The Difference

Skeptic

Banned
Joined
Jul 25, 2001
Messages
18,312
In Israel's biggest fire ever, Turkey, Egypt, Jordan, and... the PA came to Israel's aid.

In the meantime, lots of Arab TV stations declared their glee of Allah punishing Israel. Especially the likes of Hizbullah, Hamas, and other brave resisters of imperialism.

Also -- a bus of jailers, which came to help removing a prison's inmates from the fire, was caught in the blazes and 22 perished. The list of dead includes many non-Jews (esp. Arab Druze) who were just as self-sacrificing as the Jews.

In the meantimes, Arab (to judge form the locations of the fire and those arrested in connection) arsonists tried to make the evil Jewish state suffer by starting more fires.

(It is important to note that two Arabs were arrested for starting the original fire as well, but the police chief emphasized that, assuming they are guilty, the fire was NOT arson but due to criminal negligence on their part -- the "criminal" part being them running away and not reporting the fire started to spread after a small fire they made in camp on vacation started spreading.)

Oh, and finally -- Turkey came to Israel's aid, Netanyahu [Israel's PM] made a point of thanking it especially in a speech, Turkey's Islamist PM made clear this is in no way a sign of the warming of relationships, coming as it does a week after he threatened war against Israel.

Ah well.

My conclusion? Many Muslim people are moderate and decent (duh). But the moment they, like Hamas, Hizbullah, Turkey's PM or the arsonists, who -- experience shows -- are probably members of the Islamist movement in Israel -- become what is euphemistically known as "devout" Muslims, they become stupid, violent thugs.

Whether Islamism makes people violent and stupid or violent and stupid people are attracted to Jihadis, is an open question.
 
In Israel's biggest fire ever, Turkey, Egypt, Jordan, and... the PA came to Israel's aid.

In the meantime, lots of Arab TV stations declared their glee of Allah punishing Israel. Especially the likes of Hizbullah, Hamas, and other brave resisters of imperialism.

Also -- a bus of jailers, which came to help removing a prison's inmates from the fire, was caught in the blazes and 22 perished. The list of dead includes many non-Jews (esp. Arab Druze) who were just as self-sacrificing as the Jews.

In the meantimes, Arab (to judge form the locations of the fire and those arrested in connection) arsonists tried to make the evil Jewish state suffer by starting more fires.

(It is important to note that two Arabs were arrested for starting the original fire as well, but the police chief emphasized that, assuming they are guilty, the fire was NOT arson but due to criminal negligence on their part -- the "criminal" part being them running away and not reporting the fire started to spread after a small fire they made in camp on vacation started spreading.)

So the cops are saying it's not arson, it's not terrorism, and, in fact, the kids they arrested are Druzi (not Muslim). But somehow you still decide that:

the arsonists, who -- experience shows -- are probably members of the Islamist movement in Israel
Despite the evidence showing otherwise - you're still trying to spin this as a terrorist arson attack?

Jumping to the wrong conclusion before the information is available is one thing - but acknowledging that the conclusion is wrong, and jumping to it anyway? That's a whole new level of wrong.
 
Last edited:
Er, Cleon, I am claiming OTHER people are arsonists, NOT the ones who started the original fire. Once again, after the blaze was already going on for a day or so, OTHER people started fires -- and those of who were caught starting those new fires, not the original ones, were Arabs. As for "jumping to conclusions" -- I am simply extrapolating from both what is known about the arsonists caught already this time, and about previous cases of such arson.
 
Last edited:
UAV footage of the arsonists: http://www.flix.co.il/tapuz/showVideo.asp?m=3769859

Cleon, first, I don't see how you can definitively argue that fire can't be used as a method of terrorism.

Secondly, the two druze arrested were suspected of throwing molotovs into a different area, which was not the starting point of the giant blaze that's still going today:

Police: Arrested arson suspects not linked to Israeli fire

The origin of the giant blaze is still being investigated, so there's nothing to 'spin' as of yet.

Skeptic is still free to speculate all he wishes then.
 
rather than showing appreciation from the Muslims who have come to the aid of the Jewish people, the right-wing Zionists here at JREF instead search far and wide for a way to instead attack Muslims.

nice. and typical.

and expected. Right-wing Zionists simply cannot fathom a world where non-Jews come to the aid of the Jewish State, let alone Muslims.
 
rather than showing appreciation from the Muslims who have come to the aid of the Jewish people, the right-wing Zionists here at JREF instead search far and wide for a way to instead attack Muslims.

Just wanted to repeat this truism.

What an utterly pathetic, childish and foolish OP. Not just attack muslims but also attack Islam.
 
I pray that Netanyahu is not swayed by the forces of hate and bigotry in his country, that might use this as another opportunity to attack Muslims and Arabs.

So far, it looks like Bibi is doing the right thing, by thanking the Turks, Jordanians, Palestinians, and others who have offered to help Israel in this desperate hour.

Again, this OP proves that some Jews prefer to see themselves as constantly hated and persecuted victims, even in times of help and caring from those who often strongly disagree with Israel. For some Jews, being hated and despised is part of the Jewish experience that must never go away.
 
that was nice to see.

it was amazing to see countries that very often have highly comabative relations with Israel, decided to put politics aside when their neighbor was in need.

it shows that we can work together.

nevermind the incredible poetic nature of Christians and Muslim from around the region coming to Israel's aid, to put out a large "holocaust".
 
Arriving at nine in the morning on Sunday, Ayish said, "We were received respectfully." He added, "After all, we're dealing with a humanitarian issue which knows no borders," Ma'an reported.

"We hope that we will have a major role in fighting the fire and in the humanitarian effort on Mount Carmel," a Palestinian firefighter told Channel 10. "It's, like, peace."

When asked by Israel Radio how they felt about fighting a fire in Israel, the Palestinians responded that it was partly a humanitarian work, partly their job as firefighters, and that they believe Israel would help in the same way should the Palestinians ever find themselves in a similar situation.

Jordanian firefighters were also sent to help fight the Carmel fire on the ground.
:)
 
rather than showing appreciation from the Muslims who have come to the aid of the Jewish people, the right-wing Zionists here at JREF instead search far and wide for a way to instead attack Muslims.

nice. and typical.

and expected. Right-wing Zionists simply cannot fathom a world where non-Jews come to the aid of the Jewish State, let alone Muslims.
Commented on this here with your attempted derail:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6624402&postcount=294

So as stated above, two-way street and nothing unusual.

Again, let me ask you again since this was avoided time and time again, what is right-wing about any of the commentary here again? Another knee-jerk response.

How can one not be critical or speculate about arson (see date of Skeptic's comments) from certain groups simply because there are countries with Muslim majorities involved in aiding Israel?

And regarding your last point about coming to the aid of Israel, which somehow translates to coming to the aid of Jews. Is it possible to fathom the concept that coming to the aid of Israel would imply coming to the aid of all it citizens? Especially factoring in that the area where the fire is taking place has the highest concentrations of Muslims, Christian, Baahi, and Druze villages/town/cities in all of Israel? Ones I regularly visit as well.

The short-sightedness and dimwittedness of some of the posters in this thread is appalling, but not surprising....
 
Last edited:
Just wanted to repeat this truism.

What an utterly pathetic, childish and foolish OP. Not just attack muslims but also attack Islam.
Oh dear. Can't attack Islam can we? Albeit Islamism was stated.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed uncivil comment
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I made a post titled "the difference", precisely about how different Arabs and/or Muslims are behaving differently about this fire: some try to help put it out, even sacrifising their lives to do so (and, yes, Druze *do* consider themselves Arab, at least that's what Druze told me face to face), others dance with glee at the Jews' misfortune and try to set fires themselves.

And what do I get? People attacking me for the mere fact that I dared to mention that some Muslims or Arabs reacted disgustingly to the fire. Not to mention totally misreading what I wrote as if I claimed those who set the original fire did it deliberately (when I explicitly noted that they did not, precisely so it would be clear that when I speak about the arsonists, I mean *others*, and am *not* claiming the original fire-starters were arsonists).

Mind you, if I noted ONLY that, I could see their point. If I noted only what Hizbullah did and ignored what the PA did, they would have a point. But the whole point of my post is to note that different people react differently and to give credit as well as blame. But clearly here reading this post as an "attack" on Arabs or Muslims is due simply to the fact that not EVERY Arab I mentioned was praised, because I didn't censor myself and note ONLY the good side of the behavior of Arabs and/or Muslims.

This, so to speak, is your brain on political correctness. When you have your own little PC "thought police" turned on on the "high" setting all the time, nthing but cliche-filled feel-good stories about the victim group du jour (Arabs or Muslims, in this case) counts in one's mind as being "objective". Everything else is "bigtory", "Islamophobia", "racism", "right-wing", etc., etc.
 
wasnt it compareble in other fires?
some christian Firefighters risked their live to fight the fire while other Christians told the public on National TV that the Fires are Gods punishment.
 
wasnt it compareble in other fires?
some christian Firefighters risked their live to fight the fire while other Christians told the public on National TV that the Fires are Gods punishment.

Yes,

But this is in a conflict zone that flares up in war between religious communities every ten years or so. I find the Arab and Turkish help encouraging an it shows we can transcend our differences.

Skeptic also noticed that some extremist scumbags used the situation to start more fires.

For reasons I do not understand, he seems to catch a lot of flak for that.

The basic conflict in the world is not between communities, but between decent people and scumbags.







As an aside: I've hiked in that area.
Our guide wouldn't even allow us to leave organic waste such as orange peelings. It's a delicate bit of nature that will probably need several hundred years to grow back. :(
 
And what do I get? People attacking me for the mere fact that I dared to mention that some Muslims or Arabs reacted disgustingly to the fire.

the Muslim nations of Jordan, Turkey, Egypt, and even the Palestinians, send supplies, aid, and even their own firefighters to help the Jewish State put out their fires.

and what do YOU do? you create a thread that somehow finds a way to turn a story of brotherhood and overcoming political differences, as another chance to bash Muslims.

people attack you for it .......and you have no idea why.

;)


..honestly, this is no different than a few bigoted Haitains spreading rumors that the "evil Jewish Israelis" who came to their aid during the earthquake, were secretly stealing eye corneas from the dead.
 
Last edited:
I'm rather saddened by the reaction to this thread. If praising the people doing good in a bad situation while criticizing the people doing evil in a bad situation is wrong, I have ever desire to be in the wrong.

Great job all those helping with the fires and their damage. Go to hell arsonists.
 
I think the combined positive efforts of Egypt, Jordan, Turkey, and the Palestinians...surely outweighs the negative efforts of a couple of jerks.

But not if you are Johnny-One-Note, who must always portray the Jews as victims, no matter what the circumstances.
 
Cleon, first, I don't see how you can definitively argue that fire can't be used as a method of terrorism.

Uh...Well, I don't see how I could (or did) argue that, either. I certainly don't think any such thing.

In other news...A 14-year-old boy has admitted to accidentally starting the wildfire by throwing his burning hookah coal into the woods. The other two kids were released.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom