The Bush Resume

Tricky said:

Thanks DJ, but I don't ascribe that motive to RanFan. He admits to being a Clinton supporter, and most of his positions aren't radical. I do not understand why he has taken such a protective stance on GWB, because it is inconsistant with his usual rational (if right-of-center) approach to things, but I'll not say it is a mindless sheep mentality.

Maybe some of the others, though...:p

(And I have voted for Republicans too.)
Thanks Tricky,

Your words mean allot to me.

I have always been passionate and right now I am having one of those weeks. One of my clients has sat on an invoice for nearly a month. I didn't know this and was expecting the money and the virus is giving me fits with several of my clients servers. So my passions are rather sensitive.

I genuinely like Bush. It might have just been rhetoric but I believe in the concept of passionate conservative or something like that. I like his father and I like him. I don't think he is perfect and I accept that he has had a privileged life but then so have many of the elites that are so looked up to by many on the left.

I welcome debate, discussion, criticism and even mockery of the institution and even the person. Just allow me the right to rebut without assuming that I am blind a right wing robot.

Again, thanks Tricky.
 
"I welcome debate, discussion, criticism and even mockery of the institution and even the person."

Don't think so. What Kenny did was mockery, and you didn't welcome it. By making this distinction about "to his face" you want to define what is acceptable mockery.

"I have posted critisism of Bush on this forum. I have posted jokes about Bush on this forum. I have posted embarassing things about Bush on this forum. I would never be such a prick and a coward as to smile at someone while I flipped them off."

None of that was to his face. I doubt you would say the same things if you met him. I'll assume you'll say you would, OK?

What Kenny did was innocuous. Most people don't even see the secret sign without pointing it out. Only way he could do it and not be subject to being forcefully ejected and subject to harrassment by certain government agencies, which he probably will be anyway.

Methinks you doth protesteth too much.

But I understand your point.

Edited to add:
P.S. Sympathies with the invoice thing, I got the same situation right now. If it ain't in the mailbox today I'm screwed.
 
Re: Re: The Bush Resume

dwb said:


Good job pasting a useless E-mail message into a topic. Crikey...

Good technique: the points you know are true you blow off as unimportant. The ones you aren't sure about, you want proof. Read the papers, don't just listen to Rush Limbaugh's distortions. I am not going to spend a lot of time trying to convice someone of anything who equates a drunk driving conviction with the struggle for independence. Wow. That's a new low even for a Bush apologist.

Edited to add:
RandFan
I genuinely like Bush. It might have just been rhetoric but I believe in the concept of passionate conservative or something like that

It's compassionate conservatism. You believe in it without even knowing what the term is? If that doesn't show your blind allegiance to anything this man does, I don't know what would. Personally, I'll at least need to know what something is before I'll willingly believe in it.
 
RandFan said:
I have always been passionate and right now I am having one of those weeks. One of my clients has sat on an invoice for nearly a month. I didn't know this and was expecting the money and the virus is giving me fits with several of my clients servers. So my passions are rather sensitive.
Very sorry to hear that. My home PC is diseased and I am going to wipe and reload this weekend. What a pain. Hope your clients are understanding.

RandFan said:
I genuinely like Bush. It might have just been rhetoric but I believe in the concept of passionate conservative or something like that. I like his father and I like him.
I think Dubya would be a great beer-drinking pal (just don't get him started on religion!), but simply not presidential caliber. The same was not true of his dad. Although I disagreed with a lot of what GHWB did, he was no idiot. He coined the term "voo-doo economics" and gave Reagan a good run for his money. I was disappointed that he sold out to him and even more disappointed when he showed no spine during Iran-Contra, but I think he did a good job during Desert Storm. It was a measured and appropriate reaction to an attack on one of our allies. He also understood foreign policy, having been CIA director, and did pretty well, except for throwing up on the Japanese Prime Minister.

RandFan said:
I don't think he is perfect and I accept that he has had a privileged life but then so have many of the elites that are so looked up to by many on the left.
I don't care that he is rich, or that many of the left are rich either. But he is like a charicature of a spoiled rich kid. He does his best to help his rich friends while ignoring the poor. He expects his past to be covered up for him. He had his rich friends bail him out every time he had a failed business. He got into College because of his rich connections. He got out of Viet Nam because of his connections. He has no sense of noblesse oblige. If he had taken advantage of all his wealth and connections to become a smart, thoughtful, commanding person, then I would respect him a lot more. Instead, he seems to simply turn over the running of the country to his puppeteers.

As a person, Dubya may be a nice guy. As the leader of the most powerful country in the world, he is almost a total failure.

RandFan said:
I welcome debate, discussion, criticism and even mockery of the institution and even the person. Just allow me the right to rebut without assuming that I am blind a right wing robot.
I hope that is what we will do. It is easy for me and you and everyone else here to let their emotions enter the arguments, so we sometimes have to back off and cool down. I don't agree with some of the arguing tactics of my ideological comrades (give it a rest, Ion ;)) but we are all only human. Except for Ed.

RandFan said:
Again, thanks Tricky.
You have done the same for me often.
 
I cannot remember the quote exactly, or even who said it. But this ongoing debate about GWB reminds me of this statement:

“Democracy does not guarantee that we will get the government we need. But we often get the government we deserve.”
 
Re: Re: Re: The Bush Resume

Mark said:
Good technique: the points you know are true you blow off as unimportant. The ones you aren't sure about, you want proof.
Close, but no cigar. It's more like: Concede that there are some valid points, but point out that there's plenty of fluff in there as well. I have nothing wrong with relevant criticisms on the job Bush is doing as president (if you've read my stuff on the forums, you would see that I myself have criticized him as well). What I dislike are the cheap pot shots, like some of the ones you posted. I don't like them now, and I didn't like them a few years ago when they were cheap shots at Clinton, either.

Mark said:
Read the papers, don't just listen to Rush Limbaugh's distortions.
I do read the papers, and I don't listen to Rush Limbaugh. How 'bout one for you: don't make assumptions on the person you're arguing with.

Mark said:
I am not going to spend a lot of time trying to convice someone of anything who equates a drunk driving conviction with the struggle for independence. Wow. That's a new low even for a Bush apologist.
A drunk driving conviction 20+ years ago is irrelevant today. Obviously the guy learned something from it. You're the one that posted proclaiming Bush as the first president that was a criminal when elected, I'm just the one that pointed out you're wrong.

BTW, good technique on your part as well: accuse me of being something I'm not (a Bush apologist), then write me off as part of an un-convincible group of disciples. My intention was never to justify Bush's actions, but rather, to point out the absurdity of the E-mail.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: The Bush Resume

dwb said:
Close, but no cigar. It's more like: Concede that there are some valid points, but point out that there's plenty of fluff in there as well. I have nothing wrong with relevant criticisms on the job Bush is doing as president (if you've read my stuff on the forums, you would see that I myself have criticized him as well). What I dislike are the cheap pot shots, like some of the ones you posted. I don't like them now, and I didn't like them a few years ago when they were cheap shots at Clinton, either.

I do read the papers, and I don't listen to Rush Limbaugh. How 'bout one for you: don't make assumptions on the person you're arguing with.

A drunk driving conviction 20+ years ago is irrelevant today. Obviously the guy learned something from it. You're the one that posted proclaiming Bush as the first president that was a criminal when elected, I'm just the one that pointed out you're wrong.

BTW, good technique on your part as well: accuse me of being something I'm not (a Bush apologist), then write me off as part of an un-convincible group of disciples. My intention was never to justify Bush's actions, but rather, to point out the absurdity of the E-mail.

I accept your criticism; I did make assumptions about you, for which I don't have sufficient evidence. I apologize for that.

As for the rest of it, all those points are all matters of public reord. If, as you seem to indicate, you are really only interested in the truth, then I suggest you do a Google search on any of them. I do not have the time in my day to do the research for you...nor should I have to if you are truly interested in the facts.

And yes, when a President sets himself up as some sort of moral compass, as this one has done, then I do think his drunk driving conviction is relevant. As is his alleged history of drug abuse. It was fair game with Clinton; why can't we ask the same of Bush?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: The Bush Resume

Mark said:
I accept your criticism; I did make assumptions about you, for which I don't have sufficient evidence. I apologize for that.
Yes, well, my tone could have been a little more gentle, too. I'm no insurance adjuster, but I'd say we were both at fault. Let's just hug and call it even! :)

Mark said:
And yes, when a President sets himself up as some sort of moral compass, as this one has done, then I do think his drunk driving conviction is relevant. As is his alleged history of drug abuse. It was fair game with Clinton; why can't we ask the same of Bush?
Agreed, somewhat. As for the drunk driving conviction, it's something that happened in the '70s, he admitted to it, and it hasn't happened since. He doesn't even drink any more. Even as a moral compass, he stands the test because he made a mistake, realized it, and eventually took action to assure it would never happen again (i.e. quit drinking). That's A-OK in my book, I hardly expect anyone to be perfect.

As for the recreational drug use as a young'n, I don't think it was relevant when Clinton ran and I don't think it should be for Bush. Kudos to Clinton for trying to be more open about it (does anyone really believe he didn't inhale?), but if happened 20+ years ago and they learned their lesson, I'm okay with that.

Look, people do dumb things when they are young, and if they learn quickly enough, we shouldn't fault them for being young and stupid. One could even argue that he understands how dangerous drugs can be, because he's tried them.

Now, if he was snortin' coke as governor of Texas, I would say that it should be an issue during a presidential campaign. I do see the difference between minor offenses many years ago, and a chronic problem.
 
subgenius said:
"I welcome debate, discussion, criticism and even mockery of the institution and even the person."

Don't think so. What Kenny did was mockery, and you didn't welcome it. By making this distinction about "to his face" you want to define what is acceptable mockery.

"I have posted critisism of Bush on this forum. I have posted jokes about Bush on this forum. I have posted embarassing things about Bush on this forum. I would never be such a prick and a coward as to smile at someone while I flipped them off."

None of that was to his face. I doubt you would say the same things if you met him. I'll assume you'll say you would, OK?

What Kenny did was innocuous. Most people don't even see the secret sign without pointing it out. Only way he could do it and not be subject to being forcefully ejected and subject to harrassment by certain government agencies, which he probably will be anyway.

Methinks you doth protesteth too much.
Fair enough, I'll give you the last word.

But I understand your point.

Edited to add:
P.S. Sympathies with the invoice thing, I got the same situation right now. If it ain't in the mailbox today I'm screwed.
What kills me is it is not like it's someone trying to balance the books on my efforts which is bad enough but if it is because there is no money then there is no option. But this project couldn't even be started without being funded.
 
No! I want the last word! But I don't have one. It's been a fun debate, fellas.

Wait, here's one (my own; if anyone else ever said it, I don't want to know):

Voting for the lesser of 2 evils is still voting for evil.
 
"it is a mindless sheep mentality"

RandFan: I'm sorry, I didn't mean to directly accuse you of such an attitude, although it was your post that did prompt me to reply. I specifically didn't name you because, as others have pointed out, I don't believe your views are dogmatic and blindly follow any one political bias.

I also liked the GWB campaign "compassionate conservatism" talk. Sadly, it was just that, talk. He has done little to demonstrate he was serious and actually did give a damn.

I also believe he performed very well the few months following 9/11, at least as it relates to reacting to that tragedy. However, I don't believe his actions were extraordinary and beyond that of what I would expect from any reasonable person.

He actions the past year to year to 18 months, however, as Tricky pointed out, have been abysmal. I completely agree with won't reiterate Tricky's excellent analyses.

I will continue to question peoples apparent blind support of GWB in light of all this. That's what prompted my comments.
 
Re: Re: The Bush Resume

dwb said:


Is this true? Have you researched the other 42 presidents, or is this just more drivel?


Thank you for jogging my memory.

According to David McCullough in his recent biography of John Adams, Adams essentially took the last 2 years of his Presidency off.

I don't know if it adds up, but towards the end of Jefferson's term he would spend large times of it away from Washington.

Ike really like to fish a lot.

TR did a lot of hiking and nature trips.

I think we can safely classify the above charge as hyperbole as is most of the e-mail.
 
Re: Re: Re: The Bush Resume

Mike B. said:


Thank you for jogging my memory.

According to David McCullough in his recent biography of John Adams, Adams essentially took the last 2 years of his Presidency off.

I don't know if it adds up, but towards the end of Jefferson's term he would spend large times of it away from Washington.

Ike really like to fish a lot.

TR did a lot of hiking and nature trips.

I think we can safely classify the above charge as hyperbole as is most of the e-mail.

I have no idea what you guys are debating but its hardly fair to compare taking time off during the time of John Adams, Jefferson with anything like what's going on today.
 
"As for the recreational drug use as a young'n, I don't think it was relevant when Clinton ran and I don't think it should be for Bush."
The problem is that his putative supporters did make it an issue with until their guy was on the spot.
Kudos to you if it wasn't an issue.
Although, I believe there's a big difference between cannabis or alcohol use, and alcohol, cannabis or cocaine abuse.
No evidence of abuse in one case, evidence of alcohol, cannabis and cocaine abuse in the other.
Not to suggest that a person in recovery is disqualified from anything.
Two further issues:
GWB has adamantly denied participation in any program of recovery.
The hypocrisy.
 
subgenius said:
The problem is that his putative supporters did make it an issue with until their guy was on the spot.
Kudos to you if it wasn't an issue.
I should make it clear that I in no way condone recreational drug use, or breaking of the law by using controlled substances.

However, if it's something that was done for a very short time many years ago, I consider it a non-issue. If Clinton or Bush made a couple bad choices when they were 22, well, I can hardly fault them as 50-somethings (how old are they, anyway?)

Indeed, the propaganda machine was in full force to exploit Clinton's admission of marijuana use, and that same machine was silent on Bush's cocaine use. Funny that.
 
subgenius said:

Wrong.
Most of them have some achievments, and qualifications, even if you can also find "bad stuff" to put on the resume.

Maybe you'd like to take my challenge to list George's achievments that qualified him to be president?
Warning, no generalities accepted.

Bonus points for Clarence Thomas' "qualifications."

Uhm, you think that that 'resume' was an genuine attempt at listing Bush's achievements? No, it was just a compilation of all the 'bad' things that he has done. Never mind the fact that many of those things are not under his sole control and others are a matter of opinion as to whether or not they are 'bad.' Anyone who has the time can make one for any president. I will not take you up on your offer since I do not care enough about Bush to research any achievements he may have had before becoming president. The phoney resume is obviously not a serious criticism of Bush, it is just a fallacy filled rant by someone who does not like him.
 
ssibal said:

Uhm, you think that that 'resume' was an genuine attempt at listing Bush's achievements?
...
The thing is that I cannot think of one achievement by Bush since he took office in January 2001, two and a half years ago.

He starts issues bigger than his abilities and is incapable to address and finish them.
 
Ion said:

The thing is that I cannot think of one achievement by Bush since he took office in January 2001, two and a half years ago.

Well, like many things in the fake resume it is all up to opinion. What you see as a 'bad' thing someone else may see as an achievement. I am against his faith based initiative but unfortunately many people see that as an achievement. Now, I see the removal of Saddam and his regime as an achievement while others do not. It all depends on who you ask, the fake resume is not very objective.
 
RandFan said:
I genuinely like Bush. It might have just been rhetoric but I believe in the concept of passionate conservative or something like that. I like his father and I like him. I don't think he is perfect and I accept that he has had a privileged life but then so have many of the elites that are so looked up to by many on the left.
Well, my take is that "lik[ing]" someone is no substitute for respecting them. Bush Sr.'s Iran-Contra involvement, his slimy use of Willy Horton (against Dukakis), and his assertion that atheists are not American citizens are just three things that come to mind which serve to cancel out any so-called likability. Frankly, I think repugnance is a better fit.

As to the son, it is even more to the point. While he no doubt pets doggies and kisses babies, his person-to-person "charm" has all the sincerity of a frat boy or salesman.

You may disagree, and I can respect an opposing opinion. I would, however, ask that anyone interested in analysis of GWB's deeds as opposed to what he says is "in [his] heart" take five minutes the next time they are in a bookstore and just read the introduction to "The Bush Dyslexicon" by Mark Crispin Miller.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom