Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Presidents have been making the wrong calls about Afghanistan for 20 years now; at this point, it's practically a job requirement.

Does something disqualifying stop being a disqualification because a lot of people can't achieve?

To quote Eddie Vedder, "can't find a better man"?
 
Presidents have been making the wrong calls about Afghanistan for 20 years now; at this point, it's practically a job requirement.
A bit longer than that, more like 60+ years.

In the late 70s my boyfriend at the time said when we pulled out and Russia moved in that it would be their Vietnam. I disagreed because it was more desert and not jungle, IOW easier to attack the enemy.

I believe Russia had interests in building an oil pipeline, I've forgotten. That's when we were funding Bin Laden in that particular proxy fight against Russia.

Turned out the boyfriend was right, pressure on Russia by her citizens who were tired of losing sons, husbands and fathers resulted in Russia pulling out.

Skip ahead to 2001 and you have a training ground for Al-Qaeda which we attacked. Forget all the Iraq tragedy, a mess that continues, we moved into Afghanistan again.

I think it's devastating how the Taliban and their Sharia law treat women. Getting the Taliban out was one of the better things that happened when Bush started these tragic wars.

I'm amazed that only a couple thousand US troops were holding the Taliban back. I have mixed emotions about them taking the whole country in such a short period of time.

It seems like Biden's plan is to offer financial aid to the Taliban when they take over the country. I doubt that is going to matter to them but I could be wrong. Seems to me they have another source more to their liking and that is the Wahhabism that flourishes in the very rich Saudi population.

It is a huge mess.
 
Last edited:
He was extremely wrong, made a specific prediction, and it was over an issue that was primary concern of a president.

If you are a shareholder in a company, and the CEO makes a horrible prediction regarding a fundamental issue in their role as CEO, it might lead you to question your confidence.

So what would you suggest? Biden to keep our troops in Afghanistan for another 2 fruitless decades? In twenty years, they'll not be any more of a 'democratic nation' than they've been for the last thousand years. IOW: never.
 
So what would you suggest? Biden to keep our troops in Afghanistan for another 2 fruitless decades? In twenty years, they'll not be any more of a 'democratic nation' than they've been for the last thousand years. IOW: never.

For the wrong prediction? Democrats should impeach him, boot him out of office, and have Harris take over. But the correct decision was to pull troops out regardless of the prediction.
 
For the wrong prediction? Democrats should impeach him, boot him out of office, and have Harris take over. But the correct decision was to pull troops out regardless of the prediction.

Keep in mind Trump made this decision. Biden didn't reverse course.
 
Keep in mind Trump made this decision. Biden didn't reverse course.

To me, it looks like Bob isn't concerned about that. It's about the correctness of the thing that Biden said, rather than the action and any merits or demerits, that he seems to be focusing upon.
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind Trump made this decision. Biden didn't reverse course.

This wouldn't be punishment for the decision. It would be lack of faith in his decision making and reasoning in matters of foreign relations. Can you trust someone to make decisions when they have such a poor grasp of the situation?
 
To me, it looks like Bob isn't concerned about that. It's about the correctness of the thing that Biden said, rather than the action and any merits or demerits, that he seems to be focusing upon.


In Bob's own quote, President Biden said it was "unlikely", not that it would never, ever, ever happen. Lots of unlikely events end up happening.
 
So what would you suggest? Biden to keep our troops in Afghanistan for another 2 fruitless decades? In twenty years, they'll not be any more of a 'democratic nation' than they've been for the last thousand years. IOW: never.

The choice wasn't to stay forever or leave now no matter what. The U.S. could have taken the time to extract the tens of thousands of Afghans who have helped the U.S. and who are now in danger of immediate execution, and made clear that Taliban interference would delay our departure.

There's also an argument to be made that U.S. troops are and should be stationed wherever it serves our interests. U.S. troops have been deployed throughout Europe and the Pacific since the end of WWII, and in Korea since the end of the Korean War. There are 600+ U.S. military installations abroad of one kind or another. I'm not sure keeping 2500 troops in Afghanistan indefinitely to prevent a Taliban takeover would have been a bad investment.
 
Chieffi

For the wrong prediction? Democrats should impeach him, boot him out of office, and have Harris take over. But the correct decision was to pull troops out regardless of the prediction.

Ridiculous. Making a bad prediction is not an impeachable offense.
 
The choice wasn't to stay forever or leave now no matter what. The U.S. could have taken the time to extract the tens of thousands of Afghans who have helped the U.S. and who are now in danger of immediate execution, and made clear that Taliban interference would delay our departure.

There's also an argument to be made that U.S. troops are and should be stationed wherever it serves our interests. U.S. troops have been deployed throughout Europe and the Pacific since the end of WWII, and in Korea since the end of the Korean War. There are 600+ U.S. military installations abroad of one kind or another. I'm not sure keeping 2500 troops in Afghanistan indefinitely to prevent a Taliban takeover would have been a bad investment.

The US was never going to extract "tens of thousands of Afghans".

I do think it shouldn't have been done so quickly without a better plan to extract those Afghans that had been our translators, etc. That the Taliban would take over so quickly was a miscalculation on Biden's part, no question. He put too much faith in the American trained Afghan army's abilities to hold off the Taliban. But he is sending in 3,000 troops now to help with the extractions.

Whether or not keeping 2500 troops there indefinitely would have been enough to prevent a Taliban takeover is very, very questionable.
 
The US was never going to extract "tens of thousands of Afghans".
.....


Why not? The U.S. did it in Vietnam, and hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese who couldn't get out were killed.
The imminent collapse of the Afghan government is in plain sight. On July 14th, the Biden Administration announced Operation Allies Refuge, an airlift program for Afghan translators and others who worked for the U.S. military. An estimated eighteen thousand Afghans who worked with American troops during the war are eligible; their family members included, the number of potential evacuees comes to some seventy thousand. State Department officials say that they are working to implement the plan.
https://www.newyorker.com/news/dail...could-save-tens-of-thousands-of-afghan-allies
 
Last edited:
.....
Whether or not keeping 2500 troops there indefinitely would have been enough to prevent a Taliban takeover is very, very questionable.

Sure, there's no guarantee. But it worked for many years. And apparently one reason Afghan army units are surrendering in droves is that they can no longer count on U.S. support. This doesn't have to be happening this way.
 
in what sense?

In the sense that it's not a "high crime or misdemeanor".

Being angry that the president made a bad prediction is a reason not to vote for him, that's it. Add it to the pile. Compare it to the pile of issues you have with other candidates. Figure it out on election day.
 
Last edited:
AS gnome said, a prez making a bad prediction is not a 'high crime or misdemeanor'. If we could impeach a prez every time he made a bad prediction, we'd have impeached every president.

technically can impeach for anything. Solely the discretion of Congress


But as an alternative, you can call for his resignation for this offense
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom