Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sure, there's no guarantee. But it worked for many years. And apparently one reason Afghan army units are surrendering in droves is that they can no longer count on U.S. support. This doesn't have to be happening this way.

We didn't just have 2500 troops there 'for many years'. We never had less than 3500 and for most of the time, far more than that. It was claimed there were 2500 by the beginning of 2021, but the NYT reported here there actually about 1,000 more troops than the Pentagon had reported. In 2017, there were at least 14,000 troops. In Nov. 2020, there were at least 4,500 after a withdrawal of thousands during Trump administration.

As Rear Admiral Kirby, the Pentagon spokesman said, money can't buy the will of the Afghan army to fight.
 
Why is it an 'offence'?

I don't necessarily think it is. I'm asking because I want to understand how others think, and when people ask for options, I am presenting extreme options (call for resignation) to expand the range of the topic.

As a 538 fanboy, I have some thoughts about what a prediction is, and what it means to make them And that is why I couched Biden's prediction as really focusing as poor judgement on his primary sphere of influence. I want to see how much value others put on it.
 
I don't necessarily think it is. I'm asking because I want to understand how others think, and when people ask for options, I am presenting extreme options (call for resignation) to expand the range of the topic.

As a 538 fanboy, I have some thoughts about what a prediction is, and what it means to make them And that is why I couched Biden's prediction as really focusing as poor judgement on his primary sphere of influence. I want to see how much value others put on it.

He would base the opinion on the information provided to him by the military and intelligence chiefs.

I am also surprised by the speed of the advance but it is not completely unexpected. Once the US and allied troops pulled out it was all up in the air. No one knew how well the army would stand up on their own. Their seeming total collapse in just a few days is the surprise, I would have given them a month to six weeks longer.
 
Last edited:
He would base the opinion on the information provided to him by the military and intelligence chiefs.

I am also surprised by the speed of the advance but it is not completely unexpected. Once the US and allied troops pulled out it was all up in the air. No one knew how well the army would stand up on their own. Their seeming total collapse in just a few days is the surprise, I would have given them a month to six weeks longer.

If no one knew how well they would do on their own, then it seems to be very poor judgement to make a bold prediction.
 
He would base the opinion on the information provided to him by the military and intelligence chiefs.

I am also surprised by the speed of the advance but it is not completely unexpected. Once the US and allied troops pulled out it was all up in the air. No one knew how well the army would stand up on their own. Their seeming total collapse in just a few days is the surprise, I would have given them a month to six weeks longer.

Gen. Wesley Clark outlined why the Taliban could take over so quickly. It mostly boils down to the corruption of the government and the failure of leadership. He said that there is a culture of the government officials 'from the top down' to 'line their own pockets'. He added that there were "years and years of mismanagement and corruption and people who were half-heartedly committed in order to get a paycheck and leaders who took pay from them and didn't provide the logistics." He also said there was "no real support from the citizenry of the government and no loyalty up and down the chain of command."

The will to fight just dissipated and they basically just let the Taliban waltz in with very little to no resistance.

Years ago, I read a book by Khaled Hosseini, A Thousand Splendid Suns. , that takes place in Afghanistan and covers about 30 years. I remember how struck I was by the culture there that was basically based on corruption and loyalty to family above absolutely everything else. The attitude was "if you can get away with it and it benefits the family" it was fine regardless of legality. It was not only acceptable, it was expected. Years of endless invasions and fighting within the internal tribes and ethnicities promoted this attitude. The Pushtuns, the largest and most influential group, detest the Hazaras not only for being a different ethnicity, but for being Shi'as and not Sunnis. As I've said before, the idea of an Afghan nation is just a mirage. It doesn't exist in the culture.
 
Yep, breaking things and killing people is relatively easy, particularly for Americans. But, as I said back when all this started, "building a nation" in Afghanistan would be a multi-generational project, that would require explicitly breaking down their entire society, and building it anew. Basically, take the accusations of "cultural imperialism" to heart, and deliberately, actually wage a cultural war.

Short of that, you might as well not even bother trying.

It's like the Cold War: it is going to me a multi generational struggle with Islamic Fundamentalism.
And in many ways more dangerous: As bad the Soviet System was, there was a certain rationality involved;they knew any kind of direct action on US Soil would be a bad move. Espoinage, yes, but nothing beyond that.
You don't have that with Islamic Militants.
 
We didn't just have 2500 troops there 'for many years'. We never had less than 3500 and for most of the time, far more than that. It was claimed there were 2500 by the beginning of 2021, but the NYT reported here there actually about 1,000 more troops than the Pentagon had reported. In 2017, there were at least 14,000 troops. In Nov. 2020, there were at least 4,500 after a withdrawal of thousands during Trump administration.

As Rear Admiral Kirby, the Pentagon spokesman said, money can't buy the will of the Afghan army to fight.

I was wrong about the timeline. I should have said "a few thousand" for years. The point still is that if a few thousand U.S. troops could prevent a Taliban takeover, it might not be a bad investment. I don't want to see thousands of people murdered, or every woman and girl returned to the Middle Ages.
 
Last edited:
Gen. Wesley Clark outlined why the Taliban could take over so quickly. It mostly boils down to the corruption of the government and the failure of leadership. He said that there is a culture of the government officials 'from the top down' to 'line their own pockets'. He added that there were "years and years of mismanagement and corruption and people who were half-heartedly committed in order to get a paycheck and leaders who took pay from them and didn't provide the logistics." He also said there was "no real support from the citizenry of the government and no loyalty up and down the chain of command."

Was Clark was in the West Point class of 1966 so I can a feeling with him it's a case of "I have seen this movie before, and it was called South Vietnam".

It's a horrible situatioin; I don't think we can write the loss of Afghanistan off like we could VIetnam.
The war with Islamic Militants is going to be like the cold war: a multiantional struggle. It's one I don't think we can just walk away from.
 
....
Years ago, I read a book by Khaled Hosseini, A Thousand Splendid Suns. , that takes place in Afghanistan and covers about 30 years. I remember how struck I was by the culture there that was basically based on corruption and loyalty to family above absolutely everything else. The attitude was "if you can get away with it and it benefits the family" it was fine regardless of legality. It was not only acceptable, it was expected. Years of endless invasions and fighting within the internal tribes and ethnicities promoted this attitude. The Pushtuns, the largest and most influential group, detest the Hazaras not only for being a different ethnicity, but for being Shi'as and not Sunnis. As I've said before, the idea of an Afghan nation is just a mirage. It doesn't exist in the culture.

That goes back to the Bush administration, which apparently imagined that Afghanistan could be turned into Canada or Disneyland or someplace by propping up thoroughly corrupt figureheads. If the U.S. had gotten out after it routed the Taliban, the Afghan warlords might have divvied up the country and shared power more or less peacefully. I still think the way we're leaving now isn't the best way or the only way, for us or for ordinary people just trying to live.
 
As much as I sympathize with the people, especially the women and girls, there was little gain for them even during the last 20 years outside the US controlled cities. In the rural areas, the tribal ways continued, especially within the majority Pashtuns. Their culture is one of male dominance, women covering up, not being educated, and marrying them off young as baby producers.
 
That goes back to the Bush administration, which apparently imagined that Afghanistan could be turned into Canada or Disneyland or someplace by propping up thoroughly corrupt figureheads. If the U.S. had gotten out after it routed the Taliban, the Afghan warlords might have divvied up the country and shared power more or less peacefully. I still think the way we're leaving now isn't the best way or the only way, for us or for ordinary people just trying to live.

The Taliban would have come back regardless with the help of Pakistan and other terrorist groups like al-Qaeda. They were never going to go away. They're fanatical and highly dedicated religious ideologues.
 
Biden statement:

When I came to office, I inherited a deal cut by my predecessor—which he invited the Taliban to discuss at Camp David on the eve of 9/11 of 2019—that left the Taliban in the strongest position militarily since 2001 and imposed a May 1, 2021 deadline on U.S. Forces. Shortly before he left office, he also drew U.S. Forces down to a bare minimum of 2,500. Therefore, when I became President, I faced a choice—follow through on the deal, with a brief extension to get our Forces and our allies’ Forces out safely, or ramp up our presence and send more American troops to fight once again in another country’s civil conflict. I was the fourth President to preside over an American troop presence in Afghanistan—two Republicans, two Democrats. I would not, and will not, pass this war onto a fifth.

For the entire statement: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing...tement-by-president-joe-biden-on-afghanistan/
 
The choice wasn't to stay forever or leave now no matter what. The U.S. could have taken the time to extract the tens of thousands of Afghans who have helped the U.S. and who are now in danger of immediate execution, and made clear that Taliban interference would delay our departure.

There's also an argument to be made that U.S. troops are and should be stationed wherever it serves our interests. U.S. troops have been deployed throughout Europe and the Pacific since the end of WWII, and in Korea since the end of the Korean War. There are 600+ U.S. military installations abroad of one kind or another. I'm not sure keeping 2500 troops in Afghanistan indefinitely to prevent a Taliban takeover would have been a bad investment.
First, how do you know they all would want to just leave?

And second, the world has a huge enough refugee crisis as it is. Where would all these people go?

I want the Afghans to reject the Taliban and I hope we do something to protect women and girls from them. We'll have to see how this pans out. You know the old insanity meme is to keep doing what you were doing and expect a different outcome. 20 years with little to show for it is evidence we needed to do something else.
 
First, how do you know they all would want to just leave?

And second, the world has a huge enough refugee crisis as it is. Where would all these people go?

I want the Afghans to reject the Taliban and I hope we do something to protect women and girls from them. We'll have to see how this pans out. You know the old insanity meme is to keep doing what you were doing and expect a different outcome. 20 years with little to show for it is evidence we needed to do something else.

I doubt a lot of people here in the US would want "tens of thousands" of Muslim Afghan refugees to be allowed to immigrate here.
 
I doubt a lot of people here in the US would want "tens of thousands" of Muslim Afghan refugees to be allowed to immigrate here.

At last check, Republicans were doing what they could to even obstruct the direct cooperators in Afghanistan who had been promised sanctuary by our military from actually receiving that sanctuary.
 
I doubt a lot of people here in the US would want "tens of thousands" of Muslim Afghan refugees to be allowed to immigrate here.
But we were happy to accept their help, at great personal peril to themselves and their families (or perhaps anyone who could potentially have knowledge of their whereabouts if they go to ground).

With such an attitude as described (not attributing this position to any specific person), I can't imagine why there's a negative opinion of the U.S. in many parts of the world.

"Thanks for the assistance, now go to hell."

Or perhaps remain in hell, as the case may be.
 
First, how do you know they all would want to just leave?



And second, the world has a huge enough refugee crisis as it is. Where would all these people go?



I want the Afghans to reject the Taliban and I hope we do something to protect women and girls from them. We'll have to see how this pans out. You know the old insanity meme is to keep doing what you were doing and expect a different outcome. 20 years with little to show for it is evidence we needed to do something else.

The world also has a people being beheaded or kidnapped for ransom or tortured to make an example of problem.
 
Also, this is not a new problem, I recall Jon Stewart highlighting this issue way back in Obama's administration. We've been ******* this dog for quite a while, now.
 

I really want to support Biden, but though he might not pass on a war in Afhansitan, he will pass on a struggle with Islamic Fundamentalism that is going to go on for along time..maybe longer then the COld War. It will probably move to a different battlefiedl, that is all.\
But, yeah, Trump made a huge mistake in his Deal with the Taliaban.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom