The Bush Resume

Luke T. said:


It is very likely. Have you been watching the news lately?

The Democratic state House legislators have all run away to Arizona to avoid being outvoted on some redistricting legislation. The Texas Democrat Senate did the same a few months ago, except they ran away to Oklahoma.

Have you read about this? The Republicans, through redistricting, are attempting the most blatant, grotesque power grab ever. Tom DeLay has even invoked the Homeland Security legislation to attempt to arrest the Democrats. It's ugly.

I have always been a fierce non-partisan, but Republican, anti-American, antics over the last 2 years are enough to make me register as a Democrat. Or at least make me puke my guts out. It's obscene.

Edited to add this from the N.Y. Times:
“The Texas power grab is part of a trend. Republicans, who now control all three branches of the federal government, are not just pushing through their political agenda. They are increasingly ignoring the rules of government to do it. While the Texas redistricting effort failed, Republicans succeeded in enacting an equally partisan redistricting plan in Colorado. And Republicans in the Senate -- notably those involved in the highly charged issue of judicial confirmations -- have been just as quick to throw out the rulebook...



“And Mr. DeLay recently revealed how he felt about rules of general applicability. When he tried smoking a cigar in a restaurant on federal property, the manager told him it violated federal law. His response, according to The Washington Post, was, "I am the federal government."



-- NY Times, Editorial Observer, 5/27/03

This is why I have always been against either party controlling all branches of government.
 
Mark said:
I have always been a fierce non-partisan, but Republican, anti-American, antics over the last 2 years are enough to make me register as a Democrat. Or at least make me puke my guts out. It's obscene.
You are unfamiliar with history. The Republicans got their ideas from the Democrats. California is the most gerrymandered state in the nation. Thank you Democrats.

Anti-American? :mad:
 
Mark said:
Have you read about this? The Republicans, through redistricting, are attempting the most blatant, grotesque power grab ever. Tom DeLay has even invoked the Homeland Security legislation to attempt to arrest the Democrats. It's ugly.
You know, such a claim makes me question your next one.

I have always been a fierce non-partisan, but Republican...
Ever hear of Richard J. Daley, how about the teamsters? 200 years of American history and politics and this is the worse that you know of? How can you be fiercely non-partisan and not know the history of politics in America. What is it you base your ideology on?

Take a poly sci class someday.
 
Mark said:
This is why I have always been against either party controlling all branches of government.
The one thing I will agree with.
 
RandFan said:
You are unfamiliar with history. The Republicans got there ideas from the Democrats. California is gerrymandered/Democrat state in the nation.
Gerrymandering comes from a time before either Republicans or Democrats existed. It was named for Elbridge Gerry, a Jeffersonian, who as Governer of Massachusetts in 1811, redrew districts like a "grotesque salamander", hence the term.

Republicans did not invent gerrymandering, but the Texas Repubs. have gone farther than ever before, stretching one Austin district all the way down to the coast more than 200 miles away. (Some wags have called this "Perrymandering", after Governer Perry) Also, redistricting was, by rule, only to be done in the years after the census. The Texas R's threw out that rule, along with every rule for allowing debate. Then, after cutting programs for the poor everywhere across the state, they tried to portray the "renegade Democrats" as heartless.

They have illegally used Federal resources to hunt them down, held a hate-filled party to destroy the Democrats' recently vacated headquarters, and in short, behaved like total asses.

BTW, these are also the same legislators who are leaning towards allowing "intelligent design" to be taught in Texas public schools.

No, I really can't think of much good to say about them.
 
RandFan said:
You know, such a claim makes me question your next one.

Ever hear of Richard J. Daley, how about the teamsters? 200 years of American history and politics and this is the worse that you know of? How can you be fiercely non-partisan and not know the history of politics in America. What is it you base your ideology on?

Take a poly sci class someday.

I don't approve of the Democrats doing it either, which puts me ahead of your partisanship. But the Republicans have taken it to a whole new level by trying to arrest the Democrats and invoking the Homeland Security Act. You can use all the grumbling emoticons you want, but the Republicans and their attempts to circumvent, and even repeal the first and fourth ammendments is anti-American. Deal with it.

As I said, what puts me ahead of you is that I don't make excuses when either party pulls this kind of crap.
 
Tricky said:
BTW, these are also the same legislators who are leaning towards allowing "intelligent design" to be taught in Texas public schools.

No, I really can't think of much good to say about them.
Fair enough, we Californians have Gray Davis, you have the legislature. I guess you will have to wait for the next election to do something about them.
 
Mark said:
I don't approve of the Democrats doing it either, which puts me ahead of your partisanship. But the Republicans have taken it to a whole new level by trying to arrest the Democrats and invoking the Homeland Security Act. You can use all the grumbling emoticons you want, but the Republicans and their attempts to circumvent, and even repeal the first and fourth ammendments is anti-American. Deal with it.

As I said, what puts me ahead of you is that I don't make excuses when either party pulls this kind of crap.
I make no excuses, politics is politics. Labeling it anti-american and making extreme and demonstrably wrong claims reveals your partisianship inspite of your protestations (There are far worse power grabs in history).

If you want we can all pretend that you are not partisan.
 
Tricky said:

Gerrymandering comes from a time before either Republicans or Democrats existed. It was named for Elbridge Gerry, a Jeffersonian, who as Governer of Massachusetts in 1811, redrew districts like a "grotesque salamander", hence the term.

Republicans did not invent gerrymandering, but the Texas Repubs. have gone farther than ever before, stretching one Austin district all the way down to the coast more than 200 miles away. (Some wags have called this "Perrymandering", after Governer Perry) Also, redistricting was, by rule, only to be done in the years after the census. The Texas R's threw out that rule, along with every rule for allowing debate. Then, after cutting programs for the poor everywhere across the state, they tried to portray the "renegade Democrats" as heartless.

They have illegally used Federal resources to hunt them down, held a hate-filled party to destroy the Democrats' recently vacated headquarters, and in short, behaved like total asses.

BTW, these are also the same legislators who are leaning towards allowing "intelligent design" to be taught in Texas public schools.

No, I really can't think of much good to say about them.

The interesting thing is that when the national media cover this at all, they usually report it as though the Democrats are being comical or obstructionists. So much for the "liberal" media.
 
RandFan said:
Fair enough, we Californians have Gray Davis, you have the legislature. I guess you will have to wait for the next election to do something about them.

Ah yes, Gray Davis with a 35 Billion Dollar Deficit, bad. (1.8% of the State economy)

George W. Bush with a 450 Billion Dollar Deficit (650 if he weren't raiding Social Security), good. (4.2% or 6% of the National economy, depending on which figure you use).

I wonder when Republicans will start caring more about their country, and less about their party?
 
Tricky said:
Also, redistricting was, by rule, only to be done in the years after the census.
Yes, and Presidents by rule are supposed to get their federal judge nominations by simple house vote. But Democrats in the house threw out that rule this year and in an unprecedented move used the filibuster to force a cloture vote 2/3rds for Bush to get his nominees. I guess it depends on who is throwing out the rules.
 
Mark said:


Ah yes, Gray Davis with a 35 Billion Dollar Deficit, bad. (1.8% of the State economy)

George W. Bush with a 450 Billion Dollar Deficit (650 if he weren't raidning Social Security), good. (4.2% or 6% of the National economy, depending on which figure you use).
Tax revenue for the US did not have an increase signigicantly greater than costs. California DID!

Big difference.

I wonder when Republicans will start caring more about their country, and less about their party?
Are we still pretending that you are not a partisan?
 
RandFan said:
Tax revenue for the US did not have an increase signigicantly greater than costs. California DID!

Big difference.

Are we still pretending that you are not a partisan?

I'm not. I never voted for Clinton. I never voted for either Bush.

However, rank and file Democrats tend more often to be questioners about their own positions (I am not talking about the leaders), while rank and file Republicans tend to be so smug and morally certain about all their positions. So, in that sense, yes, I do tend to favor the Democrat viewpoint.

And I'm glad you think bankrupting the Federal budget via an ill-advised tax cut and grossly increased spending was better than bankrupting it some other way. Me, I disagee; I think bankrupting it under any circumstance is a bad idea. And I felt the same way when Carter was in office and the deficit was in the hundreds of millions.

Funny how, all my life Republicans have been telling me deficits are bad (I agreed with them). Now they say they are OK (Unless you are Gray Davis). Were they lying then? Or now?
 
interesting

I am a libertarian so I certainly don't believe in any sort of enforced equality (other than that guaranteed by the Constitution and alluded to in the Declaration of Independence.) But wouldn't it be interesting to see where all of us would end up if we all had to actually start from scratch. I wonder where the likes of George W. would end up had he had to start from ground zero. He is clearly an absolute mediocrity of a human being. I wonder how far he would have gotten if he had come from where I came from - nobody and nothing and nowhere. I think it is a safe bet he'd be stocking shelves at Walmart or maybe he would have worked himself up to assistant manager at a McDonalds. Life is not fair and I would suppose it's not supposed to be, but it would sure be interesting to see what would happen if it was.
 
Mark said:
[...while rank and file Republicans tend to be so smug and morally certain about all their positions. So, in that sense, yes, I do tend to favor the Democrat viewpoint.
Yeah, I see what you mean. Take this thead for instance. No smugness or moral certainty. Riiiight! Tell me more about your not being a partisan. You are selling the point so well.

And I'm glad you think bankrupting the Federal budget via an ill-advised tax cut and grossly increased spending was better than bankrupting it some other way.
Where did I say that I was glad about grossly increased speinding?

Funny how, all my life Republicans have been telling me deficits are bad (I agreed with them). Now they say they are OK (Unless you are Gray Davis). Were they lying then? Or now?
Odd since the Democrats I know are doing the same thing.
 
Re: interesting

billydkid said:
I wonder where the likes of George W. would end up had he had to start from ground zero. He is clearly an absolute mediocrity of a human being.
It should be noted that he did not wash out of Flight Training which according to my cousin and uncle (pilots) not something mediocre people do. He graduated college. The average person will not. I don't think Bush is a mental giant but I don't think he is the simpleton those on the left love to make of him.
 
RandFan said:
Yes, and Presidents by rule are supposed to get their federal judge nominations by simple house vote. But Democrats in the house threw out that rule this year and in an unprecedented move used the filibuster to force a cloture vote 2/3rds for Bush to get his nominees. I guess it depends on who is throwing out the rules.

A technical quibble...the Senate confirms judges, not the house.

A political quibble: I suspect that all of the many Clinton Nominations that the Republican Senate killed and stalled by "proceedure" went completely by your notice...Presidents don't get their nominies unless they can get the proc.sess to work for them...fillabusters are part of the process...one party's obstructionist fillabuster technique is the other party's patriotic attempt to preserve the constitution, Congressional power, etc.

My only point is, if you didn't condemn what happened to the clinton judges, don't condemn what the Dems are doing to a very few Bush judges...by EVERY measure, Bush is getting far more of his judges through and confirmed and in much faster time....Besides, the ones that are being fillabustered are really scarey...at least if you believe in small things like seperation of church and state....
 
Need to add:

I was busted for shop lifting while attending Yale.
I was busted for posession of cocaine, but was let go and my records were sealed after my daddy called.
 
headscratcher4 said:
A political quibble: I suspect that all of the many Clinton Nominations that the Republican Senate killed and stalled by "proceedure" went completely by your notice...
No, not at all. There is a difference though. In this instance there are enough votes to move the nomination out of commite. The Democrats have decided that since they can't otherwise stop a floor vote that they would use the fillibuster. Like I said, such a move for judges is unprecedented.

My only point is, if you didn't condemn what happened to the clinton judges, don't condemn what the Dems are doing to a very few Bush judges...
My only point was to rebut Tricky's notion that there was something particularly nefarious about doing thing differently than tradition calls for. It's called politics, the Republicans are seeking advantage every bit as much as the Democrats. If one is going to be fair then one must agree to that fact.

And yes I freely admit that the Republicans did much the same. I very much opposed what they did to Lani Guiner (she wasn't nominated as a judge).
 
Malachi151 said:
Need to add:

I was busted for shop lifting while attending Yale.
I was busted for posession of cocaine, but was let go and my records were sealed after my daddy called.
??? People make mistakes. Could you explain the importance of this? I never thought Clintons personal problems made him a bad or average leader.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom