The Difference

Sorry:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millwall_F.C.#Supporters_and_hooliganism

Millwall's fans were stereotyped as hooligans. To refer to violent Millwall fans as their "number one fans" -- with any number of scare quotes -- would be to play off that stereotype. More loaded than innocent in my opinion. Just like Skeptic's statement.



The number of times I've looked up ironic in the dictionary....
It doesn't always mean it's just an innocent joke.

Let's see. I guess this is the meaning you're thinking of:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irony
"Ironic statements (verbal irony) often convey a meaning exactly opposite from their literal meaning."

Even if Skeptic hadn't himself described his use of the word as 'euphemistic', I'd be hard pressed to believe he was trying to convey the exact opposite of the word's meaning. Did Skeptic mean that "devout" Muslims are those Muslims who are the exact opposite of devout -- or something approaching the exact opposite of devout? I might be wrong, but I didn't get the impression that was his intention.

You want to go on calling it "ironic" -- scare quotes! -- go ahead. That doesn't stop it being loaded.

Yes, the exact opposite of the literal meaning.

'Devout' as in 'we are the real and true devout Muslims/Christians/Conservatives/Constitutionalists so what we are doing and advocating must be in line with Islam/Christianity/Conservatism/the Constitution no matter how far from the literal meaning of the ideology we stray and those not following us aren't true believers' kind of 'devout'.

That's what it was a euphemism for, also making 'devout' ironic because they are not. Or at least they are not any more than the people who actually helped with the fires.

That's the way I read it. I also read it as only part of a much longer post. To get so worked up over 'devout' and ignore the larger message is nitpicking.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed incivility


Would be interesting to see a test done on the reactions by the international community ranging from over the past 2 decades until today on their changing reactions to, for instance:

1) Devout Christian
2) Devout Jew
3) Devout Muslim
4) Devout Hindu
...
Range the reactions and how aggressively people come to the defense of those mentioned when they are for example critisized/'attacked' in the various media outlets/sources/etc.

I would see nowadays a stronger reaction and defense to those of #3 over anyone else ever since 9/11, but hey, just my opinion. Wouldn't surprise me if the yuppies on this forum would try to pigeonhole me as an Islamophobe which usually groups like CAIR were responsible for doing...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed incivility


Would be interesting to see a test done on the reactions by the international community ranging from over the past 2 decades until today on their changing reactions to, for instance:

1) Devout Christian
2) Devout Jew
3) Devout Muslim
4) Devout Hindu
...
Range the reactions and how aggressively people come to the defense of those mentioned when they are for example critisized/'attacked' in the various media outlets/sources/etc.

I would see nowadays a stronger reaction and defense to those of #3 over anyone else ever since 9/11, but hey, just my opinion. Wouldn't surprise me if the yuppies on this forum would try to pigeonhole me as an Islamophobe which usually groups like CAIR were responsible for doing...

muslims are the only group that are discriminated in my country, Jews are not Christians are surely not etc. but Muslims often get lumped into the same group as terrorists, while strangely enough those people that do that mostly christians, would themselfe never place in the same group as North ireland Terrorists.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
muslims are the only group that are discriminated in my country, Jews are not Christians are surely not etc. but Muslims often get lumped into the same group as terrorists, while strangely enough those people that do that mostly christians, would themselfe never place in the same group as North ireland Terrorists.
Can't judge from what's stated above that Jews aren't discriminated against in Switzerland or not. The prior is untrue. Anti-Muslims discrimination has been on the rise, but to stick in an 'only' is rubbish.

If you're going to reply to what I post, at least make an attempt to understand what I'm stating and address it rather than making up a different argument altogether.
 
Can't judge from what's stated above that Jews aren't discriminated against in Switzerland or not. The prior is untrue. Anti-Muslims discrimination has been on the rise, but to stick in an 'only' is rubbish.

If you're going to reply to what I post, at least make an attempt to understand what I'm stating and address it rather than making up a different argument altogether.

Name an other group than Moslems that are discriminated against by our law.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed incivility


Would be interesting to see a test done on the reactions by the international community ranging from over the past 2 decades until today on their changing reactions to, for instance:

1) Devout Christian
2) Devout Jew
3) Devout Muslim
4) Devout Hindu
...
Range the reactions and how aggressively people come to the defense of those mentioned when they are for example critisized/'attacked' in the various media outlets/sources/etc.

I would see nowadays a stronger reaction and defense to those of #3 over anyone else ever since 9/11, but hey, just my opinion. Wouldn't surprise me if the yuppies on this forum would try to pigeonhole me as an Islamophobe which usually groups like CAIR were responsible for doing...

'Devout' without scare quotes.
Do you mean to quiz us on our reactions to people who are genuinely devout, not ironicly devout? Interesting, if so.

I think the increase in defence can be explained by the increase in criticism. Because not all the criticism is justified. Especially when a distinction is made between moderate Muslims and devout Muslims, as if people can't be both.

Come back and complain when someone defends stoning, even in moderation... rather than when someone defends devout Muslims who don't stone.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
'Devout' without scare quotes.
Do you mean to quiz us on our reactions to people who are genuinely devout, not ironicly devout? Interesting, if so.
Quiz? I said reaction to when seeing said term. Not a nicely packaged CNN program about a Q&A about religious practices, ie the Hajj or Christmas in Nazereth.

I think the increase in defence can be explained by the increase in criticism. Because not all the criticism is justified. Especially when a distinction is made between moderate Muslims and devout Muslims, as if people can't be both.
I don't think a distinction is necessary, as I don't believe that this distinction exists and to my knowledge is unique only when talking about Muslims, especially here, where you have artificially created the divide between moderate and devout, compared to moderate and radical/extremist as has been usually the case in the media and this very thread. The latter I could see the distinction of, not moderate, devout or the ridiculous 'ironicly devout'.

This is as much as I'm going to delve into this deflection of yours.

Come back and complain when someone defends stoning, even in moderation... rather than when someone defends devout Muslims who don't stone.
Steering as usual. And nice attempt at pigeonholing and who could've missed this false premise you're leading with. Back to your usual bag of tricks. ;)

Come back when you can seriously respond.
 
I don't think a distinction is necessary, as I don't believe that this distinction exists and to my knowledge is unique only when talking about Muslims, especially here, where you have artificially created the divide between moderate and devout, compared to moderate and radical/extremist as has been usually the case in the media and this very thread.

I didn't create the divide. Skeptic imagined it when he began by talking about moderate Muslims and then went on to speak about what happens when they become "devout".

Many Muslim people are moderate and decent (duh). But the moment they, like Hamas, Hizbullah, Turkey's PM or the arsonists, who -- experience shows -- are probably members of the Islamist movement in Israel -- become what is euphemistically known as "devout" Muslims, they become stupid, violent thugs.

That's what I was responding to, and then you popped in out of nowhere with your questions.

The latter I could see the distinction of, not moderate, devout or the ridiculous 'ironicly devout'.

You've not been reading the thread, have you?

Come back when you can seriously respond.

Come back when you've read the thread at least well enough to understand the references to irony.
 
Last edited:
I didn't create the divide. Skeptic imagined it when he began by talking about moderate Muslims and then went on to speak about what happens when they become "devout".
My question was more of a general one and I'm pretty sure Skeptic didn't invent or imagine this artificial divide in this OP.

As a sidenote, there's a bit of interpreting on your end to support this: "...then went on to speak about what happens when they become "devout"..."

As with your admission on the previous page. I would chalk it down as another case of paranoia.

That's what I was responding to, and then you popped in out of nowhere with your questions.
Perhaps you could point out where I replied to either you or Skeptic directly regarding this distinction? The OP was general enough to post what I posted.

You've not been reading the thread, have you?
Yes I have. Bit of a disconnect still. Above applies.

Come back when you've read the thread at least well enough to understand the references to irony.
Learn to reply to those speaking directly at you first.

Ironicly devout, by the way, was your invention. Irony is text without clear indication of its use is somewhat difficult to spot, is it not?
 
My question was more of a general one and I'm pretty sure Skeptic didn't invent or imagine this artificial divide in this OP.

As a sidenote, there's a bit of interpreting on your end to support this: "...then went on to speak about what happens when they become "devout"..."

As with your admission on the previous page. I would chalk it down as another case of paranoia.

Really? What's your interpretation?

Skeptic said:
Many Muslim people are moderate and decent (duh). But the moment they, like Hamas, Hizbullah, Turkey's PM or the arsonists, who -- experience shows -- are probably members of the Islamist movement in Israel -- become what is euphemistically known as "devout" Muslims, they become stupid, violent thugs.


Perhaps you could point out where I replied to either you or Skeptic directly regarding this distinction? The OP was general enough to post what I posted.


Yes I have. Bit of a disconnect still. Above applies.


Learn to reply to those speaking directly at you first.

I see. You weren't replying to me. And you knew what I was talking about when I mentioned irony. I certainly didn't guess the last.

Ironicly devout, by the way, was your invention. Irony is text without clear indication of its use is somewhat difficult to spot, is it not?

Tyr_13 was the first to say that devout was intended ironicly. I pointed out that Skeptic said it was a euphemism. Skeptic deleted what he had to say on the matter.

Have fun sticking to your story.
 
Really? What's your interpretation?
More along the lines of Tyr-13's interpretation of it, compared to the more alarmist version of yours.

I see. You weren't replying to me. And you knew what I was talking about when I mentioned irony. I certainly didn't guess the last.
So are you going to reply? I would like to see other people's replies on the matter since I know what your position might entail.

Tyr_13 was the first to say that devout was intended ironicly. I pointed out that Skeptic said it was a euphemism. Skeptic deleted what he had to say on the matter.

Have fun sticking to your story.
Not difficult to stick to my story since it hasn't been commented on yet.
 
If you cannot post in a civil manner, or stay on topic, then don't post. I've already had to move quite a few posts off to AAH, and edit a few more. Any further bad behavior will be met with Warnings.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
It was a bureaucratic mistake. Their permits are being reprossessed.

Correct, and it should be noted that all the Israeli papers came out with strong condemnation of this idiotic mistake. But as I said before, FireGarden, Israeli beurocracy = rather angry elephant in a shop of extremely delicate Chinese vases.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom