Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
And what - in detail - does this have to do with the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)?

FWIW, Henry Hsieh is very active in an on-line, Zooniverse-based, citizen scient project, Comet Hunters. Having been active in it some time ago, I think you'll be very disappointed if you take part, Sol88 ... despite all the hard work of all the citizen scientists, no new tailed-asteroids have been found: "Currently no we haven't found a comet, yet in the data." by the Comet Hunters PI, barely a month ago (link).
 
Answer me this if you can, why is this not a scientifically valid mechanism?

or

Just answer yes/no to the following simple question

Is there charge separation in the plasma's on/around a comet?
And how, prey tell, is this relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)? You know, what this thread is about?

Not in some hand-wavy fashion, but in detail. Preferably quantitatively.
 
Wow could you imagine the size of the electric currents when magnetic fields the size of Galaxies move past one another!!! Must be bloody huge!

Can't beat ampere's law! :D

Ahhhhh the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE!

though in the context I was talking about it's charge separation of the solar wind!
So this is an OT post?

You know, not actually relevant to the topic of this thread, the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).
 
so we are all on the same page!

I've been using FAC, Birkeland Currents, double layers....etc for awhile now. 9 odd years.
Really?

And these are relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), how, exactly?

So if we all them kinetic plasma effects we'll all read from the same book. :thumbsup:
Good luck in your attempt to re-write physics textbooks, Sol88.

In the meantime, please explain - in detail, preferably quantitatively - how this is relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)?
 
I see that Sol88 has not even attempted to answer any of your - highly pertinent - questions Indagator.

<snip>

Now your turn, Sol88! As the resident expert in the electric comet, please ...

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...
I'd like to have a go, based on my own reading of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), both here and at EU central. Also the Electric Sun idea/SAFIRE, as it's also central to this thread.

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
Per acolytes, no, never. Even when there are screamingly obvious, wild inconsistencies, no underlying principles are wrong.

02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
This is a bit more complicated, as EU zealots happily promote wildly inconsistent views of what physics "the electric star" (or Sun) is founded on. They sometimes get snarky with each other over these inconsistencies.

03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
...
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
...
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
...
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
... 20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No
Not relevant to this thread, sorry.

05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
Proponents of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) are extremely reluctant to answer this question! :jaw-dropp I don't think I've encountered an answer.

07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
For comets, and asteroids, yes. It plays a central role.

11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
Yes.

12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
No. Although I think there may be grudging acknowledgement that at least some asteroids may have dust on their surfaces.

13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
Yes.
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
No.

15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
Yes. But it has no relevance to comets (as far as I know).

16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
Yes. It's central. From here:

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, ~1 V to ~100 kV inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons
3ac) All comets are observed to be different, so one would expect 3aa and 3ab to change accordingly

3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance


19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
I can't answer for Sol88. However, from what I've read, the answer is no.
 
Stupid and irrelevant fantasy to derail from his many comet delusions

Wow could you imagine the size of the electric currents when magnetic fields the size of Galaxies move past one another!!!
25 June 2018: Stupid and irrelevant fantasy about galactic magnetic fields to derail from his many comet delusions.

The stupidity is
  • The size (volume!) of magnetic fields that creates the force on charged particle.
  • The minute strength of galactic magnetic fields automatically means strong electric currents.
  • Vagueness of galactic magnetic fields "moving past each other".
  • Continued stupidity about Debye length which make plasma in general act like neutral gas on galactic scales.
As explained in the article, it is moving charged particles in the galactic magnetic field that produce measurable effects (synchrotron emission).

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Usual lies about science (lunar wake) to derail from his many comet delusions

Slide titled WIND Summary: Replenishment of the Wake is interesting in the context of comet tails!
22 June 2018: Usual lies about science (lunar wake) to derail from his many comet delusions.

The presentation is "Lunar Wake as a Unique The Lunar Wake as a Unique Plasma Physics Laboratory". The Lunar wake is a feature of the solar wind as it is absorbed by the Moon leaving a "trailing low-density void or wake".

A comet tail is gases and dust emitted from a sublimating comet nucleus and producing a relatively dense cloud left behind ss the comet moves - thus the ion and dust tails. There is also interaction with the solar wind. Comet tails are the opposite of a low-density (lower than the solar wind) void :jaw-dropp!

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
And how, prey tell, is this relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)? You know, what this thread is about?

Not in some hand-wavy fashion, but in detail. Preferably quantitatively.

This is the crux of the whole argument.

Go ask any "expert" here on charge separation in space plasmas, see what they say.

Ask jd116, as tusenfem has only hinted at kinetic plasma effects!
 
And how, prey tell, is this relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)? You know, what this thread is about?

Not in some hand-wavy fashion, but in detail. Preferably quantitatively.
This is the crux of the whole argument.

Go ask any "expert" here on charge separation in space plasmas, see what they say.

Ask jd116, as tusenfem has only hinted at kinetic plasma effects!
Sol88, I'd like you to meet Sol88, the resident expert in the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

Here's the most recent version of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), as agreed to by Sol88 (link):

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
1d) the main minerals are silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron

2) the nucleus of a comet contains no ices for sublimation

2a) ices are in general Water, Carbon Dioxide and Carbon Monoxide
2b) the others volatiles are also solid, including oxygen

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, ~1 V to ~100 kV inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons
3ac) All comets are observed to be different, so one would expect 3aa and 3ab to change accordingly

3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)


No mention of "charge separation" whether in "space plasmas" or anywhere else. Yes, there are hints, e.g. "usually negatively charged" and "potential difference", but "the crux of the whole argument" is clearly:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

Maybe you should have an offline conversation with Sol88, to get the story straight? ;)
 
Kinetic effects are in essence the ELECTRIC COMET!
Not according to Sol88 ... see my last post.

For avoidance of doubt, the "essence the ELECTRIC COMET" is this:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.
 
Basically nine odd years of debating this very fact!

MHD is king! (maths is easier)

Except that's not reality! (maths is extremely complex and too scary)
 
And how - in quantitative detail - does this relate to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)? Not handwaving, details.
Kinetic effects are in essence the ELECTRIC COMET!
And even when you are asked to refrain from hand-waving, you present just just hand-waving, and no details.

Is it because hand-waving is in essence the ELECTRIC COMET?
 
Sol88, I'd like you to meet Sol88, the resident expert in the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

Here's the most recent version of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), as agreed to by Sol88 (link):

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
1d) the main minerals are silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron

2) the nucleus of a comet contains no ices for sublimation

2a) ices are in general Water, Carbon Dioxide and Carbon Monoxide
2b) the others volatiles are also solid, including oxygen

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, ~1 V to ~100 kV inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons
3ac) All comets are observed to be different, so one would expect 3aa and 3ab to change accordingly

3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)


No mention of "charge separation" whether in "space plasmas" or anywhere else. Yes, there are hints, e.g. "usually negatively charged" and "potential difference", but "the crux of the whole argument" is clearly:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

Maybe you should have an offline conversation with Sol88, to get the story straight? ;)

No mention of "charge separation" whether in "space plasmas" or anywhere else. Yes, there are hints, e.g. "usually negatively charged" and "potential difference", but "the crux of the whole argument" is clearly:

No that's the whole shebang right there!

The comets is a rock violating the quasi-neutrality of the solar plasma stream!

From that we get complex electric fields, double layers, beams or "jets", charged nano-dust, electric currents...kinetic plasma effects! :D

These applied electric fields on the surface of the comet, most commonly along the terminator but also the small scale terminators from over hangs, boulders, scarps, depressions..etc can be extremely intense this can cause electrostatic disruption of the surface rock releasing fine dust and trapped water from the hydrated minerals along with electrochemical reactions.

This released water vapour can form frost on the surface of the nucleus and ice in the coma. ;)

All of this is ONLY possible if there are kinetic plasma effects at comets...the ELECTRIC COMET!
 
Not according to Sol88 ... see my last post.

For avoidance of doubt, the "essence the ELECTRIC COMET" is this:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

May or may not be true!

Who knows!!

but we can measure kinetic plasma effects!
 
Right, so let's try and salvage this dreadful, unscientific mess that is the electric comet.

So, we have the solar wind. It encounters a comet. Somehow the electrons and ions in the SW get separated. In a medium with a Debye length of ~ 10m. This causes currents. We can't measure them over two years, but they just are. Then they do..... something.....probably involving invisible double layers, and this causes electric woo at the surface. Which remains undetected. This electric woo causes O- to be ejected from the comet. Which remains undetectable. This O- then somehow combines with H+ from the solar wind, to form water. And ice. Despite there being no O-, and nowhere near enough H+. This carries on even when the water is detected close to the nucleus, and the solar wind is not even close, and there still isn't any O-. And the water created has a very different D/H ratio to that of the SW H+.
All of the aforesaid happens because the comet is a rock which was blasted off a planet by some sort of Velikovskian interplanetary lightning bolt, involving Venus doing handbrake turns around the solar system. And despite the fact that there is no rock to be seen. It also, somehow, depends on the comet moving from areas of different charge, due to an undetectable radial electric field, causing it to be out of balance with the non-existent radial electric field as it approaches the Sun. Have I summed that up accurately, Sol88?

So, in summary, what's not to believe?:jaw-dropp


Right, so the story really goes like this:

Once upon a time long long ago, there was nothing. Then something happen and matter, mathematics and time come into existence. This was a tumultuous peroid with lots of complicated maths happening. After a long time the Universe become to be understood to be made up of 23% Dark matter with 72% dark energy! This left mankind with only 4% tangible matter!

This model involves the gas giants that do hand brake turns around the solar system are Nice model and the GrandTack Model.

The End
 
No mention of "charge separation" whether in "space plasmas" or anywhere else. Yes, there are hints, e.g. "usually negatively charged" and "potential difference", but "the crux of the whole argument" is clearly:

No that's the whole shebang right there!

The comets is a rock violating the quasi-neutrality of the solar plasma stream!

From that we get complex electric fields, double layers, beams or "jets", charged nano-dust, electric currents...kinetic plasma effects! :D

These applied electric fields on the surface of the comet, most commonly along the terminator but also the small scale terminators from over hangs, boulders, scarps, depressions..etc can be extremely intense this can cause electrostatic disruption of the surface rock releasing fine dust and trapped water from the hydrated minerals along with electrochemical reactions.

This released water vapour can form frost on the surface of the nucleus and ice in the coma. ;)

All of this is ONLY possible if there are kinetic plasma effects at comets...the ELECTRIC COMET!


And another non-answer! What electric fields? From Philae? Rosetta? At 0 metres? What surface rock? Zero evidence. What electrochemical reactions? How are you doing that? Lol. How is water turning into ice on the dayside? Too hot.
And, not to put too fine a point on it, you haven't got a clue what 'kinetic' means when it comes to plasma. Yes? So, we are still stuck with a scientifically impossible bunch of woo, with zero evidence to back it up. Correct? Yes, would be the answer to that.
Go away; learn some science.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom