Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
First, how do you know they all would want to just leave?

And second, the world has a huge enough refugee crisis as it is. Where would all these people go?

I want the Afghans to reject the Taliban and I hope we do something to protect women and girls from them. We'll have to see how this pans out. You know the old insanity meme is to keep doing what you were doing and expect a different outcome. 20 years with little to show for it is evidence we needed to do something else.

American Troops on the ground is the only realistic, way we can protect women and girls from the Taliabn,.
I think a number of semi pacifists here are going to learn the problem with Pacisfism is it turns the world over to the bad guys.
 
But we were happy to accept their help, at great personal peril to themselves and their families (or perhaps anyone who could potentially have knowledge of their whereabouts if they go to ground).

With such an attitude as described (not attributing this position to any specific person), I can't imagine why there's a negative opinion of the U.S. in many parts of the world.

"Thanks for the assistance, now go to hell."

Or perhaps remain in hell, as the case may be.

:thumbsup:
 
At last check, Republicans were doing what they could to even obstruct the direct cooperators in Afghanistan who had been promised sanctuary by our military from actually receiving that sanctuary.
The cynic in me says this is purely motivated by the idea that in the future they can campaign on how Biden abandoned them.
 
I really want to support Biden, but though he might not pass on a war in Afhansitan, he will pass on a struggle with Islamic Fundamentalism that is going to go on for along time..maybe longer then the COld War. It will probably move to a different battlefiedl, that is all.\
But, yeah, Trump made a huge mistake in his Deal with the Taliaban.

Islamic Fundamentalism isn't going anywhere regardless of what Biden did/does in Afghanistan. More American troops dying there isn't going to change that.
 
The world also has a people being beheaded or kidnapped for ransom or tortured to make an example of problem.

I don't disagree with that. Just suggesting increasing the migratory refugee problem is not the easy answer it was being portrayed as.

Have you opened your house to a refugee family? Donated a significant amount to a relocation charity?
 
The cynic in me says this is purely motivated by the idea that in the future they can campaign on how Biden abandoned them.

Oh, believe me...they will. Trump brokered the deal to leave with the Taliban but it will be all Biden's fault. Remember that one of Trump's campaign promises was to get us out of 'endless wars'.

“The Endless Wars Must End!” US President Donald J. Trump tweeted on October 19 last year, one of a dozen of his tweets using the phrase in 2019. “I inherited a total mess in Syria and Afghanistan, the ‘Endless Wars’ of unlimited spending and death. During my campaign I said, very strongly, that these wars must finally end,” the president tweeted on February 1, 2019. And: “I was elected on getting out of these ridiculous endless wars, where our great military functions as a policing operation to the benefit of people who don’t even like the USA,” Trump tweeted on October 7, 2019.
https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/ending-the-endless-war-trope/

When he did so, many GOP were praising him. This from the Nevada GOP:

PRESIDENT TRUMP IS FULFILLING HIS PROMISE TO END ENDLESS WARS
This Saturday, The Trump Administration Signed An Agreement In Afghanistan That Paves The Way For Peace In The Country And Ending America’s Involvement In The Conflict

From RNC Research
The Facts:
THIS SATURDAY, THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION SIGNED AN AGREEMENT IN AFGHANISTAN THAT IS PAVING THE WAY FOR PEACE IN THE COUNTRY
During his campaign for President, then-candidate Donald Trump promised to end America’s involvement in “endless wars.”
This Saturday , the Trump Administration signed a preliminary peace agreement with the Taliban that sets the stage to end “America’s longest war.”
Under the agreement , the U.S. will withdraw nearly 5,000 troops from the country in 135 days in exchange for a Taliban agreement to not allow Afghanistan to be used for transnational terrorism.
Time Magazine reported that other components of the agreement included an agreement that U.S. counterterrorism forces stay in the country, permissions for the CIA to operate in Taliban-held areas and details of how the Taliban’s promises to reduce violence will be monitored and verified.
The deal has been called the ” best chance to end this conflict ,” a ” decisive move ” towards peace, and ” the best path ” for the united states.
The war in Afghanistan is the longest in U.S. history, a conflict that has killed more than 3,500 U.S. and NATO troops and cost U.S. taxpayers nearly 900 billion dollars.
PRESIDENT TRUMP’S MOVE TO END THE WAR IN AFGHANISTAN FOLLOWS THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION’S PREVIOUS VICTORY OVER ISIS

As a fellow ISF member is fond of saying: It's only bad when the Democrats do it.
 
I don't disagree with that. Just suggesting increasing the migratory refugee problem is not the easy answer it was being portrayed as.

Have you opened your house to a refugee family? Donated a significant amount to a relocation charity?

I have not. But I'm also not a charitable person. Not for selfishness, but just extremely low risk tolerance. I don't think I will ever achieve a level of savings where I feel safe.
 
I don't disagree with that. Just suggesting increasing the migratory refugee problem is not the easy answer it was being portrayed as.



Have you opened your house to a refugee family? Donated a significant amount to a relocation charity?
Not really sure it was portrayed as "easy."

However, I'm well aware that "the right thing to do" and "the easy thing to do" rarely are found together.
 
Last edited:
I don't disagree wiht anything that has been said about Trump's roll in this; but, frankly, it is clear to all who do not have on king size blinders that the whole withdrawal was done too quickly and was badly planned, and that is on Biden.
he is starting to take fire from some Democrats on it.
 
Last edited:
I got a sick feeling this might cost the Dems the next two eletctions, and the US it's democracy.
 
I don't disagree wiht anything that has been said about Trump's roll in this; but, frankly, it is clear to all who do not have on king size blinders that the whole withdrawal was done too quickly and was badly planned, and that is on Biden.
he is starting to take fire from some Democrats on it.

What would a slower withdrawal or better planned look like to you?
 
Well so far it's casualty free. I'm not sure hanging around for a couple more weeks or months would have inspired some kind of resistance or kept the Taliban from gaining control of the country any more than the last 20 years did.
 
I don't disagree wiht anything that has been said about Trump's roll in this; but, frankly, it is clear to all who do not have on king size blinders that the whole withdrawal was done too quickly and was badly planned, and that is on Biden.

Agreed.

It reminds me of how Jimmy Carter will be forever remembered for the botched rescue attempt of the Iranian hostages. 6 months into Biden’s Presidency, I think this fiasco has an excellent chance of sticking to Biden the same way. I support 100% ending that war, but pulling troops out only to have to send them back in when clearly foreseeable events on the ground occur does not show mastery of the situation. Now, imagine the Taliban rolling into Kabul and taking Americans hostage, and/or overrunning our troops with massive casualties. Both sickening, but not unimaginable outcomes. And it would be 100% on Biden, irrespective of what tfg did or didn’t do.

Edited to add: This announcement/press conference shows a depressing level of naïveté in hindsight: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing...on-the-drawdown-of-u-s-forces-in-afghanistan/
 
Last edited:
Islamic Fundamentalism isn't going anywhere regardless of what Biden did/does in Afghanistan. More American troops dying there isn't going to change that.

But how many were actually dying in recent years? And they are after all combat troops, not visiting civilians.

The attitude of hand wringing over every death of a professional warrior befuddles me. And then these exhortations of, "Bring the troops home!" Especially when their country's citizenry are slaughtering themselves by the tens of thousands at home for no good cause.

The way things are on the US home front, it wouldn't much surprise me if soldier could be more likely to die at the hands of a fellow American than an Afghani.
 
The US Administration's haste in leaving Afghanistan before ensuring the safety of all those Afghanis who aided them and were promised security in exchange maddens me. It's very much a case where none shall be left behind. Abandonment of any of these people is tantamount to leaving US troops behind, in my books.

The treacherous betrayal of the Kurds will never be forgotten by me, either.

Allies in war are as worthy as one's own citizens.
 
The US Administration's haste in leaving Afghanistan before ensuring the safety of all those Afghanis who aided them and were promised security in exchange maddens me. It's very much a case where none shall be left behind. Abandonment of any of these people is tantamount to leaving US troops behind, in my books.

The treacherous betrayal of the Kurds will never be forgotten by me, either.

Allies in war are as worthy as one's own citizens.

This, I'll agree with. Going further with the concept, those who have actually actively worked to aid our country with real risk to their lives, family, and livelihood are far more deserving of our country's aid and shelter than those who were born here and are thus legally citizens, but actively work to harm our country.
 
I got a sick feeling this might cost the Dems the next two eletctions, and the US it's democracy.

I don't think so. You think Americans give a damn about Afghanistan? I don't. Look what happened in Lebanon a few years ago. Was that a campaign issue in any election?
 
I doubt a lot of people here in the US would want "tens of thousands" of Muslim Afghan refugees to be allowed to immigrate here.


It was already the announced plan to extract the Afghans who helped the U.S. and their families. Special visa categories were created. There was a proposal to move them to Guam to be vetted and processed. "Tens of thousands" of refugees, not enough to fill one stadium, distributed across the country would be a trivial number. Over 70,000 have already been moved since 2008. The U.S. just didn't act fast enough this time.
https://www.npr.org/2021/07/14/1016...nd-others-who-aided-u-s-to-begin-in-late-july
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-58020494

And of course the U.S. doesn't have to move everybody to Cleveland. Getting them out of Afghanistan would be the first step, then moving them to another country -- the U.S. or elsewhere -- would come next.
 
I don't think so. You think Americans give a damn about Afghanistan? I don't. Look what happened in Lebanon a few years ago. Was that a campaign issue in any election?

Plus, by late 2022 everyone will have forgotten this, for a number of reasons, one of them being that about 117,098 scandals will have happened between now and then.
 
I don't think so. You think Americans give a damn about Afghanistan? I don't. Look what happened in Lebanon a few years ago. Was that a campaign issue in any election?

To refresh, 241 Marines and other troops were killed in the bombing of their barracks in Lebanon in 1983, and the U.S. effectively left the country. The next year Reagan won the 1984 election in a landslide. If the U.S. can get out of Afghanistan without new American deaths, many voters will say that's all they need to know.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Beirut_barracks_bombings
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom