The certainty of God's existence.

The certainty of God is another kind and degree of human certainty.

Then there is the pseudo certainty of people atheists who insist that there is no God.

Can you please explain what the difference is between these two certainties?

(Not that you're going to even read this post let alone respond to it)
 
It seems that the one side keeps logically arguing for a first cause, and the other side says why can't it go back forever or why is the first cause "personal". Did I miss the post where it was explained how we know First Cause=God?
No, you didn't miss that post.
 
I, for one, am convinced by yrreg's arguments.

He says he knows for certain that God exists. He knows for certain!

And after so many threads and so many pages of declaring his certainty, I finally see he must be right... because he is as certain as he is of the nose on his face and his external sex organ.

You see, if his nose exists and his external sex organ exists, God must also exist, because he is just as certain of God's existence as he is of his nose and external sex organ.

All of Christianity then logically flows from external-sex-organ-certainty.

The Freudian argument for the existence of God? (And what about, "Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar"?)

But can you imagine the ritual that would arise? (Sorry.) The bishop's crosier, the pope's tiara, all the holy phallic symbols...
 
BTW, The KCA (which has never been defeated) is only one of many cosmological arguments.
In fact come to think of it, cosmological arguments really have been defeated.

First, unless Hume's problem of necessary connection has been solved and I didn't find out, it is invalid in the first place to use causality as the basis for a metaphysical argument.

And in the second place all cosmological arguments are based on the unjustified dogma that anything with a beginning must have an antecedent cause.

We know that there is no logical necessity for the Universe to have an antecedent cause. The universe may or may not have a cause.

But the corollary is that even if the universe does have a cause there is no necessity that it be "eternal" or "timeless".

And even if the cause was timeless there is no necessity that it have a mind. Physicists are already speculating about new theories which might eliminate space-time as the basis for a description of reality.

So anybody who bases there religious belief - even in part - upon the cosmological argument is pretty much fooling him/herself.
 
The KCA (which has never been defeated) is only one of many cosmological arguments. Additionally Its only one component of a few that I use to validate that God exists.
The KCA is fatally flawed because it isn't parsimonious. Period. The KCA suffers from the turtles all the way down problem. Who caused god?

Asserting that god has always existed and/or exists outside of time is turtles all the way down. Mental gymnastics doesn't help.
 
All right, I guess I'll restate things in a more serious way. I don't "deny the existence of God." I am not an atheist. I do deny that there is any way in which to logically prove the "certainty of God's existence." I am not a theist. I choose to mindfully experience God as I understand the transcendence of God, so I am a contemplative. There is no understanding and no certainty; to speak about God is to fill a bowl which must be empty (there is also no bowl, no fullness, and no emptiness), so I am a mystic. The human mind is the most astonishing thing there is. :) I'm still trying to figure out a good theology for that. But really, yyreg, why not respond to some of these things? Why not prove that you want to do something with this thread besides baiting atheists?[/QUOTE]


But he's had so much practice, he's a master baiter
 
your nose, your external sex organs...are proofs enough that God exists

Yrreg

Quit clowning around. Come on, nobody is buying that your whole belief in god(s) rests on your having a penis and a nose. Children who believe in Santa Claus might believe as you do but not adults.

Really now, what is the evidence that convinced you of god(s)?
 
That post from me was an invitation for atheists to think of the kinds and degrees of certainty.


So this means that you are not going to, or do not have to, comment on anything that I said in my post?

That post from you contained 565 words and a number of different topics.

In the post you:
  • Commented that it is good that atheists are aware of their noses and sex organs.

  • Asked atheists to think about how they are certain of the existence of their noses and sex organs.

  • Asked if anyone was aware that there are those who would argue that you can not be certain of the existence of noses and sex organs.

  • Demonstrated that noses and sex organs can be certified to exist because you can touch them.

  • Demonstrated that one's own existence (as well as others') can be certified by conducting the lead pipe experiment and observing the results.

  • Asked why it is important to be certain of God's existence.

  • Argued that this certainty is important lots of people.

  • Claimed that it is not of any importance to atheists.

  • Claimed that atheists talk all the time and write articles and books showing that certainty of the existence of God is not important to them.

  • Claimed that atheists talk all the time and write articles and books attempting to prove that God does not exist.

  • Claimed that atheists suffer from Theophobia.

  • Pointed out that other individuals think atheists are under the influence of Satan.

  • Asked what the certainty of the existence of noses and sex organs has to do with the certainty of God's existence.

  • Restated your "definition" of God, again.

The points highlighted in red, brought up by you, are what I was responding to.


Back to certainty about God's existence, that post you responded to is an invitation for atheists to think about the kinds and degrees of certainty.


You said that once. I demonstrated above that my reply to your post was appropriate due to the points brought up in the post itself, by you, as well as the topic of this thread, namely: The certainty of God's existence.

Here's the link to my post again, for your convenience:
(http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4989904&postcount=429)

I await your response.
 
First you owe me an aplogy for telling lies about my beleifs. If I can go back and find the offending post you can to.
Lies? Aren't you being a little histrionic? I'm sorry if you didn't like the exact wording of my statement, but you did reject Buddhism, yes? Buddhism has been around for some 2500 years, yes? This fact runs counter to your defense of the KCA based on its age, yes?
 
Day-yamn ! I have lost count of how many people I am trying to answer. I think at least six people are all talking at the same time. Anyway before my lunch break someone asked me to explain P6, adding that they really did not understand it. Well, in my opinion P6 is a weak link in the premises. Its not readily understandable to a secular mind (because most secular people think in a different manner than metaphysical thinkers. Think Godel sitting with the logical positivists at the Vienna circle) Godel was a metaphysical thinker others brilliant logical positivists.

I do not agree fully with Dr Craig on P-6. I am more than likely wrong because every time I questioned Dr Craig he has prevailed graciously. It was I that did not understand his argument! Some of his argument touches on GR tensed and untensed to, etc.

Anyway, I know what Dr Craig take P6 is. Do you want my explanation or Dr Craigs ideas concerning P6? I am sure Dr Craigs metaphysical treatise wont be satisfying to any 'positive' thinker. Nor will mine I suppose, considering some of the responses I have been receiving. So what shall it be my or Craigs proposal on C-6. I am just trying to cut down on my work load, because Koon and a few other philosophers have slightly different ideas.

I hope this makes sense I just woke up.

; {>
 
Lies? Aren't you being a little histrionic? I'm sorry if you didn't like the exact wording of my statement, but you did reject Buddhism, yes? Buddhism has been around for some 2500 years, yes? This fact runs counter to your defense of the KCA based on its age, yes?

For the THIRD time;

Foster Zygote writes; " You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is, in fact, older than Christianity. If your above reasoning is valid, then why are there still Buddhists after twenty-five centuries?
You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is, in fact, older than Christianity. If your above reasoning is valid, then why are there still Buddhists after twenty-five centuries?"

Rev Writes; "After that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak."

Please get your claims correct in the future? I have a difficult enough time defending myself , your fabrications don't help....
; {>

The exact wording was incorrect. I said I still use some Buddhist/eastern mysticism beliefs. I did not say I rejected it I said it was unsatisfying like wanting a steak instead of salad. If I said Buddhism was like eating dog poo when I wanted a steak, you might say that was rejecting Buddhism.

So yes an apology. I deserve something for having to look it up twice to defend myself. It gets old.

; {>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom