Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Given that the EU 'theory' (and I use the word theory in its loosest version, fantasy would be a better term really), relies on the electric sun, what are your / their predictions for the solar probe on the way to the sun now Sol88?
Given the currents and electric fields you claim present there to make the electric comets work, the probe imo should be shorted out (and give an impressive cometary tail) in short order.
If that does not happen and if the probe functions normally as if there is no EU predicted massive electric field around the sun, will you than finally accept that there is no electric sun and therefore no electric comets?

And don't get me wrong, I understand there is electromagnetism in and around the sun, I just also understand it is generated BY the sun as a result of the nuclear reaction constrained by gravity, and not the other way around.
 
For Sol's benefit I'll try to show why Harvey and Tom's calculations lead to the same conclusion, despite looking somewhat different on paper.

First off, we have the Coulomb constant, ke, which is a known number. However, Harvey and Tom use it differently, but this will have no bearing on the result. ke is derived from Gauss's law, and is given as 1/ 4πε0, where ε0 is the vacuum permittivity, and Tom uses this form in his calculation.
So, essentially, Harvey gets rid of ke by multiplying each side of the equation by 1/ ke. For Tom, he needs to get rid of it by multiplying both sides by 4πε0/ 1.
It will have precisely the same effect.
Another difference, is that Harvey just equates the two force laws, and works out what charge would be needed to fully cancel gravity for the mass as measured by Rosetta (35 gigavolts). Of course, that isn't the figure we need. EU say that a charge is cancelling out some proportion of the measured mass/ gravity. So, if you want the comet to be 2000 kg/m3, and we take the measured density of ~ 500 kg/m3, that means that you need to have it (4 - 1) x Harvey's result, i.e. 3 x 35 = 105 gigavolts.

Tom has done things slightly differently, and has built the real and apparent masses into his equation, assuming we can leave the s/c mass as it is. So, he has Gm (M' - M), where m = s/c mass, M' = mass required by EU, and M is the mass as measured by Rosetta. He then converts that into an equation using density values, mass = density x volume.
So Tom, having inserted an EU value of 2000 kg/m3, and a measured value of 400 kg/m3, comes up with a distributed charge between s/c and comet of 3.65 x 10-4 C2. And that is basically as far as he goes.
So, given the charge on Rosetta worked out by Harvey, we know that it is 10-8 C. Therefore, from Tom's final figures, we know the charge on the comet must be 3.65 x 104 C. From the capacitance estimated by Harvey of 67P, of 0.3uF, we can work out the voltage on the comet from Q = CV. So, V = Q/C, = 3.65 x 104 C/ 3.0 x 10-7 F.
Which gives us ~ 1.2 x 1011 V. That is 120 gigavolts. That is not possible.

http://dealingwithcreationisminastr...14/12/electric-comets-iii-mass-vs-charge.html

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

All well a good champ but too simplistic! :D

Are you sure old Tom and Harvey have covered all the variables here?

What if they where to chuck in the Debye-Huckel expression, jd116?
 
What if they where to chuck in the Debye-Huckel expression, jd116?

A complete irrelevance, as you would understand if you knew anything about science and maths. You need a charge on the comet to make it appear as if the gravity, and therefore mass and density are 4+ x lower than solid rock. What is the charge, and how are you going to calculate it?
 
Last edited:
If that does not happen and if the probe functions normally as if there is no EU predicted massive electric field around the sun, will you than finally accept that there is no electric sun and therefore no electric comets?


A believer who hasn't gone all the way down the rabbit hole might. The true believers, no. Their excuses will take different forms but will end, as they must, with accusations of incompetence or conspiracy.
 
A complete irrelevance, as you would understand if you knew anything about science and maths. You need a charge on the comet to make it appear as if the gravity, and therefore mass and density are 4+ x lower than solid rock. What is the charge, and how are you going to calculate it?

I’m after about 100kv/m electric field centred on the nucleus.

You only Have 0.0083240685 Newton’s of force at 9.98e12kg mass of the nucleus when the density is more in line with rock at ~2000kg/m3 the mass should be around 4.114e14kg, this would give 0.343138455 Newton’s

So we are looking for some force that can supply .335 Newton’s of push or a little over an ounce to offset the mainstream “measured” and the expected gravitational pull from EC.

Not really much force we are talking about here.
 
A believer who hasn't gone all the way down the rabbit hole might. The true believers, no. Their excuses will take different forms but will end, as they must, with accusations of incompetence or conspiracy.

Indeed. As you infer, Sol88 has drunk far too deeply from the EU Kool-Aid well to be saved. It is a pity that some of the people who spend so much time, and show so much dedication in defending this woo, didn't spend the same time and dedication in actually learning some basic science and maths.

(Of course, had they done so, they wouldn't believe this nonsense in the first place!)
 
I’m after about 100kv/m electric field centred on the nucleus.

You only Have 0.0083240685 Newton’s of force at 9.98e12kg mass of the nucleus when the density is more in line with rock at ~2000kg/m3 the mass should be around 4.114e14kg, this would give 0.343138455 Newton’s

So we are looking for some force that can supply .335 Newton’s of push or a little over an ounce to offset the mainstream “measured” and the expected gravitational pull from EC.

Not really much force we are talking about here.

Show us the equation that brings you to this almost certainly erroneous conclusion. Otherwise I'm not wasting time on it.
 
2200kg/m3 x 18.7e10 = 4.114e14 kg

4.114e14 kg = m1
1250kg = m2
10km
F= 0.343138455 Newtons

9.98e12 kg = m1
1250 kg = m2
10km = d
F = 0.0083240685 Newton’s

Something like that
 
2200kg/m3 x 18.7e10 = 4.114e14 kg

4.114e14 kg = m1
1250kg = m2
10km
F= 0.343138455 Newtons

9.98e12 kg = m1
1250 kg = m2
10km = d
F = 0.0083240685 Newton’s

Something like that


I have no idea what you have done there! We're doing a BOTE calculation, so let's set out the parameters in figures that are easy to deal with:

m1 = 1 x 1013 kg.
m2 = 1.5 x 103 kg.
G = 6.7 x 10-11m3 kg-1 s-2.
r2 (which is pointless, but what the hell) = 108m.

m1 (EU) = 4 x 1013 kg. (2000kg/ m3).

So, using the measured values (and leaving out the units for brevity);

F = G m1.m2/ r2> F = (6.67 x 10-11) x (1 x 1013) x (1.5 x 103)/ 108= 10-2 N (0.01 N).

By definition, the EU value is 4 x higher, so = 0.04 N. Difference equals 0.03 N.

TBC.
 
So, on to Coulomb's law;

F = ke q1q2/ r2, where;

ke = (near as makes no difference) 1 x 1010 N m2 C−2q1 = unknown.
q2 = 10-8 C. (As calculated using an estimated capacitance by Harvey on the Rosetta blog; if Sol wants to dispute this, he'll need to show why).
r2 = 108 m.

So, we need to rearrange a bit to make the unknown, q1, the subject of the equation;
Lets multiply both sides by r2/ q2, for a start. That leaves us with;

q1. ke = F. r2/ q2

We can, if we want, now also get rid of the ke on the LHS by multiplying both sides by 1/ ke;

> q1 = F. r2/ q2. ke;

So, plugging in the values above, we get;

q1 = 0.03 x 108/ 10-8 x 1010;

> 3 x 106/ 102
= 3 x 104 C.
Whoops, that figure looks familiar! So, we need 30 000 C on the comet. What is that in voltage terms? Been there, done that. Work out a reasonable capacitance for 67P, and obtain the voltage from Q = CV (V= Q/C).

p.s.
Perhaps Sol now is starting to understand why I said the denominator (r2) cancels out, and it is pointless including it.
 
2200kg/m3 x 18.7e10 = 4.114e14 kg

2200 kg/m3 (2.2 x 103 kg/m3) x 1.87 x 1010 m3 = ~ 4 x 1013 kg

4.114e14 kg = m1
1250kg = m2
10km
F= 0.343138455 Newtons

9.98e12 kg = m1
1250 kg = m2
10km = d
F = 0.0083240685 Newton’s

Something like that

You've converted the km3 wrongly. 18.7 km3 = 18.7 x 109 m3. Which can be expressed also as 1.87 x 1010 m3.
That would have got you the right answer,. Shift the decimal point 1 place left in your first calculation, and the two forces you end up with are ~ 0.034 N - 0.08 N, which is what I've got, near as makes no difference, above.
However, there is no need for such precision for a BOTE calculation. Make the maths easy by rounding, do a quick calculation, and see if it is worth doing the equation again with more precision. It isn't :)
 
Last edited:
Jd116, how much charge is a comet allowed to have?

Is 23 coulombs a lot in your book jd116?

At something like 150kV

Hey maybe you could even preempt E. Behar
The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be signicant close to the nucleus.

What’s significant?

I’m bett’n on around the 1e5V/m.
 
Last edited:
Jd116, how much charge is a comet allowed to have?

Is 23 coulombs a lot in your book jd116?

At something like 150kV

Hey maybe you could even preempt E. Behar

What’s significant?

I’m bett’n on around the 1e5V/m.

An ambipolar electric field is NOT caused by a charge of the comet.
 
Jd116, how much charge is a comet allowed to have?

Is 23 coulombs a lot in your book jd116?

At something like 150kV

Hey maybe you could even preempt E. Behar

What’s significant?

I’m bett’n on around the 1e5V/m.

You can bet on whatever the hell you like. You're wrong. In your fantasy the comet needs 30 000 C. That equates to a voltage of ~ 100 gigavolts. It isn't there. End of story.
 
You can bet on whatever the hell you like. You're wrong. In your fantasy the comet needs 30 000 C. That equates to a voltage of ~ 100 gigavolts. It isn't there. End of story.

No.

I’m looking at something that only has to supply a puny .26 Newton’s of force.

And

An electric field of around 1e5kV.
 
Last edited:
I’m looking at something that only has to supply a puny .26 Newton’s of force.

And I did the maths for you above. You need 30 000 C on the comet. End of story. And that was for 0.03 N, not 0.26. You really need to sort this maths thing out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom