The certainty of God's existence.

I thought we were talking about if the Big Bang theory implied many universes or simply this universe. When I say implied it was the best word I could think of. Just as when I am talking about your face and its structures, I am implying those structures include ONE nose.

Of course as I have said so many times I see it when I close my eyes, any student knows that we can only go back to The Planck Epoch immediately after the Big Bang (t=0) with our current science. Before that according to science (but not the KCA, because it’s a philosophical/ cosmological argument) we can’t say too much we lack a complete quantum theory of gravity to help us delve into that era.
Which is where (or when) the actual formation of the Universe, and or other universes might have occurred.

So, how does the Big Bang address the origin of the Universe, i.e. at or "before" T=0, how does it address the potential origin of other universes, and if it doesn't, how the heck can it imply anything about whether or not there are other universes?
 
a God that talks to online debatants in debates about Theism/Atheism while children around the globe are starving pisses me extremly off.

what kind of ******* god is that pls? has he nothing more important to do that supporting theists in their online debates? why doesnt he support starving christian children in moscouw for example?
what an ******* he is.

DC are you partaking of the recipe this morning?

; {>
 
wollery said:
Which is where (or when) the actual formation of the Universe, and or other universes might have occurred.

Still in all the time-lines and discussions I have seen popular writes or schoary papers they all speak of universe in the singular.

So, how does the Big Bang address the origin of the Universe, i.e. at or "before" T=0, how does it address the potential origin of other universes, and if it doesn't, how the heck can it imply anything about whether or not there are other universes?

I have never said that the BB addresses what happens before the P era or T-0 in scientific terms. In fact I have fell all over myself saying that we can't using science know what happened 'before' T-0. Here read this its a generic description of the big bang;

"For an incomprehensibly small fraction of a second, the universe was an infinitely dense and infinitely hot fireball. A peculiar form of energy that we don't know yet, suddenly pushed out the fabric of spacetime in a process called "inflation", which lasted for only one millionth of a second."

http://www.thebigview.com/spacetime/universe.html

Do you see universe in plural? No and you won't in any paper either! UNIVERSE NOT UNIVERSES (caps for emphasis only)

......U------N------I------V------E-----R-----S-----E .........

Not universes. I hope we can get over this then maybe we can progress on to the various evidences for the existence of God....

Time to go to the market...

; }>
 
Last edited:
God is my conscious he gave all of us one. If the secular war lords would not be fighting over the love of money all of them could feed themselves. God is the Christian missions in Africa, IMO god works in the frame work of natural law, miracles are a very rare occurrence that harms the universe. We are his hands that feed the starving...or doesn't. We are expected to feed the starving children for God. Not to do so demonstrates our selfishness. Yes, that includes this christian.

If you take the time to learn the truth about God maybe it won't be so difficult to love him.

; {>: <-----------lower lip piercing...

Secular warlords?
Moslems and Christian Warlods they are. they both belive in the same God they just follow a diffrent manual for that god.

Religions are a cancer for the humanity.
Religions and its follower killed millions of people.
 
I have never said that the BB addresses what happens before the P era or T-0 in scientific terms. In fact I have fell all over myself saying that we can't using science know what happened 'before' T-0.

And yet you keep claiming it supports your ideas of one universe, one try. By definition, the 'try' must have happened before the P era. Therefore, the big bang theory says nothing about OUOT.
 
Still in all the time-lines and discussions I have seen popular writes or schoary papers they all speak of universe in the singular.



I have never said that the BB addresses what happens before the P era or T-0 in scientific terms. In fact I have fell all over myself saying that we can't using science know what happened 'before' T-0. Here read this its a generic description of the big bang;

"For an incomprehensibly small fraction of a second, the universe was an infinitely dense and infinitely hot fireball. A peculiar form of energy that we don't know yet, suddenly pushed out the fabric of spacetime in a process called "inflation", which lasted for only one millionth of a second."

http://www.thebigview.com/spacetime/universe.html

Do you see universe in plural? No and you won't in any paper either! UNIVERSE NOT UNIVERSES (caps for emphasis only)

......U------N------I------V------E-----R-----S-----E .........

Not universes. I hope we can get over this then maybe we can progress on to the various evidences for the existence of God....
Of course a website devoted to discussion of the Big bang doesn't say anything about other universes. Because we have no information, can have no information, about other universes.

The Big Bang does not say anything about other universes, only this universe!

The Big Bang therefore cannot say anything at all about how many universes there may be, or how many "attempts" were made at making universes before this Universe came into existence.

What part of that concept are you having difficulty with. No paper, or website, discussing the Big Bang will discuss other universes, because the Big Bang doesn't address other universes. So linking to websites about the Big Bang and saying "look, it doesn't mention other universes is an exercise in futility.

Please, please, please, explain how the Big Bang can tell us anything about the possibility of other universes. Because that is precisely what you are claiming it can do.
 
I think that, like most fundamentalists, RevD cannot deal with, or perhaps even conceptualize, uncertainty. So when someone says "The Big Bang theory doesn't say there must be only one universe; in fact it doesn't say anything at all about numbers of universes", he hears them saying that the Big Bang theory says there must be more than one universe. Similarly, if some science academy says that there is nothing in science that proves God doesn't exist, he assumes that this must mean that the academy is saying God exists. Fundamentalists can't cope with the answer "we don't know".
 
Ha ha well if I met you I wouldn't say " Hey Pixy do you know that you have a nose stuck on the front of your face? I would hope that that would be obvious. Hey wait I have one for you! Your nose has two holes in it!

~ Really! ~ ....
I see you haven't let your membership to Non-Sequitur of the Month Club lapse.

Asking me to show a source or prove that the standard model of the big bang implies one universe demonstrates a rank utter misunderstanding of big bang cosmology.
On your part, yes.

Its like me asking one of the members to source a statement like ‘you have a nose on your face’.
No. It's not like that in any way.

That the big bang model implies one universe us just as obvious as that!
If it's as obvious as that, I'm sure that you can present this obvious evidence.

We'll wait. While you find it. I'm sure it won't take you long.

After all, it is, apparently, obvious.

I am not trying to be cute, no I am dead serious! There is a nose hanging right off the front of your face!
Perhaps there is. So?

Really guys are you serious?
Completely.

The standard BB model/theory implies that the BB created only ONE universe and it implies so when speaking about it.
No. First of all, that's not what you claimed previously. Second, it doesn't necessarily even imply that.

Why for goodness sake does any description of the big bang read thusly;

The Big Bang is the cosmological model of the initial conditions and subsequent development of the universe that is supported by the most comprehensive and accurate explanations from current scientific evidence and observation.
Yes. And?

As used by cosmologists, the term Big Bang generally refers to the idea that the universe has expanded from a primordial hot and dense initial condition at some finite time in the past, and continues to expand to this day.
Yes. And?

Now I ask you if the standard model implied more than one universe why oh why isn’t there any plurals for the word UNIVERSE.
Why should there be? Big bang cosmology doesn't, and can't, address the point of how many universes there may be. It has no implications one way or another.

THE UNIVERSE began to expand.
Yes, it did.

THE UNIVERSE EXPANDS TO THIS DAY.
Indeed it does.

Not the universe(S) began to expand.
No. The big bang theory refers to our Universe, the only one we can observe. It has no implications as to how many universes there may be.

NOT the UNIVERSES , and continues to expand to this day.
No. The big bang theory refers to our Universe, the only one we can observe. It has no implications as to how many universes there may be.

In fact YOU WON”T FIND a site describing basic Big Bang cosmology with the PLURAL form of UNIVERSE.
I'm sure I can, but it's irrelevant. The big bang theory refers to our Universe, the only one we can observe. It has no implications as to how many universes there may be.

Trying to get you Mr Wolly and the atheist apologists members to accept contemporary big bang cosmology has been an exercise in futility.
We accept it fine. You're just wrong.

Oh, and strawman, ad hominem

Of course I know why you and the atheist apologist members here refuse to accept the blatantly obvious, its because a one universe one try model points towards a creation and finally a creator.
Strawman, ad hominem, begging the question.

However your continuing dismissal of obvious facts really do harm your credibility, in an overall sense.
Strawman.

I will clarify ONE MORE time due to comments made in another thread that clearly states my understand of basic contemporary Big Bang Cosmology.
Feel free.

1.….I am standing by my claims that when speaking in general terms the Big Bang implies there is only one universe.
You are wrong. It makes no such implication.

2.….This does not mean that the BB rules out other universes, it simply means that when speaking of BB cosmology the BB implies one universe.
You are wrong. It makes no such implication.

3.… If there are more universes predicted or implied it is noted and a mechanism is given that could theoretically produce other universes. One example of a standard model variation adds theoretical language for these universes being created in the inflation era of the BB or just before T-0 via the effects of quantum loop gravity.
Irrelevant. There are models wherein the big bang itself generated multiple universes (e.g. chaotic inflation). There are also models wherein the big bang is one of many such.

I hope this clears up any misconceptions etc.
Apparently not. You're still wrong.

If anyone reading this decides to retain their many universe big bang theory I can not stop them, so as I have said we can agree to disagree.
No. We can't agree to disagree. It's not a mattter of opinion. We are right, and you are wrong.

You can reconcile yourself to being wrong, of course, and we can't stop you.

But you're still wrong.
 
Still in all the time-lines and discussions I have seen popular writes or schoary papers they all speak of universe in the singular.
How is that relevant?

Do you see universe in plural? No and you won't in any paper either! UNIVERSE NOT UNIVERSES (caps for emphasis only)
Again, how is that relevant?

Not universes. I hope we can get over this then maybe we can progress on to the various evidences for the existence of God....
You're still wrong.
 
Are heaven and hell within this universe?

No Mamn' not according to my paradigm. Hell is not a destination for humans in general , and heaven is Gods eternal abode (not that he doesn't visit time from time to time but I see very little evidence for it). In the bible God usually sends an envoy for temporal missions.

"Disclaimer all the above is in general lay terms"

; }>
 
Last edited:
Proof that heaven and hell exist with no bible references please.
 
Last edited:
Wolly said:
Of course a website devoted to discussion of the Big bang doesn't say anything about other universes. Because we have no information, can have no information, about other universes.

Science have theoretical constructions from variations of the BB that describe other universes and how they might come about. I have said that a zillion, maybe 2 zillion times! That is what you have been fighting me about tooth and nail ie (if the BB implies one universe vs you saying it could implies many universes). I am wondering about you Wolly ,I really am! You are backing up and denying what you have already posted.

The Big Bang does not say anything about other universes, only this universe!

You said in an earlier reply that the big bang could generate other universes or doesn’t rule out other universes? Well newsflash VARIATIONS of the BB could theoretically spawn other universes. However I have been saying all along that the STANDARD model of the BB implies one universe.

The Big Bang therefore cannot say anything at all about how many universes there may be, or how many "attempts" were made at making universes before this Universe came into existence.

Have you lost your professional bearing Wolly?
We can describe what other universes may be like but we can not observe them, that is much different than not knowing how they might exist. Everything about the big bang is theory and theoretical constructions.

What part of that concept are you having difficulty with. No paper, or website, discussing the Big Bang will discuss other universes, because the Big Bang doesn't address other universes. So linking to websites about the Big Bang and saying "look, it doesn't mention other universes is an exercise in futility.

You said that the BB does not rule out other universes. I said true but the big bang implies ONE universe.

Please, please, please, explain how the Big Bang can tell us anything about the possibility of other universes. Because that is precisely what you are claiming it can do.

????? Please tell me what is your day job? ( I already know what the members think you do) Anyway, here is one article describing how other universes might come about in the inflationary era of the BB.

“Multiverse (many universes)
Any of various concepts of the universe according to which the region that can be directly observed by us, now or in the future, is only part of an enormous ensemble of such regions, or island universes. The whole is the multiverse: the region we can observe is our universe or the observable universe. The inflationary theory of the Big Bang implies that the observable universe could occupy one ‘bubble’ in a vast sea of such bubbles. Since the boundary of our bubble is receding at the speed of light, owing to the expansion of space, we cannot observe the greater universe beyond. “

There are other much clearer sites where other theoretical variations of the BB describe meta universes. However as I have said so many times, the Standard Model of the BB implies ONE universe. And by implying only one universe it has important theological implications.

; {>

addendum

This is getting complex and long to the point that we are losing sight of why I claim that the BB implies one universe. And that this one universe theory is the prevailing theory. That means that its the best theory we have and best supported.

The reason I am saying that the one universe Big Bang theory is important to theological issues, and it helps the KCA tie into science. That's because anything that begins to exist (the universe) must have a cause if its existence.

And that is what this whole one universe Big Bang theory is the best supported most valid theory we have for the orgins of the universe.

From the web

What is the currently most accepted model for the Universe?

The current best fit model is a flat ΛCDM Big Bang model where the expansion of the Universe is accelerating, and the age of the Universe is 13.7 billion years.

Will the Universe expand forever or re collapse?
This depends on the ratio of the density of the Universe to the critical density. If the density is higher than the critical density the Universe will re collapse in a Big Crunch. But current data suggest that the density is less than or equal to the critical density so the Universe will expand forever. See Part 3 of the

http://www.astro.ucla.edu/~wright/cosmology_faq.html#bestfit

; {>
 
Last edited:
????? Please tell me what is your day job? ( I already know what the members think you do) Anyway, here is one article describing how other universes might come about in the inflationary era of the BB.

“Multiverse (many universes)
Any of various concepts of the universe according to which the region that can be directly observed by us, now or in the future, is only part of an enormous ensemble of such regions, or island universes. The whole is the multiverse: the region we can observe is our universe or the observable universe. The inflationary theory of the Big Bang implies that the observable universe could occupy one ‘bubble’ in a vast sea of such bubbles. Since the boundary of our bubble is receding at the speed of light, owing to the expansion of space, we cannot observe the greater universe beyond. “

There are other much clearer sites where other theoretical variations of the BB describe meta universes. However as I have said so many times, the Standard Model of the BB implies ONE universe. And by implying only one universe it has important theological implications.

; }>
*sigh*

Yes, other universes might come about from variant theories of the standard Big Bang model. But that isn't what we are talking about.

What you are saying is that the Big bang model tells us something about what happened at or "before" T=0, and certainly before the Planck era. But you have already admitted that the standard inflationary hot Big Bang model that you are using tells us nothing about anything before the Planck era.

So which is it? Does the Big Bang model tell us about anything before the Planck era or not? Please make up your mind.
 
We understand why you're so desparate to hold on to your one universe, one try theory, Rev. It's unfortunate for you that it's one of the building blocks of your argument, so I can see that you don't want to give up the point - it means that the rest of your arguments are going to fall flat. But it's just getting silly now, it's clear that your interpretation is just wrong.
 
Ha ha well if I met you I wouldn't say " Hey Pixy do you know that you have a nose stuck on the front of your face? I would hope that that would be obvious. Hey wait I have one for you! Your nose has two holes in it!

~ Really! ~ ....:cool:

Asking me to show a source or prove that the standard model of the big bang implies one universe demonstrates a rank utter misunderstanding of big bang cosmology. Its like me asking one of the members to source a statement like ‘you have a nose on your face’. That the big bang model implies one universe us just as obvious as that! I am not trying to be cute, no I am dead serious! There is a nose hanging right off the front of your face!

Really guys are you serious?

Yup, you use
-argument by assertion
-argument by incredulity
-argument by common sense

all of which are fallacies of construction

GR says that we can not see outside the universe. If you can only see one process, that does bnot imply one process. It is a constraint on information.
 
Generally speaking it says the universe began about 14b years ago. (meta) Universe formation would of occurred in the inflationary era or earlier if quantum loop gravity is to be trusted as a theory.
Nope, speculation is speculation
...






Well you admitted the important part we can work on the above falsehood next.

Fallacy of construction again.

You assert your conclusion and add personal spin.

Your inference is not an implication and again it is GR which says that we can not see outside space/time, not the BBT.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom