Bit confused by this statement jean Tate perhaps you maybe able to help.
I'll certainly try.
Are you able to make a list with all the viable cometary models presented AFTER Whipples icy conglomerate model (the dirtysnowball).
This is a field of astronomy/space science about which I know very little, so take the following with a grain of salt.
Since 1950, what Whipple presented in his paper has been a basis for many different models. And since spacecraft started flying near comets, many new models have been published, with scopes that go beyond Whipple's, and some which are quite narrow in scope.
As I really only have knowledge of Whipples model and the Electric comet model.
Have you heard the expression "chalk and cheese"? Other than that you have chosen to use the word "model" for what you earlier today (my time) presented as the "ELECTRIC COMET model" (my shorthand), the two have ~nothing in common. At ~any level.
So are there any other viable models of comets you know of?
I was totally unaware that the "ELECTRIC COMET model" is viable, in any sense of the word!
Perhaps we could discuss them in this thread.
I have no intention of discussing anything other than whatever electric comet model you choose to present. In this thread. At least until you change your mind about SAFIRE.
If there is no other viable model(mainstream) peer reviewed Yada yada yada and the electric comet is our (crackpot pseudo-science) model and whipples model is wrong, is that still a false dichotomy?
Yes.
!