Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88: A lie about "bloody pages arguing about" ambipolar electric fields

And you thought that not important to share with our lurker friends after we spent bloody pages arguing over them existing at comets?
20 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "bloody pages arguing about" electric fields on comets, including ambipolar electric fields.
There are 15 posts in this thread alone containing the word ambipolar. No one has said they do not exist.

What we are saying is that your absolutely ignorant delusions about comets include an imaginary electric field between the Sun and comets. An electric field between electrons and ions in comet coma is not that fantasy. Every time you mention a cometary electric filed you are lying about your comet delusions.
 
Naw, Sol88's SOP appears to be just find some mainstream paper that simply mentions electro-magnetic interactions in relations to comets and then simply portray it as supportive EC and EU even if it directly refutes them (overall neutrality). Same thing with the dust assertions, find something that says dust can be levitated and assert it as supportive regardless of the specific conditions involved.


This. Critical analysis begins and ends with word-search.
 
This. Critical analysis begins and ends with word-search.

But it doesn't even seem to be a comprehensive word search. I see this so often with crank science proponents' citations. Can't they even do a similar search in the target citation for the words or indications that it doesn't support their assertions? I don't even do a word search, often just a quick read of the key points in the reference and the counter indications are obvious.
 
Last edited:
Naw, Sol88's SOP appears to be just find some mainstream paper that simply mentions electro-magnetic interactions in relations to comets and then simply portray it as supportive EC and EU even if it directly refutes them (overall neutrality). Same thing with the dust assertions, find something that says dust can be levitated and assert it as supportive regardless of the specific conditions involved.

Yes, you are completely correct.
This is, for a long time already, not a "electric comet" thread, but a "attack and misinterpret mainstream" thread, in order to find that one small comment (e.g. ambi-polar electric field) to vindicate the EC idea.
Indeed, anything electromagnetic will be taken as a confirmation that the EC idea has merit, even though many important aspects, like the creation of OH or H2O in the coma are totally debunked.
 
And you thought that not important to share with our lurker friends after we spent bloody pages arguing over them existing at comets?

And what exactly do you expect from the ambi-polar electric field?
How strong do you think it is, and what effect will it have on the dust?
Will this electric field lead to the discharges that will EDM the surface of the comet?
 
And what exactly do you expect from the ambi-polar electric field?
How strong do you think it is, and what effect will it have on the dust?
Will this electric field lead to the discharges that will EDM the surface of the comet?

Well let's back the truck up here ay?

put comet in title
put double layer in abstract
double layers are rare breed, though

I don't know about kettle of fish, don't you think that that would depend on where the double layer is, how strong the double layer is, etc.

Just got to love these immediate assumptions of EU-tians, if you have a DL then everything is solved.
Dear Sol, please explain us how this double layer is created, set up, and what it is doing to the jets.

Tusenfems post from aways back...

Whenever your ready there cob!
 
http://esoads.eso.org/abs/1991JGR....96.7731L

Back to you sport :D

Jd116 might like to pay attention here.

I am. These are processes that happen within the coma, once the dust has been lofted there by gas. It says nothing about surface effects. As Tusenfem says, you need to explain how a DL would form within a diamagnetic cavity, and how it would then loft dust into the coma. Explosively. From a very localised area. Not happening.
 
Yes, you are completely correct.
This is, for a long time already, not a "electric comet" thread, but a "attack and misinterpret mainstream" thread, in order to find that one small comment (e.g. ambi-polar electric field) to vindicate the EC idea.
Indeed, anything electromagnetic will be taken as a confirmation that the EC idea has merit, even though many important aspects, like the creation of OH or H2O in the coma are totally debunked.

And what exactly do you expect from the ambi-polar electric field?
How strong do you think it is, and what effect will it have on the dust?
Will this electric field lead to the discharges that will EDM the surface of the comet?


Correct on both counts. According to the EC prognostications the comet carries a substantial charge that results in catastrophic discharges that will EDM the surface. That ain't no ambi-polar electric field but just a direct potential difference relative to the comet with periodic conductive pathways. Sol88 mentioned the comet losing excess electrons before so I'll ask again.


Generally how many "excess electrons" does "The ELECTRIC COMET" notion propose such a comet has?
 
Also, what one should take into account is why such a small electric field is needed, to quote Madanian et al. [2016]:

Quasineutrality requires that the electron and ion densities be the same, and under certain conditions an ambipolar electric field is required to achieve quasi-neutrality.

(with the omission that "the same" holds for volumes greater than the Debye sphere)

Or another quote fromVigren et al. [2017]

From LAP measurements during a few radial scans Edberg et al. (2015) reported an on average r−1 decay in the electron number density. Combined with a hot and more constant electron temperature, such a density decay can (depending on the magnetic field environment) set up an ambipolar electric field due to the electron pressure gradient, which accelerates cometary ions radially outward.

And the fields are rather small, say with Rosetta at 200 km from 67P and the accelerated particles have 100 eV, so 100 V over 200 km or so, which is less than 1 mV/m !!

And yes, when it is there, it does something with the plasma environment, but nothing as crazy and wild as the EC proponents are wanting us to believe is happening.
 
Sol88: Lies about a tusenfem post which is not about his ambipolar delusion

Well let's back the truck up here ay?
21 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a tusenfem post which is not about his new delusion that ambipolar electric fields are double layers.

On 6th January 2015 tusenfem wrote
put comet in title
put double layer in abstract
double layers are rare breed, though

I don't know about kettle of fish, don't you think that that would depend on where the double layer is, how strong the double layer is, etc.

Just got to love these immediate assumptions of EU-tians, if you have a DL then everything is solved.
Dear Sol, please explain us how this double layer is created, set up, and what it is doing to the jets.
This post is that papers about cometary double layers are extremely rare. There are 46 according to SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS). I have read one before and it was on double layers inside the comet the nucleus :eek:! Some of the results are false positives, e.g. one using data on 67P's coma from the Double Focusing Mass Spectrometer.
 
And yes, when it is there, it does something with the plasma environment, but nothing as crazy and wild as the EC proponents are wanting us to believe is happening.
What is worse is that these are electric fields local to the comet reducing with distance as in that Vigren et al. [2017] quote "on average r−1 decay in the electron number density".

A fundamental part of the EC delusion is that there is an electric field between the Sun and a comet. It is totally stupid to go on for months or years about locally produced electric fields that are irrelevant. Doubling up on that with imaginary and irrelevant double layers is doubly stupid. Sol88 has being whining about his cometary double layers delusion since at least 6th January 2015.
 
374 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 16 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 16 November 20107 Sol88: Lies about what he quotes as an answer to a question.
  2. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of writing the title only of a paper.
  3. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust.
  4. 20 November 2017 Sol88: The insanity yet again that a description in quotes is a model.
  5. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A part truth for once - more "cherry picking and buzz words" and lies and delusions on the way and already added to his signature.
  6. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Electric fields lies about the mainstream and his comet delusions.
  7. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Deluded "double layer" lie about Deca et. al.
  8. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Double "plasma boundary" lie - not a double layer, not in the paper.
  9. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Question derailing yet again from his comet delusions.
  10. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A link to the insanely deluded Thunderbolts cult.
  11. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Idiocy and lies about highly collimated dust jets, etc.
  12. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Confirms how gullible he is by linking to the totally insane Thunderbolts cult again.
  13. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about an ambipolar electric field being a double layer.
  14. 20 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about Deca et. al. containing double layers.
  15. 20 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "bloody pages arguing about" electric fields on comets, including ambipolar electric fields.
 
Also, what one should take into account is why such a small electric field is needed, to quote Madanian et al. [2016]:



(with the omission that "the same" holds for volumes greater than the Debye sphere)

Or another quote fromVigren et al. [2017]



And the fields are rather small, say with Rosetta at 200 km from 67P and the accelerated particles have 100 eV, so 100 V over 200 km or so, which is less than 1 mV/m !!

And yes, when it is there, it does something with the plasma environment, but nothing as crazy and wild as the EC proponents are wanting us to believe is happening.

What does it do, Tusenfem?

You may remember this as well...
From the behaviour of the magnetic eld components it was deduced that there are not only currents perpendicular to the magnetic field (taking care of the shielding of the cavity) but there are also strong field-aligned currents in alternating directions.

As comprehensively covered by D . E. Scott, Ph.D. (EE)

And

This leads to t nT. They realize that this folding leads to two regions with oppositely directed eld, similar to the Earth's magnetotail, and thus that there needs to be a cross-tail current through Ampere's law (Eq. (1)), with t 8 A for a tail length of t 6 km. Ip [1979] assumes that (part) of this current can suddenly be channeled through the cometary atmosphere, in a similar way to what happens in the Earth's tail during a substorm [Bostr¨om, 1974]. This eld-aligned current can then, again, be used to increase the ionization rate near the nucleus.
Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk 1



And what effect would this have on the double layers we are discussing?
 
Last edited:
Also, what one should take into account is why such a small electric field is needed, to quote Madanian et al. [2016]:



(with the omission that "the same" holds for volumes greater than the Debye sphere)

Or another quote fromVigren et al. [2017]



And the fields are rather small, say with Rosetta at 200 km from 67P and the accelerated particles have 100 eV, so 100 V over 200 km or so, which is less than 1 mV/m !!

And yes, when it is there, it does something with the plasma environment, but nothing as crazy and wild as the EC proponents are wanting us to believe is happening.

Yeah very small pissy electric fields, nothing to see hear folks, move along.

@Tusenfem, what strength are the electric fields that are set up between sunlit and shadowed areas?

You are aware it will set up an electric field? :confused:
 
Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his comet delusions

What does it do, Tusenfem?
21 November 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his comet delusions.

21 November 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irerlvant link to a deluded Thunderbolts cult "prophet". (D . E. Scott)
As soon as we see "Birkeland" we know this is the Thunderbolt cult inane delusion of Birkeland currents doing magic.

21 November 2017 Sol88: A lie - his delusion of cometary double layers is being pointed out yet again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom