Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A Double Layer (Ambipolar electric field), are we getting to at least reading from the same book Tusenfem, even if we are not on the same page!

An ambi-polar electric field is not a double layer.
Am ambi-polar electric field can create a double layer if it can detach itself from the cathode and move into the plasma proper. I think Raadu (1989) explains this.

The ambi-polar electric field at the comet is created by electrons that want to move out, and because they are lighter they move more quickly than the ions, and this creates an ambi-polar electric field in order to keep the electrons at bay.
 
Question for you jd116, using your vast knowledge of plasma and indeed the electric comet theory, what happens at a strongly outgassing comet, say comet 17P Holmes?

How much area in m2 is that for the outside visible coma/plasma boundary, or the double layer sheath?

Starting to get into some real numbers here now, jd116. Care to have a go at your calculations for that no h2o can be made as the EU has said?

Shall we wheel out old Franklin Anariba, PhD for another show round the block? What’ya Reckon Captain Swoop, Dancing David? Round again?

More idiocy. You seem to forget that the H2O is measured close to Halley and 67P. It doesn't matter what is going on thousands of kilometers away. The solar wind at a strongly outgassing comet is getting nowhere near the nucleus. ~ 4500 km at Halley. It would have been much further at Hale-Bopp.
There is nowhere near enough H+, and no O-. So, your mechanism is impossible.
And we know what is causing the outgassing at 17P Holmes, because it had an outburst, after which ice grains are detected. So, your mechanism is not only impossible, but unnecessary. As has been explained numerous times.

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf
 
Last edited:
I'll ask Sol this again: if electrostatic levitation is the main driver of dust release, how come the coma is at its dustiest (around perihelion) when the solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus? This is the time when EL cannot happen, but also happens to coincide with the highest outgassing rates. Kills it dead right there, doesn't it?
And let's see what the idiot Thornhill and his sidekick have to say about the dust:

The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical
arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no
dust or debris on the surface during the active phase
, even if a shallow layer
of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet
becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

And yet we have more dust during the active phase. And no possibility of electrostatic levitation. Strange, don't you think?

Please explain.
 
I'll ask Sol this again: if electrostatic levitation is the main driver of dust release, how come the coma is at its dustiest (around perihelion) when the solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus? This is the time when EL cannot happen, but also happens to coincide with the highest outgassing rates. Kills it dead right there, doesn't it?
And let's see what the idiot Thornhill and his sidekick have to say about the dust:



And yet we have more dust during the active phase. And no possibility of electrostatic levitation. Strange, don't you think?

Please explain.

Ya bloody drongo :boggled:

Am I understanding you correctly, jonesdave116, when I say the sublimation from the heat, (long wave infrared radiation),of subsurface ice and the subsequent release of neutral molecules into the coma to be ionised by EUV light, has the power to trump the ambipolar electric fields set up and sustained via the mechanism explained in the paper.

So we have energetic electron and ions doing all sorts of wonderfully complex, for the mathmagicians, behaviours that surprise scientists according to the “Ivey dust Ball”. This is achieved thru the ambipolar double layers set up that ARE coupled to the solar wind.

The ELECTRIC COMET is trying to charge equalise by getting rid excess electrons, very much like in the mechanism described in the paper.

The solar wind is not needed to reach the surface. These double layers very much throw a spanner into the sublimation works. :blush:

This has implications for your other question jd116.
 
More idiocy. You seem to forget that the H2O is measured close to Halley and 67P. It doesn't matter what is going on thousands of kilometers away. The solar wind at a strongly outgassing comet is getting nowhere near the nucleus. ~ 4500 km at Halley. It would have been much further at Hale-Bopp.
There is nowhere near enough H+, and no O-. So, your mechanism is impossible.
And we know what is causing the outgassing at 17P Holmes, because it had an outburst, after which ice grains are detected. So, your mechanism is not only impossible, but unnecessary. As has been explained numerous times.

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf


Tail excursion paper is going to be a very interesting read.

So still a ways off then Tusenfem?
 
An ambi-polar electric field is not a double layer.
Am ambi-polar electric field can create a double layer if it can detach itself from the cathode and move into the plasma proper. I think Raadu (1989) explains this.

The ambi-polar electric field at the comet is created by electrons that want to move out, and because they are lighter they move more quickly than the ions, and this creates an ambi-polar electric field in order to keep the electrons at bay.

And you thought that not important to share with our lurker friends after we spent bloody pages arguing over them existing at comets?

Cheers champ.
 
As quoted by Sol:
Am I understanding you correctly, jonesdave116, when I say the sublimation from the heat, (long wave infrared radiation),of subsurface ice and the subsequent release of neutral molecules into the coma to be ionised by EUV light, has the power to trump the ambipolar electric fields set up and sustained via the mechanism explained in the paper.

Would somebody kindly translate that sentence into understandable scientific English, so that I might understand what it means? TIA.
 
Ya bloody drongo :boggled:

Am I understanding you correctly, jonesdave116, when I say the sublimation from the heat, (long wave infrared radiation),of subsurface ice and the subsequent release of neutral molecules into the coma to be ionised by EUV light, has the power to trump the ambipolar electric fields set up and sustained via the mechanism explained in the paper.

So we have energetic electron and ions doing all sorts of wonderfully complex, for the mathmagicians, behaviours that surprise scientists according to the “Ivey dust Ball”. This is achieved thru the ambipolar double layers set up that ARE coupled to the solar wind.

The ELECTRIC COMET is trying to charge equalise by getting rid excess electrons, very much like in the mechanism described in the paper.

The solar wind is not needed to reach the surface. These double layers very much throw a spanner into the sublimation works. :blush:

This has implications for your other question jd116.

"The ELECTRIC COMET is trying to charge equalise by getting rid excess electrons, very much like in the mechanism described in the paper."?

Nope, the Ambipolar electric field is a result of quasinutrality, that the, solar wind, plasma and comet system are overall neutral. Expressed by your own quote from that paper earlier.

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind elec- trons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.

That's not "getting rid excess electrons" as you assert, as that would take "excess", well, ions. By all means please show how the solar wind has "excess" ions for your asserted "trying to charge equalise by getting rid excess electrons"?

Generally how many "excess electrons" does "The ELECTRIC COMET" notion propose such a comet has? Exactly how does the solar wind produce the correct number of "excess" ions to "charge equalise" such a comet as you assert?

from the cited and quoted paper..

https://physics.aps.org/featured-article-pdf/10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.205101

The solar wind is mass loaded by cold cometary ions as a consequence of the outgassing cometary neutral atmosphere that is ionized as it expands [39].

Starting with a neutral solar wind and neutral comet, thus "outgassing cometary neutral atmosphere", you can get "Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions". Overall neutrality is critical to "the mechanism described in the paper" as it is to the simulation the paper represents.
 
As quoted by Sol:


Would somebody kindly translate that sentence into understandable scientific English, so that I might understand what it means? TIA.


Basically translate to "Sol88 doesn't understand the paper nor "the mechanism explained in the paper"".

Apparently not understanding that the ambi-polar electric field simply means the fast moving electrons tend to drag the slower moving ions with them. Just as those slower moving ions tend to slow down the fast moving electrons. As a result of, and maintaining, overall quasineutrality it actually goes against the EU or just EC (and Sol88's own) assertions.
 
Basically translate to "Sol88 doesn't understand the paper nor "the mechanism explained in the paper"".

Apparently not understanding that the ambi-polar electric field simply means the fast moving electrons tend to drag the slower moving ions with them. Just as those slower moving ions tend to slow down the fast moving electrons. As a result of, and maintaining, overall quasineutrality it actually goes against the EU or just EC (and Sol88's own) assertions.

What I figured is that Sol still wants to invoke some sort of electric woo to explain the dust in the coma. My question, which he refuses to answer, was what sort of electric woo is he proposing, when the coma is at its dustiest? Given that the solar wind is not reaching the nucleus at that time, then levitation is out of the question.
As for the ambipolar field proposed by Deca, et al; that is for the coma when the comet is outgassing weakly. It is not a surface effect, and therefore cannot be used as a method for lifting grains from the surface. It certainly is of no relevance to the surface once a diamagnetic cavity forms.

So, I'll ask again; what is lofting dust into the coma once a diamagnetic cavity forms, Sol? Electric pixies?
 
What I figured is that Sol still wants to invoke some sort of electric woo to explain the dust in the coma. My question, which he refuses to answer, was what sort of electric woo is he proposing, when the coma is at its dustiest? Given that the solar wind is not reaching the nucleus at that time, then levitation is out of the question.
As for the ambipolar field proposed by Deca, et al; that is for the coma when the comet is outgassing weakly. It is not a surface effect, and therefore cannot be used as a method for lifting grains from the surface. It certainly is of no relevance to the surface once a diamagnetic cavity forms.

Naw, Sol88's SOP appears to be just find some mainstream paper that simply mentions electro-magnetic interactions in relations to comets and then simply portray it as supportive EC and EU even if it directly refutes them (overall neutrality). Same thing with the dust assertions, find something that says dust can be levitated and assert it as supportive regardless of the specific conditions involved.
 
And you thought that not important to share with our lurker friends after we spent bloody pages arguing over them existing at comets?

Cheers champ.

Personally, I don't recall anybody arguing about the existence, or otherwise, of ambipolar fields in the cometary ionosphere. Had they done so, I would have referred them to the fact that this is old news.

The role of electric fields in the cometary environment (1984)
Cravens, T.E.; Gombosi, T.I.; Gribov, B.E.
https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:15060349
This is a conference abstract. Note that this date is prior to the Halley encounter. So they are not only known about, but were predicted.

The field is also mentioned in this paper:
The electron density and temperature in the tail of comet Giacobini-Zinner (1986)
Marconi, M. L. & Mendis, D. A.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/GL013i004p00405/full (paywalled)

And also here:
Magnetohydrodynamic Models of Comet Halley (1994)
Lindgren, C. J.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1994PhDT........50L

You will note that the ambipolar diffusion in that abstract is, quite obviously, happening outside the diamagnetic cavity.

An ambipolar electric field is also invoked in this paper, discussing the AMPTE artificial comet experiments:

Dynamics of the AMPTE artificial comet (1986)
Haerendel, G. et al
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...cial_comet/links/53da42980cf2631430c807cf.pdf

So Tusenfem has hardly been keeping a state secret. All the above information could have easily been found by anybody who bothered to do a search on Scholar, using the appropriate terms.
 
Methinks that Sol is getting confused between ambipolar electric fields and double layers. Probably a safe assumption on my part. As Tusenfem explained in post #574, they are not the same thing. In post #569, Sol links to this paper:

The Search for Double Layers in Space Plasmas
Andersson, L. & Ergun, R. E.
http://lasp.colorado.edu/home/mop/files/2015/08/KeilingIV.2Andersson.pdf

Here is what they say about the formation conditions for DLs:

In collisionless plasma, there are surface, current, and gradient types of DLs. A surface DL is created by currents to and from the surface, which results in a sheath between the surface and the plasma that may carry a net potential. Examples of surface DLs are probe/sensor interaction wit plasmas [Langmuir, 1929], spacecraft interaction with space plasmas, and the Moon’s interaction with the solar wind [Halekas et al., 2003]. A gradient DL (or currentless DL) is associated with strong magnetic and/or density gradients resulting in charge separations [Charles, 2009;Scime et al.2010]. This type of DL is being studied actively as a potential application to ion thrusters. Finally, the current-driven DL is a result of interaction between two different plasma regions with a strong, field-aligned current. If the drift between the electrons and ions is large enough, two stream [e.g.,Buneman, 1959] instabilities can develop, which can lead to DLs. In this chapter, we focus on the last of these types of DL.

So, surface DLs require a current to and from the surface. On the moon it is due to the interaction with the solar wind. Not happening at a comet at the time of highest outgassing. Refer to 'diamagnetic cavity' and '0 nT', if the reason for this escapes you.

In the case of the other two types, these could only occur in the coma, and so have nothing to do with dust lifting. They would also be detected by the instruments on 67P. And Tusenfem, who knows a thing or two about DLs, tells us that they weren't.
 
Sol88: The repeated idiocy of writing the title only of a paper


Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet
20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of writing the title only of a paper.

20 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust.
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet (paper) (PDF)

20 November 2017 Sol88: The insanity yet again that a description in quotes is a model.
The first paragraph in the paper is:
Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped “icy dirt balls” left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules [1–4]. When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail. Historically, this process revealed the existence of the solar wind and the interplanetary magnetic field [5–8]. Comets are critical to decipher the physics of gas release processes in space. The latter result in mass-loaded plasmas [9,10], which more than three decades after the Active Magnetospheric Particle Tracer Explorers (AMPTE) space release experiments [11] are still not fully understood.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A part truth - more "cherry picking and buzz words" and lies and delusions

More cherry picking and buzz words on the way...
20 November 2017 Sol88: A part truth for once - more "cherry picking and buzz words" and lies and delusions on the way and already added to his signature.
 
Sol88: Ambient electric fields lies about the mainstream and his comet delusions

same paper as above
20 November 2017 Sol88: Electric fields lies about the mainstream and his comet delusions.
The mainstream know that comets have electric fields.
His comet delusions do not include any electric fields for the comet.

20 November 2017 Sol88: Deluded "double layer" lie about Deca et. al.
There are no double layers in Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet (paper) (PDF).

20 November 2017 Sol88: Double"plasma boundary" lie - not a double layer, not in the paper.
 
Sol88: A question to derail from his comet delusions but with his DL delusion

So if, hypothetically, ...
20 November 2017 Sol88: A question to derail from his comet delusions but with his ignorant double layer delusion.

20 November 2017 Sol88: The usual "ices" in quotes lie.
 
Sol88: Idiocy and lies about highly collimated dust jets, etc

...The electrons appear ‘spiky’ or filamentary, the dust ‘jets’ are filamentary and fine structured along with being highly collimated.
20 November 2017 Sol88: Idiocy and lies about highly collimated dust jets, etc.
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet (paper) (PDF) by Deca et. al.
The electrons are not 'spiky’ or filamentary.
The electrons are not related to dust jets.
A lie of 'jets" when they are jets.
Dust jets are not "highly collimated".
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Confirms how gullible he is by linking to the totally insane Thunderbolts cult

Hell, why not ...
20 November 2017 Sol88: Confirms how gullible he is by linking to the totally insane Thunderbolts cult again.

20 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about an ambipolar electric field being a double layer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom