The certainty of God's existence.

There are other good definitions.
What was that lense maker's definition that Einstien believe in?
"Spinoza"? I forget his name.
Spinoza's God was the deterministic system of which everything in nature is a part.
 
Intriguing...


Permit me to try and offer a short, informative statement about the "Big Bang implies one universe" thing.


The Big Bang theory discusses one universe.
It does not, however, say that there is only one universe.
Nor does it imply there is more than one universe.
It simply doesn't discuss the possibility of other universes at all.
Such discussion is beyond the scope of what the Big bang theory explains.



Does writing a report on the book Don Quixote imply that Don Quixote is the only book ever written?
 
Last edited:
That's not a definition. That's not even coherent.

Come now. Philosophy 101 students have been thinking about it for 1000 years at least.

I actually encountered it in high school, but we had a pretty ambitious humanities teacher in my high school.
 
Does writing a report on the book Don Quixote imply that Don Quixote is the only book ever written?
Are you suggesting there may be others?
Some random website said:
The alpha and the omega of the novel form, the first true novel, the best-selling novel and in the eyes of most of the world, the greatest novel of all time. Cervantes uses the theme of the idealistic, insane knight and the devoted, down to earth squire to portray many complex themes through a plethora of unforgettable incidents, tragic and comic in a blend of great variety and colour.
Do you see them talking about NOVELS? I don't. Therefore, my horse has fleas, and you're all haters.
 
There are other good definitions.
What was that lense maker's definition that Einstien believe in?
"Spinoza"? I forget his name.
Baruch Spinoza used the word "God" as a label for natural forces. We can call nature "God" if we like, but then I can call my cat a dragon. Doing so doesn't mean it is unreasonable to lack belief in dragons.

But if you cannot fathom what "that which no greater can be thought" means, I have to say that you are on your own.
I can think about it to be sure, but it's a definition that is too vague to be useful for determining the existence of gods.
 
God is an entity greater than which nothing can be conceived.

When something exists in fantasy, it can take on whatever attributes desired, with infinite possibilities.
When something exists in reality, it is constrained to be only that which it truly is.

Therefore, God exists as a fantasy.

I doubt that I'm the first person who ever thought of that, but I had never thought of it before, and I thought I would share it with others.
 
Are you suggesting there may be others?

Do you see them talking about NOVELS? I don't. Therefore, my horse has fleas, and you're all haters.



Well, fortunately, in regards to books (but not universes), we have evidence of other books.
Of course, that may all just be a clever ruse purported by devious scoundrels seaking to lead me astray from the truth of Cervantes.


Actually, I just (finally!) finsihed reading Les Miserables. The full, unabridged version. Ugh. It took me 6 months, with a 3-year hiatus after the first 4 months, because I got really bored of all meandering digressions. Seriously, I thing Hugo had ADD or something. I mean, 25 pages on sewers?

DQ is, in fact, next on my list. Hence it being the first to pop into my mind when thining of well-known and read works. At 1,000 pages, it is about 200 pages shorter than Les Mis.
I really hope that Cervantes is less prone to ridiculous levels of detail and off-topic rambling than Hugo was.



But the analogy, at least, might help shed some light on what seems to be a few people talking past one another.
 
Which of course is just redefining God out of existence.
Yes, it is just atheism in denial.

That is what they told Spinoza at the time.

And that Rabbi's answer was that Einstein was simply finding a diplomatic way of saying he did not believe in God.
 
Last edited:
But the analogy, at least, might help shed some light on what seems to be a few people talking past one another.

No, analogies are hate speech and evil. See the discussion about the FSM, IPU, Orbiting Teapot, and other entities used to try to explain about the evidence for God.

Never, never, never, use an analogy. And don't get me started on similes and metaphors!
 
Well, fortunately, in regards to books (but not universes), we have evidence of other books.
Book-like objects, certainly, but can you assert that they are true books?

Actually, I just (finally!) finsihed reading Les Miserables. The full, unabridged version. Ugh. It took me 6 months, with a 3-year hiatus after the first 4 months, because I got really bored of all meandering digressions. Seriously, I thing Hugo had ADD or something. I mean, 25 pages on sewers?
He was the Neal Stephenson of his day.

Or maybe he was paid by the word. No, that was Dumas.

Shorter Les Mis: (Almost) everybody dies.
 
I can think about it to be sure, but it's a definition that is too vague to be useful for determining the existence of gods.
Well let's make the definition a little less vague, presumably this is a maximally great entity defined as:

Def 1 : T(x) means it is possible to form a mental representation of x
Def 2: G(x,y) means x is greater than y
Def 3: M(x) means [latex]\forall x \forall y [ M(x) \wedge T(x) \wedge T(y) \rightarrow G(x,y) ][/latex]
​
If this is wrong someone please correct it.

Otherwise the questions are:

1. What is the definition of "great"?
2. Does the definition connote that the mental representation is greater, or that the ostensible referent is greater?
3. If the latter does the definition connote "conceived to be greater" or "actually greater"?
​
 
Last edited:
Well let's make the definition a little less vague, presumably this is a maximally great entity defined as:

Def 1 : T(x) means it is possible to form a mental representation of x
Def 2: G(x,y) means x is greater than y
Def 3: M(x) means [latex]\forall x \forall y [ M(x) \wedge T(x) \wedge T(y) \rightarrow G(x,y) ][/latex]
​
If this is wrong someone please correct it.

IMO Def 3 should read: [latex]\forall x \forall y \ne x [ M(x) \wedge T(x) \wedge T(y) \rightarrow G(x,y) ][/latex]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom