Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So which mass do i use rc?

Wiki's 9.98e12 kg or M. Pätzold's 9.982e9 kg?

Pätzold states the mass as  (9,982 ± 3) × 109 kg. I think you'll find that 9 (thousand) 982 x 109 = 9.982 x 1012!
 
Last edited:
No, you focus. What is Coulomb's law? What is the gravitational law? Both of them have r2 as the denominator. Ergo, they cancel out.
This has nothing to do with the flight team. They measured the mass, and therefore the gravity, using Doppler effects on the RSI. That tells them at what velocity to orbit the spacecraft in bound orbits. At 5 km the velocity required will be higher than at 20 km. If they had got it wrong, the spacecraft would either crash or fly off to who knows where. They didn't get it wrong, did they? So, what is causing Rosetta to orbit in bound orbits (i.e. not using propulsion, merely gravity) when you think the damn thing is 5 x heavier than measured? Let me spell this out again; It. would. crash.

gravitational law = FIXED CAN NOT BE CHANGED (except via more or less mass)
Coulomb's law = Variable power, can be attractive OR repulsive.

BOTH are inverse square laws.

Is this correct jd116? this is my limited understanding.
 
Great so we can lock in

9.98e12 kg for the mass
1.87e10 m3 for volume
533 kg/m3 for density
662.2m3-m2 for GM
6.8e-4 m-s-2 for g

orbit distance for both Newton and Coulomb's laws = 10km

Lock them in?
 
Great so we can lock in

9.98e12 kg for the mass
1.87e10 m3 for volume
533 kg/m3 for density
662.2m3-m2 for GM
6.8e-4 m-s-2 for g

orbit distance for both Newton and Coulomb's laws = 10km

Lock them in?

No, you do not need an orbital distance! As Tom Bridgman stated:

The fact that both force laws are inverse-square allows distance between the masses, r, to cancel out. This leaves: ......

And as Prof. Harvey Rutt stated:

So the r^2 cancels out, it does have the right functional form.
So q1q2=Gm1m2/ke.

Otherwise do what you want. Harvey has already done it for you. Just copy his calculation.
 
gravitational law = FIXED CAN NOT BE CHANGED (except via more or less mass)
Coulomb's law = Variable power, can be attractive OR repulsive.

BOTH are inverse square laws.

Is this correct jd116? this is my limited understanding.


is this also correct jd116?
 
is this also correct jd116?

Both laws have r2 as the denominator. So they cancel out. It doesn't matter what distance you are calculating, because whatever it is will be the denominator in both laws. And will therefore cancel out.
 
So yes or no?

gravitational law = FIXED CAN NOT BE CHANGED (except via more or less mass)
Coulomb's law = Variable power, can be attractive OR repulsive.

BOTH are inverse square laws.

is this also correct jd116?

Newtons requires either more or less MASS with distance being fixed to change the ATTRACTIVE only gravitational force.

Coulomb requires more or less CHARGE with distance being fixed to change the ATTRACTIVE or REPULSIVE electrostatic force.

Fair call?
 
Last edited:
Coulomb's law: F = ke q1q2/ r2

Ok what would happen if q1 AND q2 are both the same sign?



Then what would happen if the same were true for m1 AND m2?

r2 still holds true!
 
Last edited:
So how many newtons of attractive force does the mass of the comet and the mass of Rosetta work out to?

How many newtons of repulsive force does the charge of the comet and the charge of Rosetta work out to?
 
Both laws have r2 as the denominator. So they cancel out. It doesn't matter what distance you are calculating, because whatever it is will be the denominator in both laws. And will therefore cancel out.

What happens when one force is attractive and one is repulsive? how do they cancel out?
 
What happens when one force is attractive and one is repulsive? how do they cancel out?

Because the calculations both have r2 as the denominator. It is the denominator that cancels out. That is the distance of the spacecraft from the comet. You want to make it 10 km? Then we have F = ke q1q2/ 10 000m2 to work out the non-existent repulsive force, and F = G m1m2/ 10 000m2 to work out the gravitational force. You are dividing both by the same number. It therefore cancels out. Whatever distance the s/c is from the nucleus is going to be the denominator.
So, what you end up with is ke q1q2 = G m1m2. To rearrange that, multiply both sides by 1/ ke to get rid of ke from the LH side, and you end up with;

q1q2 = G m1m2/ ke.

Now, from that we know m1 (mass s/c), m2 (mass comet as measured), G and Ke are constants that can be looked up. We know the voltage on q1 (s/c). So to complete the calculation we need to estimate the capacitance of the s/c and the comet. Relatively straightforward. We can then figure out, in Coulombs how much charge is distributed between the s/c and comet. From the capacitance and voltage we can work out how many Coulombs are on the s/c and therefore how many need to be on the comet. From the capacitance of the comet, we can work out the voltage required from Q = CV. That is, V = Q/C. And you'll find that this has been done. It is a ludicrous figure of ~ 100 gigavolts. It isn't tenable.
 
Last edited:
Well the flight team for Rosetta needed something so they could ORBIT the nucleus, like you said Jd116 and with fuel to spare!!

Focus jd116, focus

LINK

So, tusenfem is wiki on the money here sport?

Which one would you like to use? the 10 or 100km jd116?

I don't care, you can use the wiki numbers, that's fine.
It also does not matter if you use 10 or 100 km for orbital distance. For generality you can use α × 10 km.
 
Coulomb's law: F = ke q1q2/ r2

Ok what would happen if q1 AND q2 are both the same sign?



Then what would happen if the same were true for m1 AND m2?

r2 still holds true!

my gawd, man, YOU are supposed to be the Electric Anything expert, and you don't even know how coulomb's law works?

What the frak do you want to calculate, STATE THAT FIRST!!!
Do you want to equate Newton and Coulomb?
Do you want to disturbe Newton by Coulomb?
WHAT DO YOU WANT?
 
So how many newtons of attractive force does the mass of the comet and the mass of Rosetta work out to?

How many newtons of repulsive force does the charge of the comet and the charge of Rosetta work out to?

You have the numbers, put them in the friggin equations and tell us!
 
Essentially Sol, what we are doing by cancelling out the denominator, is calculating the charge required on the comet at 0 m, i.e. the surface. The charge 'felt' by the s/c will lessen as 1/ r2 as you move away from the nucleus, just as the gravitational force 'felt' will drop off as 1/ r2. So, we can do a whole series of calculations for varying orbital parameters, but there is no point. Surely the charge in question is that on the comet surface. And that would disrupt any material known to man.
 
Last edited:
For Sol's benefit I'll try to show why Harvey and Tom's calculations lead to the same conclusion, despite looking somewhat different on paper.

First off, we have the Coulomb constant, ke, which is a known number. However, Harvey and Tom use it differently, but this will have no bearing on the result. ke is derived from Gauss's law, and is given as 1/ 4πε0, where ε0 is the vacuum permittivity, and Tom uses this form in his calculation.
So, essentially, Harvey gets rid of ke by multiplying each side of the equation by 1/ ke. For Tom, he needs to get rid of it by multiplying both sides by 4πε0/ 1.
It will have precisely the same effect.
Another difference, is that Harvey just equates the two force laws, and works out what charge would be needed to fully cancel gravity for the mass as measured by Rosetta (35 gigavolts). Of course, that isn't the figure we need. EU say that a charge is cancelling out some proportion of the measured mass/ gravity. So, if you want the comet to be 2000 kg/m3, and we take the measured density of ~ 500 kg/m3, that means that you need to have it (4 - 1) x Harvey's result, i.e. 3 x 35 = 105 gigavolts.

Tom has done things slightly differently, and has built the real and apparent masses into his equation, assuming we can leave the s/c mass as it is. So, he has Gm (M' - M), where m = s/c mass, M' = mass required by EU, and M is the mass as measured by Rosetta. He then converts that into an equation using density values, mass = density x volume.
So Tom, having inserted an EU value of 2000 kg/m3, and a measured value of 400 kg/m3, comes up with a distributed charge between s/c and comet of 3.65 x 10-4 C2. And that is basically as far as he goes.
So, given the charge on Rosetta worked out by Harvey, we know that it is 10-8 C. Therefore, from Tom's final figures, we know the charge on the comet must be 3.65 x 104 C. From the capacitance estimated by Harvey of 67P, of 0.3uF, we can work out the voltage on the comet from Q = CV. So, V = Q/C, = 3.65 x 104 C/ 3.0 x 10-7 F.
Which gives us ~ 1.2 x 1011 V. That is 120 gigavolts. That is not possible.

http://dealingwithcreationisminastr...14/12/electric-comets-iii-mass-vs-charge.html

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom