For Sol's benefit I'll try to show why Harvey and Tom's calculations lead to the same conclusion, despite looking somewhat different on paper.
First off, we have the Coulomb constant, ke, which is a known number. However, Harvey and Tom use it differently, but this will have no bearing on the result. ke is derived from Gauss's law, and is given as 1/ 4πε
0, where ε
0 is the vacuum permittivity, and Tom uses this form in his calculation.
So, essentially, Harvey gets rid of ke by multiplying each side of the equation by 1/ ke. For Tom, he needs to get rid of it by multiplying both sides by 4πε
0/ 1.
It will have precisely the same effect.
Another difference, is that Harvey just equates the two force laws, and works out what charge would be needed to fully cancel gravity for the mass as measured by Rosetta (35 gigavolts). Of course, that isn't the figure we need. EU say that a charge is cancelling out some proportion of the measured mass/ gravity. So, if you want the comet to be 2000 kg/m
3, and we take the measured density of ~ 500 kg/m
3, that means that you need to have it (4 - 1) x Harvey's result, i.e. 3 x 35 = 105 gigavolts.
Tom has done things slightly differently, and has built the real and apparent masses into his equation, assuming we can leave the s/c mass as it is. So, he has Gm (M' - M), where m = s/c mass, M' = mass required by EU, and M is the mass as measured by Rosetta. He then converts that into an equation using density values, mass = density x volume.
So Tom, having inserted an EU value of 2000 kg/m
3, and a measured value of 400 kg/m
3, comes up with a distributed charge between s/c and comet of 3.65 x 10
-4 C
2. And that is basically as far as he goes.
So, given the charge on Rosetta worked out by Harvey, we know that it is 10
-8 C. Therefore, from Tom's final figures, we know the charge on the comet must be 3.65 x 10
4 C. From the capacitance estimated by Harvey of 67P, of 0.3uF, we can work out the voltage on the comet from Q = CV. So, V = Q/C, = 3.65 x 10
4 C/ 3.0 x 10
-7 F.
Which gives us ~ 1.2 x 10
11 V. That is 120 gigavolts. That is not possible.
http://dealingwithcreationisminastr...14/12/electric-comets-iii-mass-vs-charge.html
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278