The Bush Resume

And BTW, I should add that I find some of the content of the "resume" leading off this thread to be spurious and tenuous. No need to exaggerate when the truth will do quite nicely.
 
subgenius said:
Still waiting to hear about his achievments that qualified him for the office.
What do you consider adequate qualification for the job? He was a businessman and the governor of a large state. What more is needed? Presidents need to know how to run the executive branch, and they need to be a good "front man".

Whether Bush was a good governor, and how good a front man he was, it was for the voters to decide. He lost the popular vote, which chaps a lot of people, but hey, that's the electoral college for you. Don't like it? Campaign to get it repealed.

I'm curious to know how being vice president necessarily qualifies you to be president more than being a governor does. The office of the VP, depending on the president, can be merely one big dog and pony show. Look how much Truman was left in the dark.

I don't think Bush is a wonderful president, but we could have done a lot worse.
 
"Still waiting to hear about his achievments that qualified him for the office."

We're well in to the era where name recognition or "celebrity" is the primary "achievement" necessary to hold political office. Bush is president because his father was president. I don't believe GWB is stupid, he has been smart enough to know how to take advantage of his family name and what's been given him. I also believe if his father wasn't president, GWB wouldn't be either. I would love to see someone make a compelling case otherwise.
 
If he was a governor or businessman and failed that wouldn't be an achievment.
I take it the answer is "I don't know of any."
"Could do worse" is like "Not an imbecile" hardly a qualification for any job.
I don't want to beat him up, I think the point has been made.
I hope we all get through OK.
 
subgenius said:
I take it the answer is "I don't know of any."
What do you consider adequate qualification for the job? He was a businessman and the governor of a large state. What more is needed?

What is considered sufficient qualifications for me might not be for you, so, what do you consider as possible qualifications to be president?
 
dwb said:
What do you consider adequate qualification for the job? He was a businessman and the governor of a large state. What more is needed?

What is considered sufficient qualifications for me might not be for you, so, what do you consider as possible qualifications to be president?
Please just answer the question. Do you know of any (however you define it)?
Last time, if he failed at the jobs you cite those wouldn't be achievments, right?

Come on this shouldn't be so difficult. He's president.
 
dwb said:
I don't think Bush is a wonderful president, but we could have done a lot worse.

With an annual deficit of almost 3/4 of a trillion dollars; Osama, and Mullah Omar still on the loose; 2 countries invaded and nothing accomplished; the 1st and 4th ammendments under serious assault...

How eaxctly could we have done a lot worse?
 
Look, if y'all want to criticize Bush, at least make the criticisms valid.

What specific policy measures has Bush supported/created that were a failure? I'll start: The Patriot Act. I don't think they can offer evidence that it has decreased the risk of homeland terrorism, yet it has encroached on our privacy rights. My turn again: he has yet to veto a spending bill, contributing to massive budget deficits.

If you say he's not qualified for the job, then say what you think is adequate qualification. Bill Clinton was the governor of a medium-sized state rated almost dead last in education metrics such as standardized test scores. Ronald Reagan was an actor and the governor of a large state. Bush (43) was a businessman and governor of a large state.

Cheap shots are all well and good, but they don't accomplish much. Saying he's a failure without pointing out why, saying he's not qualified, then demanding that other people justify his qualifications, isn't much better. Why isn't he qualified for the job?

Edited to add: Whoops, looks like Mark beat me to the punch by two minutes on pointing out some valid criticisms.
 
subgenius said:
Please just answer the question. Do you know of any (however you define it)?
Last time, if he failed at the jobs you cite those wouldn't be achievments, right?
You're the one that made the assertion that he is not qualified, last I knew that meant the burden of proof was on your shoulders, not mine. I'm not taking that monkey, it doesn't belong to me. :)

I don't think he was a failure as governor, I guess that's where we differ in opinion.
 
dwb said:
You're the one that made the assertion that he is not qualified, last I knew that meant the burden of proof was on your shoulders, not mine. I'm not taking that monkey, it doesn't belong to me. :)

I don't think he was a failure as governor, I guess that's where we differ in opinion.
I said no one can list a specific achievment that qualified him.
Not "thinking he was a failure" is not only not specific, but still not an acievment. Its getting worse: "could have done worse", "not an imbecile", "not a failure."
I'm not taking the monkey either, I didn't vote for him.
 
subgenius said:
I said no one can list a specific achievment that qualified him.
I said he was a businessman and governor of a large state. You immediately implied that those don't count, because: "If he was a governor or businessman and failed that wouldn't be an achievment."

So, after taking that to mean the achievements I listed don't count, I asked you what you would consider sufficient qualifications, to which you began stepping around the question. I don't think he failed as governor, so that counts for me.

Either accept my answer (viz. being governor of a large state) and stop saying "no one" can give you an answer, or admit that there is no answer that will satisfy you, since you already believe he was not qualified.
 
We discussed this 'achievement' from an objective viewpoint in another thread:
ssibal said:

...
Now, I see the removal of Saddam and his regime as an achievement while others do not.
...
1.) the war in Iraq being done against the process in place in U.N. undermines democracy;

2.) the possibility of a Bush success in the Iraq's war is undermined by guerilla, making Bush not finishing ever "...the removal of Saddam...".

Based on 1.) and 2.), the war in Iraq is not a Bush achievement, it is a Bush failure.

One more big failure in Bush's resume.
 
Mark said:

With an annual deficit of almost 3/4 of a trillion dollars; Osama, and Mullah Omar still on the loose; 2 countries invaded and nothing accomplished; the 1st and 4th ammendments under serious assault...

How eaxctly could we have done a lot worse?
It beats me:

Bush must be president of wasted time and resources.
 
Ion said:

It beats me:

Bush must be president of wasted time and resources.

I agree, although I would change it to read, "Imperial President of Wasted Time and Resources."
 
dwb said:
I said he was a businessman and governor of a large state. You immediately implied that those don't count, because: "If he was a governor or businessman and failed that wouldn't be an achievment."

So, after taking that to mean the achievements I listed don't count, I asked you what you would consider sufficient qualifications, to which you began stepping around the question. I don't think he failed as governor, so that counts for me.

Either accept my answer (viz. being governor of a large state) and stop saying "no one" can give you an answer, or admit that there is no answer that will satisfy you, since you already believe he was not qualified.
Would failing at something be sufficient to you?
"Being" something is not the same as an achievment. What specifically did he achieve as governor or businessman?
Otherwise all failures are achievers in your book even if they were atrocious. If "being" is sufficient for you I accept that that is your standard.
I'll take any other of your measures of success other than just "being" something. I have mine but then we'd get off an answer to the question. Any of your own measures of acheiving something will do. Shouldn't be so hard.
Like saying there's no god. I'm not saying there's not, but I haven't seen any evidence of it yet. I didn't say he wasn't qualified. Educate me.
There are answers that would satisfy me. Anything specific. Anything.
 
subgenius said:

Would failing at something be sufficient to you?
"Being" something is not the same as an achievment. What specifically did he achieve as governor or businessman?
Otherwise all failures are achievers in your book even if they were atrocious. If "being" is sufficient for you I accept that that is your standard.
I'll take any other of your measures of success other than just "being" something. I have mine but then we'd get off an answer to the question. Any of your own measures of acheiving something will do. Shouldn't be so hard.
Like saying there's no god. I'm not saying there's not, but I haven't seen any evidence of it yet. I didn't say he wasn't qualified. Educate me.
There are answers that would satisfy me. Anything specific. Anything.

Businessman - I could imagine that some people think he's a successful businessman because he was richer at the end of it than when he started.

Governor - dwb states very clearly that he doesn't think Bush failed as Texas Governor. That's his opinion, and I would imagine, if he tried, he could point to specific successes that match his cirteria.

Here's the problem, no one is ever going to be able to prove to subgenius that Bush was qualified. His successes are too partisan.
 
specious_reasons said:
Governor - dwb states very clearly that he doesn't think Bush failed as Texas Governor. That's his opinion, and I would imagine, if he tried, he could point to specific successes that match his cirteria.
Yep.

specious_reasons said:
Here's the problem, no one is ever going to be able to prove to subgenius that Bush was qualified. His successes are too partisan.
Yep.

Besides, like I said, subgenius has already made up his mind that Bush was/is not qualified to be president. How do I know this?

1. He did not vote for Bush.

2. He states that no one can give an example of an achievement that qualifies Bush to be president.

3. He refuses to give criteria that would satisfy him apropos to presidential qualifications.

We could argue all day, but it's a really nice day, and I'd like to go fly a plane right now. Cheers. (BTW, I respect subgenius and his opinion, and I've read a lot of his stuff on these forums. This is just something we're clearly not going to gain consensus on. I don't think Bush is a wonderful president, but I do think he's qualified for the job.)
 
All I'm asking for is a specific success. What's so hard about that? I don't have to enumerate what they could be, they're obvious, but here's some: standard of living, improved education, cleaner air, water, lower crime, better health...something, anything.
Does that help? I know you can do it. I've just never see/heard it. I'm sincerely asking for you to educate me/us.

Hope you enjoy your day, its gorgeous here in Michigan. I, too, am going to go out and soak some of it up. Doesn't last long around here.
Vrooom. (Sound of me zooming off on my motorscooter to a birthday party.)
Fly a plane? Wow.
 
The question was what achievements qualify him for office.

The only reply I have seen so far is that he was a businessman and a governor.

Yes, well there are millions of businessmen in America, and hundreds of governors/ex-governors.

Again, whay achievement[i/] has Geroge Bush accomplished that sets him apart as the most quaified man in America to lead our country?

I honestly don't think anyone can seriously anwser that question, except with the anwser that "got the votes" (which will always be in question)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom