I didn't say he shouldn't be criticized at all. I said the GOP criticism rings hollow, which is a pretty different thing to say.
We're talking about several different things here by the way and I think you're conflating them when it's convenient to your position. If we're talking about politics and the withdrawal's impact on 2022 Congressional races, the 2024 election, long term polling, what the GOP criticism of Biden means, etc. we should be looking at the long term impact. He's taking some criticism on both sides for sure, but if the withdrawal is consists of getting Americans out and tens of thousands of Aghani civilians out without any kind of mass casualties, which so far is what it has been and it's certainly possible the Taliban have the most interest in ending this war out of anyone, I don't think there's much to talk about a year from now.
My experience is that not many people are paying too much attention and people will be glad we're out when it's done. There's many reasons his polling may be dipping and a successful withdrawal, even if it looked a little ugly, could easily bounce him back.
But if you want to talk about how it could be handled better, the humanitarian costs, the difficulties facing the Afghan people, the moral obligations, the communication and coordination between our allies, yeah that's a seperate thing. But I'm trying to talk about the politics of it.