paper was so full of nonsense, and there should be a rebuttal paper that shows that it is completely impossible what these peeps proposed, but I am not sure about the status of that paper. Just thinking out a mechanism that works in the lab, does not mean that you can just willy-nilly apply it to cometary dust, without looking whether the actual ingredients for the mechanisms are available.

Righto, speculate away!


How does a dirtysnowball have/make O2?

Feel free to jump in jd116. ;)

My moneys on INTENSE electric fields are involved.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Idiotic statement to detail from his comet delusions.

The dust is charged!
1 February 2018 Sol88: Idiotic statement to detail from his comet delusions.

We have been citing ices and dust comet papers that have detected charged dust for a long time :jaw-dropp!

The "charged dust" in his comet delusions has never been detected.
[URL="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12167179#post12167179]His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, imaginary "jets" of charged dust from the nucleus being electric currents, etc. etc. [/URL]
 
Sol88: Usual idiocy to derail from his comet delusions

Righto, speculate away!...
1 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy to derail from his comet delusions.
tusenfem gives good reasons to doubt the paper.

1 February 2018 Sol88: A lying question to derail from his comet delusions.
Possible mechanisms (including the one in that dubious paper!) for O2 production are in the papers we and he have cited.

1 February 2018 Sol88: A stupid "INTENSE electric fields are involved" assertion for O2 production when there are no "intense" electric fields measured around comets.
 
1 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy to derail from his comet delusions.
tusenfem gives good reasons to doubt the paper.

1 February 2018 Sol88: A lying question to derail from his comet delusions.
Possible mechanisms (including the one in that dubious paper!) for O2 production are in the papers we and he have cited.

1 February 2018 Sol88: A stupid "INTENSE electric fields are involved" assertion for O2 production when there are no "intense" electric fields measured around comets.

What do think RC on how O2 fits in the the dirtysnowball model?
 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_current

the dust is a component in the discharge from the comet to the solar wind.

And what is that supposed to mean?
There have been no detections in RPC of any "discharge" signature.
Heck, during the big "Argawal" event, there is no signature in the magnetic field, let alone a "discharge" signature.

Just throwing around claims with some cherry picked quotes from papers (without looking if those cherries actually fit together) does not science make.

And what exactly are we to do with your wiki link to electric current? I gave the definition of electric current in the post you quoted. What exactly do you want to say here, or are you just trolling as usual?
 
Righto, speculate away!


How does a dirtysnowball have/make O2?

Feel free to jump in jd116. ;)

My moneys on INTENSE electric fields are involved.

It doesn't make O2. It is almost certain that the O2 is present within the H2O ice. Hence its correlation with water vapour production.
On a related note, I had a reply from Prof. Giapis. Here is the crux of what he said, which merely confirms what myself and Tusenfem have said:

Good questions. O2 at ~5% is truly baffling. Our work cannot explain that, though it explains every other trend and dependency observed.

Indeed. There may be other mechanisms that could explain the O2 production, and its correlation with H2O. However, I believe I read that the various authors had looked at these, and they couldn't explain the quantity. Therefore they discarded them.

Our ion fluxes are from the measurements of Nilsson et al., which are for pre-perihelion at 3AU. Nilsson (Science, 2015) asserts that the “accelerated” ions hit the comet nucleus. Thus, our study applies to the time before the diamagnetic cavity forms. You are right to question what happens after that and we have not addressed that, though puzzled immensely by it.

Don't think I need to say more on that.

Even for preperihelion, the ion fluxes measured are too low for our mechanism to explain the observed O2 abundance—as acknowledged in our the paper. As long as there are energetic ions bombarding the nucleus, O2 is produced—however, not enough for 5% O2.

Ditto.

There is currently a Correspondence exchange under consideration in Nature Commun. that sheds light into this mystery. You may want to look it up when it gets published in the next couple of months. If your curiosity cannot be contained, here is a hint.

f you understand our mechanism of O2 production, then think about what happens when water ions bombard Rosetta surfaces. These “cold” ions, "heading in one direction - that is, away from the comet", have been measured by Nilsson et al. and they arrive at Rosetta with 100x the flux of the “accelerated” water ions returning to the nucleus. These “cold” ions are always present at Rosetta irrespective of the diamagnetic cavity. Because the spacecraft is negatively charged, these ions are accelerated against Rosetta surfaces to energies sufficient to produce oxygen on Rosetta. The remaining question is the composition of exposed Rosetta surfaces (covered by MLI). Your homework is to find out whether these surfaces contain a man-made oxide to enable the O2 production—if they do, you have a probable answer.

Errrr, no. Sorry, Prof. but that doesn't wash. ALICE has seen the O2 close to the nucleus. It obviously isn't created by the spacecraft.
(EDIT: ALICE doesn't actually detect the O2. What they say is:

This geometry allowed Alice, beginning in mid-April 2015, to observe a number of outbursts above the sunward limb. These outbursts are characterized by sudden increases in the atomic emissions, particularly the semi-forbidden OI λ1356 multiplet, over a period of 10-30 minutes, without a corresponding enhancement in long wavelength solar reflected light characteristic of dust production. The corresponding increase in the brightness ratio OI λ1356/OI λ1304 suggests that O2, detected for the first time in a comet by Bieler et al.(2015), is the primary source of the additional gas. This is the same spectroscopic diagnostic used to determine that O2 is the dominant species in the exospheres of Europa and Ganymede (Hall et al. 1995, 1998).

THE NATURE AND FREQUENCY OF THE GAS OUTBURSTS IN COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO OBSERVED BY THE ALICE FAR-ULTRAVIOLET SPECTROGRAPH ON ROSETTA
Feldman, P. D. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.05249.pdf

/EDIT)

Seems like they had an idea, and thought they'd run with it. Neither they, nor it appears, the peer reviewers, were particularly au fait with the environment of a comet, and the work managed to get published. It probably shouldn't have been, in my view.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to edit my above post further, re the ALICE observations. I should have dug deeper. It appears that ALICE can directly detect O2, and did so. It does this by measuring UV absorption from the continuum of various stars that periodically appear close to the line of sight of the nucleus. If I'm reading the paper correctly, then the measurements are made in the coma at distances from 4 - 20 km from the nucleus. This is not the spacecraft distance, but the distance of the measurements made by ALICE from the nucleus. ROSINA measurements of O2 were made 'in-situ' at the spacecraft. ALICE samples areas of the coma remotely.

H2O and O2 Absorption in the Coma of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Measured by the Alice Far-Ultraviolet Spectrograph on Rosetta
Keeney, B. A. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/469/Suppl_2/S158/3865158
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Deluded lies actually about his comet decisions for once

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_current

the dust is a component in the discharge from the comet to the solar wind.
2 February 2018 Sol88: Deluded lies actually about his comet decisions for once :eek:!

He is lying that a discharge exists and deluded about any discharge "to the [neutral] solar wind".

He is lying about the detected charged dust being a current as his link shows. The dust from comets is both negatively and positively charged. There is no evidence of a net movement of either charge, e.g. outward from the comet nucleus - the definition of an electric current.
 
Last edited:
15 December 2014: Electric comets still do not exist!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)

10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

I found yet another lying blog entry from the deluded Wal Thornhill on 1 February 2018.

630 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 31 January 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 31 January 2018 Sol88: Multiple idiocy and a lie derailing from his comet delusions
  2. 31 January 2018 Sol88: An "all dust" lie when he quotes dust to water ratios
  3. 31 January 2018 Sol88: Boring delusion that his comet delusions include negatively charged dust.
  4. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie - it was some nanoparticles that were found to be negatively charged.
  5. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about jonesdave116's post to derail from his comet delusions.
  6. 31 January 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing papers about ices and dust comets.
  7. 31 January 2018 Sol88: Yet another lie about his comet delusions which has that comet surfaces are burnt.
  8. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Idiotic "rubs it in" lie about a quote to derail from his comet delusions
  9. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Totally idiotic question to derail from his comet delusions.
  10. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Stupidity of citing the documented liar Wal Thornhill.
  11. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Stupidity of emphasizing that Wal's fantasies are just water magically appears and not how or how much!
  12. 1 February 2018 Sol88: A lie about the mainstream contradicting itself when every paper he has ever cited is about ices and dust comets.
  13. 1 February 2018 Sol88: The repeated and abysmal idiocy that any issues with the mainstream is support for his comet delusions.
  14. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Idiotic statement to detail from his comet delusions.
  15. 1 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy to derail from his comet delusions - tusenfem gives good reasons to doubt the paper.
  16. 1 February 2018 Sol88: A lying question to derail from his comet delusions.
  17. 1 February 2018 Sol88: A stupid "INTENSE electric fields are involved" assertion for O2 production when there are no "intense" electric fields measured around comets.
  18. 2 February 2018 Sol88: A pathetic and obvious attempt to derail from his comet delusions
  19. 2 February 2018 Sol88: Deluded lies actually about his comet decisions for once :eye-poppi!
 
It doesn't make O2. It is almost certain that the O2 is present within the H2O ice. Hence its correlation with water vapour production.
On a related note, I had a reply from Prof. Giapis. Here is the crux of what he said, which merely confirms what myself and Tusenfem have said:



Indeed. There may be other mechanisms that could explain the O2 production, and its correlation with H2O. However, I believe I read that the various authors had looked at these, and they couldn't explain the quantity. Therefore they discarded them.



Don't think I need to say more on that.



Ditto.



Errrr, no. Sorry, Prof. but that doesn't wash. ALICE has seen the O2 close to the nucleus. It obviously isn't created by the spacecraft.
(EDIT: ALICE doesn't actually detect the O2. What they say is:

This geometry allowed Alice, beginning in mid-April 2015, to observe a number of outbursts above the sunward limb. These outbursts are characterized by sudden increases in the atomic emissions, particularly the semi-forbidden OI λ1356 multiplet, over a period of 10-30 minutes, without a corresponding enhancement in long wavelength solar reflected light characteristic of dust production. The corresponding increase in the brightness ratio OI λ1356/OI λ1304 suggests that O2, detected for the first time in a comet by Bieler et al.(2015), is the primary source of the additional gas. This is the same spectroscopic diagnostic used to determine that O2 is the dominant species in the exospheres of Europa and Ganymede (Hall et al. 1995, 1998).

THE NATURE AND FREQUENCY OF THE GAS OUTBURSTS IN COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO OBSERVED BY THE ALICE FAR-ULTRAVIOLET SPECTROGRAPH ON ROSETTA
Feldman, P. D. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.05249.pdf

/EDIT)

Seems like they had an idea, and thought they'd run with it. Neither they, nor it appears, the peer reviewers, were particularly au fait with the environment of a comet, and the work managed to get published. It probably shouldn't have been, in my view.


Thank you jd116 for your time in digging a little deeper.


Your statement It is almost certain that the O2 is present within the H2O ice. Hence its correlation with water vapour production. would be inline with the “dirtysnowball” model.

This “ice” is becoming more and more “magical”. :D
 
Sol88: Persistent "ices" lie when ices have been detected on comets

This “ice” is becoming more and more “magical”.
2 February 2017 Sol88: Persistent "ices" lie when ices have been detected on comets.

2 February 2017 Sol88: Idiocy of real world ice being "magical"
Comets grow in the early solar system by accruing molecules of water and oxygen. Water freezes at a higher temperature than oxygen. A mixture of water and oxygen molecules become a mixture of water ice and oxygen as they cool. More cooling and the oxygen freezes. (More complex than this but we do not want to strain his brain cells :p)
This even happens at the relatively high temperatures here on Earth. Water ice has incursions of oxygen. We study the history of oxygen levels by analyzing the oxygen in ice cores.
 
Last edited:
Huh? How is it magical? One type of ice resides within the other. Not rocket science.

Layered or nucleated? One can ONLY assume from ANY of the Rosetta or Philae data returned on how the “ice” (remember ALL the other molecules detected as well) is structured and that must by the same definition “reside” within the other????

Dirtysnowball straight up there brother! :thumbsup:

If the O2 is being MADE.....why not water? Your argument, of not enough H+ MEASURED is getting weaker. :boggled:

Changes the game somewhat.
 
Last edited:
The MONEY is still on INTENSE electric fields!

Whata reckon Tusenfem?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom