Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Idk I live in a super red county in a purple state and people are just not talking about this. And they probably won’t if there’s no some kind of mass casualty event, or the US pulls out safely and brings tens of thousands of Afghans along I feel there’s just not not much there for most people. It seems to me like it’s completely over shadowed by COVID and vaccine mandates and school starting and masks right now.

Yep! :thumbsup:
 
I also think that the current GOP criticism of Biden for doing what they wanted and insisting we aren’t helping our Afghan allies but at the same time they’re immigrants so they can’t come here arguments ring pretty hollow.
 
Get ready for a Red tide in 2022. Most Americans do not like seeing the US humiliatied like this. Maybe the people in trendy liberal neighborhoos don't mind, must most Americans do.
IMHO we use military force to open a route to the airport, but I know you would not agree with that, since any use of force is wrong in your book That is why I don't like pacifists very much. It means tur ing the world over to the evil doers.

And there you go again..... Stop it.

For your information, I'm not a pacifist nor do I think force should never be used. But why let facts get in the way of a good hyperbolic and false accusation?
 
Last edited:
I should also point out that the Democratic mouthpiece MSNBC ;) hasn't gone all negative on Biden so far. Of course the GOP is trying to make hay of it.

Just curious, dudalb, are and if so where are you getting all that reinforcement for your doom and gloom posts?

I think in the long run Biden will look like the one POTUS that stuck his neck out in order to get done what should have been done a long time ago. Biden is old enough to remember how stupid it was to stay and stay in Vietnam.
 
He wants Biden and the 'Dems' to look bad?

As someone whose hatred of Trump and contempt for the GOP should be clear from my posting history....


BuT i see that criticism of Biden is now regarded as approval for Trump is the new dogma around here.
I see that actually criticising both parties when they mess up is simply unthinkable for some people.
I see that blind support for your party's leader is now dogma for both sides.
 
I also think that the current GOP criticism of Biden for doing what they wanted and insisting we aren’t helping our Afghan allies but at the same time they’re immigrants so they can’t come here arguments ring pretty hollow.

When it come to the Afghans refugees, many in the GOP are the biggest hypocrites on earth. Won't deny that.
But I reject this whole "Biden should not be critisided" crap.
 
If no on cares about Afghanistan, why are his poll numbers in freefall?
I think there is a certain amount of whistling past the graveyard around here.
 
As someone whose hatred of Trump and contempt for the GOP should be clear from my posting history....


BuT i see that criticism of Biden is now regarded as approval for Trump is the new dogma around here.
I see that actually criticising both parties when they mess up is simply unthinkable for some people.
I see that blind support for your party's leader is now dogma for both sides.

No.

The entire situation is a profound thrice-damned ****-show, likely sparked by poor intelligence and planning.

However, things are getting done. Imperfectly, but they are getting done. You just seem to have decided what the final outcome will be.

I'll wait and see what the final result is before I pile on blame.
 
If no on cares about Afghanistan, why are his poll numbers in freefall?
I think there is a certain amount of whistling past the graveyard around here.

Covid mostly. From CNBC:
The president began the month with an average job approval rating of 51.5%, down from 54% at the start of May.

By Tuesday, Biden’s average approval rating had fallen to 47%, the lowest so far in his presidency.
Still, pollsters caution that Americans tend to judge their presidents based on domestic policy, not foreign policy.

So the drop in Biden’s overall approval ratings likely reflects the somewhat lower approval for his Covid handling, more than it does the sharp drop in voters who approve of how the Afghanistan withdrawal is being handled.

A recent NBC News poll found that approval of Biden’s Covid handling fell from 69% in April to 53% in August, a 13-point drop.

Meanwhile, just 25% of voters said they approved of Biden’s handling of the situation in Afghanistan.

“The promise of April has led to the peril of August,” Democratic pollster Jeff Horwitt, who conducted the NBC News poll, told the network.

“It is the domestic storm, Covid’s delta wave, that is causing more difficulties at this stage here at home and for President Biden.”

Horwitt’s Republican counterpart on the NBC poll, Bill McInturff, was more succinct. “The best way to understand this poll is to forget Afghanistan,” he said.

I think Biden's drop in Covid approval is because a lot of people expected him to perform some kind of miracle and be able to convince the anti-vaxxers and Republicans to get vaccinated. More fools they. Biden couldn't convince them to get vaccinated under any circumstance at this point because they've dug in their heels when it comes to any Democrat telling them "what to do". The only thing that's going to convince them now is a personal connection to a loved one dying/almost dying or other incident that scares the stupid out of them.
 
But they did not begin to plummet until Afganistan.
I agree that normally domestic issues drive the polls, but once in a while Foreign Affairs takes over and this is one of those times.
I could argue that if it is over covid, then that is long term worse for the Dems, but that is anoher argument.
 
But they did not begin to plummet until Afganistan.
I agree that normally domestic issues drive the polls, but once in a while Foreign Affairs takes over and this is one of those times.
I could argue that if it is over covid, then that is long term worse for the Dems, but that is anoher argument.

And this, too, shall pass. People have very short memories and that's especially true when it comes to things that don't affect them personally.

To compare, Trump's polling numbers were at the lowest in his presidency about 200 days into it (August): only 36% approved. He began in Jan. with a 45.5% approval rating. That's about a 10 point drop. But by April, 2018 he was back up to over 40% and climbed to almost 49% by April 2019.
 
Over 58,000 people have been evacuated so far with another week to go with around 20,000+ per day being evacuated.
If the Taliban controls all the access to the airport and is not allowing any Afghans to leave, what are we supposed to do?
Apparently a few dozen thousand cases of human-scale quantum tunneling.

i see that criticism of Biden is now regarded as approval for Trump is the new dogma around here.
I thought any criticism of Biden must be an automatic case of obsession with Bernie! :eek:

If no on cares about Afghanistan, why are his poll numbers in freefall?
They aren't. They're sinking, but there's no honest way to squeeze "freefall" out of the pace.

And you know the reasons. We've already been talking about this for a while right here in this thread. You even responded to a small part of it yourself, although it was only to throw another one of your endless supply of "Bernie Bernie Bernie" balls at it so I doubt you even really looked first. You're a bit late to try to act like you're the one bringing us this new revelation.

But they did not begin to plummet until Afganistan.
Aside from the fact that "plummet" is another round of dishonesty about the speed of the decrease... yes, the decrease did in fact start months before this. Your track record of always saying exactly the opposite of reality on every single point in politics is holding strong.
 
Last edited:
Still waiting for the "disaster, humiliation" people to come up with a single point to show that that's what this even is...
 
And there is an example of why Americans generally, regardless of party, have such a low opinion of Congress:

https://whdh.com/news/officials-moulton-fellow-congressman-flew-into-kabul-tuesday-without-telling-military/

Bipartisan stupitdity.This is pure showboating. They can accomplish nothing but publcity for themselves, and creating another. headache for the people on the ground.
It's the did not bother to tell the military they were coming that gets to me.
I just HATE this kind of Grandstanding. I would like to see these two put to the end of hte line in the evacuation line.
And I hope, when they get back, they git a good butt kicking by Pelosi.

Update; Two already rebusked by Pelosi.
 
Last edited:
The Taliban has said it will not honor a cease fire against Americans if we stay past Aug. 31. Biden is protecting the lives of our troops.

And apparently nothing else matters, including throwing his allies under the bus. **** them. So much for a return to multilateralism after Trump.

Over 58,000 people have been evacuated so far with another week to go with around 20,000+ per day being evacuated. Not exactly a "clear epic failure".

It is because Biden is the reason for why there is such mad last second scramble. The fact that all the planes have not crashed and burned after takeoff doesn't exactly make up for Biden causing the problem in the first place. But hey Biden says it was always going to end up like this no matter what and he regrets nothing.
 
Last edited:
When it come to the Afghans refugees, many in the GOP are the biggest hypocrites on earth. Won't deny that.
But I reject this whole "Biden should not be critisided" crap.

I didn't say he shouldn't be criticized at all. I said the GOP criticism rings hollow, which is a pretty different thing to say.

We're talking about several different things here by the way and I think you're conflating them when it's convenient to your position. If we're talking about politics and the withdrawal's impact on 2022 Congressional races, the 2024 election, long term polling, what the GOP criticism of Biden means, etc. we should be looking at the long term impact. He's taking some criticism on both sides for sure, but if the withdrawal is consists of getting Americans out and tens of thousands of Aghani civilians out without any kind of mass casualties, which so far is what it has been and it's certainly possible the Taliban have the most interest in ending this war out of anyone, I don't think there's much to talk about a year from now.

My experience is that not many people are paying too much attention and people will be glad we're out when it's done. There's many reasons his polling may be dipping and a successful withdrawal, even if it looked a little ugly, could easily bounce him back.

But if you want to talk about how it could be handled better, the humanitarian costs, the difficulties facing the Afghan people, the moral obligations, the communication and coordination between our allies, yeah that's a seperate thing. But I'm trying to talk about the politics of it.
 
I didn't say he shouldn't be criticized at all. I said the GOP criticism rings hollow, which is a pretty different thing to say.

We're talking about several different things here by the way and I think you're conflating them when it's convenient to your position. If we're talking about politics and the withdrawal's impact on 2022 Congressional races, the 2024 election, long term polling, what the GOP criticism of Biden means, etc. we should be looking at the long term impact. He's taking some criticism on both sides for sure, but if the withdrawal is consists of getting Americans out and tens of thousands of Aghani civilians out without any kind of mass casualties, which so far is what it has been and it's certainly possible the Taliban have the most interest in ending this war out of anyone, I don't think there's much to talk about a year from now.

My experience is that not many people are paying too much attention and people will be glad we're out when it's done. There's many reasons his polling may be dipping and a successful withdrawal, even if it looked a little ugly, could easily bounce him back.

But if you want to talk about how it could be handled better, the humanitarian costs, the difficulties facing the Afghan people, the moral obligations, the communication and coordination between our allies, yeah that's a seperate thing. But I'm trying to talk about the politics of it.

This pretty much encapsulates my thoughts. :thumbsup:

If there are mass American casualties, Biden will take a hit. If not, the pundits will talk about it, but the voting public will not change their positions on Biden.
 
Won't even take mass US casualties, an ongoing parade of US Citizens in Taliban hands will do it quite nicely. Remember what cost Jimmy Carter the White Houee.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom