The certainty of God's existence.

Science have theoretical constructions from variations of the BB that describe other universes and how they might come about.
Uh, no.

I have said that a zillion, maybe 2 zillion times!
And guess what? It's neither correct nor relevant.

That is what you have been fighting me about tooth and nail
Wrong!

ie (if the BB implies one universe vs you saying it could implies many universes).
Wrong. Completely, utterly, and irredeemably wrong.

You haven't understood any of the dozens of posts on this subject, and I'm beginning to doubt whether you have read them.

Big bang cosmology does not imply multiple universes, and no-one is claiming it does.

Big bang cosmology does not imply a single universe. You are claiming it does. You are wrong.

I am wondering about you Wolly ,I really am! You are backing up and denying what you have already posted.
No. He's pointing out that you have, yet again, either failed to understand a very simple point or deliberately misrepresented the argument.

You said in an earlier reply that the big bang could generate other universes or doesn’t rule out other universes?
Doesn't rule out.

Well newsflash VARIATIONS of the BB could theoretically spawn other universes.
Irrelevant.

However I have been saying all along that the STANDARD model of the BB implies one universe.
And wrong.

Have you lost your professional bearing Wolly?
I'll guess, no.

We can describe what other universes may be like but we can not observe them, that is much different than not knowing how they might exist. Everything about the big bang is theory and theoretical constructions.
Yes. How is this relevant?

You said that the BB does not rule out other universes. I said true but the big bang implies ONE universe.
And he is right and you are wrong.

????? Please tell me what is your day job? ( I already know what the members think you do) Anyway, here is one article describing how other universes might come about in the inflationary era of the BB.

“Multiverse (many universes)
Any of various concepts of the universe according to which the region that can be directly observed by us, now or in the future, is only part of an enormous ensemble of such regions, or island universes. The whole is the multiverse: the region we can observe is our universe or the observable universe. The inflationary theory of the Big Bang implies that the observable universe could occupy one ‘bubble’ in a vast sea of such bubbles. Since the boundary of our bubble is receding at the speed of light, owing to the expansion of space, we cannot observe the greater universe beyond. “

There are other much clearer sites where other theoretical variations of the BB describe meta universes. However as I have said so many times, the Standard Model of the BB implies ONE universe.
Wrong.

And by implying only one universe it has important theological implications.
False premise, begging the question.

This is getting complex and long to the point that we are losing sight of why I claim that the BB implies one universe.
Because you think it would support your argument. It doesn't, and in any case, it's not true.

And that this one universe theory is the prevailing theory.
Strawman.

That means that its the best theory we have and best supported.
Irrelevant.

The reason I am saying that the one universe Big Bang theory is important to theological issues, and it helps the KCA tie into science.
Ah. It ties the argument that isn't based on science into science. Wonderful.

Also, wrong.

That's because anything that begins to exist (the universe) must have a cause if its existence.
In fact, you have defined this such that the Universe is a special case, and cause and effect only applies to the creation of the Universe. Which means that your entire argument is a non-sequitur.

And that is what this whole one universe Big Bang theory is the best supported most valid theory we have for the orgins of the universe.
Argumentum ad populum strawman.

What is the currently most accepted model for the Universe?

The current best fit model is a flat ΛCDM Big Bang model where the expansion of the Universe is accelerating, and the age of the Universe is 13.7 billion years.
Irrelevant.

Will the Universe expand forever or re collapse?
This depends on the ratio of the density of the Universe to the critical density. If the density is higher than the critical density the Universe will re collapse in a Big Crunch. But current data suggest that the density is less than or equal to the critical density so the Universe will expand forever.
Irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
You know eh? why would you think that I said that?
You have what you mistakenly consider a theological argument that you mistakenly believe is valid based on premises that you mistakenly believe are true, that you mistakenly believe is supported by your mistaken perception of big bang cosmology.

What do I win?
 
You have what you mistakenly consider a theological argument that you mistakenly believe is valid based on premises that you mistakenly believe are true, that you mistakenly believe is supported by your mistaken perception of big bang cosmology.

What do I win?

See you let the cat out of the bag..that question was for dafydd. No worries he may not recognize the answer. Technically its a cosmological argument but I guess you can call it a theological argument, but that would weaken it sigificantaly.

However, the KCA forms a syllogism and that is what makes it lovely and strong like me. However any syllogism depends on the validity of its premises and I haven't seen a good challenge to the first three yet, from here or the halls of professional debate. Of course that is only one evidence leg of many evidences for the existence of God.

; {>
 
Last edited:
See you let the cat out of the bag..that question was for dafydd. No worries he may not recognize te answer.its a cosmological argument but I guess you can call it a theological argument, however the KCA forms a syllogism and that is what makes it lovely. However any syllogism depends on the validity of its premises and I haven't seen a good challenge to the first three yet, from here or the halls of professional debate. Of course that is only one evdience leg of many evidences for the existence of God.

; {>

There have been plenty of good challenges to the premises. It's just that you don't acknowledge them as such, then claim to have won the debate.

It's appropriate behaviour for an Yrreg thread, I'll give you that.
 
See you let the cat out of the bag..that question was for dafydd. No worries he may not recognize the answer. Technically its a cosmological argument but I guess you can call it a theological argument, but that would weaken it sigificantaly.

However, the KCA forms a syllogism and that is what makes it lovely and strong like me. However any syllogism depends on the validity of its premises and I haven't seen a good challenge to the first three yet, from here or the halls of professional debate. Of course that is only one evidence leg of many evidences for the existence of God.

; {>

You have an arguement? That's news to me.
 
There have been plenty of good challenges to the premises. It's just that you don't acknowledge them as such, then claim to have won the debate.

It's appropriate behaviour for an Yrreg thread, I'll give you that.

I claim the KCA part of the debate is inconclusive. I am proud to be raised to the status of an Yrreg thread in your eyes and I will try to do right by you.:duck:

: }>
 
See you let the cat out of the bag..that question was for dafydd. No worries he may not recognize the answer. Technically its a cosmological argument but I guess you can call it a theological argument, but that would weaken it sigificantaly.

However, the KCA forms a syllogism and that is what makes it lovely and strong like me.
You mis-spelled "wrong".

However any syllogism depends on the validity of its premises
The truth of its premises, and the validity of its logic.

and I haven't seen a good challenge to the first three yet, from here or the halls of professional debate.
Then go back and read the thread again, because you appear to have missed about 95% of it.

All your premises have been demolished.

Of course that is only one evidence leg of many evidences for the existence of God.
Better or worse?
 
Quote: from you
And by implying only one universe it has important theological implications.

quote: from me
No it doesn't.



Are you being deliberately obtuse,or are you really that stupid?
 
Now you are learning to speak just as you have been taught. good boy!

; {>

What an insulting,ignorant rear end you are.You have no intelligent answers to my questions so you resort to calumny.You'll find "calumny" in a dictionary,under "C"
 
Last edited:
No Mamn' not according to my paradigm. Hell is not a destination for humans in general , and heaven is Gods eternal abode (not that he doesn't visit time from time to time but I see very little evidence for it). In the bible God usually sends an envoy for temporal missions.


Ah, so our universe really is part of a multiverse, and those parallel universes do have different laws of physics.

Got it.
 
Where does the Big Bang address the origin of the Universe?

It addresses the development of the Universe from a time 10-43 seconds after the start of expansion.

The Big Bang only addresses the development of one Universe, but that is not the same as implying that there is only one Universe.

Your understanding of basic contemporary Big Bang cosmology is wrong.

Maybe you should read up on Cosmogony, which does address the origins of the Universe, but is entirely speculative.

Until you can show how the Big Bang addresses the question of the origin of the Universe you will continue to fail in your attempts to convince anyone here of your position.
.
There's an oldie but goodie... "The devil can quote scripture".
Watching an alleged theist quote science should carry a similar caveat. :)
 
Secular warlords?
Moslems and Christian Warlods they are.

W called Chirac in France to invoke the assistance of France to fight Gog and Magog in Iraq.


they both belive in the same God they just follow a diffrent manual for that god.

Religions are a cancer for the humanity.
Religions and its follower killed millions of people.
...
 
What was it you feared?

Eternal Hell, first and foremost.... I have a flexible enough imagination to envision my Grandparents screaming in the flames every night when I go to bed cause they weren't "born again"

ALSO- God monitors our every thought like Big Brother- without a "God" judging every deed, word, and secret thought I can live my mental life in peace as it's MEANT to be.
WITH a cosmic "Big Brother" this is impossible cause you guard all your thoughts and constantly pray for forgiveness every time a short skirt walks by. It's THAT absurd.
 
I don't believe in multiple universes. I'm not aware of any evidence for them. I am not troubled by the notion that this universe is improbable. There is no evidence that any universal constant could be other than what it is. If this is the only universe, OTOU, and physical constants aren't variable, then a universe very close to this one is pretty much inevitable, just because of the 'nature of reality'. This is very convenient for my atheism, no need for billions of ad hoc universes to explain away the improbability of this one.

Yet I am fully capable of understanding that the BB theory does not have any implications about how many universes there might be, because it is a theory about how this universe that we occupy came to be in the state that it's in, not a theory about how many universes there are. Pity, it would be nice to have the back-up for my opinion on how many universes there are, but it just isn't in the BB.

Rev, to me this is as plain as the nose on your face. How you cannot see that the BB theory implies nothing about other universes (except perhaps that if there are any they too started in similar fashion) is hard to grasp.

Perhaps you are stuck in a mental loop or are talking past us. I've certainly been involved in disagreements where that was the case. Just this morning: you didn't change the date on the calendar like we asked/yes, I did/no you didn't/look, here is print showing the change/that's next month's calendar/yeah, isn't that what you wanted changed? If we had some way of 'showing you the calendar', maybe we could get past this (to me, negligible) point.

In the meantime, please consider this: when you're all alone on a non-theological argument (really! if you're right, it does not mean 'therefore, God') on a skeptic's forum, it's a good idea to re-examine your position. If I go on the economics or politics forum, I may be in the minority, but I'm never alone as long as my logic is sound. It's the nature of economics and politics (and humans) that we are not always going to be able to agree on premises, but we can agree on whether an argument is sound, even if we can't agree on whether it is true. Rev, this bit about the BB theory implying only one universe just isn't sound. Your conclusion doesn't follow. And if it did, it wouldn't support your other arguments.

This isn't an argument, just sharing: if I were God, I would make lots of universes. It sounds like grand fun and not very hard (me being omnipotent and omniscient), I really can't think of anything I'd rather be doing if I was an eternal being. I might even create every possible universe.

Just sayin'.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom