The certainty of God's existence.

Oh get off that silly thing. I have already responded to that, maybe you missed it. Jesus Christ beat the money changers out of the temple, his anger was righteous. I feel my little remarks were wholly justified because I had endured so much before I responded, well not even in kind.

If that is the best you can do to demonstrate my hate its just funny that's all. Now I have to clean my keypad off because I spewed my cheerios all over it reading that.

Have a look at some of the comments you have made towards rregg if you want to see real hate.

; {>
When did I say you were demonstrating hate? I just feel you were demonstrating a bit of a nasty side. I never made any attack on you prior to your demand for an apology and I have not made one since.

Oh, and would you be so kind as to point out a single hateful statement that I have made regarding Gerry. Really, I challenge you to provide a single quote of myself that can be characterized as hateful toward Gerry or anyone else.
 
Oh get off that silly thing. I have already responded to that, maybe you missed it. Jesus Christ beat the money changers out of the temple, his anger was righteous. I feel my little remarks were wholly justified because I had endured so much before I responded, well not even in kind.

If that is the best you can do to demonstrate my hate its just funny that's all. Now I have to clean my keypad off because I spewed my cheerios all over it reading that.

Have a look at some of the comments you have made towards rregg if you want to see real hate.

Okay, not only spiteful but also smug and contemptuous.


Who wants revenge?

Gosh, who said this?
Don't worry I am sure you will get everything you deserve with interest compounded for eternity when the time comes. I wish I could be there!


BTW religion bands together people not divides them. There are billions of Christians that banded together. Then we have a billion or more Islamic faithful brothers and sisters. Then Secular/Nonreligious/Agnostic/Atheist: 1.1 billion, then Hinduism: 900 million, then : 394 million in the Chinese traditional religion, then Buddhism: 376 million then, 300 million primal-indigenous, last but not least , when you add up the Secular/Nonreligious.

And many of those people are trying very hard to kill each other - over religion.


And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.

Like the Catholic/Protestant bombings in Ireland and the eternal war in the Middle East? Like the Crusades and Inquisition? Like AIDS spreading like wildfire through Africa while bishops preach against the use of condoms? Like Mother Theresa feeding starving children while denying their parents the knowledge that could have kept them from having more children they couldn't care for? Like the Church's centuries-long war against science? Like two thousand years of persecution against the Jews? Like oppression of women in the Muslim world?

Didn't a devout evangelistic Christian lead us into this mess in Iraq?

Yeah, those secularists are real dangerous guys. :rolleyes:

I don’t but it seems that many of the bad apple heap it upon the devout. I am just exceedingly happy that we have billions more shovels than your guys, we may need them before its over.

And there's more of that Christian tolerance and loving kindness.
 
Who wants revenge?
You it would seem.

BTW religion bands together people not divides them.
False. Religious hatred, bigotry and wars have been the main stay for hundreds of years.

And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.
The wars, greed and other problems associated with secular humanists has no link to secular humanism. There is no dogma that calls for muder or killing. Religion on the other hand contains the warrant for killing throughout the Bible, Koran and other scripture.

Well don’t tell that to the moneychangers that he beat out of the temple with a whip. And when he returns he is going to be just a little angry.
There was no such person but anyone can rationalize vigilantism. It doesn't make it right.

The bible for those that take the time to learn how to read it isn’t contradictory. It’s a collection of texts written for two separate ideals. Your scripture simply means what it says. That’s why I am against the death penalty among other reasons.
All the while hoping and waiting for the day that the humans you percieve as the bad guys are punished and the humans that picked the right religion are not.

Of course! Even in our righteous anger we should forgive.
If you did so there would be no need for righteous anger.

Choice, personal choice is the key. If you choose to play chicken in an interstate without a car you will surely die.
I know that there are cars on the interstate. God? Which god? Does it even exist?

I am just exceedingly happy that we have billions more shovels than your guys, we may need them before its over.
Us vs Them. You don't see me as an equal human being.

BTW: I wasn't going to respond to the absurd statement but the Bible is so full of contradiction it takes major mental gymnastics to get through.

If I tell you something I think is contradictory you might have an explanation for why it is. Here's the problem. 100 christians and Jews will likely have different explanations.

I can demand that I have an explanation for why I believe that the world is flat (not spherical) but an explanation doesn't make it true.
 
Have a look at some of the comments you have made towards rregg if you want to see real hate.
I'm going to challenge you on this.

Yrreg has called atheists stupid and he has had his posts edited for his abusive language.

Could you demonstrate to me anything equal to that that FosterZygote has said?

I think you have serious confirmation bias. Most of the posters responses pale in comparison to yrreg's abuse.

And to the extent that he does recieve abuse, if it exists, I would submit that it is in response to something he has said.

So, I think it very appropriate to hold you to this one. I don't appreciate your claim in the face of the very arrogant and often abusive posts by yrrreg.
 
I am always amused when people accuse atheists of violence and killing, particularly humanist atheists. (What exactly do they think humanist means?)

The atheists aren't the ones claiming someone had to die to fix all of the world's problems...
 
I am always amused when people accuse atheists of violence and killing, particularly humanist atheists. (What exactly do they think humanist means?)

The atheists aren't the ones claiming someone had to die to fix all of the world's problems...

Hi, newby here but I can shed some light on this Atheist/Violence idea.

I think it goes back to the Cold War. During the 80s I was a Born-Again zealot and read lots of propoganda about Communist atrocities. Of course Communists are Atheists, so it follows that all the Stalin-ist/Mao-ist/Ho Chi Minh-ist Gulags etc were the work of "Atheists" and "Secular Humanists."
(Did Ho Chi Minh have Gulags??)

Many Fundamentalist churches really believed Secular Humanism was a Communist plot to corrupt America- I bought into this propoganda for a LONG time...
 
Welcome, Bob!

I have heard that justification before, I can certainly understand why they want to believe such things, and there have been a few threads as to why that claim is false. I mostly find the hypocrisy inherent such statements amusing, or else I would have to despair for the human race.

I am glad to hear you realized that what you were told was propaganda. Enjoy the forums!
 
Hi, newby here but I can shed some light on this Atheist/Violence idea.

I think it goes back to the Cold War. During the 80s I was a Born-Again zealot and read lots of propoganda about Communist atrocities. Of course Communists are Atheists, so it follows that all the Stalin-ist/Mao-ist/Ho Chi Minh-ist Gulags etc were the work of "Atheists" and "Secular Humanists."
(Did Ho Chi Minh have Gulags??)

Many Fundamentalist churches really believed Secular Humanism was a Communist plot to corrupt America- I bought into this propoganda for a LONG time...
Hi Bob,

BTW: If that's you on that stupid enzyte commercial please wipe that stupid grin off your face. The stuff doesn't really work.

Anyway, welcome to the forum.

Yeah, I advocated this view at one time. The problem is that the attrocity was the result of dogmatic adherence to fundamentalist beliefs (Communism) and cultures of personality.

There is no text or dogma that exists because of atheism that provides the warrant for abbuse and attrocity. The same can't be said of religion.
 
MikeSun said:
Good FSM in alfredo sauce, you are wrong! If ontological arguments are considered evidence, then why would't "intuition" and "reason" (being the basis of said arguments) hold up in court as evidence? You avoided that question once, but rejecting/ignoring the tough questions doesn't make them go away.

Cases are won on circumstantial evidence, and intuition and reason are used in the decision making process that ultimately end up as a guilty or innocent verdict. [/quote]

You seem so convinced that an argument "based on intuition and reason" is evidence, I started to doubt myself. So I looked up the word evidence. If you notice, the definition does not contain the words "argument," "intuition," or "reason." So, please read the link and learn what evidence means. Please read all definitions and try to understand them before you reply, that will save me loads of time.

I know what it means you simply are too much of a baby to admit defeat.

Just guessing at definitions and hoping you're right leaves lots and lots of room for error. (hey! :idea: just like religion!)

Or; (hey! :idea: just like athiesm)

...the wars. atheists. cause. :covereyes Yes, because nobody fights in the name of God.

I could fight in the name of mike that doesn't mean that mike condones it

I'm glad you posted this. I now realize I'm conversing with someone who does not have a firm grip on reality. Saves me even more time.

Reported , have a nice day.

; }>
 
We don't hate Yregg,we love him for the many laughs he gives us.You are very amusing too,thank you.

Sure you do!. <<<---- sarcasm.... it seems to me that you absolutely hate him. If you really do love him I sure wouldn't want to see how you respond to someone you hate.

; {>
 
BTW religion bands together people not divides them.
Actually, it does both. Are you really going to ignore the astonishing amount of violence committed throughout human history in the name of religion? Even in the Old Testament in books like Joshua and Judges we find glorification of religiously motivated genocide.

There are billions of Christians that banded together. Then we have a billion or more Islamic faithful brothers and sisters.
And these two groups alone have never engaged in bloody warfare over their respective beliefs?

And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.
That appears to be a rather loaded statement. You seem to be implying that secular humanism is more likely to lead to such wars than Christianity. Can you name any wars that were started in the name of secular humanism? I can name several conducted by Christians out of greed.

The bible for those that take the time to learn how to read it isn’t contradictory. It’s a collection of texts written for two separate ideals. Your scripture simply means what it says. That’s why I am against the death penalty among other reasons.
There are a great many contradictions to be found within the Bible. For example: who was the father of Joseph the husband of Mary? And the Bible is certainly not prohibitive of punishment by death. It lists quite a few crimes for which it then proscribes the punishment of death. Heck, the Bible even advocates slavery.

Jim Jones was satanic in my book, but that goes for all groups.
No True Scotsman fallacy.
 
In that case, you cannot prove that God exists. If you actually believe what you just wrote, your argument is not only wrong, but a priori pointless.

No one can really prove anything to a perfect accuracy. (remember my teaching? Nothing is 100% certain?) However we can prove something to a reasonable level that most would agree, that is the best we can do. When in a court of law what do you think proving something beyond a reasonable doubt means? Here is some source information; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_doubt

; {>
 
Sure you do!. <<<---- sarcasm.... it seems to me that you absolutely hate him. If you really do love him I sure wouldn't want to see how you respond to someone you hate.
It's easy to see the beam in anothers eye.

Your responses at times would mostly certainly call for a similar response.

I wonder if yrreg hates people or just likes to abuse them.
 
How is it not cherry picking? Why is it that there Christian sects that disagree with you?

That the many, many instances of Christ's exhortations to forgive and to have hope for one's enimies were actually the true sentiments of Christ and not a hand full of cherry picked scriptures used to justify what they view as sin.

Well, first what exactly is cherry picking? If you reference an encyclopedia to prove a point that's not cherry picking. And that is how I reference the bible. I can defend my beliefs with scripture which simply means I am a Christian. I too try to live by the teachings of christ so I don't know what you are speaking of.

You will have to give me precise examples of what and why you think I 'cherry pick' scripture. Then I can either defend my words or not.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Sure you do!. <<<---- sarcasm.... it seems to me that you absolutely hate him. If you really do love him I sure wouldn't want to see how you respond to someone you hate.

; {>

Nobody hates yrreG. There are many who are exasperated at his dishonesty in arguing his cause. If you could get him to honestly address other posters' reasoned arguments for one week, I would donate $100 to your food kitchen.
 
Well, first what exactly is cheery picking? If you reference an encyclopedia to prove a point that's not cherry picking. And that is how I reference the bible. I can defend my beliefs with scripture which simply means I am a Christian. I too try to live by the teachings of christ so I don't know what you are speaking of.

You will have to give me precise examples of what and why you think I 'cherry pick' scripture. Then I can either defend my words or not.

; {>

Generally, the problem with using references from the bible is that different parts contradict each other. The only way to resolve this would be to assume that the surrounding text provides a very specific context. As such, any reference from the bible, must, in all fairness, come with a hefty amount of context.
 
Lord Emsworth said:
Unfortunately, the ontological arguments aren't at all. That is, they are not proof or evidence for anything in particular. They are word games; at best defining something in the most general terms in the real world as "God."

So is mathematical constructs word games. I agree that ontological arguments are weaker than the KCA for example and just mentioned them in passing. Still they are a valid form of argument.

For an analogy, you can easily define that the top, i.e. the highest point of any mountain be called "peak." No problem at all. If there is a mountain, there is also a peak.

Yes, ontological arguments use reason and common sense.

Likewise, you can insist that the necessary bits/greatest bits/whatever of reality be called "God." And if there is a reality - and there is - then "God" by definition exists as well. No problem either.

Correct. If you agree to the conditions of the argument.

Except that people expect something more than that, and there is really no need for any convoluted eyewashing. ;)

Yes that's why ontological arguments are not satisfying to me and its why I would rather use a cosmological argument to describe my reasons for believing in a supernatural/metaphysical first cause. However an ontological argument describing the same thing (God) is like using another math to describe the same problem. Saying that one is less satisfying than the other does not detract from the credibility of either one.

Of course, that you can call stuff names is not what is debated or denied by atheists. Of course we could call the necessary bits of reality (for example) "God." Of course we could call the maximally great thingamajig (along with its now fully meaningless omnis) "God."

I know were you are going with this, if the FSM has the attributes of God it doesn't mean that the FSM is a derogatory fabrication dreamed up by christian haters, it would be God.

But ... underneath the words and letters? Nothing would change at all. There'd still be the particulars left to be hashed out.

Yes correct

We'd be arguing, to switch back in the analogy, whether the peak of our mountain that we've "proven" to exist is made of granite rock, or rather chocolate. Is it covered in pixie dust? Are bigfoots living there? And what does "chocolate" mean anyway? Will any brownish stuff do?

Well, yes but it wouldn't matter because we are trying to show that the mountain has a peak, and that peak is God. Look I agree with you that ontological arguments are not satisfying, that's why I do not use one as my primary argument for evidence of Gods existence. And this well written reply is another reason I don't use ontological arguments, its too easy for a layperson observer to discount an ontological argument even though its correct.

It is not entirely different with the KCA. Only that with the KCA - apart from the utter meaninglessness of its conclusion(s) - you have its unsound premises and its invalidity, that make for gorgeous red herrings, as additional "benefits."[/spoiler]

The premises to anyone that does not have an ax to grind. In fact they are undeniably sound. And the conclusion that God did it is a reasonable rational conclusion IMO.

; {>
 
Last edited:
No one can really prove anything to a perfect accuracy. (remember my teaching? Nothing is 100% certain?)

Forget this guy, he's just here to preach, in case this wasn't obvious until now. There's nothing more to gain from going forward with this. He's already been disproven on every account possible. Even for bystanders it is obvious by now.
 
That's good to hear. I'll let Northern Ireland know you've sorted out all of their problems.

In every large group there are going to be a few that muck it up. However when you consider all the worlds religions the northern Ireland thing is not worth mentioning. I mean nearly five billion religion total (Just guessing I didn't add up all the religions) vs a few radical Catholics and Protestants? Come on. As I said wars fought over secular concerns far far outweigh religious war.

; {>
 
This thread has gotten long and difficult to follow all the nuances. Let me see if I understand the several points that have been made:

The frustraion level is rising and so goes the posts that contain personal material. Its like a bunch of toothless loins trying to find a soft spot on a turtle. In the end they will either choke or go away hungry. Thanks for adding to the situation fisher.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom