Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Lawrence O'Donnell's take on what is realistically possible in the Afghanistan evacuation.

He compares today with the evacuation of Saigon. Some of what he says will surprise most or all of you.

12 minutes

 
"Look, we're using a C-47 in Kabul! We used C-47s in Saigon too!"

The hopeless bleating that this is totally a disaster because we still have some of the same models of helicopter that we had a few decades ago has never been anything but an accidental confession that the person who's resorting to it can't come up with anything that's actually, really going so wrong in this.
 
Last edited:
Really? We've gotten over 51,000 people out without firing a shot, including over 5,000 Americans. You consider that completely botched?

Yes, completely botched.

Hopefully the evacuations continue successfully, although it would have been nice for there to have been better planning so we didn't have to rely on hope.
 
Would going golfing instead have been acceptable to you?
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/71669611d41286474d.jpg[/qimg]

I have go laugh at your need to throw in the word "teleprompter" as if that has one iota of relevancy. But your reason for doing so is laughingly obvious.

So is being on vacation, being upset over interrupting a vacation then making a 20 minute teleprompter vacation speech, no questions allowed from the press then going back on vacation at home while there's a crisis going on ok with you?

A round of golf takes a few hours.

Teleprompter is relevant because it looks like Biden is a deer in headlights at times.

Seriously, watch the UK or news from unbiased other sources besides CNN or MSNBC and you see a very different picture. They don't care about editing out Biden's obvious flaws like not remembering the names of his own appointees.
 
I can see I need to get my tin foil hat dusted off.

Impugning my motives repeatedly tells me you have nothing to really say.

Hmm. And this coming from someone who chastises me for giving more than two examples supporting my point in response to another poster. I had no idea you were a member of the Quota police. You might want to show your badge next time.
 
Seriously, watch the UK or news from unbiased other sources besides CNN or MSNBC and you see a very different picture. They don't care about editing out Biden's obvious flaws like not remembering the names of his own appointees.

I do watch the UK news and the coverage here is comparable to CNN and MSNBC - probably because it's firmly rooted in reality, not the ridiculous nonsense promoted by FOXNews, OANN and the like.
 
Oh, he put out some statements basically taking credit for a logistical operation already in progress.

Anyone with a sense of what the problem is could have told you last year that delivery was never the major hurdle, so this just lands to me as another failure to lead in a meaningful way.

LOL! The 'plan' was basically to send vaccines to a state distribution site and then wash their hands of anything else. States often had no idea how many vaccines they would be getting or when due to poor communication.

We've withdrawn.from Afghanistan but the issue is how and why.

We got soldiers out only to have to send some back in, so the timely withdrawal has become a blunder in that respect.

I agree.

We've responded to an epidemic, but the issue is how and why.

Batches of vaccine are being destroyed for lack of recipients, so timely delivery is actually quite a blunder in that sense.


And, again, how is that Biden's fault? Is he responsible for the anti-vaxxers and for the mainly Republicans who refuse to get vaccinated so the vaccines go unused and expire? Is he responsible for the right wing media spreading false information about the vaccines or the "I read it on the internet" idiots who think they cause miscarriages and make you magnetic?

This all reads like the higher priority is political point scoring and victories on paper that don't pan out in concrete terms.

Well, welcome to politics!
 
So is being on vacation, being upset over interrupting a vacation then making a 20 minute teleprompter vacation speech, no questions allowed from the press then going back on vacation at home while there's a crisis going on ok with you?

Someone's been watching Fox, OAN and Newsmax again. I especially like the "being upset over interrupting a vacation" bit. Who made that one up?
You or Tucker?

A round of golf takes a few hours.

And a golf course has no situation room where the POTUS can talk directly to his National Security advisors and other advisors to be kept up on what's happening like Camp David has:



Teleprompter is relevant because it looks like Biden is a deer in headlights at times.

Seriously, watch the UK or news from unbiased other sources besides CNN or MSNBC and you see a very different picture. They don't care about editing out Biden's obvious flaws like not remembering the names of his own appointees.

Oh, yeah....we've heard the 'watch foreign news videos where they don't edit out his dementia flubs" before. When asked to provide links to such sources and thus the alleged non-edited videos, we heard nothing but crickets. I think that was you, but I'd have to double check.

I see it's now the plural: appointees. You're referring to Sec. Austin. I know you like to think he forgot Austin's name, even though he had just mentioned it a few minutes earlier. Snopes has a different view:

It should also be noted that Biden was likely reading from a teleprompter during this event. While the viral interpretation of this clip is that Biden “forgot” Austin’s name, another plausible explanation would be that Biden tripped over the word “secretary” and then stumbled through an overly folksy correction.

On the other hand, we have Trump calling all these people by the wrong name including Kevin McCarthy, John Bolton, Netanyahu, Jeff Sessions, and Paul Ryan:

https://nowthisnews.com/videos/politics/every-time-that-donald-trump-couldnt-remember-someones-name
 
I am a UK citizen and watch UK TV news and read our MSM. I haven't seen any examples of dementia or confusion on the part of Biden. The occasional stumble which is probably due to his stutter rather than any other reason. Now Trump on the other hand... the number of examples of his confusion, his illiteracy, his inarticulateness, his lack of common knowledge, his bombast, his lack of a plan or of principles, his out and out lying not to mention covefe and hamberders... the hypocrisy of Trump supporters who can see that and handwave it away is amazing.
 
I watched that Lawrence O’Donnell piece and was a little jarred by what seemed like him trying to put a rosy face on a very ugly situation.

Now, I’m not so sure. Yes, plans for contingencies seem inadequate and the rapid fall of Kabul was not adequately foreseen. But we’re watching history being written day by day and hour by hour. In retrospect this withdrawal may end up being seen very differently than the apparent mess in which we seem to be embroiled. Something along the lines of, “In spite of intelligence failures and gross missteps in the first days after the fall of Kabul, the U.S. managed to morph the evacuation of Americans and friendly Afghans into one of the, if not THE largest airlifts in history, with little or any loss of American troops operating within close proximity to the occupying and heavily armed Taliban forces”.

We’ll see. It could all go completely to hell today or tomorrow with U.S. troops engaging the Taliban with casualties on both sides. And then what? Interesting times, and all that…
 
Maybe you should think outside the very blue district you live in.
America wanted out, but not in the way it is happening.

Just not enough to actually do things like welcome Afghan Refugees, remember how popular Trumps Muslim ban was outside of such very blue disctricts. Not at all clear what these less blue areas think should have been done differently.

And if the evacuation goes bad..which it easily could. Biden has to get Americans AND the Afghan allies out.

Yea Right, we never bother getting our allies out especially if they are muslim. We didn't I Iraq, we didn't in Vietnam why should we suddenly change?
 
Why is what bigoted (or at best blithely unconcerned) people want given equal or higher priority than what people who helped us and now stand under threat of violent reprisal need to be safe?

Why is this trotted out as if it makes some kind of reasonable sense?

My point is that this was all inevitable and just following basic US policy of what the past 50 years or so? Why would we expect Biden on his own to change that much inertia? How would he actually do it and what role would congress have to take?
 
Intelligence might be a failure. But is that Biden's fault or the intelligence agencies?

Don't you get it everything is Biden's fault, regardless of it he had any power to change it or not or the people can come up with something he could have actually done differently that would be a better outcome.

Like we should have gotten refugees out, but of course where they would go is an open question and America is clearly not willing to take a couple hundred thousand Afghan refugees. Does the president even have the power to unilaterally make that kind of decision or does congress need to be involved?
 
I wonder if the clear crap show of the Taliban taking over is making it politically more viable to accept these refugees than it was a few months ago?
 
My point is that this was all inevitable and just following basic US policy of what the past 50 years or so? Why would we expect Biden on his own to change that much inertia? How would he actually do it and what role would congress have to take?

Actually this was perfectly avoidable! The Peace Deal By Taliban Trump did not Include the Afgan Government, and did not force the Taliban to admit Osama Bin Laden, was responsible for 9/11/2001.
It was done by Trump to try and salvage the 2020 Election, after his Racism was fully exposed, it was political gaslighting.
 
Oh, yeah....we've heard the 'watch foreign news videos where they don't edit out his dementia flubs" before. When asked to provide links to such sources and thus the alleged non-edited videos, we heard nothing but crickets. I think that was you, but I'd have to double check.

By foreign news sources, they probably mean Russia Today.
 
Really? We've gotten over 51,000 people out without firing a shot, including over 5,000 Americans. You consider that completely botched?
I think it goes to show that we had the ability to do this even better in a planned, coordinated way.

The fact that our armed services and associated personnel have performed admirably under the circumstances gives lie to any notions that "the military" blew it.
 
Hmm. And this coming from someone who chastises me for giving more than two examples supporting my point in response to another poster. I had no idea you were a member of the Quota police. You might want to show your badge next time.
This is you avoiding my point and making up some nonsense about a quota.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom