Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
What? He and Harvey, both PhDs who know far more about the subject than you ever will, independently arrived at the same way of working out the necessary charge. If you think otherwise, then tell us which equation you are using, instead of posting rubbish. Give us the numbers, or give up.

Let's be honest, Sol - you haven't got a clue, have you? You don't know which equation to use and, even if you did, you wouldn't know which numbers to put in there. You likely heard the idiot Thornhill say something about charge cancelling gravity, and, as usual, have just taken the loon's word for it, because you aren't scientifically adept enough to see why it's wrong. And neither is he.
Clue: it's a fairy story, with no science to back it up. Not to mention zero evidence.
 
This is my way to show "the lurkers" how incapable you are.
Did you look at the figure now?
Did you compare the SW ion and com electrons?
Did you compare the SW electrons and com ions?
Did you look at the densities in the colorbar?
Did you do ANYTHING? Don't answer that, it's retorical.

I see colour, low density but still not all back to quasi neutrality :D

So how far are you saying, in round km, from the point of speration berfore there all happily back together?
 
[3rd person]Sol88 looks at his signature line and remembers those immortal words “The WWW never forgets”.[/3rd person]
 
[3rd person]Sol88 looks at his signature line and remembers those immortal words “The WWW never forgets”.[/3rd person]

Correct, it doesn't. And the inability of any EC proponents to explain the findings is there for all to see. As are David Talbott's predictions. As is the measured gravity of the comet. And the total lack of rock. And the total lack of electric discharges. And all the ice and volatiles.
So, your failure is writ large for some considerable time to come.
 
Correct, it doesn't. And the inability of any EC proponents to explain the findings is there for all to see. As are David Talbott's predictions. As is the measured gravity of the comet. And the total lack of rock. And the total lack of electric discharges. And all the ice and volatiles.
So, your failure is writ large for some considerable time to come.

Tom was wrong. :D


Oh dear
 
there is nothing to prove wrong, because you don't even have a clue what you are talking about.


Ha ha ha neither do you. :D

Same as the question put to you about how far from the nucleus the separated ion and electrons get back together.
 
Tom was wrong. :D


Oh dear

No, he wasn't, and neither was Harvey. If you think the numbers are wrong, then show the error. If you think two PhDs have both come up with same equation, and got it wrong, then tell us the correct equation. You wouldn't know if it was wrong or not, as you obviously don't have the foggiest clue how to go about working the problem out. Which is why you are capable of believing this nonsense in the first place. Ignorance is bliss for the woo merchants.

  • What is cancelling the gravity?
  • How is it cancelling the gravity?
  • How do we work this out?

If you cannot answer those questions, with the relevant equations and maths, then you have no argument. Email the idiot Thornhill if you have to, but I've never seen him use numbers, either. You have no mechanism to explain the observed density of the comet. Find one.
 
Ha ha ha neither do you. :D

Same as the question put to you about how far from the nucleus the separated ion and electrons get back together.

all the necessary information is in figure 1 of jan's paper, toodles!
 
Ha ha ha neither do you. :D

Same as the question put to you about how far from the nucleus the separated ion and electrons get back together.

Sol, if you are so exercised by this, why don't you email Jan Deca? His paper will be written to be understood by fellow scientists. In particular, plasma physicists. Just get in touch, say that you are a student, or just have a keen amateur interest in plasma physics, and would like some clarification on the implications of his paper regarding...yada, yada, yada. I've done it loads of times whilst doing degrees and at other times. I don't see why I should do it this time, though. It's your woo, you run with it. Otherwise drop it. It is an irrelevance, anyway. Tusenfem has likely got better things to do than walk you through a paper aimed at professionals. It has no bearing on the total lack of electric woo on the surface, or the total lack of rock, or the total lack of the radial electric field invented by EUists. Or the total lack of any explanation for the measured density/ gravity. You are still batting zero, evidence wise. This carry on is all just a smokescreen to avoid having to deal with that. What you have, Sol, is called faith. Religions are built on it. And so is EU woo. No science, no evidence.
 
all the necessary information is in figure 1 of jan's paper, toodles!

Does that include the field aligned currents flowing down the tail?

Or just the solar wind and cometary plasma out to only 1500km?

This charge separation is HUGE!

Not real good news for the dirty snowball/icy dust ball but REAL good news for those EC cranks :D
 
Not real good news for the dirty snowball/icy dust ball but REAL good news for those EC cranks

Errr, for any dummies around, let us just do a concise run down of what was discovered at 67P; zero electrical woo on the surface. Correct? Zero rock. Correct? Zero evidence of some scientific pygmy's idea about water being created by the solar wind (lol), correct?
Sol, you are talking garbage, as usual. Care to update your idiocy to match actual observation? Frankly, Sol, you are a waste of space. You are scientifically illiterate. Correct? We need one of the other scientifically illiterate loons who came up with this crap to turn up and explain it. However, we all know that that is not going to happen. Eh? Trust me, if Dave had seen anything in the data in favour of this idiotic woo, he'd have been all over this place. Yes? The fact that he disappeared in Dec 2014 tells you everything you need to know. Correct? EC was a massive failure. Oh dear. Who'd have thought? Well, anybody with an IQ in the right hand half of a Bell curve. Yes?
 
So, here is an open invitation to any EUist to try to explain the electric comet nonsense. Sol can copy this post over to dunderdolts, if he so pleases. We need someone who understands this EC woo, and is also capable of high school level mathematics, and has at least a Bachelors degree in a relevant science. Perhaps then we might make some headway into understanding what Sol cannot explain, namely:

Why is the comet density ~ 500 kg/m3?
If the answer to that is some sort of electric repulsion, then tell us how much you need, and show us the equation you are using.

Is the comet made of rock?
If so, where is it? Why is it not seen by multiple instruments?

What are the jets from the nucleus?
If the answer is some sort of electric discharge woo, then show us its detection in the data.

Why are numerous asteroids on cometary orbits not behaving like comets?

Where is the water vapour, and other volatiles, coming from?

Where is the ice coming from?
Please explain how impacting a comet throws out a shed load of ice, and leaves a crater too big for a rocky surface, if the comet is actually made of rock.

That should do for now. The list is far from exhaustive, but anyone that can give rational and quantitative answers to the above will have accomplished more than Sol ever has on this thread.
 
My apologies if this was already posted in this long thread [emoji16]

youtu be/keJAQIWEyzY

If someone can fix the link, please. I can't post links yet.
It's Safire update from the last year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
My apologies if this was already posted in this long thread [emoji16]

youtu be/keJAQIWEyzY

If someone can fix the link, please. I can't post links yet.
It's Safire update from the last year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keJAQIWEyzY

The problem that people on here have with this SAFIRE thing, is that there is no working model for an electric sun, so what the heck are they basing their experiments on?
There was a long running thread devoted to the electric sun idea, here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=193096&highlight=electric

Let's just say that there are serious problems with it/ them!
 
My apologies if this was already posted in this long thread [emoji16]

youtu be/keJAQIWEyzY

If someone can fix the link, please. I can't post links yet.
It's Safire update from the last year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Welcome to ISF, SDG! :)

I’m not sure whether you intend to defend SAFIRE as science or not; however if you are, could you please let us know how the density, temperature, and pressure radial gradients of SAFIRE compare with those of the Sun?
 
What Harvey did not take into account and DOES change is napkin calculation is the following.





Looking at what the nucleus, it could be model as a polarised dielectric sphere whose properties change in conjunction with the variable ambipolar electric field.


this pic of a polarised of dielectric sphere is interesting. Look at those streamline, they look familiar
[qimg]http://i64.tinypic.com/x6hbtf.jpg[/qimg]

So we can work of few more equations and assumption into the calculation, run that bad boy see what we come up with?

Charge 1 C = Rosetta
Charge2 C = 67P
Force N = known
Distance km = Known

We should get what we are after?
Is this your “spherical cow” effort?

Sol88, I’m very disappointed. :(

If you won’t even attempt to do a relatively simple calculation, I can say with 100% confidence that you will never convince anyone here that the ELECTRIC COMET model has legs.

And if you refuse to address the data that lead to estimates of comets’ densities, you will surely confirm lurkers’ views that you are unwilling to engage in a science-based discussion.

Care to have another go?
 
Does that include the field aligned currents flowing down the tail?

Or just the solar wind and cometary plasma out to only 1500km?

This charge separation is HUGE!

Not real good news for the dirty snowball/icy dust ball but REAL good news for those EC cranks :D

- what field aligned current along the tail?
- the figure is pretty clear in what it shows.
-what does huge man, care to enlighten us and put some actual numbers to this claim and how you calculated that?
- whatever you say sol
 
ok let's break it down then from W.T."Tom" Bridgman's page of whinges.


How much of this plasma does the comet nucleus intercept?
How long would it take for the charge on the nucleus to neutralize?
Now how long will it take for the nucleus to neutralize charge?
What happens then, and why?
Is the amount of additional charge attracted (most likely solar protons) sufficient to explain the amount of OH and water production measured per the Thornhill model for the comet OH emission?
How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?
Where's the battery or generator that maintains the potential between the comet nucleus and the solar wind?

These where toms questions to his calculation on the charge required for electrostatic repulsion to be a factor to which I answered...

Originally Posted by tusenfem View Post
You do realise, I hope, that you have give no answers to the questions?
Just putting down a link to a paper which does not even mention cometary surface charge as an answer to a question about how the comet gets charged seem strange, to say the least.
Thus we shall conclude that EC has no answers (what a surprise).

Sorry I did not realise.

I asked you a question a couple posts back about charge neutralisation and you refused to post your answer to...

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.

J.Deca
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

So how far away from the nucleus does this occur again?

Q 2&3 have the same answer which does affect 4!


The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be signicant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric field points radially outward from the nucleus.

The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
E. Behar

How does this electric field effect Toms assumption and his calculation for electrostatic repulsion of Rosetta and the dust?

2. How long would it take for the charge on the nucleus to neutralize?

3.Now how long will it take for the nucleus to neutralize charge?
Tusenfem?

Jd116, I can’t do the maths, can you help me with Toms calculations using E. Behar’s modeling?


To which everyone ignored.

I even asked the expert mathematicians here for a hand and no one, not even jd116 the math guru, can do the maths when i’ve at least presented some of the variables and the more correct model of the plasma interactions going on at a comet.

Tom’s simplistic calculations never took into account the complex interplay electric fields have and more and more are being found at comets.

The second population gained most of its energy in the close vicinity of the nucleus where cometary ions largely dominate and where the acceleration appears to be driven by an ambipolar electric eld. The ion motion in the yz-plane is radially away from the comet independent of the solar wind electric eld direction. This population thus comes from a part of the coma where the local ambipolar electric eld governs the ion motion, and the solar wind electric eld has much less inuence. In agreement with Behar et al. (2016a) and Nilsson et al. (2017), the present observations point towards the existence of an additional electric eld accelerating all cometary ions towards the anti-sunward direction. The data thus suggest, that there is a third electric eld in the vicinity of the comet, in addition to the solar wind and ionospheric ambipolar electric elds, affecting both the cometary ion populations. The density of the two cometary ion populations reveals an intrinsic asymmetry of the coma of 67P, with higher densities in the southern CSE hemisphere. This shows that the solar wind electric eld does have some inuence on the expanding population, even though not much inuence is seen in the ow direction.
Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period L. Bercic1,2, E. Behar2,1, H. Nilsson2,1, G. Nicolaou2,4, G. Stenberg Wieser2, M. Wieser2, and C. Goetz3

So Tom was WRONG in his assumptions. Now someone here willing to have another crack at his incorrect calculations?

Comets are rock.

Nested double layers anyone?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom