So is mathematical constructs word games.
No, mathematical constructs are mathematical constructs.
I agree that ontological arguments are weaker than the KCA for example
That's pretty sad, then.
and just mentioned them in passing. Still they are a valid form of argument.
Internally, maybe. But certainly not a sound form of argument.
Yes, ontological arguments use reason and common sense.
Well,
there's your problem.
Try logic and evidence instead. It actually works.
Correct. If you agree to the conditions of the argument.
But all you've achieved then is redefining God to fit your argument. So God is now chocolate ice cream, or some such.
Yes that's why ontological arguments are not satisfying to me and its why I would rather use a cosmological argument to describe my reasons for believing in a supernatural/metaphysical first cause.
As we have seen, though, your cosmological argument is a complete failure too.
However an ontological argument describing the same thing (God) is like using another math to describe the same problem. Saying that one is less satisfying than the other does not detract from the credibility of either one.
No. What detracts from their credibility is the multitude of logical fallacies.
I know were you are going with this, if the FSM has the attributes of God it doesn't mean that the FSM is a derogatory fabrication dreamed up by christian haters, it would be God.
RevD, you have hate on the brain. It's a problem.
Well, yes but it wouldn't matter because we are trying to show that the mountain has a peak, and that peak is God.
If you redefined "God" to mean "six million tons of granite... or possibly chocolate", sure.
Unhelpful, though.
Look I agree with you that ontological arguments are not satisfying, that's why I do not use one as my primary argument for evidence of Gods existence. And this well written reply is another reason I don't use ontological arguments, its too easy for a layperson observer to discount an ontological argument even though its correct.
Correct? It's a unicorn hunt. (To explain, since this might not show up on your list of fallacies, it's a form of cherry-picking, coupled with equivocation. You find
something, and call it a unicorn. Which doesn't make it a unicorn.)
The premises to anyone that does not have an ax to grind.
That sentence no verb. But what you are trying to say is clear, and false, and an appeal to motive.
In fact they are undeniably sound.
Soundness is a property of an argument, not a premise. Premises are true or false. All of yours are false.
If they are undeniable, then it should be easy for you to support them. So, please do. Start with P1. Work your way forward.
And the conclusion that God did it is a reasonable rational conclusion IMO.
If all the premises were true, there would still be
at least two non-sequiturs involved. So no, it is neither reasonable nor rational.