Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88!

I make note of your obsessive need to cite mainstream peer-reviewed articles, claiming that they somehow support your electric comet model. If I understand correctly, your electric comet needs an electric star to operate! Where is the definitive peer-reviewed "eu" article on the electric sun? My research turns up no such paper! Why is there no peer-reviewed literature on your electric star? Are "eu scientists" unable to generate a stout, science based paper that would be worthy of my consideration? Or perhaps, only members of the religion (with a "small" donation, of course) get to learn about the real "mysteries" of the electric universe!

Mainstream scientists are not ever allowed in our 'lectric uvinerse "club houz!"

Sol88, my friend! As you appear to be unable or unwilling to answer my questions, would you be so kind as to talk to the folks at Thunderbolts (on my behalf, as I am certain they won't let someone like me into their "club houz"), and get them to send me copies of all "eu" publications and textbooks written to date, for my "scientific" consideration? On their dime! Of course! Thornhill and company can reach me here to discuss shipping instructions! And anything else that may come up in conversation!

It's very simple: Comets are rocks discharging in the solar wind....


A sad and pathetic statement really! No proof! No physical mechanism! No predictive model! Just words!

No wonder the "eu" can't get grants and funding for basic research! With unscientific statements like that ......

Sol88! Every time you post, you and the electric universe are being judged! Given your behaviour at ISF over the last 9+ years, what kind of impression do you think you've made for the world to see? What is more important to you, scientific truth? Or martyrdom?

As an aside, if your electric comet needs so much mainstream science, as is evident by your constant referencing of mainstream literature, why is there no predictive model? Almost a decade for you alone? And no mathematical model to share with the science community? THE ELECTRIC COMET IS AN EPIC FAILURE!

Now, why would anyone want to be associated with that?
 
again from tusenfem's paper:
ok understood but I asked for clarification on
What in laymens terms are the kinetic plasma effects that would be expected?

All kinds of kinetic instabilities that can repress the growth of the modified Ion Weibel instability..

I don't know why you're getting so prickly?

probably because you don't present any real stuff on electric comet, not even 1 pages of actual "electric "science"" has been written by any EC acolyte, and here you keep on telling "mainstream" that they are wrong

The link to Koenders, C., Glassmeier, K.-H., Richter, I., Ranocha, H., & Motschmann, U.2015, Planet. Space Sci., 105, 101 comes back with

Meh, A&A's problem/fault, not mine, and ADS is easily found.
 
From my original list of 20 questions (and there will be many more "electric" lists to follow), please recall ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No


To learn, we ask questions! To grow, we build on previously acquired knowledge! Have you, Sol88, learned anything on this forum? Have you learned anything from me?

Sol88!

Are you part of a fundamentalist "eu" religion? It is obvious from your commentary, and failure to answer my simple "Yes/No" questions that you are certainly not a part of anything resembling a science! You see, my first four questions were designed to gauge your level of fundamentalist beliefs with respect to the "eu" religion! Your earlier dismissive, "Good luck," indicates fundamentalist arrogance and a fear-filled unwillingness to engage! Pity! When I came to the ISF, you had an opportunity to turn on your "eu" charms and openly share your views! Perhaps even changing my mind on the electric universe (it could happen, though the burden of proof is extremely high -- it requires a predictive mathematical model). Instead, you chose to ignore! Deflect! Dismiss! Denigrate! Avoid! Obfuscate! The list is long and ugly! In my opinion (and I am sharing this for all current and future readers of this thread to consider and discuss), you exhibit many traits common to members of a fundamentalist religion. Thoughts?

To illustrate, an "eu scientist" would answer my questions thus, ...
01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... YES!
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... YES!
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... YES!
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... YES!

Evidence of an open mind and a willingness to be wrong in what they "study" .... Someone capable of engaging in a genuine debate! On the other hand, ...

An "eu fundamentalist" would answer my questions quite differently, ... if ever ...
01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... NO!
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... NO!
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... NO!
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... NO! NEVER!

Your avoidance could be indicative of fundamentalist behaviour. Are you part of a fundamentalist religion, my friend? There are science-minded people on this thread willing to help you escape .... Myself included!

To date, many learned individuals have answered your questions with the hopes of educating you! Unfortunately, they have failed! You do not learn! Because you ignore, or violently oppose information that is shared with the best of intentions, I would like to propose a fair and equitable discussion protocol here on the electric comet thread! I hope others will join me! I don't want Sol88 to hijack the "electric comet" thread with unnecessary mainstream discussions!

Sol88! You only get to ask one question when you answer a question!

Let's start here ....

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ...


Remember, Sol88, people are reading your responses! They want to learn about the electric comet! Don't let them down!
 
Last edited:
I might also ask for the

how does this finding fit with Identification of comet Hyakutake's
extremely long ion tail from magnetic field signatures
Geraint H. Jones*, Andre  Balogh* & Timothy S. Horbury

The two have nothing to do with eachother, what part of "the near tail region" don't you understand?

what's being violated? and why would the violations be unlikely?

Why highlight something, and then ask "what" ?
 
What type of structure does it have then, if not simple draped fields, tusenfem?

Complex draped fields?

Did you read the paper?
It has the deflection pattern as described by Koenders et al.

Even all the way back to and presumably well beyond 3.0 odd AU? Identification of comet Hyakutake's extremely long ion tail from magnetic field signatures Geraint H. Jones, Andre  Balogh & Timothy S. Horbury

No, how on earth can you come to such a conclusion. The two papers have nothing to do with each other, because Geraint's paper clearly shows expected magnetic field structure from "classical" draping.

Checked against what? do we have a model? other than the Electric Comet?

It would be nice if you had some scientific edumacation and if your reading comprehension would be a lot better.
We see something, but we don't have an explanation for it. Therefore, it would be nice to have a dedicated numerical simulation, which may or may not show us what is causing the helical wave.

Pity paints a more holistic picture, kinetic effects and all.

No, this was about the large scale structure, the details of current sheets etc. around 67P are discussed in other papers by me and colleagues of mine.

Ohh...kinetic plasma effects...what equations are more suited here, tusenfem?

yeah, whatever, as if you would understand them if I wrote them up. This is a scientific paper, addressed to my colleagues, who know how to interpret this statement.

That's very interesting!

Indeed, it is basic turbulence theory

It is a real pity along with the instruments time resolution.
Wow tails are REALLY BIG structures!!
[/qutoe]

Can't be that much of a surprise and I am sure you know the regular size of a cometary coma.

ELECTRIC CURRENT!!

Squirrel !!

Could be a frame of reference thing? The enormous differences in fly-by velocities of the spacecraft and their angle thru these current sheets, reckon we'll find in the data after a few more papers of current both going to and from a comet. Like in the Birkeland current model Don Scott ponied up a few years back now.

No it cannot be a "frame of reference thing", whatever that may mean in your language.
The velocity of the spacecraft is 3 m/s, the motion of the wave is ~130 m/s so there is no "enormous difference" and I have no idea what "current sheets" you are talking about. And field aligned current, for obvious reasons, cannot create a travelling helical wave, (homework assignment for Sol88, why is this obvious?).

Any way just a few observation from tusenfems paper.

Care to discuss?

All I need to say is in the paper, and the corrections to your misinterpretations of the content of my paper are above and in previous posts.
 
It's very simple: Comets are rocks discharging in the solar wind....
Loony tunes stuff again. No discharges. No rock. Please point us to the data for these impossible, invisible discharges, and the invisible rock that they are impossibly coming from. Indagator is right; you have nothing more than a scientifically illiterate, religious belief in this idiocy, and can't back it up with any evidence, nor science, because there is no evidence and no science. It is a fairy story concocted by idiots. And they have managed to con a handful of scientifically challenged dolts, such as yourself. Why on Earth would anybody give such nutjobs the time of day?
Go away, get an education, and stop polluting this board with utter inanities.
 
The single most dramatic prediction of the electric comet model is this: on close inspection a comet nucleus will reveal the well-defined effects of the electrical arcs that progressively etch away the surface and accelerate material into space.

Hahahahahahahahaha..............

oh-wait-you-were-serious.jpg
 
No it cannot be a "frame of reference thing", whatever that may mean in your language.
The velocity of the spacecraft is 3 m/s, the motion of the wave is ~130 m/s so there is no "enormous difference" and I have no idea what "current sheets" you are talking about. And field aligned current, for obvious reasons, cannot create a travelling helical wave, (homework assignment for Sol88, why is this obvious?).

Sorry my bad. I meant the Halley Amanda and Rosettas relative velocity and angle through the various plasma layers of 67P

Rosetta relative velocity to 67P is good for photos not as good for RPC.
 
Last edited:
Sorry my bad. I meant the Halley Amanda and Rosettas relative velocity and angle through the various plasma layers of 67P

Rosetta relative velocity to 67P is good for photos not as good for RPC.

Rosetta's velocity was just fine, it was only the continuous terminator orbits that made it a little "boring"
 
For anybody interested, the final batch of OSIRIS images of 67P has just been released.

https://imagearchives.esac.esa.int/index.php?/category/1

Just follow the links with the blue asterisk in the bottom right corner. Prizes available to anyone that finds EDM happening in any of the images :)

EDIT: I should have mentioned that these images include those taken as Rosetta approached the surface for its 'landing'.
 
Last edited:
Please enlighten us why that is important?

You coy old dog you!

Ok then...


Charge separation! The Electric Universe!!!:D

Any separation of charges around 67p, tusenfem?

Or are you in the reality check, jd116 camp?
 
Last edited:
Charged dust for breakfast this morning but it all got caught in an electric field!

Saw it leave the plate as a diffuse cloud before coming together into beams or jets and accelerating away!

Imagine my surprise!

Oh well back to frosty frakes for breakfast, nice and safe. I understand how frosty frakes taste.
 
Yup, EDM on the surface causing the fine dust, before accelerating the products away in colimated jets!

Also in those intense applied electric fields on the nucleus surface, electro-chemistry happens! We see this in the absolute zoo of organics observed on comets.

Hydrogen
Oxygen
Carbon

Majik!
 
Last edited:
We’ll dig thru a few more pictures and show the “short” between the surface and the sheath boundary (double layer).

These are some of the largest most explosive “jets” seen by OSIRIS. Would have been a real treat to have Rosetta or a cube sat down the tail at the time these events happened.

But I thought we are not allowed to use bunny pictures to prove a point?

Hence all the papers.
 
Yup, EDM on the surface causing the fine dust, before accelerating the products away in colimated jets!

Also in those intense applied electric fields on the nucleus surface, electro-chemistry happens! We see this in the absolute zoo of organics observed on comets.

Hydrogen
Oxygen
Carbon

Majik!

Total, unadulterated, unscientific crap. No wonder you believe the trash you believe! Lol.
 
Yup, EDM on the surface causing the fine dust, before accelerating the products away in colimated jets!

What EDM (lol)? Please show us the signature in the data that was collected over 2+ years from 0m to 1500 km.
What 'electrochemistry? How are you doing this woo?

We’ll dig thru a few more pictures and show the “short” between the surface and the sheath boundary (double layer).

What double layer? Please show its signature in the data collected over 2+ years.

Honestly, talk about deranged!
 
Last edited:
Yup, EDM on the surface causing the fine dust,..................

Tell us Sol - from your extensive knowledge of electric woo, what signature would be seen of this discharge by an instrument looking directly at it in FUV? Should it resemble the spectrum of reflected sunlight from dust?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom