Indagator
Scholar
- Joined
- May 2, 2018
- Messages
- 112
[size=+2]COMET DENSITY - PART 1/3![/size]
Sol88, I think your electric "asteroid" suffers from a density identity problem! You might want to get that checked!
As you've noted, Sol88, density is a derived quantity. The volume of an object is easily obtained from "photographic" evidence such as that provided by the OSIRIS instrument onboard Rosetta. No problem there, right? What's at issue is the object's mass. Can we maintain our focus on the mass (and gravity field) determination issue? No side-tracks? No deflections? No distractions?
Saturn's mass has been measured and refined by several radio science experiments! Both Voyager 1 and 2 had flyby encounters on 1980/11/12 and 1981/08/25 respectively. Whilst orbiting Saturn over 13 years, Cassini made literally millions of mass and gravity field measurements using its onboard Radio Science Subsystem (RSS)! Today, we report the density of Saturn as 687 kg/m^3. As you'll no doubt note, that value is less than that of liquid water! Is that significant? Do you know where the volatile ice lines are for our star at this point in its life cycle? For completeness, Saturn's eccentricity is given as 0.0565.
Rosetta's OSIRIS and RSI instruments were used to measure the bulk density of 21/Lutetia and 67P/CG. The literature reports values of 3400 kg/m^3 for the asteroid, and 533 kg/m^3 for the comet! Again, for completeness, 21/Lutetia has an orbital eccentricity of 0.164, while 67P/CG is determined to be 0.641!
Furthermore, it is worth noting that the Lutetia fly-by took mere hours with a closest approach of ~3160 kms. How might this impact the mass determination? A conservative volume estimate (established with both OSIRIS data and ground-based observations using AO) resulted in a derived volume with an error estimated to be ~8%. Following analysis of the RSI data, the mass determination was found to contain an error of ~1%. Thus, the cumulative error in the calculated bulk density is estimated to be less than 10%! In your "ec" expert opinion, Sol88, is the reported bulk density of 21/Lutetia accurate enough? Can we agree that the bulk density for 21/Lutetia is 3400 +/- 300 kg/m^3, which is consistent with that of an asteroid?
Regardless of what you might have to say about Lutetia's bulk density, Sol88, I think you should analyze the data to VERIFY that it has not been "corrupted" by "evil scientists" with an agenda to suppress your "electric asteroid" model! From this point forward, I would like to refer to your "model" as either the "electric rock" or "electric asteroid" as you have made claim that the only difference between comets and asteroids is their orbital eccentricity! Of course, everyone but you knows this to be WRONG! Evidence? Again I refer you to the 13 eccentricity data points that you refuse to acknowledge (but will have to one day as I'm not going to go away)! Any lurkers want to throw in with Sol88? ... Didn't think so!
Six minutes using a variety of search techniques and here you go .....
The LUTETIA FLYBY data includes 56295 data records, in six tables, for both x-band and s-band antennas. Referring to the information clipped from the six data headers, we observe that during the 10 hour fly-by, approximately 8.5 hours of data was collected!
DATA_SET_NAME = "ROSETTA-ORBITER LUTETIA RSI 1/2/3 LUTETIA FLY-BY 0120 V1.0"
MISSION_ID = "ROSETTA"
MISSION_NAME = "INTERNATIONAL ROSETTA MISSION"
MISSION_PHASE_NAME = "LUTETIA FLY-BY"
PROCESSING_LEVEL_ID = 3
PRODUCT_TYPE = "RDR"
TARGET_NAME = "21 LUTETIA"
TARGET_TYPE = "ASTEROID"
OBSERVATION_TYPE = "TARGET GRAVITY"
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911214_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T12:14:09.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:06:21.500
ROWS = 13933
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911827_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T18:27:13.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:27:33.499
ROWS = 3621
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911948_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:48:42.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T21:57:36.500
ROWS = 7735
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911213_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T12:13:21.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:05:59.500
ROWS = 13959
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911647_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:47:40.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:22:49.500
ROWS = 9310
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911948_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:48:46.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T21:57:42.500
ROWS = 7737
TOTAL RECORDS = 56295
As I've said before, science is iterative! We know that 21/Lutetia is an asteroid with a bulk density of 3400 kg/m^3. Start by analyzing the 56295 data records from the asteroid flyby to get a handle on what the RSI can tell us about mass and gravity fields. Once you've successful navigated your way through this trivial exercise, you may proceed to an analysis of the 100's of thousands of 67P data points,
To paraphrase Matthias Pätzold, there are several techniques available to determine the mass of an asteroid (or any celestial object for that matter), but by far the most accurate is spacecraft tracking during a "close" flyby, or escort.
Fill yer boots, Sol88! And good luck!
PostScript - Apologies, Sol88! I should have asked earlier - Can you even do math? Do you know how to do a statistical least-squares fit procedure? Does the phrase "least-squares fit procedure" mean anything at all to you? Do you know what "significant figures" are? Do you know how to work with vectors?
More to follow .......... including my feedback on the Deca paper!
Sol88, I think your electric "asteroid" suffers from a density identity problem! You might want to get that checked!
As resident expert in the electric comet model, you claim that there are problems with the determination of density for comets! PROVE IT! I suggest (as have others) that you use the actual RSI data!
As you've noted, Sol88, density is a derived quantity. The volume of an object is easily obtained from "photographic" evidence such as that provided by the OSIRIS instrument onboard Rosetta. No problem there, right? What's at issue is the object's mass. Can we maintain our focus on the mass (and gravity field) determination issue? No side-tracks? No deflections? No distractions?
Saturn's mass has been measured and refined by several radio science experiments! Both Voyager 1 and 2 had flyby encounters on 1980/11/12 and 1981/08/25 respectively. Whilst orbiting Saturn over 13 years, Cassini made literally millions of mass and gravity field measurements using its onboard Radio Science Subsystem (RSS)! Today, we report the density of Saturn as 687 kg/m^3. As you'll no doubt note, that value is less than that of liquid water! Is that significant? Do you know where the volatile ice lines are for our star at this point in its life cycle? For completeness, Saturn's eccentricity is given as 0.0565.
Rosetta's OSIRIS and RSI instruments were used to measure the bulk density of 21/Lutetia and 67P/CG. The literature reports values of 3400 kg/m^3 for the asteroid, and 533 kg/m^3 for the comet! Again, for completeness, 21/Lutetia has an orbital eccentricity of 0.164, while 67P/CG is determined to be 0.641!
Furthermore, it is worth noting that the Lutetia fly-by took mere hours with a closest approach of ~3160 kms. How might this impact the mass determination? A conservative volume estimate (established with both OSIRIS data and ground-based observations using AO) resulted in a derived volume with an error estimated to be ~8%. Following analysis of the RSI data, the mass determination was found to contain an error of ~1%. Thus, the cumulative error in the calculated bulk density is estimated to be less than 10%! In your "ec" expert opinion, Sol88, is the reported bulk density of 21/Lutetia accurate enough? Can we agree that the bulk density for 21/Lutetia is 3400 +/- 300 kg/m^3, which is consistent with that of an asteroid?
Regardless of what you might have to say about Lutetia's bulk density, Sol88, I think you should analyze the data to VERIFY that it has not been "corrupted" by "evil scientists" with an agenda to suppress your "electric asteroid" model! From this point forward, I would like to refer to your "model" as either the "electric rock" or "electric asteroid" as you have made claim that the only difference between comets and asteroids is their orbital eccentricity! Of course, everyone but you knows this to be WRONG! Evidence? Again I refer you to the 13 eccentricity data points that you refuse to acknowledge (but will have to one day as I'm not going to go away)! Any lurkers want to throw in with Sol88? ... Didn't think so!
Six minutes using a variety of search techniques and here you go .....
The LUTETIA FLYBY data includes 56295 data records, in six tables, for both x-band and s-band antennas. Referring to the information clipped from the six data headers, we observe that during the 10 hour fly-by, approximately 8.5 hours of data was collected!
DATA_SET_NAME = "ROSETTA-ORBITER LUTETIA RSI 1/2/3 LUTETIA FLY-BY 0120 V1.0"
MISSION_ID = "ROSETTA"
MISSION_NAME = "INTERNATIONAL ROSETTA MISSION"
MISSION_PHASE_NAME = "LUTETIA FLY-BY"
PROCESSING_LEVEL_ID = 3
PRODUCT_TYPE = "RDR"
TARGET_NAME = "21 LUTETIA"
TARGET_TYPE = "ASTEROID"
OBSERVATION_TYPE = "TARGET GRAVITY"
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911214_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T12:14:09.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:06:21.500
ROWS = 13933
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911827_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T18:27:13.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:27:33.499
ROWS = 3621
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFSL02_DPS_101911948_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:48:42.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T21:57:36.500
ROWS = 7735
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911213_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T12:13:21.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:05:59.500
ROWS = 13959
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911647_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T16:47:40.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:22:49.500
ROWS = 9310
DOPPLER_TABLE = "R63ODFXL02_DPX_101911948_00.TAB"
START_TIME = 2010-07-10T19:48:46.500
STOP_TIME = 2010-07-10T21:57:42.500
ROWS = 7737
TOTAL RECORDS = 56295
As I've said before, science is iterative! We know that 21/Lutetia is an asteroid with a bulk density of 3400 kg/m^3. Start by analyzing the 56295 data records from the asteroid flyby to get a handle on what the RSI can tell us about mass and gravity fields. Once you've successful navigated your way through this trivial exercise, you may proceed to an analysis of the 100's of thousands of 67P data points,
To paraphrase Matthias Pätzold, there are several techniques available to determine the mass of an asteroid (or any celestial object for that matter), but by far the most accurate is spacecraft tracking during a "close" flyby, or escort.
Fill yer boots, Sol88! And good luck!
PostScript - Apologies, Sol88! I should have asked earlier - Can you even do math? Do you know how to do a statistical least-squares fit procedure? Does the phrase "least-squares fit procedure" mean anything at all to you? Do you know what "significant figures" are? Do you know how to work with vectors?
More to follow .......... including my feedback on the Deca paper!