Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A "All double layers are electric fields" lie

All double layers are electric fields.
20 April 2018: A "All double layers are electric fields" lie when replying to a "ambipolar electric field" post.

For others:
Double layers have electric fields produced by separated layers of charges in plasma..
Ambipolar electric fields are the electric fields produced by not "separated layers" of charges in plasma. Ambipolar diffusion means that electrons diffuse with different velocities then ions, volumes of positive charge density can be left behind and thus electric fields.
 
Last edited:
Thanks.

Just so that I'm quite clear on this: you mean what Whipple proposed in his 1950 ApJ paper (ADS link)?

As a matter of curiosity, have you read that paper? If so, how well would you say that you understood it?

Yes, i’ve read the paper and understand it well.

Do you think Whipples model still holds?
 
A dumb question showing his inability to read and understand science

Is this correct tusenfem?
20 April 2018: A dumb question showing his inability to read and understand science.
I give the definition of double layers and a couple of references to ambipolar electric fields and he cannot understand that they do not have the same source of electric fields (layers versus volumes)!
 
20 April 2018: A dumb question showing his inability to read and understand science.
I give the definition of double layers and a couple of references to ambipolar electric fields and he cannot understand that they do not have the same source of electric fields (layers versus volumes)!

That’s great! We now have a new plasma expert I can ask questions of with out having to annoy tusenfem all the time.

So do the double layers found at Halley fill your criteria for double layers, rc?

As found by Laakso in Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley
 
Not necessarily but that they are NOT dirtysnowballs any more either as stated here (again):

And?

The relatively simple concept which you have failed for years to grasp is that disproving one model doesn't prove your alternative. You still need evidence in favor of your model. And you don't have that.

The internal structure of comets isn't exactly what people once thought, though that isn't shocking since we had never previously studied one up close. But we've known for a very long time, and these recent probes only confirm, that comets have a gas tail created by sublimating ices. We also know from these recent probes that they have low mass densities. These facts are incompatible with your model. Comets cannot be rocks blasted off the earth by lightning from Venus, because they aren't made of rock.

The standard model of comets will be adjusted and refined as we gather more data with greater detail and precision. But none of it will make your model correct. We already know it's wrong, because we already have enough data to prove it's wrong. It won't magically stop being wrong.
 
And?

The relatively simple concept which you have failed for years to grasp is that disproving one model doesn't prove your alternative. You still need evidence in favor of your model. And you don't have that.

The internal structure of comets isn't exactly what people once thought, though that isn't shocking since we had never previously studied one up close. But we've known for a very long time, and these recent probes only confirm, that comets have a gas tail created by sublimating ices. We also know from these recent probes that they have low mass densities. These facts are incompatible with your model. Comets cannot be rocks blasted off the earth by lightning from Venus, because they aren't made of rock.

The standard model of comets will be adjusted and refined as we gather more data with greater detail and precision. But none of it will make your model correct. We already know it's wrong, because we already have enough data to prove it's wrong. It won't magically stop being wrong.

Ok, I agree some what but...

NEW mainstream model coming up.

Leaning to be more non-volatile (dusty, organics, consolidated) than volatile (icy).

Plasma plays a dominate role.

Way I see it, if Whipple’s model was not used as the basis for designing the Philea lander capture/restraining system and had, at least, the data from the MUPUS-PEN before hand for the designers...hindsight now.

Deal’d be done. :D

Anywhoo, we prod along with establishing the previously unexpected and somewhat surprising findings from the RPC team.

Hold in there, we are nearly down to the surface. Presently at the “diamagnetic cavity’s” double layer, the one directly above the nucleus.
 
Last edited:
Your paper “A Tail Like No Other” will be an interesting new piece of the pie wrt what we have observed closer to the nucleus.

I’m very much looking forward to it being published so we can start fitting the pieces together.

You know the bigger picture.
 
Yes, i’ve read the paper and understand it well.
Cool! :)
Do you think Whipples model still holds?
Hmm ... not really sure what you mean by "holds", but judging by the large number of citations to the 1950 paper in the last decade or two, I'd say that at least some aspects of the "model" (why the scare quotes? I'm not sure you're using the word in the same way I would, or as would the authors of the >500 papers which cite Wipple's) are still quite useful today.

Anyway, I think Ziggurat's recent post is highly pertinent ...
 
Ok, I agree some what but...

NEW mainstream model coming up.

Leaning to be more non-volatile (dusty, organics, consolidated) than volatile (icy).

That may vary from comet to comet, and will obviously change over the comet's lifetime.

Plasma plays a dominate role.

What does this mean? Their orbits are not dominated by plasma, but by gravity. Heating isn't dominated by plasma, but by ordinary light from the sun. Sublimation isn't some weird plasma effect, it's ordinary thermodynamic phase change. So what, exactly, is dominated by plasma?

The gas tail of a comet will exhibit plasma effects, but this has been known for a long time from spectroscopy. I'm sure there's lots to discover about the details, but that requires data, and the EU folks aren't any help in this regard. Nor do these plasma effects support the EU comet theories over mainstream ones.

Anywhoo, we prod along with establishing the previously unexpected and somewhat surprising findings from the RPC team.

Some of the findings are unexpected. Lots of them are not. Most of the focus is on the unexpected findings rather than the expected ones because, well, duh.

And frankly, if you don't have any unexpected findings, the mission was probably a waste.
 
Cool! :)

Hmm ... not really sure what you mean by "holds", but judging by the large number of citations to the 1950 paper in the last decade or two, I'd say that at least some aspects of the "model" (why the scare quotes? I'm not sure you're using the word in the same way I would, or as would the authors of the >500 papers which cite Wipple's) are still quite useful today.

Anyway, I think Ziggurat's recent post is highly pertinent ...

From your understanding of Whipples paper, jean tate and the data returned from the majority of missions to comet nuclei to date, would it be fair to say the majority of ice is of the subsurface type?

I.e under some form of non volitile refractory/organic’s layer?
 
That may vary from comet to comet, and will obviously change over the comet's lifetime.



What does this mean? Their orbits are not dominated by plasma, but by gravity. Heating isn't dominated by plasma, but by ordinary light from the sun. Sublimation isn't some weird plasma effect, it's ordinary thermodynamic phase change. [b[So what, exactly, is dominated by plasma?[/b]

The gas tail of a comet will exhibit plasma effects, but this has been known for a long time from spectroscopy. I'm sure there's lots to discover about the details, but that requires data, and the EU folks aren't any help in this regard. Nor do these plasma effects support the EU comet theories over mainstream ones.



Some of the findings are unexpected. Lots of them are not. Most of the focus is on the unexpected findings rather than the expected ones because, well, duh.

And frankly, if you don't have any unexpected findings, the mission was probably a waste.

Ummmm.....those “plasma effects” comprise electrical circuits not just “local” to the nucleus! Like in the ELECTRIC COMET

If we start adding up some of the spatial scales involved including the data from Ulysses, Vega 1-2, and Rosetta...

No doubt gravity/mass/momentum is at play here but the very paper jean tate referenced above is comets don’t all ways play the gravity game nicely. And it’s pretty clear from the data returned the “little rockets” (cometary “jets”) have no cards in the game.
 
Last edited:
That may vary from comet to comet, and will obviously change over the comet's lifetime.



What does this mean? Their orbits are not dominated by plasma, but by gravity. Heating isn't dominated by plasma, but by ordinary light from the sun Sublimation isn't some weird plasma effect, it's ordinary thermodynamic phase change. So what, exactly, is dominated by plasma?

The gas tail of a comet will exhibit plasma effects, but this has been known for a long time from spectroscopy. I'm sure there's lots to discover about the details, but that requires data, and the EU folks aren't any help in this regard. Nor do these plasma effects support the EU comet theories over mainstream ones.



Some of the findings are unexpected. Lots of them are not. Most of the focus is on the unexpected findings rather than the expected ones because, well, duh.

And frankly, if you don't have any unexpected findings, the mission was probably a waste.

Infrared heat, the only tool in your kit to tinker on Whipples sublimation model!

Far more than good ‘ol sunlight going on with comets and the Sun! :)
 
Last edited:
From your understanding of Whipples paper, jean tate and the data returned from the majority of missions to comet nuclei to date, would it be fair to say the majority of ice is of the subsurface type?

I.e under some form of non volitile refractory/organic’s layer?
Really interesting question, Sol88! :)

Let's make sure we're on the same page, OK?

"the majority of missions to comet nuclei to date" - Rosetta and 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, sure. What other missions, and comets, did you have in mind?

"the majority of ice is of the subsurface type" - "majority": By mass? volume? something else? "ice": as in H2O? or all ices, which would include CO2? something else?

"of the subsurface type" - gonna need help here! Ice is ice (unless you're referring to things like crystalline, amorphous, etc; are you?), so maybe you mean ~is not within {some distance} of the surface?

"under some form of non volitile refractory/organic’s layer" - that seems to make the "subsurface" term clearer (I assume "volitile" is a typo, you mean "volatile", right?) But ... is a film of ~a few molecules' thickness such a layer? or does it have to be, say, ~100m?

Oh, and why is Whipple's paper relevant?
 
Ummmm.....those “plasma effects” comprise electrical circuits not just “local” to the nucleus!

So what? Their spatial extent may be huge (depending on what you want to include), but that's hardly the only measure of their importance, is it?

No doubt gravity/mass/momentum is at play here but the very paper jean tate referenced above is comets don’t all ways play the gravity game nicely.

Yeah, who would have thought that ejecting gas could push an object in space?

And it’s pretty clear from the data returned the “little rockets” (cometary “jets”) have no cards in the game.

I don't believe you.
 
Infrared heat, the only tool in your kit to tinker on Whipples sublimation model!

Far more than good ‘ol sunlight going on with comets and the Sun! :)

Why would I be stuck with only Whipple's 1950 paper? That makes no sense.

But even in regards to that paper, you're confused. The full spectrum of light coming from the sun acts to heat the surface of the comet, not just infrared light. It's the subsequent transfer of heat from the surface to the interior which relies upon infrared radiation, since the surface isn't hot enough to radiate in the visible or above.
 
Really interesting question, Sol88! :)

Let's make sure we're on the same page, OK?

"the majority of missions to comet nuclei to date" - Rosetta and 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, sure. What other missions, and comets, did you have in mind?

"the majority of ice is of the subsurface type" - "majority": By mass? volume? something else? "ice": as in H2O? or all ices, which would include CO2? something else?

"of the subsurface type" - gonna need help here! Ice is ice (unless you're referring to things like crystalline, amorphous, etc; are you?), so maybe you mean ~is not within {some distance} of the surface?

"under some form of non volitile refractory/organic’s layer" - that seems to make the "subsurface" term clearer (I assume "volitile" is a typo, you mean "volatile", right?) But ... is a film of ~a few molecules' thickness such a layer? or does it have to be, say, ~100m?

Oh, and why is Whipple's paper relevant?

Ok, we’ll narrow the scope. What was the percentage of surface ice on 67P?

Yada Yada yada....

Therfore all the rest of the “ice” required of whipples model is subsurface. Under some form of consolidated non-volatile/organicly layer and ,at least visually, the consolidated “stuff” is very rocky like, so we could call it rock?


CQTQVQ
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom