Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
An insult and an insane lie about a paper being on EDM

None needed
Replies to 22 June 2018: An insane EDM lie.
With
22 June 2018: An insult and an insane lie about a paper being on EDM.
Insane because he has a quote clearly not about EDM because there are no electrical discharges :jaw-dropp.

Electrostatic disruption of a charged conducting spheroid by Jay Roderick Hill and , D. A. Mendis
  • Published in 1981 and only cited 19 times.
  • Grains, not his delusion of solid rock.
  • Electrostatic forces (electrical discharges are very not static).
  • Possibly not on the surface.
 
Lying "Asteroid–comet continuum" citation to derail from his many comet delusions

22 Jun 2018: Lying "Asteroid–comet continuum" citation to derail from his many comet delusions.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system by Henry H. Hsieh
Dormant and Extinct Comets explains that dormant or extinct comets are caused by ices not sublimating and gives several reasons.
Main-Belt Comets have "apparently sublimation-driven activity" and then explains the evidence for water and sublimation-driven dust emission.
Disrupted Asteroids is that some main belt "comets" look like the result of impacts or rotation disruption events creating dust emission events.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Like tusenfem said, boring terminator orbits did not lend themselves well to observing this layer with high resolution.

Actually, I said nothing of the kind, to quote myself:

Rosetta's velocity was just fine, it was only the continuous terminator orbits that made it a little "boring"

Again having trouble with your comprehensive reading during you electric breakfast?
 
Please enlighten us in full detail how different mass leads to charge separation?



I am in the real science camp

Like on the Moon, Asteroids...comets

Slide titled WIND Summary: Replenishment of the Wake is interesting in the context of comet tails!
 
Last edited:
Oh brother, he learned a new word.

so we are all on the same page!

I've been using FAC, Birkeland Currents, double layers....etc for awhile now. 9 odd years.

So if we all them kinetic plasma effects we'll all read from the same book. :thumbsup:
 
Why don't you use the search function? Tusenfem has already told you this. You just keep repeating the same inane crap, over and over. Sorry, but scientifically impossible woo is not suddenly going to become possible just because you want it to.


So yes?
 

No.

Ahhhhh the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE!

Which doesn't exist as far as real science is concerned. And is a science-free zone.

though in the context I was talking about it's charge separation of the solar wind!

Doesn't matter. It ain't happening. Besides, where is the solar wind around perihelion, when the most interesting stuff is happening? All you've got to play with within a minimum of 1500 km of the action, is overwhelmingly neutrals, and a small percentage of water ions. What do you want them to do? Spell it out.
 
Right, so let's try and salvage this dreadful, unscientific mess that is the electric comet.

So, we have the solar wind. It encounters a comet. Somehow the electrons and ions in the SW get separated. In a medium with a Debye length of ~ 10m. This causes currents. We can't measure them over two years, but they just are. Then they do..... something.....probably involving invisible double layers, and this causes electric woo at the surface. Which remains undetected. This electric woo causes O- to be ejected from the comet. Which remains undetectable. This O- then somehow combines with H+ from the solar wind, to form water. And ice. Despite there being no O-, and nowhere near enough H+. This carries on even when the water is detected close to the nucleus, and the solar wind is not even close, and there still isn't any O-. And the water created has a very different D/H ratio to that of the SW H+.
All of the aforesaid happens because the comet is a rock which was blasted off a planet by some sort of Velikovskian interplanetary lightning bolt, involving Venus doing handbrake turns around the solar system. And despite the fact that there is no rock to be seen. It also, somehow, depends on the comet moving from areas of different charge, due to an undetectable radial electric field, causing it to be out of balance with the non-existent radial electric field as it approaches the Sun. Have I summed that up accurately, Sol88?

So, in summary, what's not to believe?:jaw-dropp
 
Right, so let's try and salvage this dreadful, unscientific mess that is the electric comet.

So, we have the solar wind. It encounters a comet. Somehow the electrons and ions in the SW get separated. In a medium with a Debye length of ~ 10m. This causes currents. We can't measure them over two years, but they just are. Then they do..... something.....probably involving invisible double layers, and this causes electric woo at the surface. Which remains undetected. This electric woo causes O- to be ejected from the comet. Which remains undetectable. This O- then somehow combines with H+ from the solar wind, to form water. And ice. Despite there being no O-, and nowhere near enough H+. This carries on even when the water is detected close to the nucleus, and the solar wind is not even close, and there still isn't any O-. And the water created has a very different D/H ratio to that of the SW H+.
All of the aforesaid happens because the comet is a rock which was blasted off a planet by some sort of Velikovskian interplanetary lightning bolt, involving Venus doing handbrake turns around the solar system. And despite the fact that there is no rock to be seen. It also, somehow, depends on the comet moving from areas of different charge, due to an undetectable radial electric field, causing it to be out of balance with the non-existent radial electric field as it approaches the Sun. Have I summed that up accurately, Sol88?

So, in summary, what's not to believe?:jaw-dropp

Thanks. There were some aspects of this nonsense that I had not realised: it's even worse than I thought.
 
The killer that Sol88 can never address is that there are asteroids in the asteroid belt that go through the same orbital area as the five that have comas because they are comets. There are tens in not hundreds taht go through the same spaces yet show no comas.

then there are objects that come from very deep space like Oumuamua, and long period rocky bodies. They never show comas either despite the fact there should all sorts of magic charge differential built up.
 
ALICE was never designed to search for these signatures ALICE—THE ULTRAVIOLET IMAGING SPECTROMETER ABOARD THE ROSETTA ORBITER D. C. Slater1, J. Scherrer1, J. Stone1, M. F. A’Hearn2, J. L. Bertaux3, P. D. Feldman4, and M. C. Festou5, and S. A.Stern5[/I] but it did find this "surprising" finding...



The effects of dust outbursts on the anomalistic features observed by Rosetta Alice around 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko John Noonana, Eric Schindhelma, Joel Wm. Parkera, Andrew Steffla, Michael Davisb, S. Alan Sterna, Zuni Levinc, Sascha Kempfc, and Mihaly Horanyic

And mainstream find it's a problem and need to mitigate it's intensity!! :boggled:

Kinetic plasma effects. Charge separation in action!

Now where did that dust from my breakfast end up one wonders?

And this is relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), how?
 
Like tusenfem said, boring terminator orbits did not lend themselves well to observing this layer with high resolution.

but

At Halley

Vega flew thru this

[qimg]http://i68.tinypic.com/5wku1x.jpg[/qimg]

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons at Comet Halley H.Laakso
And this is relevant to this thread - the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) - how, exactly?
 
None needed <snip>

Electrostatic disruption of a charged conducting spheroid Jay Roderick Hill and , D. A. Mendis



What is NEEDED are intense applied electric fields!!!
How "intense"? And how do these relate to the electric fields in the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)? Please be specific.

These will be found on the terminator between shadowed and sunlit areas!

And kinetic plasma effects make this more than a mere possibility!

The ELECTRIC COMET!!

Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rules 0/12. Insults clothed in sophistry are still insults.
Um, no. Just no.

You have agreed to at least an outline of a summary of some aspects of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), here. If you think that anything in this post (that I'm quoting) is consistent with even this outline of a summary, please be kind enough to show where and how. Please be specific and exact.

FWIW, I can see nothing - at a quantitative level - that is consistent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom