Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88: Idiotic repeat of an uncited quote after a source is asked for

Mmmmm...wake up!
16 November 20107 Sol88: Idiotic repeat of an uncited quote after a source is asked for
jonesdave116 wrote yesterday: So, where are you getting dust grains of umpteen hundred microns lifted off of a comet? Please answer, with references.
(my emphasis added)

And of course: 16 November 20107 Sol88: Lies about what he quotes as an answer to a question.
The above question is in the context of dust being ejected through electrostatic charging. The previous Where is the paper saying that dust grains of many hundred microns can be levitated off of a comet? post makes this clear.

Another possibility is the impact of nano dust on very large grains, such as the objects with diameters in the 0.14–0.50 m range observed by the OSIRIS
is not "0.14–0.50 m range" objects being electrostatically ejected :eye-poppi! This is nano dust hitting larger objects with no lifting or ejecting mentioned.
The source is Acceleration of ions and nano dust at a comet in the solar wind
 
Last edited:

I don't think anyone in the community uses "complex plasma" when they mean "dusty plasma".
Anywho, at the moment their is nothing in the RPC data that shows that dust has any significant influence on the plasma dynamics around 67P.
So I might as well claim (tongue-in-cheek) that around 67P there is lots of gas and plasma and no dust.
 
Last edited:
But not accepted yet? :confused:

Well duh! NO.
Submission ... editor looking for reviewers ... at least 2 weeks if not more time for writing the review ... then make revisions and reply to reviewers ... check by editor and reviewers ... possible second round ... typesetting ... proof reading ... publication
My paper is now at step 3 (at referee)

This is how the real scientific world works. It is not like what your EU buddies do, just write something, dump it on their blog and claim to have a publication.
 
Tusenfem may be able to comment on this extract from the paper:



Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies
Wang, X. et al
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2016GL069491/full (paywalled)

In particular whether the experimental set up is applicable to a comet at ~3.5 AU.
Not that it matters, as this will not do what Sol wants it to. Particularly when we consider that the bulk of the outgassing occurs when the solar wind has no access to the nucleus.

ETA:
I just noticed that Eberhard Grün was a co-author on the above paper. He has been involved in a number of papers related to 67P, and was lead author of the Feb 19 outburst paper. He also was a co-author on the Agarwal paper that has got Sol so exercised! So, if he's not suggesting explosive, localised electrostatic levitation, we can be pretty damn sure that it isn't an option.

I will have to take a look at the paper (remember having seen a presentation about the hopping dust). I can get you the pdf probably.
 
Are you saying gas drag can accelerate 10nm dust to 10km/s?

Ahh of course the "rocket" effect... hah aha ha little dust rockets :)

And what has any of that got to do with lifting dust from the surface? The paper you are quoting is based on a simulation for charged nanograins once they are already in the coma, outside the diamagnetic cavity. It has nothing whatever to do with electrostatic levitation of dust.
And the dust speeds measured in the Agarwal paper are nothing like 10 km/s! Why don't you actually read the papers, instead a skimming them, looking for buzzwords to cherry pick completely out of context?
From the Agarwal paper:

The peak of detections occurred around ut 09:00, and the particle speeds were typically <3 m s−1

So, of course, none of this helps you to explain how dust, from a very localised area, is being electrostatically levitated (explosively!). And it doesn't help you to explain the large amount of dust in the coma around perihelion, when a diamagnetic cavity is in place, and electrostatic levitation cannot happen. And where do you think all the gas in the coma is coming from, if not from sublimation of the observed ices?
 
I will have to take a look at the paper (remember having seen a presentation about the hopping dust). I can get you the pdf probably.

Cheers. I actually downloaded the paper, but wasn't sure about the applicability of the process at comets. Then I noticed that Eberhard Grün was a co-author, so figured that he would be well aware of the cometary environment, and that the mechanism is applicable. As he was also a co-author on the Agarwal paper, and that didn't mention any of Sol's impossible explosive levitation, I'm figuring that we can 100% consign that idea to the dustbin of loopiness, with the rest of EUs ideas.
 
Ahh Jeez Sol. Stop making an eejit of yourself. Eh? What do you think nm means? Just for a clue, try nanometers. Yes? Then look at the Agarwal paper. How many times do you need to show your ignorance in this thread? It doesn't bother me, but it ought to bother you, I'd have thought.
Just for a laugh, tell me how the outgassing is happening at perihelion. When there is a shed load of dust around? Remember the diamagnetic cavity, dear? And where was the solar wind? Well, not within 1500 km. Eh? So, what is your mechanism? Let's hear it.

The mechanism is bait, switch, arm wave and a bunny picture
 
AND NONE OF THESE QUOTES STATE THAT COMETS ARE DIRTY SNOWBALLS; OR ARE YOU INCAPABLE OF READING COMPREHENSIVELY?????????????

Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped “icy dirt balls” left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules [1–4]. When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail.

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Just one of many.

Dirty snowballs,icy dirt balls,deepfriedicecream ;0

from 2017 mate :mad:
 
Last edited:
Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped “icy dirt balls” left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules [1–4]. When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail.

And what is wrong with that quote? Looks damned accurate to me. There is ice and there is 'dirt', as in dust.
 
All right, let’s back up down the track here. This new, for me anyway, paper answer a question I had asked aways back in the thread.

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind elec- trons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Seems that’s answered that! :) faintly remember Jonesdave116 and I getting in a bit of a quibble over it.

Now, I am really interested in your paper Tusenfem. Going to have any kind of that action going on?

More cherry picking and buzz words on the way...

PS whoever makes the final connection between this amount of Electrical, more specifically PLASMA activity and the dust being electrodynamicaly ejected from the rock, gunna look like a complete and utter idiot, ay you mob!

Fondly looks at signatures below:)
 
Last edited:
And I think me ‘ol mate Tusnefem and I can have, now, a Mano on Mano discussion on comets and DOUBLE LAYERS.

Solar wind electrons accelerate FIG. 4. Solar wind, cometary, and total (solar windþ cometary) electron energy distributions along a cut in the terminator plane [(a)–(c), respectively]. The cut is indicated in Fig. 1(e). The white band represents the comet location. towards the comet [Fig. 4(a)] under the influence of an ambipolar electric field that is generated by the large electron pressure gradient in the inhomogeneous cometary plasma [50], which further enhances the separation of the solar wind electron and ion flows.
same paper as above

And bugger me dead, sorry Tusenfem. Mainstream would have known since the discovery of the “singing” comet.

You are coy sorta chap,
hese fluctuations are probably due to a beam-plasma interaction outside the double layer, which excites plasma turbulence. Their observations are consistent with experiments on electromagnetic radiation emitted by double layers in a double plasma machine by Volwerk (1993),[50] who, however, also observed radiation from the double layer itself.
wiki

So plasma boundaries can now be called their correct term, double layers, current carrying at that to.

Ummm pretty well much what the EU mob binbanging on about for what 8-9yrs now for me a least.
 
Last edited:
Question for you jd116, using your vast knowledge of plasma and indeed the electric comet theory, what happens at a strongly outgassing comet, say comet 17P Holmes?

How much area in m2 is that for the outside visible coma/plasma boundary, or the double layer sheath?

Starting to get into some real numbers here now, jd116. Care to have a go at your calculations for that no h2o can be made as the EU has said?

Shall we wheel out old Franklin Anariba, PhD for another show round the block? What’ya Reckon Captain Swoop, Dancing David? Round again?
 
Last edited:
@Tusenfem

So if, hypothetically, the nucleus itself was at a more negative potential than the surrounding sw plasma, what would be the effect we should see, especially in regards to the suprathermal electron population and the ambipolar electric field/s and dust “jets’ powered from below?

i’d Hazard a guess and there'd more than one double layer. The electrons appear ‘spiky’ or filamentary, the dust ‘jets’ are filamentary and fine structured along with being highly collimated.

How’s sublimating ‘ice/s’ do that capper?

Sorta acting in a electrical circuit analogy, as a transformer.
 
Last edited:
Hell, why not
In this line of thinking, of utmost interest is the paper by Clark et al titled “Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/ Churyumov-Gerasimenko: observations from the Rosetta ion and electron sensor” [5]. The term “suprathermal” implies highly heated electrons possessing high kinetic energy. In the manuscript, according to the authors, suprathermal or fast-moving electrons are “accelerated by an unknown mechanism from a few eV upward to 100 s of eV and play an important role in the electron-neutral chemistry as well as in dust grain charging.” Moreover, previous studies showed that these accelerated electrons are ubiquitous, but could not agree on a particular mechanism. Several accelerating electron mechanisms have been put forth:

1. “Suprathermal” electrons are likely associated with upstream cyclotron wave fluctuations convecting tailward. In other words, the accelerating energy is provided by mass-loaded ions traveling from the direction of the sun towards the tail of the coma.
2. “Suprathermal” electrons are accelerated in a similar manner as electrons behind interplanetary collision-less bow shocks.
3. The Active Magnetospheric Particle Tracer Explorer (AMPTE) satellite showed that lower “hybrid” cyclotron waves from mass-loaded ions were responsible for the electrons. “hybrid” refers to cyclotron frequencies in between a proton and an electron.
4. Some studies ascribe “suprathermal” electron acceleration to photoionization, while other studies indicate the role of photoionization to be negligible.

It is then clear that there is no agreement on the dominant mechanism behind suprathermal electron acceleration, more so for comet 67P, which has a 100 times more tenuous coma density than comet Halley. In this context, the authors inform:
LINK

Seems its not so unknown now! from the paper
The observation of two different types of DLs in the low- altitude aurora, the observation of DLs in the magnetotail, and the implication of DLs in Jupiter ’ s and Saturn ’ s magnetospheres suggest that the DL is truly a universal process. With significant gaps in our understanding of DL, this area of research will continue to be important

A Double Layer (Ambipolar electric field), are we getting to at least reading from the same book Tusenfem, even if we are not on the same page!
 
Last edited:
All right, let’s back up down the track here. This new, for me anyway, paper vanswer a question I had asked aways back in the thread.

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Seems that’s answered that! :) faintly remember Jonesdave116 and I getting in a bit of a quibble over it.

And what question is answered here, exactly? I hope you realize that "neutralize" here does not mean you are getting neutral atoms, this means charge neutrality.

Now, I am really interested in your paper Tusenfem. Going to have any kind of that action going on?

As my paper only deals with the magnetic field, I don't think so. Then again. I don't know what "any kind of that action" is supposed to be.

PS whoever makes the final connection between this amount of Electrical, more specifically PLASMA activity and the dust being electrodynamicaly ejected from the rock, gunna look like a complete and utter idiot, ay you mob!

huh?
 
And I think me ‘ol mate Tusnefem and I can have, now, a Mano on Mano discussion on comets and DOUBLE LAYERS.
An ambi-polar electric field is not a double layer.

And bugger me dead, sorry Tusenfem. Mainstream would have known since the discovery of the “singing” comet.

Could you be a little bit more obscure?
So plasma boundaries can now be called their correct term, double layers, current carrying at that to.

Whatever you say ...
I guess you mean the current driving the singing comet instability?
Too bad that the ambi-polar electric field is radial, whereas the current is perpendicular to the magnetic field.
You see, Sol, just putting words together does not mean you have a sentence, let alone a physical theory.

Ummm pretty well much what the EU mob binbanging on about for what 8-9yrs now for me a least.

Uhhh, no
 
Question for you jd116, using your vast knowledge of plasma and indeed the electric comet theory, what happens at a strongly outgassing comet, say comet 17P Holmes?

How much area in m2 is that for the outside visible coma/plasma boundary, or the double layer sheath?

Starting to get into some real numbers here now, jd116. Care to have a go at your calculations for that no h2o can be made as the EU has said?

Shall we wheel out old Franklin Anariba, PhD for another show round the block? What’ya Reckon Captain Swoop, Dancing David? Round again?

My god, it hurts, the stupid
 
So if, hypothetically, the nucleus itself was at a more negative potential than the surrounding sw plasma, what would be the effect we should see, especially in regards to the suprathermal electron population and the ambipolar electric field/s and dust “jets’ powered from below?

you would most likely see nothing in the supra themal electrons. you will see that the cold/thermal electrons and ions would re-arrange in order that there is no potential difference between the two

i’d Hazard a guess and there'd more than one double layer. The electrons appear ‘spiky’ or filamentary, the dust ‘jets’ are filamentary and fine structured along with being highly collimated.

What the frak is so special about double layers? Not every electric field in a plasma is a double layer. I cannot fathom EU's fascination in putting in double layers everywhere, it must be that Alfven came up with them.

Which electrons appear "spiky"? In Jan's paper there is filametation in the electron density. Those filaments are 10s of km in size, so hardly spiky, most definitely not when compared to the size of the comet.

What all that other stuff is supposed to tell me, I have no idea.

How’s sublimating ‘ice/s’ do that capper?

You forget ionization my dear.

Sorta acting in a electrical circuit analogy, as a transformer.

The what in the how now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom