Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So do you agree there is charge separation happening around comets?

Can’t move forward with this discussion to you answer this question.

No charge separation = NO electric comet

Charge separation = THE ELECTRIC COMET!

So, I can see why everyone is avoiding the question.

So funny to watch. :)

Kind of reminds me of a story about Galileo Galilei

"And yet it moves they seperate " Galileo Galilei
Sol88, I think most readers are struck dumb by just how, um, ridiculous what you’re posting is.

When you take off your shirt on a cold, dry night, you’ll likely see sparks, hear crackles, and maybe feel a sting. “Static electricity”, of course. Or, as you like to say, charge separation. Does that mean you and your shirt are an electric comet (or ELECTRIC COMET)? :confused:
 
Naturally, electric shirt theory is part of the electric universe.




Though (only slightly) more seriously, given that just in a neutral atom there is "charge separation happening" between the protons and electrons. The degree of charge separation would seem to be the relevant factor for "THE ELECTRIC COMET" or just the meager electric shirt.
 
Simply lies and more insults to derail from his many comet delusions

So simple and you completely balls it up! ...
11 July 2018: Simply lies and more insults to derail from his many comet delusions.

He has the completely ignorant delusion that Comet 67P moving invalidates the calculations of Tom Bridgeman on the charges on Rosetta and 67P and their effects on measured mass.

He has the insane insult that people here and Tom Bridgeman (an astronomer!) do not know that a plasma has separated charges (ions and elections).

He has the insane delusion that just repeating the phrase 'charge separation' is physics supporting his comet delusions.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic.
 
Current "charge separation" stupidity about tusenfem's post on a lack of data

So do you agree there is charge separation happening around comets?
11 July 2018: Current "charge separation" stupidity about tusenfem's post on a lack of data about the electric comet (no data =- no electric comet).
 
Last edited:
Sol88, I think most readers are struck dumb by just how, um, ridiculous what you’re posting is.

When you take off your shirt on a cold, dry night, you’ll likely see sparks, hear crackles, and maybe feel a sting. “Static electricity”, of course. Or, as you like to say, charge separation. Does that mean you and your shirt are an electric comet (or ELECTRIC COMET)? :confused:

Does Static electricity set up electric fields?

Does Static electricity have any bearing on the solar wind plasma? (The charges that are separating are mainly from this plasma, not your shirt. :) )

Does Static electricity sustain electric currents thru a plasma?

Does Static electricity form and sustain charge carring double layers?

Does Static electricity have any relation to kinetic plasma effects?

You’ve come in at a critical time here jt, this is new breaking stuff as far as the ELECTRIC COMET is concerned.

So I choose to leave the nucleus is rock debate until such time we all are on the same page wrt charge separation around a comet, is this ok?
 
Jesus. No, he wasn't. As he and Harvey showed, you need a colossal amount of charge on the comet to cancel out gravity. It isn't there. Understand? I don't expect you do, do you? Bit beyond you this stuff, isn't it? If you think it is there, then show us, instead of posting uneducated, irrelevant garbage to avoid actual scienctific observations. Or lack thereof.
We might as well discuss QM with a chimpanzee.

No, he showed the charge would bleed off in short order nullifying any effect!

I stated there is a continuous charge imbalance as it progresses thru it’s orbit.

So yeah, dude was wrong! :D
 
Does Static electricity set up electric fields?

Does Static electricity have any bearing on the solar wind plasma? (The charges that are separating are mainly from this plasma, not your shirt. :) )

Does Static electricity sustain electric currents thru a plasma?

Does Static electricity form and sustain charge carring double layers?

Does Static electricity have any relation to kinetic plasma effects?

You’ve come in at a critical time here jt, this is new breaking stuff as far as the ELECTRIC COMET is concerned.

So I choose to leave the nucleus is rock debate until such time we all are on the same page wrt charge separation around a comet, is this ok?
Indirect, but at least you confirmed you are not willing to engage in a discussion on the density of comets (at least for now).

I will leave you to what - it seems to me - is barely coherent (it’s certainly not rational) rambling; it has IMHO no relationship to science.

Oh, what is “carring”? And “Static electricity” (capital S, lower case e)?
 
You could also reference what Sol88 agreed is the ELECTRIC COMET model, in a series of posts I started some time ago.

Of course, Sol88 is free to change his mind, but redefining the ELECTRIC COMET model to be “charge separation” is just silly ... in thunderstorms there is charge separation; per Sol88’s new ELECTRIC COMET model, thunderstorms are electric comets! :p

Jean tate, charge separation and the resultant electric fields (including double layers) and electric currents ARE the electric comet! :thumbsup:

Since the start of this thread charge separation around comets has been DENIED, now...

Is the comet nucleus causing charge separation of the solar wind plasma?
 
Last edited:
Jean tate, charge separation and the resultant electric fields (including double layers) and electric currents ARE the electric comet! :thumbsup:
Thanks for confirming that you have ripped up what you had previously signed up to; good to see that you are honest (at least in this regard).

Please let me know when you are willing to answer my questions about the density of comets (or at least five of them).
 
Does Static electricity set up electric fields?

Yep, that's what produces the arc.

Does Static electricity have any bearing on the solar wind plasma? (The charges that are separating are mainly from this plasma, not your shirt. :) )

Only as related to the ambipolar fields mentioned some time ago. The problem is the conductivity of a plasma in general doesn't really tend to support the build up of static charges.

Does Static electricity sustain electric currents thru a plasma?

Absolutely, again that is the arc discharge. The normally non-conductive air is turned into a plasma thus conducting the discharge current. Sustained until the potential difference drops below the breakdown threshold of the normally non-conductive media.


Does Static electricity form and sustain charge carring double layers?

"form and sustain" may be kind of a chicken and egg which came first question but certainly an electrostatic potential can result from a double layer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)#/media/File:Double_layer_formation.png

ETA:quote

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)

Electrostatic double layers are especially common in current-carrying plasmas, and are very thin (typically ten Debye lengths), compared to the sizes of the plasmas that contain them.




Does Static electricity have any relation to kinetic plasma effects?

Yep, again the breakdown of the normally insulating media (air) into a plasma for the arc discharge would certainly be "kinetic plasma effects"


You’ve come in at a critical time here jt, this is new breaking stuff as far as the ELECTRIC COMET is concerned.

Heck, then "the ELECTRIC COMET" must be way behind as the answers to your questions were all just basic electricity stuff.


So I choose to leave the nucleus is rock debate until such time we all are on the same page wrt charge separation around a comet, is this ok?

Given again that the real dependence is on the magnitude of charge separation around a comet, not just charge separation itself, and the basic nature of your questions above, I'm not sure if you're even in the same book.
 
Last edited:
Jean tate, charge separation and the resultant electric fields (including double layers) and electric currents ARE the electric comet! :thumbsup:

Actually "charge separation and the resultant electric fields" "and electric currents ARE" just basic electricity.

Heck, even with a double layer thrown in for good measure it still couldn't be "the electric comet!" without, well, you know, a comet in that mix.

Since the start of this thread charge separation around comets has been DENIED, now...

While others can speak for themselves but my take would be that it is the magnitude of charge separation that the "electric comet" entails that was being denied.


Is the comet nucleus causing charge separation of the solar wind plasma?

What, you mean separated more than when it left the sun?
 
Yet another lie about Bridgman and Harvey's calculation

No, he showed the charge would bleed off in short order nullifying any effect!
11 July 2018: Yet another lie about Bridgman and Harvey's calculation.
They showed that the charge started at 35,000,000,000 volts (35 gigavolts). That charge means that particle are accelerated to 35 gigavolts.
Particles accelerated by 35 gigavolts colliding with say the comet nucleus are so energetic that antimatter is created. There is also the comet coma to collide with. There is also the Rosetta spacecraft to collide with :eek:!
The result is enormous amounts of distinctive, easily detected radiation that was not been detected.

Insanity of stating the charge "bleeds off" which kills his electric comet delusions. His delusion of electric magic reducing in situ mass measurements is debunked. His delusion of jets being electrical discharges is debunked.

The other electric comet insanity that they do not mention is that before the in situ measurement of the mass of 67P, the orbit of 67P had already told us its mass.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom