Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
(1.9±1.1)×103kgm-3

Jt03 - (1.9±1.1)×103kgm-3

Yeah bloody things, tablet makes hard too!

Jt03 - (1.9±1.1)×103kgm-3

The measured masses and speeds of compact particles are in the range from 1010 to 3.9 x 107kg and from 0.3 to 12.2 ms1, respectively. The analysis of compact particle speeds versus cometocentric distance shows that in the dust acceleration region, the dust speed increases from 2.5 +- 0.8 ms1 at 10 km to 4.3 +- 0.9 ms1 at 30 km.

Can you please correctly format and clarify what these numbers are supposed to be? Maybe provide the sources if you already haven't? Thank you.
 
Updated version; there are two changes.

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−31c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
1d) the main minerals are silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, 1v to to 000’s Kv inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range 1v to 000’s v out to aphelion and the comet is receiving electrons
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)
 
Last edited:
Keeping track of my questions etc to Sol88, about the ELECTRIC COMET model (as described in this thread, with Sol88's explicit OK). And whether they've been answered or not.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT01 (source):
Observationally (or, if you prefer, empirically), comets are fuzzy/tailed things in the sky which move (relative to the stars). Interestingly, the term is used for an object which may exhibit a coma ("fuzz") or tail(s) only some of the time, e.g. Main Belt Comets (or at least some of them).

As written, the ELECTRIC COMET model is at least somewhat ambiguous: does "comet" refer to what we have, historically, observed (and may observe in future)?
Is it a "theoretical" concept, as such not directly related to what we may (or may not) observe?
Something else?


This question has not yet received a response from Sol88.
Sol88 has responded twice, here and here. No answer yet.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT02 (source):
1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
What are the main minerals or mineraloids which comprise the rock?

Sol88's answer is here. However, it is unsatisfactory in a key aspect; I asked (source):
I was not aware that aluminium and magnesium were minerals, much less high temperature ones. Are these definitions part of the ELECTRIC COMET model? Or perhaps derived from some broader ELECTRIC UNIVERSE idea?

Sol88 has yet to answer (there is a response, but not an answer). Sol88 posted an answer, sorta, here and here.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT03 (source):
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
Is this what you intended? I can make no sense of "×103kgm−3". Is this some special ELECTRIC COMET model terminology or units? Would you please clarify?

Sol88 has answered, here.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT04 (source):
2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"
What, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, are "ice/s"?

Sol88 has yet to respond.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT05 (source):
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
What is the approximate SED (spectral energy density, you may know it by another name) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining?
Same question in a more simplified form: how does the power per unit frequency (or wavelength, if you prefer) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining vary with frequency (or wavelength)?


Sol88 has yet to respond.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT06 (source):
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance
My question asks about the electric field strength (a scalar) of this radial electric field, and is in two parts:
a) is it monotonic?
b) What, to an order of magnitude approximation, is the functional form of the field strength?
You may consider using "big O notation" in your answer; for example, where r is the radial distance, ~O(r), or ~O(asinh(r))


Sol88 has yet to respond.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

As Sol88 provides answers to my questions, I will update my summary of the ELECTRIC COMET model. From time to time.
 
I haven't seen Sol88 in last few days.

Normally I'd wait before asking any more questions about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), as approved by Sol88, but I'll likely have only limited online access for the next few days myself. So I'll ask just one more question, before stopping completely, to wait for Sol88 to return (and answer at least some of the ~five open questions).

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
JT07:
3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, 1v to to 000’s Kv inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range 1v to 000’s v out to aphelion and the comet is receiving electrons


Could you clarify please, Sol88?

Specifically:
* by "v" do you mean volt (the usual symbol for which is V)?
* by "Kv" do you mean kilovolts (the usual symbol for which is kV)?
* by "000’s Kv" do you mean something like "one to a few megavolts"?
* you use "nucleus" (3aa) and "comet" (3ab); why the distinction?
* specifically, does the comet discharge electrons inbound to perihelion?
* and does the nucleus receive electrons out to aphelion?
* lastly, are 3aa) and 3ab) both true for all comets? If not, please explain
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 
Sorry, been away a few days.

I believe ft1-3 have been answered.

I can clarify jt04 -

“ices”, there are NONE required in the ELECTRIC COMET model. These would also be the REQUIRED “ice/s” for the dirtysnowball model. ATM I believe the general consensus is the “ice/s” are subsurface. We do however observe fleeting frost patches.

The water and carbon dioxide, as the main ions we detect coming off the nucleus, may not necessarily come from parent “ice/s”.
 
Last edited:
Jt05-

I believe it should be broadband.

We should detect it in ALICE, RPC, RSI and GIADA’s data but all we see is anomalies compared to the modeled dirtysnowball.
 
Last edited:
Jt06-

Not sure if I can give you any figures here but seems comets are REALLY good solar probes.

‘Sides prolly more an ELECTRIC SUN type question.
 
Jt07-

Comets are in general parlance, the whole shebang. Coma, tail, nucleus and all.

The nucleus is specific. It’s the rocky body.

As for units 100’s of thousands of volts potential difference, peaking sometime around perihelion, and/or the nucleus gets clobbered good ‘n proper by a CME.

At some point in its orbit the nucleus will obtain charge equilibrium with the surrounding plasma before moving into a region of a lower potential and slowing down wrt the Sun, “pilfering” electrons back from the solar wind, ready for the next swing round.
 
Last edited:
So I hope those answers clarify the questions you asked, jean tate?

Please feel free to seek further clarification if you deem necessary.
 
Sorry, been away a few days.

I believe ft1-3 have been answered.
Yes, it has.

As I already noted.

I can clarify jt04 -

“ices”, there are NONE required in the ELECTRIC COMET model. These would also be the REQUIRED “ice/s” for the dirtysnowball model. ATM I believe the general consensus is the “ice/s” are subsurface. We do however observe fleeting frost patches.

The water and carbon dioxide, as the main ions we detect coming off the nucleus, may not necessarily come from parent “ice/s”.
As I'm sure you now know, this is not an answer to JT04.

Here's the question again: What, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, are "ice/s"?

By convention, when you put something in quotes, you are indicating that the usual meaning of the word(s) does not apply; specifically, you have a special meaning. In this case, my impression is that you mean something like "substances other than frozen water (ice), or solid CO2". This is especially important, because the ELECTRIC COMET model seems to include a lot of non-standard terms (e.g. "v" for volts, instead of "V"), and very likely some non-standard chemistry and physics too (I'll get to that later, maybe around JT50?).

So, What, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, are "ice/s"?
 
Jt05-

I believe it should be broadband.

<snip>
What, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, does "broadband" mean?

Specifically, how does it, in any way, answer JT05?

Here's that question again:

1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm

What is the approximate SED (spectral energy density, you may know it by another name) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining?

Same question in a more simplified form: how does the power per unit frequency (or wavelength, if you prefer) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining vary with frequency (or wavelength)?
 
Jt06-

Not sure if I can give you any figures here but seems comets are REALLY good solar probes.

‘Sides prolly more an ELECTRIC SUN type question.
First, I did not ask for any "figures". If you don't understand the question, I'd be happy to try to clarify.

Here's JT06 again:

4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

My question asks about the electric field strength (a scalar) of this radial electric field, and is in two parts:
a) is it monotonic?
b) What, to an order of magnitude approximation, is the functional form of the field strength?

You may consider using "big O notation" in your answer; for example, where r is the radial distance, ~O(r), or ~O(asinh(r))
 
Jt07-

Comets are in general parlance, the whole shebang. Coma, tail, nucleus and all.

The nucleus is specific. It’s the rocky body.

As for units 100’s of thousands of volts potential difference, peaking sometime around perihelion, and/or the nucleus gets clobbered good ‘n proper by a CME.

At some point in its orbit the nucleus will obtain charge equilibrium with the surrounding plasma before moving into a region of a lower potential and slowing down wrt the Sun, “pilfering” electrons back from the solar wind, ready for the next swing round.
Thanks.

So this part of the ELECTRIC COMET model should read something like this (changes hilited)?

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, ~1 V to ~100 kV inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons


Also, you did not answer this part:

Lastly, are 3aa) and 3ab) both true for all comets? If not, please explain.
 
Snappy tracker updated:

Number of JT questions (all "so far"; all with "by Sol88, and with respect to the ELECTRIC COMET model, as approved by Sol88"):

1) Answered fully: 1 (JT03)
2) Answered partly: 2 (JT02 and JT07)
3) Responded to: 7 (i.e. 4 were responded to, but either "question denied" (JT01), or the response was not answer (JT04, JT05, JT06))
4) Asked: 7
 
Last edited:
All: I will likely not be able to post anything here until Wednesday (at the earliest) or Saturday (most likely).

If Sol88 responds to any of my open questions - especially JT04, JT05, or JT06 - feel free to add further clarifications on what the questions are actually asking (I'm confident all of you have a pretty good idea of what the questions actually are).

Also, why not ask Sol88 your own questions, on the ELECTRIC COMET model (as approved by Sol88)? I have found Sol88's responses quite enlightening (though perhaps not in a way that Sol88 himself would be happy about).
 
All: I will likely not be able to post anything here until Wednesday (at the earliest) or Saturday (most likely).

If Sol88 responds to any of my open questions - especially JT04, JT05, or JT06 - feel free to add further clarifications on what the questions are actually asking (I'm confident all of you have a pretty good idea of what the questions actually are).

Also, why not ask Sol88 your own questions, on the ELECTRIC COMET model (as approved by Sol88)? I have found Sol88's responses quite enlightening (though perhaps not in a way that Sol88 himself would be happy about).

JT04 (source):
2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"
What, in the ELECTRIC COMET model, are "ice/s"?

It's a Non Sequitur.

In the electric comet "ice/s" are not required. They ARE REQUIRED for the dirtysnowball.

i.e. the nucleus is are not made from "ice/s" but from meteoric material, ROCK.

i know this is very hard to understand jean tate.
 
JT05 (source):
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
What is the approximate SED (spectral energy density, you may know it by another name) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining?
Same question in a more simplified form: how does the power per unit frequency (or wavelength, if you prefer) of the electromagnetic radiation emitted during (or by) this process of electrostatic machining vary with frequency (or wavelength)?

Sorry, I thought my answer was appropriate. maybe I'm not understanding your question correctly. Are you able to rephrase?
 
Thanks.

So this part of the ELECTRIC COMET model should read something like this (changes hilited)?

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, ~1 V to ~100 kV inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons


Also, you did not answer this part:

Lastly, are 3aa) and 3ab) both true for all comets? If not, please explain.

All comets are observed to be different, so one would expect 3aa and 3ab to change accordingly.
 
A question for you jean tate, let call it s01

s01 - Is your understanding of cometary "jets" the same as the widely held belief as stated by wiki?
Jets
Gas and snow jets of 103P/Hartley

Uneven heating can cause newly generated gases to break out of a weak spot on the surface of comet's nucleus, like a geyser.[68] These streams of gas and dust can cause the nucleus to spin, and even split apart.[68] In 2010 it was revealed dry ice (frozen carbon dioxide) can power jets of material flowing out of a comet nucleus.[69] Infrared imaging of Hartley 2 shows such jets exiting and carrying with it dust grains into the coma.[70]

WIKI

or

HERE

maybe HERE as well.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom