The Difference

holy crap his idiocy cost 41 people their lives :(

Pretty stupid move, yeah. Unfortunately, that's why wildfires are so destructive; in conditions that are extremely hot and dry, any little ignition can destroy countless acres. They can grow out of control and spread extremely quickly (especially when it's windy).
 
I think the combined positive efforts of Egypt, Jordan, Turkey, and the Palestinians...surely outweighs the negative efforts of a couple of jerks.

But not if you are Johnny-One-Note, who must always portray the Jews as victims, no matter what the circumstances.

I don't think one has much to do with the other. I'm not judging Arabs and Muslims collectively just as I'm not judging Israel or Jews collectively. It would appear that the OP isn't judging anyone collectively and is in fact making a clear stand against doing so.

So no, the combined efforts don't 'outweigh' anything in my mind. The people doing good are in the right and those doing bad are in the wrong.
 
wasnt it compareble in other fires?
some christian Firefighters risked their live to fight the fire while other Christians told the public on National TV that the Fires are Gods punishment.

Let's put it this way.

Imagine that until, say, 10-20 years ago, the only thing any Christian would ever do when a fire happened in a Jewish neighborhood was to dance in the streets and say the Jews had it coming.

Then, over time, and slowly, it becomes the case that some (or even many) Christians no longer do that and instead join the fire brigade and help out.

Wouldn't you say that in that case this is news?

Oh, and P.S.:

it is now Hannukah, the celebration of the time where the Jews defeated the Greek (or rather, hellenized) rulers of the land and renewed the lighting of the menorah (lamp) in the temple.

After he watched the Greek squad of four fire-fighting planes help put out the fire, minister Ehud Barak couldn't stop himself from quipping, in a stage whisper, in front of the cameras: "Great -- the Greeks are putting out our fires again."

Netanyahu, all official and serious, probably wanted to kill him.
 
Update: the two kids arrested for starting the fire by mistake were released. The Israeli police is now convinced it isn't them, but another teenager, a friend of theirs, who accidentally started the fire by throwing away a still-hot ember from a hookah he used to smoke.

In the news about this discovery the tone is, "if true, it goes to prove what we kept saying -- BE CAREFUL WITH FIRE". Nobody, at least nobody interviewed on the radio on the issue (firefighters, members of ecological groups, police officers, etc.) seems to think this in any way "proves" anything about the Druze or about Arabs in general. The general attitude from the interviewees' comments on the radio isn't "hand 'im high" but "there for the grace of God goes I".
 
Let's put it this way.

Imagine that until, say, 10-20 years ago, the only thing any Christian would ever do when a fire happened in a Jewish neighborhood was to dance in the streets and say the Jews had it coming.

what mythical/imaginary land are you talking about? Surely not the USA, Canada, Britain, or any other Western state.
 
Last edited:
I just know there's something wrong about holding the actions of a few against the vast majority... can't quite remember... if only a skeptic could help me.
 
Well, that's nice of the Muslims to do so.


I hear some Palestinians are in trouble somewhere, though, can't remember where... Was it next to Israel? One would hope the Jews could go there and help them.
 
Apparently some people think Muslims should be treated like the special education kids on the short bus.

Every time they do something which is simply what common decency would expect, they should not just be thanked and acknowledged, but praised to the skies for being so wonderful; and every time they behave despicably, it should be passed over in silence, as something one should not talk about.

If I were a Muslim, I would be deeply insulted by this attitude.
 
Apparently some people think Muslims should be treated like the special education kids on the short bus.

Every time they do something which is simply what common decency would expect, they should not just be thanked and acknowledged, but praised to the skies for being so wonderful; and every time they behave despicably, it should be passed over in silence, as something one should not talk about.

If I were a Muslim, I would be deeply insulted by this attitude.

No, that's not anyone's attitude.
And the insulting behaviour is you confusing individuals and groups. How does it read to you, when you say "Every time they do something which is simply what common decency would expect, ....every time they behave despicably..."? When you're actually talking about different people. 'When some of them do this, when some of them do that...' would be more appropriate.

I realise you had good intentions in starting this thread. But what you ended up doing is revealing your ignorance about what being a devout Muslim means. It sounds like you are saying the Muslims who helped Israel are not real Muslims. They're part-time Muslims, or something. Not devout, to use your word. If you don't see that as insulting, then I wonder how you avoid such a realisation.

Read this again:

My conclusion? Many Muslim people are moderate and decent (duh). But the moment they, like Hamas, Hizbullah, Turkey's PM or the arsonists, who -- experience shows -- are probably members of the Islamist movement in Israel -- become what is euphemistically known as "devout" Muslims, they become stupid, violent thugs.

Whether Islamism makes people violent and stupid or violent and stupid people are attracted to Jihadis, is an open question.

See how you switch between 'devout Muslim' and 'Islamism'? And isn't 'Islamist' your word for jihadis and terrorists?

If that's not the message you meant to put across, then say so. But don't pretend that the only way you could be misunderstood is because of other people's attitudes.
 
Last edited:
So praising the Muslims doing good while condemning the "devout" Muslims (see those sacred quotes there, that means it's meant to be taken ironically) who are doing bad is somehow terrible because it's coming from someone who tends to use too broad a brush.

I can't believe Skeptic isn't getting more defense in this thread. Just because you don't like him or his stance overall doesn't make the OP wrong. Twisting this much is really sad to watch.
 
So praising the Muslims doing good while condemning the "devout" Muslims (see those sacred quotes there, that means it's meant to be taken ironically) who are doing bad is somehow terrible because it's coming from someone who tends to use too broad a brush.

I can't believe Skeptic isn't getting more defense in this thread. Just because you don't like him or his stance overall doesn't make the OP wrong. Twisting this much is really sad to watch.

who praised Muslims?
i praise those that actually moved their ass and went helping. I dont praise Palestinians or the PA or what ever, those individuals that came to help, they are praised.

and i think their effort overweights comments of nuts that celebrated the fires....
 
who praised Muslims?i praise those that actually moved their ass and went helping. I dont praise Palestinians or the PA or what ever, those individuals that came to help, they are praised.

and i think their effort overweights comments of nuts that celebrated the fires....

Skeptic did. He praised the Muslims doing good deeds. The bad deeds of the nuts don't get put on the same scale as the good deeds of the nice people because one doesn't go on the same scale as the other.

EDIT: Just caught my tautology in that last sentence. I mean to say that the actions of one person shouldn't reflect on the actions of other people. There is nothing to outweigh unless those were either the same people, or part of the same organization. No, I don't count 'Muslim' or 'Arab' as 'the same organization' because it's far to broad a brush.
 
Last edited:
So praising the Muslims doing good while condemning the "devout" Muslims (see those sacred quotes there, that means it's meant to be taken ironically) who are doing bad is somehow terrible because it's coming from someone who tends to use too broad a brush.

Skeptic described his use of "devout" as a euphemism. How does that work? You see a Millwall fan breaking windows, you say: "He's their number one fan!" My how inoccently ironic, and not at all playing on stereo-types.

I can't believe Skeptic isn't getting more defense in this thread. Just because you don't like him or his stance overall doesn't make the OP wrong. Twisting this much is really sad to watch.

Funnily enough... I remember defending Skeptic some years ago. Mainly because BPSCG put the part about not defending him in his sig for a while. Post 46:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=60235&page=2

What changed since then, I don't know.
 
Skeptic described his use of "devout" as a euphemism. How does that work? You see a Millwall fan breaking windows, you say: "He's their number one fan!" My how inoccently ironic, and not at all playing on stereo-types.



Funnily enough... I remember defending Skeptic some years ago. Mainly because BPSCG put the part about not defending him in his sig for a while. Post 46:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=60235&page=2

What changed since then, I don't know.

I cannot tell if you're being facetious or not with the fan thing. Perhaps it's because I don't know what Millwall is.

I could be mistaken, but it seems 'devout' Muslim is being used the same way many people say 'devout' Christian; as an ironic code word for extremist or violent fundamentalist.
 
I cannot tell if you're being facetious or not with the fan thing. Perhaps it's because I don't know what Millwall is.

Sorry:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millwall_F.C.#Supporters_and_hooliganism

Millwall's fans were stereotyped as hooligans. To refer to violent Millwall fans as their "number one fans" -- with any number of scare quotes -- would be to play off that stereotype. More loaded than innocent in my opinion. Just like Skeptic's statement.

I could be mistaken, but it seems 'devout' Muslim is being used the same way many people say 'devout' Christian; as an ironic code word for extremist or violent fundamentalist.

The number of times I've looked up ironic in the dictionary....
It doesn't always mean it's just an innocent joke.

Let's see. I guess this is the meaning you're thinking of:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irony
"Ironic statements (verbal irony) often convey a meaning exactly opposite from their literal meaning."

Even if Skeptic hadn't himself described his use of the word as 'euphemistic', I'd be hard pressed to believe he was trying to convey the exact opposite of the word's meaning. Did Skeptic mean that "devout" Muslims are those Muslims who are the exact opposite of devout -- or something approaching the exact opposite of devout? I might be wrong, but I didn't get the impression that was his intention.

You want to go on calling it "ironic" -- scare quotes! -- go ahead. That doesn't stop it being loaded.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom