Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you think the dirtysnowball model of comets still holds, jean tate?

Mainstream is RONG! THEREFORE
a new model is REQUIRED.

Let’s see what pans out, ay sport?
 
Last edited:
The premise is

Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no “ice/s”, seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!

That’s it...the ELECTRIC COMET!!!
 
Last edited:
How much surface “ice” did you say there was, jean Tate?

Must of missed that post.
You didn't.

I had an awakening, when I read that two threads had been merged. Yeah, I'm slow (I put it down to my age); I should have realized that this thread is not, in any way, about any "mainstream" model (of comets, or the Sun); rather it is entirely about "The Electric Comet Theory" and SAFIRE.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to make this explicit.

Now, do you have any sources on "The Electric Comet Theory"?

If so, please cite them; if not please say so.
 
Do you think the dirtysnowball model of comets still holds, jean tate?
Maybe, maybe not.

a new model is REQUIRED.

Perhaps.

If so, let's have a discussion about it, shall we?

However, this is not the thread to hold such a discussion.

Why not?

Because this thread is devoted to "The Electric Comet Theory" and SAFIRE.

So, do you have any sources on "The Electric Comet Theory"?

If so, please cite them; if not please say so.

Let’s see what pans out, ay sport?

I agree.

Let's start by you citing any sources you know of, on "The Electric Comet Theory", shall we?
 
The premise is

Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no “ice/s”, seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!

That’s it...the ELECTRIC COMET!!!
Thank you.

It seems that you are using the word "theory" to mean something like "a wild-ass guess, or speculation, based on hunches; the sort of thing you yammer about with some mates down at the pub, especially after you've sunk a few cold ones" - right?

But, to be clear, if this is "The Electric Comet Theory", what does it have to do with SAFIRE?

(Assuming that you confirm that what I quoted is, indeed, "The Electric Comet Theory", I welcome the opportunity to discuss, and critique, it.)
 
The premise is

Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no “ice/s”, seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!

That’s it...the ELECTRIC COMET!!!


Thanks for restating your claim for the 495th time. Now how about presenting, as requested, sources supporting it?

Wait, I hear a faint sound in the distance! It sounds like...chirping :(
 
Jean Tate, Fred burfle you do mean peer reviewed by a respectable publisher, don’t you? With math and graphs and all that jazz yeah?1
 
Last edited:
Thank you.

It seems that you are using the word "theory" to mean something like "a wild-ass guess, or speculation, based on hunches; the sort of thing you yammer about with some mates down at the pub, especially after you've sunk a few cold ones" - right?

But, to be clear, if this is "The Electric Comet Theory", what does it have to do with SAFIRE?

(Assuming that you confirm that what I quoted is, indeed, "The Electric Comet Theory", I welcome the opportunity to discuss, and critique, it.)

SAFIRE are in the lab doing empirical science, not theoretical math, that the Sun(and all stars) are not powered by internal fusion but externally, this is the premise of the ELECTRIC SUN.

The ELECTRIC COMET requires an ELECTRIC SUN...

and the way I see it either one will prove the other correct.

:jaw-dropp
 
Good question, Sol88.
Jean Tate, Fred burfle you do mean peer reviewed in a respectable publisher, don’t you? With math and graphs and all that jazz yeah?1
I can't speak for ferd (not Fred), but yeah, that would be ideal.

However, at the moment all we have (I think) is just three lines, written by you:

"The premise is

Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no “ice/s”, seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!

That’s it...the ELECTRIC COMET!!!
"

If that's all there is, or all you're prepared to discuss, fine. Then please say so, explicitly and unambiguously.

If, however, you are using as your source some document(s) (in the public domain), say by an/some "electric theorist(s)", then please cite it/them (and tell us where it/they may be found, preferably with a link(s)).
 
Thank you Sol88.
SAFIRE are in the lab doing empirical science, not theoretical math, that the Sun(and all stars) are not powered by internal fusion but externally, this is the premise of the ELECTRIC SUN.

The ELECTRIC COMET requires an ELECTRIC SUN...

and the way I see it either one will prove the other correct.

:jaw-dropp
Waiting for you to clarify what you mean by "ELECTRIC COMET".

Now that you've introduced "ELECTRIC SUN", I have - of course - the same set of questions: what source(s) can you cite? If all there is is "that the Sun(and all stars) are not powered by internal fusion but externally", then please say so explicitly and unambiguously.

Thanks mate.

Once you've answered that, I may have further questions concerning how one "requires" the other ...
 
The mods were kind enough to merge the SAFIRE thread into this one but the ELECTRIC SUN has it’s own thread going.

So, I’ll jsut stick with the ELECTRIC COMET in this thread.

With just the premise of a rock discharging in the solar wind and using standard well known plasma physics there may be another far more viable model than Whipple 60 odd yr model.

This model is call the ELECTRIC COMET.

Would you jean Tate be prepared to explore this alternate possibility?
 
Last edited:
@jean Tate

Are you comfortable with basic plasma theory?

E.g ions, electrons, electric fields and magnetic fields for simple starters?
 
Thank you Sol88.

Waiting for you to clarify what you mean by "ELECTRIC COMET".

Now that you've introduced "ELECTRIC SUN", I have - of course - the same set of questions: what source(s) can you cite? If all there is is "that the Sun(and all stars) are not powered by internal fusion but externally", then please say so explicitly and unambiguously.

Thanks mate.

Once you've answered that, I may have further questions concerning how one "requires" the other ...

Again “respectable” peer reviewed papers?

Yes, the Sun is externally powered.
 
Thanks for restating your claim for the 495th time. Now how about presenting, as requested, sources supporting it?

Wait, I hear a faint sound in the distance! It sounds like...chirping :(

Like the paper “A Complete Theory of the Electric Comet”?
 
The mods were kind enough to merge the SAFIRE thread into this one but the ELECTRIC SUN has it’s own thread going.

So, I’ll jsut stick with the ELECTRIC COMET in this thread.
Thanks Sol88.

Just to be 100% clear: we can put SAFIRE aside, at least for now, at least in this thread?

With just the premise of a rock discharging in the solar wind and using standard well known plasma physics there may be another far more viable model than Whipple 60 odd yr model.

This model is call the ELECTRIC COMET.
So, no external sources you want to cite?

Fine. Here's what we have so far (please correct anything that is inaccurate or wrong; please add anything that is missing):

The ELECTRIC COMET model is as follows:
1) comets are rocky objects
2) they have minimal to no "ice/s"
3) they seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma
4) they are discharging in the solar wind.


Would you jean Tate be prepared to explore this alternate possibility?

I am more than happy to discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model as I have summarized it (caveat: pending any amendments etc you wish to make). I will do so from what I consider to be a science-based approach. I will not discuss anything else: no other models, no ELECTRIC SUN, etc.

In fact, let me start by asking you for some clarifications:

a) the Moon is a rocky object, with minimal to no "ice/s"; yet we do not call it a comet, how come?
b) ditto for Mercury, Venus, Mars, Phobos, Deimos, and (most) asteroids
c) while there certainly are rocks on the Moon, much - perhaps nearly - all its surface is actually dust. Less certainly, the surfaces of Eros and Itokawa seem similar in the sense that there may be few, if any, rocks not covered by dust (and much of the surfaces of both may be quite deep dust). So, clarification question: what do you mean by "rocky"?
 
@jean Tate

Are you comfortable with basic plasma theory?

E.g ions, electrons, electric fields and magnetic fields for simple starters?
I'm comfortable discussing the ELECTRIC COMET model as you have presented it so far.
 
Last edited:
Ah right, I get it! Thanks for being so explicit. :thumbsup:

You are, in fact, not discussing "The Electric Comet Theory" (or SAFIRE) at all. :jaw-dropp

Rather, you are relying (entirely?) on a false dichotomy.

Yes?

Bit confused by this statement jean Tate perhaps you maybe able to help.

Are you able to make a list with all the viable cometary models presented AFTER Whipples icy conglomerate model (the dirtysnowball).

As I really only have knowledge of Whipples model and the Electric comet model.

So are there any other viable models of comets you know of?

Perhaps we could discuss them in this thread.

If there is no other viable model(mainstream) peer reviewed Yada yada yada and the electric comet is our (crackpot pseudo-science) model and whipples model is wrong, is that still a false dichotomy?
 
A Whipple assumed lie about a "Whipple's Comet Model" paper

23 April 2018: A Whipple assumed lie about a "Whipple's Comet Model" paper.

That 1999 commentary paper has Whipple in a 1950 paper demonstrating that ices sublimating could explain the acceleration of Comet Encke. Followed by 3 more papers that established the basis of the working comet, modern model. Some improvements are noted, e.g. from the entire surface producing activity to more observations showing that many comets have a small % of their surface active.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom